Water Efficiency Labelling and Standards Regulator v Renaissance Traditional Bathrooms Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Water Efficiency Labelling and Standards Regulator v Renaissance Traditional Bathrooms Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 1456

File number: ACD 42 of 2019
Judgment of: CHEESEMAN J
Date of judgment: 9 December 2022
Catchwords: CONSUMER LAW – Water Efficiency Labelling and Standards (WELS) scheme – contravention of civil penalty provisions – where three solvent respondents admit contraventions – where two insolvent respondents deemed to have admitted contraventions – where penalties for three solvent respondents agreed – where contravening conduct is deliberate and persistent – consideration of the requirements of the WELS scheme – whether agreed penalties for three solvent respondents appropriate – whether penalties proposed by the WELS Regulator are appropriate for two insolvent respondents  – Held: orders made  
Legislation:

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ss 140, 187

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 26

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 16.07

Water Efficiency Labelling and Standards Act 2005 (Cth) ss 33, 34, 44, 44A, 44C, 44D, 44F, 44M, 44Q

Water Efficiency Labelling and Standards Determination 2013 (No. 2) (Cth) ss 6, 7, 8

Water Efficiency Labelling and Standards (Registration Fees) Amendment Determination 2015 (No. 1) Sch 1

Australian Standard AS/NZS 6400:2016 Water efficient products – Rating and labelling

Cases cited:

Ainsworth v Criminal Justice Commission [1992] HCA 10; 175 CLR 564

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2018] HCA 3; 262 CLR 157

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Pattinson [2022] HCA 13; 399 ALR 599

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Apple Pty Ltd (No 4) [2018] FCA 953

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Australian Safeway Stores Pty Ltd [1997] FCA 450; (1997) 145 ALR 36

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Birubi Art Pty Ltd (in liq) (No 3) [2019] FCA 996

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Cement Australia Pty Ltd [2017] FCAFC 159

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 1405

AustralianCompetition and Consumer Commission v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2006] FCA 1730

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v EnergyAustralia Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 336

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Geowash Pty Ltd (Subject to a Deed of Co Arrangement) (No 4) [2020] FCA 23

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Google LLC (No 4) [2022] FCA 942

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v MSY Technology Pty Ltd [2012] FCAFC 56

AustralianCompetition and Consumer Commission v Real Estate Institute of Western Australia Inc [1999] FCA 18; 161 ALR 79

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Reckitt Benckiser (Australia) Pty Ltd [2016] FCAFC 181; 340 ALR 25

AustralianCompetition and Consumer Commission v Target Australia Pty Ltd [2001] FCA 1326

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Telstra [2021] FCA 502

AustralianCompetition and Consumer Commission v Virgin Mobile Australia Pty Ltd (No 2) [2002] FCA 1548

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Yazaki Corporation [2018] FCAFC 73; 262 FCR 243

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Water Efficiency Labelling and Standards Regulator v Renaiss... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCA 1456
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the court involved proceedings brought by the Water Efficiency Labelling and Standards (WELS) Regulator against several respondents who were alleged to have contravened the Water Efficiency Labelling and Standards Act 2012 (Cth) (WELS Act). The primary legal issues the court needed to decide were whether the solvent respondents had contravened the WELS Act, and if so, what appropriate penalties should be imposed. Additionally, the court had to determine whether the insolvent respondents had contravened the WELS Act and, if so, what penalties were appropriate.

The court found that all respondents had indeed contravened the WELS Act. The solvent respondents had admitted to the contraventions, and the insolvent respondents, who were in liquidation, were deemed to have admitted the contraventions by not filing a defence as required. The court considered the nature and extent of the contraventions, the circumstances in which they took place, and whether the respondents had previous similar conduct. It was found that the contraventions were deliberate and persistent. The court also considered the requirements of the WELS scheme and the need for deterrence. The penalties proposed by the Regulator were deemed appropriate, taking into account the gravity of the contraventions and the need to deter future breaches.

The court ordered that the solvent respondents be restrained from supplying unregistered WELS products and products without the required labelling for five years. The insolvent respondents were also restrained from such conduct, but enforcement of these orders against the insolvent respondents was considered for reasons of general deterrence. The court ordered pecuniary penalties for the insolvent respondents and directed that they pay the WELS Regulator's costs. The solvent respondents were ordered to pay a contribution to the WELS Regulator's costs, with the payment to be made in instalments.

Orders

Orders of the court

Renaissance Bathrooms

9. Pursuant to s 44 of the WELS Act Renaissance Bathrooms be restrained for a period of 5 years from the date of the Court’s order, whether by itself, its servants, agents or otherwise howsoever, from taking any steps to supply (within the meaning of s 7A of the WELS Act):

(a) products which are not registered as required by the WELS Determination (as in force from time to time);

(b) products without the water efficiency labelling and/or text advice required under the WELS Determination (as in force from time to time).

