Gibbons Holdings Ltd v Wholesale Distributors Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW ZEALAND

SC 53/2005
[2007] NZSC 37

BETWEENWHOLESALE DISTRIBUTORS LIMITED


Appellant

ANDGIBBONS HOLDINGS LIMITED


Respondent

Hearing:7 March 2006

Court:Elias CJ, Blanchard, Tipping, Anderson and Thomas JJ

Counsel:G P Curry and B F Peachey for Appellant


W M Wilson QC and M J Radich for Respondent

Judgment:30 May 2007 

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A.The appeal is dismissed.

B.The appellant is to pay the respondent costs of $15,000 together with its reasonable disbursements to be fixed if necessary by the Registrar.

REASONS

Para No

Elias CJ  [1]
Blanchard J  [9]
Tipping J  [30]
Anderson J  [71]
Thomas J  [77]

ELIAS CJ

[1]       By deed of assignment of lease dated 3 April 1997 GUS Properties Limited assigned to Wholesale Distributors Limited (WDL) all its “estate right title and interest in the Premises and the Lease all as set out in the First Schedule”.  The premises comprised a warehouse and land owned by Port Nelson Limited which were leased under a head lease dated 22 April 1982 to Gibbons Holdings Limited.  The head lease, following renewals, determines on 31 October 2023.  The First Schedule to the deed of assignment of 3 April 1997 set out the legal description of the premises and identified the lease being assigned as the “Deed of Lease dated 10 July 1991” by which Gibbons had subleased the premises to GUS.  Under the deed of sublease between Gibbons and GUS the premises were leased for an initial term determining on 30 October 2002, with the parties expressly obliged to enter into a new lease for a term expiring on 31 October 2010.  The terms of the 1991 sublease between Gibbons and GUS made it clear that the transaction was structured as two leases to avoid the sublease (which was intended to cover a period which straddled the renewal of the head lease) operating as an assignment of the head lease on expiry of its then current term.  The 1997 deed of assignment of lease between GUS and WDL was in printed form, which was adapted by the parties.  Against the printed heading “Expiry Date of Lease” contained in the First Schedule were inserted the words “31 October 2002[1] with a New Lease being granted for a term expiring 31 October 2010”.  By cl 4 of the Second Schedule WDL covenanted with Gibbons in return for Gibbons’s consent to the assignment (required under the terms of the 1991 sublease) that:

from the Date of Assignment and during the remainder of the term of the lease the Assignee will pay the rent provided for in the Lease and keep and perform all the covenants in the Lease.

[1]     In fact, the lease expired on 30 October 2002, as the deed of sublease makes clear.

[2]       Gibbons seeks to enforce the covenant to pay rent against WDL for the term expiring on 31 October 2010.  WDL maintains that its covenant to pay rent is limited…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gibbons Holdings Ltd v Wholesale Distributors Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NZSC 37
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Wholesale Distributors Limited (WDL) is the sublessee of premises held under a deed of sublease from Gibbons Holdings Limited. WDL argues that its obligation to pay rent under the sublease is limited to the term of the initial lease, which expired in 2002. Gibbons contends that WDL is obliged to enter into a new lease for a term expiring in 2010 and to pay the rent under that lease. The Court of Appeal held that WDL was liable for the rent due under the new lease. WDL appealed to the Supreme Court of New Zealand. The Supreme Court held that WDL was liable for the rent due under the new lease. The Court found that the reference to "the remainder of the term of the lease" in the deed of assignment was properly understood as a reference to the expiry date of the intended new lease. The Court also found that the subsequent conduct of WDL in entering into subsequent assignments of the lease for terms extending beyond October 2002 was consistent with the interpretation that WDL was obliged to take up the new lease. The Court rejected the argument that WDL was only obliged to indemnify GUS for any liability GUS might incur arising from default by WDL if it were not also taking on the direct obligation to pay the rental. The Court held that the meaning of the contract was to be objectively assessed in context and that the subsequent conduct of the parties could be helpful evidence as to the meaning of the contract. The appeal was dismissed with costs to the respondent.

Background

Background to the litigation

In 1991, Gibbons Holdings Limited (Gibbons) subleased premises to GUS Properties Limited (GUS) under a deed of sublease. This sublease was structured to last for 12 years less one day, expiring on 30 October 2002. Clause (u) of the sublease provided for a new lease for a period expiring on 31 October 2010. In 1997, GUS assigned its interest under the sublease to Wholesale Distributors Limited (WDL), subject to the consent of Gibbons. The assignment deed included a reference to the new lease in the First Schedule, indicating that the lease would expire on 31 October 2002, with a new lease being granted for a term expiring on 31 October 2010. Clause 4 of the Second Schedule to the assignment deed stated that WDL would pay the rent and keep and perform all the covenants in the lease during the remainder of the term of the lease. The sublease expired on 30 October 2002. Gibbons claimed that WDL was obligated to enter into the new lease and pay the rent due under it. WDL argued that its obligation to pay rent was limited to the term of the lease in existence at the date of the assignment.

The matter was initially heard in the High Court, where Ellen France J held that WDL's obligation to enter into the new lease was only an option and not a requirement. WDL appealed this decision to the Court of Appeal, where the appeal was allowed by McGrath and Glazebrook JJ, but not by Chambers J. WDL further appealed to the Supreme Court of New Zealand.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether WDL, as the assignee of the sublease, is obligated to enter into the new lease and pay the rent due under it.
2. If so, whether the obligation to enter into the new lease and pay the rent is limited to the term of the lease in existence at the date of the assignment or extends to the full term of the new lease.

Held
1. The Court held that WDL, as the assignee of the sublease, is obligated to enter into the new lease and pay the rent due under it. The obligation extends to the full term of the new lease, which was intended to expire on 31 October 2010.
2. The appeal by WDL was dismissed, and WDL was ordered to pay costs to Gibbons.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court examined the contractual documents and the context in which they were created to interpret the obligations of the parties. The deed of sublease between Gibbons and GUS provided for an initial term followed by a new lease, with a clear intention to continue the lease for a full 20-year period. The deed of assignment from GUS to WDL included a reference to the new lease, indicating that WDL was intended to be bound by the obligations under the new lease. The Court found that the phrase "remainder of the term of the lease" in the covenant between WDL and Gibbons should be interpreted in light of the commercial context and the parties' intentions to cover the full 20-year period. The Court also considered the subsequent conduct of the parties, which supported the interpretation that WDL was meant to be liable for the full term of the new lease. The Court concluded that WDL's obligation to enter into the new lease and pay the rent was not limited to the term of the lease in existence at the date of the assignment, but rather extended to the full term of the new lease as intended by the parties.