FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Virgin Mobile Australia
Pty Ltd (No 2) [2002] FCA 1548TRADE PRACTICES – misleading or deceptive conduct – misrepresentations – failure to comply with requirement to state cash price or minimum price – mobile telephone and telephone services – advertising of package – consent order – function of Court – undesirability of overlapping relief in relation to s 52 and other provisions of Part V – declaratory relief – need to precisely specify contravening conduct – injunction – notice to consumers – corrective advertising – probation order – corporate compliance program – precision of order – community service order – educational website
Trade Practices Act 1976 (Cth) ss 52, 53, 86C
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Real Estate Institute of Western Australia Inc (1999) 161 ALR 79 cited
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Real Estate Institute of Western Australia Inc (1999) 95 FCR 114 cited
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Office Link (Aust) Pty Ltd (1997) 19 ATPR 41-598 cited
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Z-Tek Computer Pty Ltd (1997) 78 FCR 197 cited
HCF Australia Ltd v Switzerland Australia Health Fund Pty Ltd (1988) ATPR 40-834 citedAUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION v VIRGIN MOBILE AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ACN 092 726 442)
W134 OF 2002FRENCH J
11 DECEMBER 2002
PERTH
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY
W134 OF 2002
BETWEEN:
AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
APPLICANTAND:
VIRGIN MOBILE AUSTRALIA PTY LTD
(ACN 092 726 442)
RESPONDENTJUDGE:
FRENCH J
DATE OF ORDER:
11 DECEMBER 2002
WHERE MADE:
PERTH
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
BY CONSENT, the Court declares that:
1.The Respondent, in trade or commerce in connection with the supply, possible supply or promotion of the supply, of mobile telephones (the “goods”), mobile telephone services and short message services (the “services”) and packages comprising the goods and services (“Telephone and Service Packages”) to consumers within Australia engaged in a breach of s 53C of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (the “Act”) by causing advertisements to be published, distributed or broadcast nationally during the period October 2001 to March 2002 in which it made representations with respect to an amount that, if paid, would constitute part of the consideration for the supply of:
1.1 the goods, without specifying the cash price of the goods; and
1.2the Telephone and Service Packages, without specifying the cash price or minimum cost of the Telephone and Service Packages.
2.The Respondent, in trade or commerce, in connection with the supply, possible supply or promotion of the supply of the goods or the Telephone and Service Packages, made false or misleading representations with respect to:
2.1the price for which consumers could obtain the goods and/or the Telephone and Service Packages from the Respondent in contravention of s 53(e) of the Act; and
2.2the conditions on which consumers could obtain the goods and/or the Telephone and Service Packages from the Respondent in contravention of s 53(g)…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Virgin Mobile... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2002] FCA 1548
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court had to decide whether Virgin Mobile's conduct constituted misleading or deceptive conduct, as prohibited by sections 52, 53(e), and 53C of the Trade Practices Act. The court needed to assess whether Virgin Mobile made false or misleading representations concerning the prices and conditions for obtaining the advertised goods and services, and whether it failed to specify the cash prices of the goods and packages as required by section 53C of the Act.
The court found that Virgin Mobile breached the Trade Practices Act by making misleading representations in its advertisements. The court held that Virgin Mobile's advertisements did not specify the cash price of the mobile telephones or the minimum cost of the packages, nor did they clearly state the costs payable on termination. Additionally, the court found that Virgin Mobile's advertisements implied that consumers could terminate the packages without incurring additional charges, which was misleading. The court concluded that Virgin Mobile's conduct was likely to mislead or deceive consumers and that the misleading conduct occurred in the course of trade or commerce.
The court ordered Virgin Mobile to issue specific notices to affected consumers, publish prominent notices in newspapers and on its website, and implement a trade practices compliance program. Furthermore, Virgin Mobile was required to create an internet site explaining advertisers' obligations under the Trade Practices Act. The court also ordered Virgin Mobile to pay the ACCC's costs. The parties had the liberty to apply to vary any of the preceding orders to the extent that they departed from the Minute of Consent Orders.
Orders
Orders of the court
BY CONSENT, the Court declares that:
1. The Respondent, in trade or commerce in connection with the supply, possible supply or promotion of the supply, of mobile telephones (the “goods”), mobile telephone services and short message services (the “services”) and packages comprising the goods and services (“Telephone and Service Packages”) to consumers within Australia engaged in a breach of s 53C of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (the “Act”) by causing advertisements to be published, distributed or broadcast nationally during the period October 2001 to March 2002 in which it made representations with respect to an amount that, if paid, would constitute part of the consideration for the supply of:
1.1 the goods, without specifying the cash price of the goods; and
1.2 the Telephone and Service Packages, without specifying the cash price or minimum cost of the Telephone and Service Packages.
