Audrey Investments Limited v McKillen

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2014-404-2542 [2015] NZHC 2225

UNDER Part 12 of the High Court Rules

IN THE MATTER

of an application for summary judgment

BETWEEN

AUDREY INVESTMENTS LIMITED Plaintiff

AND

SHANE FULTON MCKILLEN First Defendant

SHANE FULTON McKILLEN and MARTIN QUINTON FINE as Trustees of the McKillen Family Trust #3

Hearing: 6 August 2015

Counsel:

MV Robinson and EC Gellert for plaintiff
BD Gustafson and RM Cederwall for defendants

Judgment:

15 September 2015

JUDGMENT OF FAIRE J

This judgment was delivered by me on 15 September 2015 at 4:45 pm], pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date……………

Solicitors:           Simpson Grierson, Auckland

Lowndes Jordan, Auckland

Audrey Investments Limited v McKillen [2015] NZHC 2225 [15 September 2015]

Contents

Introduction ............................................................................................................[1] Background ............................................................................................................[5] The Implementation Deed....................................................................................[21] The courts approach to a summary judgment application .........................................

A plaintiff ’s summary judgment application  [23]

A defendant’s summary judgment application  [31] The issue...............................................................................................................[35] Submissions for the plaintiff ................................................................................[37] Submissions for the defendants............................................................................[42]

Relevant legal principles of contract variation...........................................................

Variation of contract  [46] Joinder of documents  [47] Authenticated signature fiction  [52] Subsequent conduct  [57]

Discussion ............................................................................................................[59] Result....................................................................................................................[66]

Introduction

[1]      The plaintiff seeks summary judgment against the first and second defendants for $2,275,309.76, plus interest on $2,195,200 at 18 per cent from 13 September

2014  until  the  date  of  judgment,  plus  summary  judgment  on  the  defendants’

counterclaim, plus costs on a solicitor/client basis.

[2]      The plaintiff’s claim is made under a guarantee.  Ex-VCL Ltd (in receivership and in liquidation) referred to in this judgment as “VNC” had issued redeemable preference shares (referred to in this judgment as “RPS”) to the plaintiff that were due to be redeemed on 30 June 2014.  The defendants guaranteed VNC’s repayment

obligations to the plaintiff.  The plaintiff has made demand and has not been paid. On the face of the guarantee, the amount claimed is owing.

[3]      The defendants raised three defences to the plaintiff’s claim. All three arise out of an allegation that at a board meeting on 8 May 2014, Mr Couillault, who was then a director of both the plaintiff and VNC, agreed on behalf of the plaintiff orally with VNC to extend the RPS redemption date to 31 December 2014. As a result, the defendants say:

(a)      That  the  plaintiff  and  VNC  contractually  agreed  to  extend  the redemption  to  31 December  2014  and  that  what  followed  was  a breach of that agreement by the plaintiff, which the defendants as guarantors are entitled to rely upon to resist the plaintiff’s claim;

(b)That  the  plaintiff’s  statement  that  it  had  agreed  to  extend  the redemption date amounted to misleading and deceptive conduct in breach of the Fair Trading Act 1986; and

(c)      That the plaintiff was estopped from enforcing the guarantee because VNC and the defendants, the guarantors, relied on the plaintiff’s statement and suffered detriment as a result.

[4]      The defendants have combined their statement of defence and counterclaim. In the counterclaim they reframe the three defences as alternative causes…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Audrey Investments Limited v McKillen and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 2225
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Audrey Investments Limited (Audrey) sought summary judgment against Shane Fulton McKillen and Martin Quinton Fine as Trustees of the McKillen Family Trust #3 (the defendants) for $2,275,309.76 plus interest and costs, claiming that the defendants had breached a guarantee agreement. The defendants raised three defences and counterclaims, arguing that Audrey had orally agreed to extend the redemption date for redeemable preference shares (RPS) from 30 June 2014 to 31 December 2014, which would mean that Audrey could not now claim the original amount due. The central issue was whether Audrey had agreed to this extension on 8 May 2014, and if so, whether this agreement was conditional on Collins Asset Management (CAM) providing funding to VNC. The court held that the application for summary judgment was premature as there were disputed issues of material fact that required resolution at trial, including the credibility of the evidence and the terms of any alleged oral agreement. The court also noted that the defendants might be able to use the joinder of documents and authenticated signature fiction to establish a written variation, but this was a matter for trial. The court dismissed both the plaintiff’s and the defendants’ applications for summary judgment and reserved costs. The court also gave directions for the future conduct of the proceeding, including deadlines for filing pleadings, completing discovery, and holding a case management conference.