Belfast Sinks

10. Pursuant to s 44 of the WELS Act Belfast Sinks be restrained for a period of 5 years from the date of the Court’s order, whether by itself, its servants, agents or otherwise howsoever, from taking any steps to supply (within the meaning of s 7A of the WELS Act):

(a) products which are not registered as required by the WELS Determination (as in force from time to time);

(b) products without the water efficiency labelling and/or text advice required under the WELS Determination (as in force from time to time).

Andrew Shaw

11. Pursuant to s 44 of the WELS Act Andrew Shaw be restrained for a period of 5 years from the date of the Court’s order, from supplying (within the meaning of s 7A of the WELS Act), or being directly or indirectly involved, or knowingly concerned in any way, in such supply, of:

(a) products which are not registered as required by the WELS Determination (as in force from time to time);

(b) products without the water efficiency labelling and/or text advice required under the WELS Determination (as in force from time to time).

BY CONSENT, THE COURT ORDERS:

Costs

12. Renaissance Bathrooms, Belfast Sinks and Andrew Shaw, jointly and severally, pay a contribution in the total sum of $75,000 to the Applicant’s costs of the proceedings.

Payment Schedule

13. The amount in Order 6 above be paid in instalments according to the following schedule:

(a) $5,000, two months after these orders are made;

(b) 14 monthly payments of $10,000, commencing one month after the payment referred to at 13(a); and

(c) $5,000, one month after the last payment referred to at 13(b).

14. In the event that any of the instalment payments in Order 13 above is not made within the time specified for that instalment, the full remaining balance of the penalty in Order 6 that has not been paid will be immediately due and payable, with interest accruing from the date these orders are made.

15. The amount in Order 7 above be paid within 28 days of these orders being made.

16. The amount in Order 8 above be paid within 28 days of these orders being made.

17. The amount in Order 12 above be paid within 28 days of these orders being made.

D. INSOLVENT RESPONDENTS (TRADITIONAL TAPS AND CASTIRONBATHS)

DECLARATIONS

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

Contraventions by Traditional Taps, the Second Respondent

18. During the period 27 March 2017 to 20 November 2019, Traditional Taps contravened s 33 of the WELS Act on a daily basis in relation to each of the 46 tap, shower and lavatory products in rows 1 to 46 of Annexure B, by advertising those products on its website when those products were not registered as required under the WELS Determination.

19. During the period 2 February 2017 to 20 November 2019, Traditional Taps contravened s 34 of the WELS Act on a daily basis in relation to each of the 25 tap, shower and lavatory products in rows 47 to 60 and 62 to 72 of Annexure B, by advertising those products on its website without the water efficiency labelling and text advice required for each product under the WELS Determination.

Contraventions by Castironbaths, the Third Respondent

20. During the period 22 May 2018 to 18 November 2019 Castironbaths contravened s 33 of the WELS Act on a daily basis in relation to each of the 13 tap and shower products in rows 1 to 13 of Annexure C, by advertising those products on its website when those products were not registered as required under the WELS Determination.

21. During the period 29 May 2018 to 19 November 2019 Castironbaths contravened s 33 of the WELS Act on a daily basis in relation to each of the 55 tap and shower products in rows 1 to 55 of Annexure D, by advertising those products on the Farmhouse Sinks website when those products were not registered as required under the WELS Determination.

22. During the period 22 May 2018 to 18 November 2019, Castironbaths contravened s 34 of the WELS Act on a daily basis in relation to each of the 25 tap, shower and lavatory products in rows 14 to 39 of Annexure C, by advertising those products on its website without the water efficiency labelling and/or text advice required for each product under the WELS Determination.

23. During the period 30 May 2018 to 19 November 2019, Castironbaths contravened s 34 of the WELS Act on a daily basis in relation to each of the 24 tap and shower products in rows 56 to 80 of Annexure D, by advertising those products on the Farmhouse Sinks website without the water efficiency labelling and/or text advice required for each product under the WELS Determination.

24. On 5 June 2015, Castironbaths contravened s 33 of the WELS Act on a total of 3 occasions by selling one tap, one shower and one lavatory product when those products were not registered as required under the WELS Determination.

PECUNIARY PENALTIES

25. For the contraventions of the WELS Act described in paragraphs 18 and 19 above, Traditional Taps, pay to the Commonwealth of Australia a pecuniary penalty of $750,000.

26. For the contraventions of the WELS Act described in paragraph 20 to 24 above, Castironbaths, pay to the Commonwealth of Australia a pecuniary penalty of $1,070,000.

Costs

27. Traditional Taps and Castironbaths pay the Applicant’s costs of the proceedings.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

ANNEXURE A: RENAISSANCE BATHROOMS PRODUCTS

Product No.

