FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v MSY Technology Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 1251
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v MSY Technol... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] FCA 1251
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to decide whether the proposed declarations and orders were appropriate relief in the circumstances. The ACCC sought declarations that the respondents had contravened consumer law, injunctions preventing future contraventions, pecuniary penalties, and orders for corrective notices and training. The respondents agreed to the proposed orders.
The court found that the proposed declarations were appropriate because they recorded the court's disapproval of the contravening conduct, vindicated the ACCC's claim, and served a deterrent purpose. The injunctions, penalties and other orders were also deemed appropriate given the admitted contraventions and to prevent future breaches. The court made the declarations and orders sought in the proposed orders.
In summary, the court approved the agreed orders which included declarations of contravention, injunctions preventing misleading representations to consumers, pecuniary penalties totalling $750,000, orders for corrective notices and training, and an obligation to implement a compliance program. The respondents also agreed to pay the ACCC's costs of $50,000.
Orders
Orders of the court
6. Each of MSY Technology and MSY Group, whether by itself, its servants, its agents or otherwise, for a period of five years from the date of this Order, in trade or commerce be restrained from publishing or causing to be published on any website operated, maintained and controlled by MSY Technology or MSY Group, written statements representing to consumers that the consumers' rights or remedies for faulty Computer Products purchased from any MSY business, are in any way limited, restricted or varied from those conferred on consumers under the ACL.
7. Each of MSY Technology and MSY NSW, whether by itself, its servants, its agents or otherwise, for a period of five years from the date of this Order, in trade or commerce be restrained from making representations to consumers who approach MSY Technology or MSY NSW in relation to faulty goods or services purchased from any MSY business, to the effect that the consumers' rights or remedies from MSY Technology and MSY NSW are in any way limited, restricted or varied from those conferred on consumers under the ACL.
8. Within 90 days of these Orders:
(a) MSY Group pay a pecuniary penalty to the Commonwealth of Australia in respect of contraventions of ss 29(1)(m) and (n) of the ACL in the amount of $200,000;
(b) MSY NSW pay a pecuniary penalty to the Commonwealth of Australia in respect of contraventions of s 29(1)(m) of the ACL in the amount of $50,000; and
(c) MSY Technology pay a pecuniary penalty to the Commonwealth of Australia in respect of contraventions of ss 29(1)(m) and (n) of the ACL in the amount of $500,000.
9. MSY Technology and MSY Group:
(a) within 5 days of these Orders agree the terms of a notice of the outcome of these proceedings with the Applicant (Notice);
(b) within 7 days of these Orders, at their expense, publish a colour copy of the Notice on the MSY Website homepage (http://www.msy.com.au/home.php) and ensure the Notice is:
(i) viewable immediately on a computer screen on access to the MSY Website homepage;
(ii) published directly above the location and contact details for the stores on the MSY website homepage;
(iii) published in a box of a size equal to the banner advertising display box viewable above the location and contact details for the stores on the MSY website homepage (but replacing the current banner advertising display box);
(iv) static (i.e. not scrolling such that the notice remains on the page and does not scroll across the page or scroll in rotation with other advertising);
(v) crawlable (i.e. its contents may be indexed by a search engine); and
(vi) maintained on the MSY Website homepage for a period of 90 days from the date of these Orders;
(c) within 15 days of these Orders, agree the terms of a webpage titled "Your ACL Rights" with the Applicant, being a sufficiently detailed description of the consumer guarantee rights conferred on consumers under the ACL and available from any MSY company (Your ACL Rights material);
(d) within 30 days of these Orders, include an accessible and prominent hyperlink labelled "Your ACL Rights" located on the MSY Website homepage, linking through to a section of the MSY Website containing the Your ACL Rights material;
(e) within 30 days of these Orders ensure that any "Terms and Conditions" or "Terms of Trade":
(i) published on the MSY Website contain a hyperlink labelled to the Your ACL Rights material; and
(ii) made available at any MSY store they operate attach and include a copy of the Your ACL Rights material,
(f) within 90 days of these Orders:
(i) publish, or cause to be published, at their expense, on the MSY Website in a prominent position on the MSY Website homepage a phone number that consumers can use to raise consumer guarantee issues with a senior MSY Group, MSY Technology or MSY NSW employee; and
(ii) ensure the person nominated under Order 9(f)(i) to respond to consumer guarantee issues raised by consumers has attended the training referred to in Order 11(a) below, and has had specific annual training for 3 years on the application of Div 1 of Pt 3-2 of the ACL and Div 1 of Pt 5-4 of the ACL.