2. The Respondent, in trade or commerce, in connection with the supply, possible supply or promotion of the supply of the goods or the Telephone and Service Packages, made false or misleading representations with respect to:
2.1 the price for which consumers could obtain the goods and/or the Telephone and Service Packages from the Respondent in contravention of s 53(e) of the Act; and
2.2 the conditions on which consumers could obtain the goods and/or the Telephone and Service Packages from the Respondent in contravention of s 53(g) of the Act,
by causing advertisements to be published, distributed or broadcast nationally, during the period October 2001 to March 2002, containing:
2.3 a representation with respect to amounts that, if paid, would constitute part of the consideration for the supply by the Respondent of:
2.3.1 the goods; and/or
2.3.2 Telephone and Service Packages;
2.4 the implied representation that a consumer who obtained a Telephone and Service Package from the Respondent was not required to pay the specified minimum monthly charge for telephone calls and/or SMS for any particular period;
2.5 the implied representation that a consumer who obtained a Telephone and Service Package from the Respondent could terminate the Telephone and Service Package without any additional payment upon termination,
in circumstances in which:
2.6 there was a cash price for the goods and a minimum amount payable for the Telephone and Service Packages;
2.7 consumers who obtained a Telephone and Service Package were required:
2.7.1 to pay the minimum monthly charge for mobile telephone calls and/or SMS for a period of 24 months in order not to be liable to pay to the Respondent the Termination Payment; or
2.7.2 if the consumer wished to terminate within 24 months of entering into the Telephone and Service Package, to give 1 month’s notice from the date of the next bill and then pay to the Respondent the Termination Payment, calculated as the Telephone Charge multiplied by the number of months remaining of the 24 month period; and
2.8 a Termination Payment was payable and the consumer was required to pay the Telephone Charge multiplied by the number of months remaining of the 24 month period.
BY CONSENT, the Court orders that:
Injunctions
3. For a period of 3 years from the date of this Order, the Respondent, its servants and agents, in trade or commerce, in connection with the supply, possible supply or promotion of the supply, of the goods, the services and/or Telephone and Service Packages to consumers within Australia, be required, when making representations to consumers in relation to the consideration by, or terms and conditions on, which consumers can obtain the goods, the services and/or the Telephone and Service Packages from the Respondent, to clearly state the following matters:
3.1 the cash price of the goods;
3.2 the cash price or minimum cost of the Telephone and Service Packages; and
3.3 the method by which any amount payable by a consumer on termination of a Telephone and Service Package is calculated.
Notice to affected consumers
4. Within 28 days of the date of this Order, the Respondent, at its expense, write in the terms of Annexure “A” to each existing Virgin Mobile customer who entered into a Dial High Club Level 30 or Level 50 package with the Respondent in the period from October 2001 to March 2002.
Public Advertisements
5. Within 28 days of this Order or in the next edition following expiry of that period, the Respondent cause to be published at its expense, an advertisement of a size not less than 15 cm wide and 15 cm deep in the form of Annexure “B” within the first twenty pages of a weekend edition of each of the following newspapers:
5.1 the Sydney Morning Herald;
5.2 the Age;
5.3 the Brisbane Courier Mail;
5.4 the Adelaide Advertiser;
5.5 the West Australian;
5.6 the Hobart Mercury; and
5.7 the Northern Territory News.
6. Within 28 days of this Order the Respondent cause, at its expense, to be published on the home page of its internet site located at URL:www.virginmobile.com.au for a period of 3 months a prominent one click link to a website containing a notice in the form of Annexure “B”.
Probation Orders
7. Within 90 days of the date of this Order, implement for all of its officers and employees a Trade Practices Corporate Compliance Program (“Compliance Program”) tailored to the Respondent’s circumstances and, to the Respondent’s reasonable endeavours, consistent with Australian Standard AS-3806, in relation to ss 52, 53 and 53C of the Trade Practices Act.
8. The Compliance Program be designed to ensure that the officers and employees of Virgin Mobile are aware of their responsibilities and obligations in relation to ss 52, 53 and 53C of the Trade Practices Act.
9. The Respondent, at its expense, cause an audit of the Compliance Program to be undertaken annually from the date of implementation for a period of 3 years. The first, second and third such audits shall be conducted by an independent external professional or organisation with trade practices law experience who is acceptable to the Applicant.
10. The Respondent, at its expense, cause to be produced and provided to the Applicant a certificate confirming the performance of the first and third Compliance Program annual audits performed in accordance with the preceding order.