Product Description

WELS Product Kind

Registration Number

RB42

Porcelain Handle - Bath Shower Mixer on Pipe Stands Chrome - Code: BSM+P-CP

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

RB43

Porcelain Handle - Basin Pillar Taps Chrome Pair - Code: RE 10 CP

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

RB44

X Handle - Basin 3 Hole Set Chrome - Code: RE 60 X CP

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

RB45

X Handle - Monobloc Basin Mixer Chrome - Code: RE 40 X CP

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

RB46

X Handle - Basin 3 Hole Set Wall Chrome - Code: RE 70 X CP

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

RB47

X Handle - Bath Shower Mixer Chrome - Code: RE 30 X CP

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

RB48

X Handle - Bath Shower Mixer on Pipe Stands Chrome - Code: BSMX+P-CP

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

RB49

X Handle - Basin Pillar Taps Chrome Pair - Code: RE 10 X CP

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

RB50

Porcelain Handle - Bib Sink Taps Chrome Pair - Code: RE 10 BIBCP

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

RB51

Porcelain Handle - High Neck Pillar Taps Pair Chrome - Code: RE 10 HN-CP

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

RB52

Porcelain Handle - Bridge Sink Mixer Chrome - Code: RE 65 CP

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20496

RB53

Porcelain Handle - Wall Bridge Sink Mixer Chrome - Code: RE 65 WM CP

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20496

RB54

Porcelain Handle - Monobloc Kitchen Mixer Chrome - Code: RE 55 CP

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20494

RB55

Porcelain Handle - Monobloc Basin Mixer With English Spout Chrome – Code: RE 55ES-CP

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20495

RB56

Porcelain Handle - Monobloc High Neck Sink Mixer Chrome - Code: RE 57-CP

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20492

RB57

Porcelain Handle - Sink Mixer - Swivelling Spout Sink Chrome - Code: RE 25H-CP

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20493

RB58

Porcelain Handle - Basin 3 Hole Set Chrome - Code: RE 60 CP

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20498

RB59

Ceramique - Exposed Valve, Rigid Kit Chrome - Code: CD 1500 ACP

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10102

RB60

Ceramique - Exposed Valve, Rigid to Flex Kit Chrome - Code: CD 1500 ACP-RF

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10093

RB61

Ceramique - Exposed Valve, Rigid to Handshower Kit Chrome – Code: CD 1500 ACP-RH

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10094

RB62

Ceramique - Concealed Valve Arm Kit Chrome - Code: CD 1500 ACCP

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10101

RB63

Ceramique - Concealed Valve Flex Kit Chrome - Code: CD 1500 ACCP-F

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10091

ANNEXURE B: TRADITIONAL TAPS PRODUCTS

Product No.

Product Description

WELS Product Kind

Registration Number

TT1

Sink Mixer with Extendable Vegie Sprayer - Porcelain Lever

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

TT2

Sink Mixer with Extendable Vegie Sprayer - Metal Lever

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

TT3

High Neck Pillar Taps - Porcelain Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

TT4

High Neck Pillar Taps - Metal Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

TT5

High Neck Pillar Taps - Cross Handles

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

TT6

Colonial Bathroom Taps - Goose Spout - Metal Lever

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

TT7

Colonial Bathroom Tap - Goose Spout - Cross Handles

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

TT8

Art Deco Bathroom Taps - Low Level Spout - Porcelain Lever

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

TT9

Art Deco Bathroom Taps - Low Level Spout - Metal Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

TT10

Art Deco Bathroom Taps - Low Level Spout - Cross Handles

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

TT11

Heritage Bathroom Tap - Porcelain Lever

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

TT12

Heritage Bathroom Tap - Cross Handle

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

TT13

Heritage Bathroom Tap - Metal Lever

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

TT14

English Bathroom Tap - Porcelain Lever

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

TT15

English Bathroom Tap - Metal Lever

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

TT16

Art Deco Basin Three Hole Set - Porcelain Lever

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

TT17

Art Deco Basin Three Hole Set - Metal Lever

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

TT18

Art Deco Basin Three Hole Set - Cross Handles

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

TT19

Heritage Basin Three Hole Set with Concealed Spout - Porcelain Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

TT20

Heritage Basin Three Hole Set with Concealed Spout - Metal Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

TT21

Heritage Basin Three Hole Set with Concealed Spout - Cross Handles

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

TT22

Traditional Bath Shower Mixer - Deck Mounted

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

TT23

Traditional Bath Shower Mixer - Wall Mounted

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

TT24

Traditional Bath Shower Mixer On Pipe Stands - Metal Lever

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

TT25

Traditional Bath Shower Mixer On Pipe Stands - Cross Handle

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

TT26

Heritage Bathroom Wall Tap Shower System - Porcelain Levers

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

TT27

Heritage Bathroom Wall Tap Shower System - Metal Levers

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

TT28

Heritage Bathroom Wall Tap Shower System - Cross Handles

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

TT29

Antique Shower System - Porcelain Levers

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

TT30

Antique Shower System - Metal Levers

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

TT31

Art Deco Shower System With Arm Rose Diverter & Slide Bar Handshower - Porcelain Levers

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

TT32

Art Deco Shower System With Arm Rose Diverter & Slide Bar Handshower - Metal Levers