10. MSY Group, MSY NSW and MSY Technology at their own expense:
(a) within 90 days of these Orders establish and implement a Compliance and Education/Training Program (Compliance Program), which in all respects complies with the requirements set out in Annexure A to these Orders;
(b) maintain and continue to implement the Compliance Program referred to in Order 10(a) above for a period of three years from the date of these Orders; and
(c) provide any documents to be provided to the Applicant pursuant to Annexure A.
11. MSY Group, MSY NSW and MSY Technology at their own expense:
(a) within 90 days of these Orders ensure that their employees, the Compliance Officer appointed in accordance with Annexure A, and any MSY Group, MSY NSW and MSY Technology directors attend and undertake ACL compliance training with particular emphasis on the responsibilities and obligations of suppliers under ss 18 and 29, Div 1 of Pt 3-2, and Div 1 of Pt 5-4 of the ACL;
(b) ensure the training referred to in Order 11(a) is administered annually to the persons referred to in Order 11(a) for a period of three years from the date of these Orders; and
(c) ensure the training referred to in Order 11(a) is to be administered by a qualified compliance professional or legal practitioner with expertise in the ACL.
12. The Director of MSY Group, MSY NSW and/or MSY Technology provide an affidavit deposing to compliance with:
(a) Order 9, to be filed in the proceeding within 10 days of complying with each obligation specified in Orders 9(a) to 9(f);
(b) Order 10, to be filed in the proceeding within 10 days of complying with each obligation specified in Orders 10(a) and 10(b); and
(c) Order 11, to be filed in the proceeding within 10 days of complying with each obligation in Orders 11(a) and 11(b).
13. MSY Group, MSY NSW and MSY Technology together, within 30 days of these Orders, pay the Applicant’s costs of the proceeding in the amount of $50,000.
14. The proceeding be otherwise dismissed.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Annexure A
COMPLIANCE AND EDUCATION/TRAINING PROGRAM
1. MSY Group, MSY NSW and MSY Technology must establish a Consumer Compliance Program (Compliance Program) that complies with each of paragraphs 2 to 18 of this Annexure A, and must undertake and complete each of the requirements specified.
Appointments
2. Within 30 days of the date of these Orders, appoint a director or a senior manager with suitable qualifications or experience in corporate compliance as a Compliance Officer with responsibility for ensuring the Compliance Program is effectively designed, implemented and maintained (Compliance Officer).
Risk Assessment
3. Within 90 days of the date of these Orders, MSY Group, MSY NSW and MSY Technology:
(a) appoint a suitably qualified, external, compliance professional with demonstrated expertise in Australian Consumer Law (ACL), comprising Schedule 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) (Compliance Advisor);
(b) instruct the Compliance Advisor to:
(i) undertake an ACL risk assessment covering the areas where MSY Group, MSY NSW and MSY Technology are at risk of contravening ss 18 and 29 of the ACL and any gaps in the existing procedures and documentation for managing these risks; and
(ii) provide recommendations for any action to be taken having regard to the outcome of the risk assessment described in paragraph 3(b) of this Annexure A to the Director(s) and senior management of the MSY Companies (Risk Assessment Report);
(c) review and implement the findings and recommendations of the Compliance Advisor as recorded in the Risk Assessment Report.
Compliance Policy
4. Within 30 days of the date of the Orders of the Court, issue a policy statement outlining MSY Group, MSY NSW and MSY Technology’s commitment to compliance with the ACL (Compliance Policy), which policy must contain:
(a) a statement of commitment to compliance with the ACL;
(b) an outline of how the commitment to ACL compliance will be realised by MSY Group, MSY NSW and MSY Technology; and
(c) a requirement for all staff of MSY Group, MSY NSW and MSY Technology to report any Compliance Program issues and ACL compliance concerns to the Compliance Officer.
