Evans v IAG New Zealand Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA ŌTAUTAHI ROHE

CIV-2019-409-705

[2020] NZHC 1326

BETWEEN

PAUL FREDERICK WILLIAM EVANS and JOY ELIZABETH EVANS

Plaintiffs

AND

IAG NEW ZEALAND LIMITED

First Defendant

INTERNATIONAL STRATEGIC DEVELOPMENT NEW ZEALAND LIMITED

Second Defendant

QBE INSURANCE (AUSTRALIA) LIMITED

Third Defendant

Hearing: 18 February 2020

Counsel:

C R Johnstone for Plaintiffs

M Ring QC and P M Smith for First Defendant No appearance for Second Defendant

D H McLellan QC for Third Defendant J McGuigan as amicus curiae

Judgment:

12 June 2020


JUDGMENT OF CHURCHMAN J


Introduction

[1]                 This proceeding concerns a case currently being heard in the Canterbury Earthquakes Insurance Tribunal (the Tribunal). The first respondent in that case, IAG New Zealand Ltd (IAG) has applied for referral of a question of law from the Tribunal to the High Court pursuant to s 53 of the Canterbury Earthquakes Insurance Tribunal Act 2019 (the Act).

EVANS and ANOR v IAG NEW ZEALAND LIMITED & ORS [2020] NZHC 1326 [12 June 2020]

Factual background

[2]                 Mr and Mrs Evans own a house at 3 Kimbolton Lane, Huntsbury, Christchurch. The house was damaged in the 2010 and 2011 Canterbury earthquakes. It was insured under a State Home Comprehensive Policy and had been so insured since it was built in 1998. Following the 22 February 2011 earthquake, Mr and Mrs Evans lodged an insurance claim with IAG (the parent company of State Insurance) for repairs on the damage to their house. This was accepted, and Mr and Mrs Evans entered into a contract with ISD, the second respondent, to repair the house, for a final contract price of $347,464.07, which IAG duly paid in total following completion of the repairs.

[3]                 Mr and Mrs Evans found the repair work to be defective and subsequently applied to the Tribunal to compel IAG to pay the costs of remedying the defective repair work. IAG disputes this application. Mr and Mrs Evans’ primary cause of action in their claim against IAG is that IAG’s obligations under the policy are not discharged until their house has been repaired to the policy standard, which in their view includes remedying defective repair work to achieve that policy standard. Put another way, the Evans’ argument is that if repair work has been carried out, but at the end of the work, the house has not been properly repaired, then IAG has not met the obligation to pay for the house to be repaired to the policy standard irrespective of the reason why the repairs have not achieved that result.

[4]                 Mr and Mrs Evans filed a joint affidavit in these proceedings. One of the topics it dealt with was the claims assessment process implemented by IAG. They deposed that once the Earthquake Commission (EQC) had confirmed that their house was over cap, State Insurance introduced them to their Canterbury Recovery Home Repair programme. They met with Mark Bone of IAG and Mike Toohey from Hawkins on 23 August 2012.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Evans v IAG New Zealand Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NZHC 1326
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court was asked to consider a question of law referred to it by the Canterbury Earthquakes Insurance Tribunal (the Tribunal) in the context of proceedings brought by Mr and Mrs Evans against IAG New Zealand Ltd (IAG) in relation to insurance claims arising from damage to their Christchurch home following the Canterbury earthquakes of 2010 and 2011. The question was whether IAG’s policy obligation to pay the cost of repairing the house to the policy standard, as and when incurred by the insured, included an obligation to pay for the reasonable cost required to remedy defective repair work. The question was referred to the Court pursuant to s 53 of the Canterbury Earthquakes Insurance Tribunal Act 2019 (the Act). The Court was required to determine whether the post-contractual conduct of IAG could be considered in determining the meaning of the contract, and whether there were any factual issues that prevented the Court from answering the question. The Court concluded that subsequent conduct is admissible as an aid to contractual interpretation, but it must be considered in the context of the overall determination of what a reasonable person, having all the background knowledge reasonably available to the parties at the time of contract, would consider the contract or term to mean. The Court also concluded that the post-claim subsequent conduct of IAG is admissible as an aid to interpreting the meaning of the policy, in order to properly colour the factual background and context of the case required for an objective assessment of the meaning of the policy clause in question. The Court held that the issue of whether the policy is merely a “to pay” one or one involving liability on IAG for the costs to remedy a defective repair, will need to be resolved by the Tribunal. The issue of whether IAG has discharged its policy obligation to meet the cost of repairing the home to an as new standard when the repairs have not achieved that result is not capable of being answered in these case-stated proceedings.