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

TT33

Art Deco Shower System With Arm Rose Diverter & Slide Bar Handshower - Cross Handles

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

TT34

Traditional Shower Rose & J Neck

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

TT35

Clasic [sic] Shower Rose & S Neck

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

TT36

High Standing Toilet Toilet

Lavatory - s6(1)(e)

N/A

TT37

High Standing Winchester Toilet - White Seat

Lavatory - s6(1)(e)

N/A

TT38

Traditional Bath Shower Mixer On Pipe Stands - Porcelain Lever

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

TT39

Brunel - Old English Bridge Sink Mixer - Porcelain Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

TT40

Brunel - Old English Bridge Sink Mixer - Metal Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

TT41

English Lever Taps - English Tap Spout - Porcelain Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

TT42

English Lever Taps - English Tap Spout - Metal Lever

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

TT43

English Lever Taps - English Tap Spout - Cross Handles

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

TT44

Colonial Bathroom Taps - Goose Spout - Porcelain Lever

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

TT45

Traditional Concealed Shower System Arm Rose Diverter & Flexible Kit - Porcelain Levers

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

TT46

Traditional Concealed Shower System Arm Rose Diverter & Flexible Kit - Metal Levers

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

TT47

Traditional Kitchen Tap

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20492

TT48

Kitchen Mixer Tap - later called 'Traditional Kitchen Mixer Tap' or 'Traditional Kitchen Mixer Tap - Metal Levers'

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20496

TT49

Traditional Kitchen Tap (later called 'Traditional Kitchen Tap - Porcelain Lever')

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20492

TT50

Antique Concealed Shower - Traditional Shower Mixer (Later called 'Traditional Shower System' or 'Traditional Shower System -Porcelain Lever')

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10101

TT51

Antique Hand Shower - Traditional Shower

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10091

TT52

Antique Flexi Shower -Mizer Shower Taps (Later called 'Heritage Shower System Arm Rose Diverter & Flexible Kit - Porcelain Lever')

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10093

TT53

Traditional Exposed Shower System (Later called ' Traditional Exposed Shower System - Porcelain Level')

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10102

TT54

Traditional Kitchen Mixer Tap - Porcelain Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20496

TT55

Traditional Kitchen Mixer Tap - Wall Mounted - Porcelain Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20496

TT56

Traditional Kitchen Mixer Tap - Wall Mounted - Metal Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20496

TT57

Victorain [sic] Kitchen Tap - Porcelain Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20494

TT58

Victorain [sic] Kitchen Tap - Metal Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20494

TT59

Country Farmhouse Kitchen Tap - Porcelain Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20495

TT60

Country Farmhouse Kitchen Tap - Metal Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20495

TT61

Country Farmhouse Kitchen Tap - Cross Handles

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20495

TT62

Traditional Kitchen Tap - Metal Lever

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20492

TT63

Brunel - Old English Kitchen Tap - Cross Handles

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20497

TT64

Traditional Exposed Shower System - Metal Lever

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10102

TT65

Traditional Shower System - Metal Lever

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10101

TT66

Traditional Shower With Flexible Kit - Porcelain Lever

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10092

TT67

Traditional Shower With Flexible Kit - Metal Lever

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10092

TT68

Traditional Concealed Shower With Flexible Kit - Metal Lever

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10091

TT69

Heritage Shower System Arm Rose Diverter & Flexible Kit - Metal Lever

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10093

TT70

Heritage Exposed Shower System Arm Rose Diverter & Handshower - Porcelain Lever

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10094

TT71

Heritage Exposed Shower System Arm Rose Diverter & Handshower - Metal Lever

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10094

TT72

Classic Toilet

Lavatory - s6(1)(e)

L01764

ANNEXURE C: CASTIRONBATHS PRODUCTS

ProductNo.

Product description

WELS Product Kind

Registration Number

CB1

English Lever Tap - English Tap Spout - Porcelain Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

CB2

English Lever Tap - English Tap Spout - Metal Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

CB3

English Lever Tap - English Tap Spout - Cross Handles

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

CB4

Colonial Bathroom Taps - Goose Spout - Cross Handles

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

CB5

English Lever Taps - English Tap Spout - Porcelain Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

CB6

Country Kitchen Tap - Cross Handles

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

CB7

Sink Mixer with Extendable Vegie Sprayer - Porcelain Lever

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

CB8

Brunel - Old English Bridge Kitchen Sink Mixer - Porcelain Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

CB9

Brunel - Old English Bridge Kitchen Sink Mixer - Metal Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

CB10

High Neck Single Pillar Tap single only - Porcelain Levers Pewter / Porcelain Lever

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

CB11

Traditional Concealed Shower System Arm Rose Diverter & Flexible Kit - Porcelain Levers

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

CB12

Traditional Concealed Shower System Arm Rose Diverter & Flexible Kit - Metal Levers

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

CB13

Art Deco Shower System With Arm Rose Diverter & Slide Bar Handshower - Porcelain Levers