Complaints Handling System
5. Ensure that the Compliance Program includes a competition and consumer law complaints handling system (Complaints Handling System) which is consistent with AS/ISO 10002:2006 Customer satisfaction - Guidelines for complaints handling in organizations.
6. Ensure that MSY Group, MSY NSW and MSY Technology staff and any customers making an ACL inquiry of any of their staff are made aware of the Complaints Handling System.
Staff Training
7. Ensure that MSY Group, MSY NSW and MSY Technology staff receive the training referred to in Order 11 of the Orders of the Court, including ensuring that this training forms part of the induction of all new directors, officers, employees, representatives and agents.
Compliance officer reports to Director(s) and Senior Management
8. Ensure that the Compliance Officer reports to the Director(s) and senior management of MSY Group, MSY NSW and MSY Technology every six months on:
(a) whether any improvements to the Compliance Program are required;
(b) whether staff require additional or refresher training on MSY’s ACL obligations; and
(c) all consumer guarantee issues reported under the Compliance Handling System or otherwise communicated to MSY Group, MSY NSW and MSY Technology by consumers in writing (including by email, via social media, or otherwise) over the last six months.
Compliance Program Review
9. MSY Group, MSY NSW and MSY Technology undertake, at their own expense, an annual review of the Compliance Program (Review) to be carried out in accordance with each of the following requirements:
(a) Scope of Review – the Review should be broad and rigorous enough to provide MSY Group, MSY NSW and MSY Technology and the ACCC with:
(i) a verification that the requirements specified in Orders 9(c), 9(e) and 9(f) of the Orders of the Court have been complied with;
(ii) a verification that MSY Group, MSY NSW and MSY Technology have put in place a Compliance Program that complies with each of the requirements detailed in paragraphs 2, 4, 5, 6, 7 and 8 of this Annexure A; and
(iii) the Compliance Reports detailed at paragraph 11 of this Annexure A.
(b) Independent Reviewer – ensure that each Review is carried out by a suitably qualified, independent compliance professional with demonstrated expertise in Australian Consumer Law (Reviewer).
(c) The Reviewer will qualify as:
(i) a suitable expert where he or she advises on ACL matters on an ongoing and regular basis and has done so for at least 3 years.
(ii) independent on the basis that he or she:
(A) did not design or implement the Compliance Program;
(B) is not a present or past staff member or director of any of MSY Group, MSY NSW and MSY Technology or any other MSY entity;
(C) has not acted and does not act for, and does not consult and has not consulted to, MSY Group, MSY NSW and MSY Technology or any other MSY entity in any competition and consumer law related matters, other than performing Reviews under the Orders of the Court; and
(D) has no significant shareholding or other interests in any of MSY Group, MSY NSW and MSY Technology or any other MSY entity.
(d) Evidence – use its best endeavours to ensure that each Review is conducted on the basis that the Reviewer has access to all relevant sources of information necessary to carry out the review, including without limitation:
(i) the ability to make enquiries of any officers, employees, representatives and agents of any of MSY Group, MSY NSW and MSY Technology;
(ii) documents relating to the risk assessment referred to in paragraph 3(b)(i) of this Annexure A, including the Risk Assessment Report;
(iii) documents relating to the Compliance Program, including documents relevant to the Compliance Policy, Complaints Handling System, staff training and induction program; and
(iv) any reports made by the Compliance Officer to the Board or senior management regarding the Compliance Program.
10. Ensure the Review is completed within one year of the date of the Orders of the Court, and that a subsequent Review is completed annually for three years.
Compliance Report
11. Use its best endeavours to ensure that within 30 days of the completion of a Review, the Reviewer includes the Review findings and recommendations in a report provided to the Director(s) and senior management of MSY Group, MSY NSW and MSY Technology (Compliance Report).