Community Service Order
11. Within 120 days of the date of this Order, the Respondent, at its expense, create or cause to be created an internet site to be maintained for a period of 6 months that explains to consumers the obligations of advertisers under the Act promoting mobile telephones, mobile telephone services and/or SMS specifically including, but not limited to, ss 52, 53 and 53C of the Act. Such internet site is to be linked to the home page of the Respondent’s internet site located at URL:www.virginmobile.com.au.
Costs
12. The Respondent pay the Applicant’s costs as agreed or assessed.
13. The parties have liberty to apply within forty eight hours to vary any of the preceding orders to the extent that they depart from the Minute of Consent Orders.
Annexure “A”
Sal name surname
St address
Suburb State Postcode
Dear (name),
Hi,
Virgin Mobile has recently settled Federal Court action taken by the ACCC in relation to Virgin Mobile’s Dial High Club advertising late last year/early this year. More particularly, during the period October 2001 to March 2002 Virgin Mobile ran a series of advertisements promoting the:
. Nokia 8310 Level 50 Dial High Club package;
. Nokia 8250 Level 50 Dial High Club package; and
. Nokia 3310 Level 30 Dial High Club package.
These advertisements did not comply with some of the consumer protection provisions of the Trade Practices Act 1974 because they didn’t:
. state the full cash price of the mobile phones/mobile phone packages; and
. clearly advise consumers of the likely costs payable on termination of the packages,
in the advertisements.
We want to make sure that the main features of your mobile phone package are crystal clear, so here is a brief explanation of how it works;
. you are required to spend a minimum of $[x] each month on calls/SMS;
. [if Level 50 $199] you pay the amount of $199 upfront for the Nokia 8310 mobile phone handset.
. [if Level 30/Level 50 no upfront] you pay nothing upfront for the [y] mobile phone handset;
. for each month that you spend $[x] minimum on calls/SMS, Virgin Mobile will pay $[z] towards the repayments on your mobile phone handset. The $[z] is the monthly instalment of the residual amount owing on your phone spread over 24 months;
. you are able to leave Virgin Mobile at any time you like provided that you pay the remaining instalments on your handset which is $[z] for the number of months remaining of the 24 month period since you joined us and any outstanding call/SMS costs. If you stay with us on your plan for at least 24 months, no outstanding payments are required on your handset if you leave us.
As part of the orders, Virgin Mobile has agreed that, in future, it will make sure its advertisements clearly state the full cash price and/or minimum cost of mobile telephone/mobile telephone and service packages and the method by which any amounts payable on termination are calculated, create an internet site explaining to consumers the obligations of advertisers in promoting mobile telephone packages and institute a trade practices compliance program.
At Virgin Mobile, we pride ourselves on providing great value and strongly believe in maintaining open and honest relationships with our customers at all times. If you have any queries or concerns about your package, please do not hesitate to contact our customer service team on xxxxxxx.
Yours sincerely,
Annexure “B”
Virgin Mobile
Federal Court Ordered Notice
In settlement of Federal Court action taken by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission, Virgin Mobile Australia Pty Ltd has admitted that it made misleading claims in advertisements, from October 2001 to March 2002, for the Nokia 8310 and 8250 Level 50, and Nokia 3310 Level 30, Dial High packages.
The Court declared that Virgin Mobile breached the Trade Practices Act by failing to state the full cash price of the mobile phones/phone packages and not clearly stating the costs payable on termination.
We should have stated that the full cash price of the Nokia 8310 was $ $1039: the Nokia 8250 was $840: and the Nokia 3310 was $268.20 and that the minimum cost of the packages was $1069, $870 and $288.40 or $306.40, respectively.
We should also have stated that if you leave the packages within 24 months, you must pay out the remaining instalments on your handset for each month remaining of the 24 months (+ any outstanding call/SMS costs) and that these monthly amounts are: $35p/m for the Nokia 8310 and 8250, and $10.35 or $11.20p/m for the Nokia 3310.
Virgin Mobile has agreed to orders which require us to state the full cash price and/or minimum cost of mobile phones/ phone packages and how any costs on leaving the packages are calculated in all future advertisements.
We have also agreed to create an internet site explaining advertisers' obligations in promoting mobile phone packages to consumers and to publish this notice.
If you have any queries about your package or this notice, please contact our customer service team on xxxxxxx.
Note:
Heading:
18pt Bold Italic Comic Sans
Subheading:
10pt Comic Sans
Body Text:
10 pt Arial
Top Margin:
Min: 8mm
Left & Right Margins
Min 8mm
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: FRENCH J