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

CB14

Traditional Exposed Shower System - Porcelain Lever

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10102

CB15

Traditional Exposed Shower System - Metal Lever

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10102

CB16

Traditional Shower System - Porcelain Lever

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10101

CB17

Traditional Shower System - Metal Lever

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10101

CB18

Traditional Shower Mixer Concealed Valve Only - Porcelain Lever

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10101

CB19

Traditional Shower Mixer Concealed Valve Only - Metal Lever

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10101

CB20

Traditional Concealed Shower With Flexible Kit - Porcelain Lever

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10091

CB21

Traditional Concealed Shower With Flexible Kit - Metal Lever

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10091

CB22

Traditional Shower With Flexible Kit - Porcelain Lever

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10092

CB23

Traditional Shower With Flexible Kit - Metal Lever

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10092

CB24

Heritage Shower System Arm Rose Diverter & Flexible Kit - Porcelain Lever

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10093

CB25

Heritage Shower System Arm Rose Diverter & Flexible Kit - Metal Lever

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10093

CB26

Heritage Exposed Shower System Arm Rose Diverter & Handshower - Porcelain Lever

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10094

CB27

Classic Toilet

Lavatory - s6(1)(e)

L01764

CB28

Traditional Kitchen Bridge Mixer Tap - Porcelain Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20496

CB29

Traditional Kitchen Bridge Mixer Tap - Metal Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20496

CB30

Traditional Kitchen Mixer Wall Mounted - Porcelain Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20496

CB31

Traditional Kitchen Mixer Wall Mounted - Metal Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20496

CB32

Victorain Kitchen Tap - Porcelain Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20494

CB33

Victorian Kitchen Tap - Metal Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20494

CB34

Country Kitchen Tap - Porcelain Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20495

CB35

Country Kitchen Tap - Metal Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20495

CB36

Traditional Kitchen Tap - Porcelain Lever

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20492

CB37

Traditional Kitchen Tap - Metal Lever

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20492

CB38

Brunel - Old English Bridge Kitchen Sink Mixer - Cross Handles

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20497

CB39

Country Farmhouse Kitchen Tap - Metal Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20495

ANNEXURE D: FARMHOUSE SINKS PRODUCTS

Product No.

Product description

WELS Product Kind

Registration Number

FS1

Antique Shower System - Metal Levers

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

FS2

Antique Shower System - Porcelain Levers

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

FS3

Art Deco Basin Three Hole Set - Cross Handles

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

FS4

Art Deco Basin Three Hole Set - Metal Lever

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

FS5

Art Deco Basin Three Hole Set - Porcelain Lever

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

FS6

Art Deco Bathroom Taps - Low Level Spout - Cross Handles

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

FS7

Art Deco Bathroom Taps - Low Level Spout - Cross Handles

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

FS8

Art Deco Bathroom Taps - Low Level Spout - Cross Handles

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

FS9

Art Deco Bathroom Taps- Low Level Spout - Porcelain Lever

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

FS10

Art Deco Bathroom Taps- Low Level Spout - Porcelain Lever

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

FS11

Art Deco Bathroom Taps- Low Level Spout - Porcelain Lever

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

FS12

Art Deco Shower System With Arm Rose Diverter & Slide Bar Handshower - Cross Handles

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

FS13

Art Deco Shower System With Arm Rose Diverter & Slide Bar Handshower - Metal Levers

Shower -s6(1)(b)

N/A

FS14

Art Deco Shower System With Arm Rose Diverter & Slide Bar Handshower - Porcelain

Levers

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

FS15

Brunel - Old English Bridge Kitchen Sink Mixer - Metal Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

FS16

Brunel - Old English Bridge Kitchen Sink Mixer - Porcelain Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

FS17

Clasic Shower Rose & S Neck

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

FS18

Clasic Shower Rose & S Neck

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

FS19

Clasic Shower Rose & S Neck

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

FS20

Colonial Bathroom Tap - Goose Spout - Cross Handles

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

FS21

Colonial Bathroom Tap - Goose Spout - Cross Handles

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

FS22

Colonial Bathroom Tap - Goose Spout - Cross Handles

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

FS23

Colonial Bathroom Taps - Goose Spout - Metal Lever

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

FS24

Colonial Bathroom Taps - Goose Spout - Metal Lever

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

FS25

Colonial Bathroom Taps - Goose Spout - Metal Lever

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

FS26

Copy of Traditional Kitchen Mixer Wall Mounted - Porcelain Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

FS27

Country Kitchen Tap - Cross Handles

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

FS28

English Bathroom Tap - Metal Lever

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

FS29

English Bathroom Tap - Porcelain Lever

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

FS30

English Lever Tap - English Tap Spout - Metal Lever

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

FS31

English Lever Tap - English Tap Spout - Metal Lever

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

FS32

English Lever Tap - English Tap Spout - Metal Lever

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

FS33

English Lever Taps - English Tap Spout - Porcelain Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

FS34

English Lever Taps - English Tap Spout - Porcelain Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

