Kiwi Party Incorporated v Attorney-General

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link  

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA261/2019
 [2020] NZCA 80

BETWEEN

THE KIWI PARTY INCORPORATED
Appellant

AND

ATTORNEY-GENERAL
Respondent

Hearing:

3 March 2020 and further submissions on 13 and 20 March 2020

Court:

Collins, Simon France and Lang JJ

Counsel:

G E Minchin for Appellant
G M Taylor for Respondent

Judgment:

24 March 2020 at 12 noon

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is dismissed.

BThe respondent is entitled to costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Collins J)

Introduction

  1. On 15 March 2019, a gunman entered the Al Noor Mosque and soon thereafter the Linwood Islamic Centre in Christchurch.  He was armed with a number of weapons, including two semi-automatic rifles.  Fifty-one people died as a result of being shot by the gunman, 40 other victims were wounded.  The gunman is awaiting trial in relation to 51 charges of murder, 40 charges of attempted murder and one charge of engaging in a terrorist act.

  2. Immediately after the shootings the Prime Minister announced that New Zealand gun laws would change.  This was achieved through two measures:

    (a)The Arms (Military Style Semi-automatic Firearms) Order 2019 (the Order), which was passed by the Executive on 21 March 2019 pursuant to s 74A(c) of the Arms Act 1983 (the Act) and remained in place for 21 days.

    (b)The Arms (Prohibited Firearms, Magazines, and Parts) Amendment Act 2019 (the Amendment Act) which took effect from 12 April 2019.

  3. In addition to revoking the Order, the Amendment Act imposed restrictions on licensed arms dealers, amended the endorsement provisions under the Act and made it an offence to sell, supply or possess any prohibited firearms, magazines or gun parts, including semi-automatic firearms.  The Amendment Act put in place a Government buy-back arrangement for the prohibited firearms, magazines and gun parts.

  4. The legislature’s response to the events of 15 March 2019 was not, however, universally approved.  The Kiwi Party was formed by a group of licensed firearms holders with the aim of challenging the lawfulness of the Order and Amendment Act.

Statement of claim

  1. Twelve causes of action are pleaded in the statement of claim filed in the High Court by the Kiwi Party.  Those causes of action seek declarations and orders for, amongst other pronouncements, that the Amendment Act has “no force of law until validated by a subsequent general election or by referendum”. 

  2. The causes of action allege that:

    (a)The Order was ultra vires.[1]

    (b)The members of the Finance and Expenditure Committee (Select Committee) which considered the Bill that became the Amendment Act made material errors of fact;[2] failed to adequately consult and consider submissions on the Bill;[3] predetermined the outcome of its processes;[4] “failed in their duty to provide the checks and balances necessary to maintain a free and democratic society”;[5] took into account irrelevant considerations;[6] failed to take into account a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kiwi Party Incorporated v Attorney-General and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NZCA 80
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Kiwi Party Incorporated sought a judicial review of a decision by the Attorney-General. The subject of the dispute was the constitutionality of the Arms Amendment Act 2019. The High Court of Australia heard the case. The Kiwi Party sought to question the validity of the Amendment Act by questioning the motives and intentions of the Select Committee. The court had to decide whether the Kiwi Party's actions were in breach of section 11 of the Parliamentary Privilege Act.

The Kiwi Party argued that the Amendment Act was inconsistent with the Treaty of Waitangi, and the court should declare the Amendment Act invalid. The court held that the Treaty of Waitangi does not create legal rights that can be breached. The Treaty of Waitangi has to be incorporated into legislation to establish an actionable right. The Kiwi Party's claim that the Treaty of Waitangi created a right to own and possess firearms and firearms parts was dismissed. The court found that the Kiwi Party's causes of action were invalid because they sought to question the proceedings of the Select Committee and the motives and intentions of the members of the Select Committee.

The High Court found that the Kiwi Party's claims were invalid and dismissed the case. The Kiwi Party appealed the decision to the High Court of Australia, which dismissed the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Section 11 defines what is meant by “questioning” proceedings in Parliament contrary to art 9 of the Bill of Rights. Section 11 provides:11 Facts, liability, and judgments or ordersIn proceedings in a court or tribunal, evidence must not be offered or received, and questions must not be asked or statements, submissions, or comments made, concerning proceedings in Parliament, by way of, or for the purpose of, all or any of the following:(a)questioning or relying on the truth, motive, intention, or good faith of anything forming part of those proceedings in Parliament:(b)otherwise questioning or establishing the credibility, motive, intention, or good faith of any person:(c)drawing, or inviting the drawing of, inferences or conclusions wholly or partly from anything forming part of those proceedings in Parliament:(d)proving or disproving, or tending to prove or disprove, any fact necessary for, or incidental to, establishing any liability:(e)resolving any matter, or supporting or resisting any judgment, order, remedy, or relief, arising or sought in the court or tribunal proceedings. The statements attributed to the Chairman of the Select Committee that form the basis of the second and fourth causes of action were not made during the deliberations of the Select Committee, but in a media interview. Nevertheless, those causes of action, as with the other causes of action, question the processes and decisions of the Select Committee. In particular, the second to eighth causes of action all invite the High Court to either:(a)question the truth, motives, intentions and good faith of the Select Committee; or(b)question the proceedings of the Select Committee for the purposes of seeking an order, remedy or relief in the form of a declaration that challenges the legitimacy of the proceedings and decisions made by the Select Committee. These attempts to question the procedures and decisions of the Select Committee breach s 11 of the Parliamentary Privilege Act and are therefore untenable. In its ninth to twelfth causes of action the Kiwi Party seeks declarations that call into question the lawfulness of the Amendment Act. The ninth cause of action seeks a declaration that the Amendment Act breaches the Treaty of Waitangi. This aspect of the case for the Kiwi Party changed between the High Court and this Court. When this cause of action was explained in the High Court it was claimed that the Treaty of Waitangi preserved taonga for Māori and that the Amendment Act removed a taonga when it prohibited the ownership, possession and use of the weapons, magazines and gun parts caught by the Amendment Act. In this Court, the arguments about alleged inconsistencies between the Amendment Act and the Treaty of Waitangi were confined to art 3 of the Treaty. Wylie J reasoned:[27]There is no jurisdiction to make a declaration that the Amendment Act is in breach of the Treaty of Waitangi. The pleading assumes that the Treaty of Waitangi creates legal rights which can be breached. The Treaty of Waitangi, although of “transcendent importance”, does not on its own confer enforceable legal rights. There has to be legislative incorporation of the Treaty to establish an actionable right. [27]Kiwi Party Inc v Attorney-General, above n 13, at [34] (footnotes omitted).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.