Jefferson v Straw Homes Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NAPIER REGISTRY

CIV 2016-441-143 [2017] NZHC 1766

BETWEEN

JOHN SCOTT JEFFERSON AND

MORAG EILEAN WILSON Appellants

AND

STRAW HOMES LIMITED First Respondent

RICHARD ERNEST NEILL Second Respondent

Hearing: 31 May 2017

Appearances:

D Kerr for the Appellants
P J Shamy for the Respondents

Judgment:

28 July 2017

JUDGMENT OF MALLON J

Introduction

[1]      Straw Homes (the first respondent) was employed to build a home for Mr Jefferson and Ms Wilson (the appellants).   There were delays and significant cost overruns in the work.  The appellants refused to pay for these overruns contending that there was a fixed price contract.   They purported to cancel the contract and employed other contractors to complete the house.

[2]     Straw Homes brought a claim for its unpaid invoices.   The appellants counterclaimed  against  Straw  Homes,  and  its  principal  Mr Neill  (the  second respondent),  alleging  their  actions  were  negligent  and  seeking  damages  in  the

amount of the costs it incurred in completing the work on the house.

JEFFERSON v STRAW HOMES LIMITED [2017] NZHC 1766 [28 July 2017]

[3]      The  District  Court  Judge  (Judge  Gibson)  found  there  was  no  fixed  fee contract.1     He found Straw Homes and Mr Neill negligent in that they failed to advise the appellants of the cost implications of building a larger house and of agreed variations.   However he found the appellants had suffered no loss.   He therefore dismissed their claim.

[4]      The appellants appeal against the District Court decision. They also apply for leave to adduce further evidence.

The facts

[5]      The appellants wished to build a straw bale house.  That form of construction is  uncommon  in  New  Zealand.   The  appellants  initially had  some  difficulty in finding  a suitably qualified  builder.    Eventually they learnt  of  Straw  Homes,  a company  which  had  previously  built  houses  using  this  construction  method. Mr Jefferson made enquiries of Mr Neill and inspected houses that Straw Homes were currently building using this method.

[6]      On  30  September  2008,  having  decided  to  proceed  with  the  build,  the appellants and Straw Homes signed an agreement for the work.  The agreement was in the New Zealand Institute of Architects’ standard form for “National Building Contracts Small Works”.   The agreement was  described as being for “managed labour only”.  The contract price was not stated.  The commencement date for the work was 1 February 2009.  Progress payments were to be made every two weeks.

[7]      The agreement permitted the appellants to engage other contractors to carry out work on the build.  It provided a process for variations (meaning any change to the contract works).  Under this process the appellants were permitted to direct Straw Homes to carry out variations.   The direction was to be in writing.   Unless the appellants otherwise directed in writing, the value of a variation was to be agreed before Straw Homes started work on it.

[8]      There was no description of the contract work in the agreement.  Nor were plans or specifications attached.  The completion date was also not specified.  This is because…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jefferson v Straw Homes Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 1766
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Jefferson v Straw Homes Limited involved a dispute between the appellants, John Scott Jefferson and Morag Eilean Wilson, and Straw Homes Limited, a building company contracted to construct a straw bale house for the appellants. The appellants alleged that Straw Homes Limited, along with its principal, Richard Ernest Neill, failed to complete the construction within a reasonable time and for no more than the agreed fixed ceiling cost, recommended and used unsuitable roofing material, and failed to properly manage and supervise subcontractors and suppliers of materials. The appellants also sought damages for the additional costs incurred in completing the build after cancelling the contract with Straw Homes Limited.

The District Court found that Straw Homes Limited was entitled to recover its unpaid invoices. However, it dismissed all of the claims brought by the appellants against Straw Homes Limited and Mr Neill, holding that Straw Homes Limited and Mr Neill had been negligent only in one aspect. Nevertheless, the appellants were not proven to have suffered any loss as a result of this negligence. The appellants appealed the District Court decision.

The court found that the contract was not a fixed price contract, as a reasonable and properly informed third party would consider the parties intended the words "contract price" to mean this was the estimated price of the build for a floor area of 278 m2. The court also found that the appellants had failed to prove they suffered any loss, as the larger house they received for their expenditure was commensurate with their additional costs. Therefore, the appeal was dismissed, and scale costs should follow the event.