FS35

English Lever Taps - English Tap Spout - Porcelain Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

FS36

Heritage Basin Three Hole Set with Concealed Spout - Cross Handles

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

FS37

Heritage Basin Three Hole Set with Concealed Spout - Metal Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

FS38

Heritage Basin Three Hole Set with Concealed Spout - Porcelain Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

FS39

Heritage Bathroom Wall Tap Shower System - Cross Handles

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

FS40

Heritage Bathroom Wall Tap Shower System - Metal Levers

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

FS41

Heritage Bathroom Wall Tap Shower System - Porcelain Levers

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

FS42

High Neck Pillar Taps - Cross handles

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

FS43

High Neck Pillar Taps - Metal Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

FS44

High Neck Pillar Taps - Porcelain Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

FS45

Sink Mixer with Extendable Vegie Sprayer - Porcelain Lever

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

FS46

Traditional Bath Shower Mixer On Pipe Stands - Cross Handle

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

FS47

Traditional Bath Shower Mixer On Pipe Stands - Metal Lever

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

FS48

Traditional Bath Shower Mixer On Pipe Stands - Porcelain Lever

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

FS49

Traditional Concealed Shower System Arm Rose Diverter & Flexible Kit - Metal Levers

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

FS50

Traditional Concealed Shower System Arm Rose Diverter & Flexible Kit - Porcelain Levers

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

FS51

Traditional Kitchen Mixer Wall Mounted – Metal Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

FS52

Traditional Kitchen Mixer Wall Mounted – Porcelain Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

FS53

Traditional Shower Rose & J Neck

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

FS54

Traditional Shower Rose & J Neck

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

FS55

Traditional Shower Rose & J Neck

Shower - s6(1)(b)

N/A

FS56

Victorain Kitchen Tap - Porcelain Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

N/A

FS57

Victorian Kitchen Tap - Metal Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20494

FS58

Brunel - Old English Bridge Kitchen Sink Mixer - Cross Handles

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20497

FS59

Country Kitchen Tap - Metal Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20495

FS60

Traditional Kitchen Bridge Mixer Tap - Porcelain Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20496

FS61

Traditional Kitchen Tap - Metal Lever

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20492

FS62

Traditional Shower System - Metal Lever

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10101

FS63

Traditional Shower System - Porcelain Lever

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10101

FS64

Traditional Shower With Flexible Kit - Metal Lever

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10092

FS65

Traditional Shower With Flexible Kit - Porcelain Lever

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10092

FS66

Heritage Exposed Shower System Arm Rose Diverter & Handshower - Metal Lever

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10094

FS67

Heritage Exposed Shower System Arm Rose Diverter & Handshower - Porcelain Lever

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10094

FS68

Heritage Shower System Arm Rose Diverter & Flexible Kit - Metal Lever

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10093

FS69

Heritage Shower System Arm Rose Diverter & Flexible Kit - Porcelain Lever

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10093

FS70

Traditional Concealed Shower With Flexible Kit - Metal Lever

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10091

FS71

Traditional Concealed Shower With Flexible Kit - Porcelain Lever

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10091

FS72

Traditional Exposed Shower System - Metal Lever

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10102

FS73

Traditional Exposed Shower System - Porcelain Lever

Shower - s6(1)(b)

S10102

FS74

Traditional Kitchen Bridge Mixer Tap – Brushed Nickel/Porcelain Lever

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20496

FS75

Traditional Kitchen Bridge Mixer Tap - Metal Levers – Chrome / Metal Lever

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20496

FS76

Traditional Kitchen Bridge Mixer Tap - Metal Levers – Nickel / Porcelain Lever

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20496

FS77

Traditional Kitchen Bridge Mixer Tap - Metal Levers – Nickel / Porcelain Lever

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20496

FS78

Traditional Kitchen Bridge Mixer Tap - Porcelain Levers Chrome / Porcelain Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20496

FS79

Traditional Kitchen Bridge Mixer Tap - Porcelain Levers Chrome / Porcelain Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20496

FS80

Traditional Kitchen Bridge Mixer Tap - Porcelain Levers Chrome / Porcelain Levers

Tap - s6(1)(a)

T20496

Background

Background to the litigation

The rules of evidence and procedure for civil matters apply in proceedings for a civil penalty order: s 44F of the WELS Act.Ancillary liability – actual knowledge of essential facts and sufficient involvement Ancillary contraventions of the civil penalty provisions are established by s 44M of the WELS Act, which relevantly provides:(1) A person must not:…(b) aid, abet, counsel or procure a contravention of a civil penalty provision; or …(d) be in any way, directly or indirectly, knowingly concerned in, or party to, a contravention of a civil penalty provision; or … To be liable in respect of an ancillary contravention, a person must have actual knowledge of the essential facts constituting the primary contraventions (although it is not necessary to prove that the person knew that those matters amounted to a contravention); and a level of involvement in the primary contraventions that satisfies one of the descriptions in s 44M(1)(b) or (d) of the WELS Act. As to the first requirement, see s 44Q of the WELS Act. LIABILITY OF THE SOLVENT RESPONDENTS The Solvent Respondents admit that they each contravened the WELS Act in the following ways.Renaissance Bathrooms Renaissance Bathrooms admits that in the period 17 May 2018 to 18 November 2019 it contravened s 33 of the WELS Act by supplying WELS products by advertising the products for sale as new products on its website ( for the purposes of its business. Renaissance Bathrooms admits contraventions of s 33, referrable to the supply of 51 different WELS products that each were required to be registered under the WELS scheme, but which were not so registered: see Rows RB1 to RB51 of Annexure A. Renaissance Bathrooms further admits that, in that same period, it contravened s 34 of the WELS Act by advertising for sale as a new product 12 registered WELS products on its website which were not WELS-labelled but which were required to be WELS-labelled or carry text advice in accordance with the WEPRL Standard: see Rows RB52 to RB63 of Annexure A. Together, the admitted contraventions of ss 33 and 34 of the WELS Act by Renaissance Bathrooms relate to 63 separate products. Belfast Sinks Belfast Sinks admits that in November 2018, in contravention of s 33 of the WELS Act, in the course of its business, it sold three WELS products as new products which were required to be, but were not, WELS registered. Each of the three sales constituted a separate contravention of s 33 of the WELS Act. The three relevant sales comprised purchases by WELS investigators, one being in person, one being over the internet, and one by telephone order. Mr Shaw The Regulator alleges that Mr Shaw caused or permitted the non-compliant WELS products to be advertised by personally sourcing, or directing or procuring the sourcing of, each of the non-compliant WELS products and directing or approving the placement of those images on the relevant websites. Mr Shaw admits liability in respect of the Renaissance Bathrooms website, but denies any liability in respect of the websites of the Insolvent Companies.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Regulator bears the onus to prove the case advanced to the requisite civil standard having regard to the gravity of the matters alleged: s 140 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth). In the present proceedings, the Insolvent Respondents were served with the amended statement of claim and leave to proceed against them in liquidation was granted, over their opposition. They have not filed a defence in the proceedings as they were required to do by orders entered on 30 January 2020 and pursuant to r 16.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth). Rule 16.07(2) provides that “[a]llegations that are not specifically denied are taken to be admitted”. By reason of r 16.07(2), the Insolvent Respondents are taken to have admitted all of the allegations in amended statement of claim. Notwithstanding that these are civil penalty proceedings, as corporations, the Insolvent Respondents do not have the benefit of privilege against exposure to a penalty: s 187 of the Evidence Act. It follows that pursuant to r 16.07 of the Rules, the Insolvent Respondents are taken to have admitted all matters pleaded in the amended statement of claim: Michell, in the matter of Aizome1 Pty Ltd (in liq) v Millar [2019] FCA 2169 at [19]. It is therefore open to the Regulator to rely on deemed admissions of all the facts pleaded in the amended statement of claim: Thunder Studios Inc (California) v Kazal (No 9) [2020] FCA 846 at [32]. On that basis, Traditional Taps is deemed to have admitted to contravening s 33 of the WELS Act in respect of 46 products (see TT1 to TT46 of Annexure B). These products were required to be registered for supply as a new product, but were not registered. Castironbaths is further deemed to have admitted to contravening s 33 of the WELS Act in respect of 13 products advertised on the Castironbaths website (see CB1 to CB 13 in Annexure C, and 55 products advertised on the Farmhouse Sinks website (see FS1 to FS55 in Annexure D). Further, Traditional Taps is deemed to have admitted to contravening s 34 of the WELS Act in respect of 26 products (see TT47 to TT72 of Annexure B). These products were required to be WELS labelled, or bear the alternative text advice, but did not. Castironbaths is deemed to have admitted to contravening s 34 of the WELS Act in respect of 26 products advertised on the Castironbaths website (see CB14 to CB 39 in Annexure C) which were not labelled as required, and 25 products advertised on the Farmhouse Sinks website which were similarly not labelled as required (see FS56 to FS80 in Annexure D). Notwithstanding that the Insolvent Respondents are deemed to have admitted the contraventions, the Regulator supplemented the deemed admissions with a body of evidence that reinforces the Regulator’s right and entitlement to relief of the kind claimed. Even though the Insolvent Respondents did not attempt to discharge their burden in respect of registration under s 33(5) of the WELS Act, the Regulator led evidence to establish that the relevant products were not registered. Evidence was led from two WELS inspectors who had undertaken examinations of the websites operated by the Insolvent Respondents on multiple occasions. The WELS inspectors combed the websites to identify specific model names and model codes associated with WELS products offered for sale by the Insolvent Respondents, and then verified that the products the subject of the s 33 contraventions were registered in the WELS register. This evidence demonstrates that the Insolvent Respondents contravened s 33 in the manner alleged by the Regulator.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Notwithstanding that the Insolvent Respondents are in liquidation, the Regulator presses the claim for relief against them “for reasons of general deterrence”. In doing so, the Regulator acknowledges that it must obtain leave of the Court to enforce against the Insolvent Respondents. CONCLUSION IN SUMMARY FORM I am satisfied that I have the power, and that it is appropriate, to make orders substantially as sought by the Regulator against the Solvent Respondents. I am also satisfied that the Regulator has established, to the requisite standard, that the Insolvent Respondents contravened s 33 and s 34 of the WELS Act as alleged. Notwithstanding that the Insolvent Companies are in liquidation, it is appropriate to make orders substantially as sought by the Regulator for reasons of general deterrence. THE STATUTORY FRAMEWORK The relevant statutory framework is comprised of the WELS Act, the Water Efficiency Labelling and Standards Determination 2013 (No. 2) (Cth) (the WELS Determination) and the ‘Australian Standard AS/NZS 6400:2016 Water efficient products – Rating and labelling’ (version published 6 April 2016) (the WEPRL Standard). The relevant period during which the contraventions occurred is from 5 June 2015 to at least 20 November 2018. References to the WELS Act in these reasons are to the consolidated version of the WELS Act registered on 27 July 2016. For the purpose of these proceedings, there is no material difference in the relevant provisions between the version of the WELS Act in force as at 5 June 2015 (being the date of the three contraventions which predate the consolidated version of the WELS Act registered on 27 July 2016) and the consolidated version registered on 27 July 2016. References to the WELS Determination are to the version registered 23 August 2016. There is no material difference in the relevant definitions and standards provided in the version of the WELS Determination that was in force at 5 June 2015. References to the WEPRL Standard are to the Australian Standard AS/NZS 6400:2016 Water efficient products – Rating and labelling, which was approved on behalf of the Council of Standards Australia on 23 December 2015, and was published on 6 April 2016. The present proceedings concern contravention of: (1) the requirement in s 33 of the WELS Act that certain WELS products be registered in order to be supplied as new products; and (2) the requirement in s 34 of the WELS Act that certain registered WELS products must be WELS labelled or carry text advice in lieu of a WELS label in order to be supplied as new products. The present proceedings do not concern allegations of contravention based on the content of the labels on the WELS products the subject of the contraventions. For this reason, it is not necessary to descend into the further reaches of what is a complicated statutory framework. The following outline of the statutory framework focusses only on the critical provisions relevant to the present proceeding. Prohibition on supply of unregistered products: s 33

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Regulator has standing to bring the present proceedings: s 44(1) – injunctions – and s 44A(1) – civil penalty orders.Declarations The Court’s power to make declarations is conferred by s 21 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). Injunctions The Court may grant an injunction restraining a person from engaging in conduct that constituted, constitutes, or would constitute an offence against the WELS Act, or contravention of a civil penalty provision: s 44(1)(a) of the WELS Act. The Court may, if it thinks appropriate, grant an injunction by consent of all parties to the proceedings, whether or not the Court is satisfied that the person has engaged, is engaging or is proposing to engage in any conduct that constituted, constitutes or would constitute, an offence against the WELS Act or a contravention of a civil penalty provision: s 44(2) of the WELS Act. The Court must not require an undertaking as to damages to be given: s 44(4) of the WELS Act. The power to grant an injunction may be exercised whether or not it appears to the Court that the person intends on engaging in the contravening conduct again, or whether the person has previously engaged in such conduct: s 44(6) of the WELS Act.Civil penalty orders An application by the Regulator for a civil penalty order must be made within four years of the alleged contravention: s 44A(2) of the WELS Act. The present proceedings were commenced within that time. If the court is satisfied that the person has contravened the civil penalty provision, the court may order the person to pay to the Commonwealth such pecuniary penalty for the contravention as the court determines to be appropriate: s 44A(3) of the WELS Act. In determining the pecuniary penalty, the Court may take into account all relevant matters, including the nature and extent of the contravention, the nature and extent of any loss or damage suffered by reason of the contravention, the circumstances in which the contravention took place, and whether the person has previously been found by a court to have engaged in similar conduct: s 44A(6) of the WELS Act. The relevant penalty for both ss 33 and 34 is 60 penalty units in the case of an individual: ss 33(3) and 34(2) respectively. If the contravenor is a corporation, the pecuniary penalty must not exceed five times the pecuniary penalty specified in the civil penalty provision: s 44A(5). At the time of the 2018 and 2019 contraventions, the value of a penalty unit was $210. The maximum penalty for each contravention by an individual was $12,600 and by a body corporate was $63,000. At the time of the three contraventions alleged against Castironbaths in 2015, the value of a penalty unit was $170 and the maximum penalty for each contravention by a body corporate was $51,000. If conduct contravenes two or more civil penalty provisions, the Regulator may commence proceedings in relation to the contravention of any one or more of those provisions. However, the person cannot be liable to more than one civil penalty provision in relation to the same conduct: s 44C of the WELS Act.