12. Ensure the Compliance Report covers whether:
(a) the Compliance Program includes all the elements detailed in in paragraphs 2, 4, 5, 6, 7 and 8 of this Annexure A, and if not, what elements need to be included or further developed;
(b) the Compliance Program adequately covers matters identified in the risk assessment referred to in paragraph 3(b)(i) of this Annexure A, and if not, what needs to be further addressed;
(c) the staff training and induction is effective, and if not, what aspects need to be further developed;
(d) the Complaints Handling System is effective, and if not, what aspects need to be further developed; and
(e) there are any deficiencies in the Compliance Program, or whether there are or have been any instances of non-compliance with the Compliance Program, and if so, the recommendations for rectifying the deficiencies identified.
Response to Compliance Report
13. Within 30 days of MSY Group, MSY NSW and MSY Technology receiving the Compliance Report, implement promptly and with due diligence any recommendations made by the Reviewer in the Compliance Report.
14. Ensure that the Compliance Officer within 30 days of the requirement in paragraph 13 of this Annexure A reports to the Director(s) and senior management of MSY Group, MSY NSW and MSY Technology confirming whether the Compliance Report recommendations have been implemented or remain outstanding, and continues to do so until the recommendations have been implemented.
Reporting to the ACCC
15. Within 90 days of the Director(s) and senior management of MSY Group, MSY NSW and MSY Technology receiving the Compliance Report, the Reviewer is to provide a report to the ACCC on:
(a) steps taken to implement the recommendations made by the Reviewer in the Compliance Report; or
(b) any outstanding steps required to implement the Compliance Report recommendations and will then inform the ACCC once those steps have been implemented.
Provision of Compliance Program documents to the ACCC
16. MSY Group, MSY NSW and MSY Technology to maintain a record of and store all documents relating to and constituting the Compliance Program for a period not less than five years.
17. If requested by the ACCC during the period of five years following the date of the Orders of the Court, at its own expense, cause to be produced and provided to the ACCC copies of all documents constituting the Compliance Program, including:
(a) the Compliance Policy;
(b) the Risk Assessment Report;
(c) an outline of the Complaints Handling System;
(d) staff training materials and induction materials;
(e) all Compliance Reports that have been completed at the time of the request; and
(f) copies of the reports to the Board and/or senior management referred to in paragraphs 3(b)(ii), 8, 11, 14 and 15 of this Annexure A.
ACCC Recommendations
18. MSY Group, MSY NSW and MSY Technology to implement promptly and with due diligence any recommendations that the ACCC may make that the ACCC deems reasonably necessary to ensure that MSY Group, MSY NSW and MSY Technology maintain and continue to implement the Compliance Program in accordance with the requirements of the Orders of the Court.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The parties seek the relief in the Proposed Orders and have jointly submitted that, in relation to the contravening conduct of the Respondents, the declarations and orders described at [16] above should be made by the Court. Declarations The Court has a wide discretionary power to make declarations under s 21 of the Federal Court Act: Forster v Jododex Australia Pty Limited (1972) 127 CLR 421 (Forster v Jododex) at 437-438; Ainsworth v Criminal Justice Commission (1992) 175 CLR 564 at 581-582. Before making a declaration the Court should be satisfied that the question in dispute is a real and not a hypothetical or theoretical one; that the applicant has a real interest in raising the issue; and that there is a proper contradictor: Forster v Jododex at 437-438 (per Gibbs J). The parties have jointly submitted, and I accept, that each of those requirements is satisfied here:(1)the proposed declarations relate to conduct that contravenes the ACL. The issue, being the contraventions of the ACL by the Respondents, is real and not hypothetical or theoretical;(2)it is in the public interest for the ACCC, the regulator under the CCA, to seek to have the declarations made and for the declarations to be made. There is a significant legal controversy in the case which is being resolved in this proceeding; and (3)the Respondents are proper contradictors, notwithstanding their consent. Each Respondent has a genuine interest in resisting the grant of relief; is a person who contravened, or was involved in contraventions of, the ACL; and is the subject of the declarations: see Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Sampson [2011] FCA 1165 at [13]-[18] (per Tracey J). Further, the declarations sought in this proceeding are appropriate because they serve to record the Court’s disapproval of the contravening conduct; vindicate the ACCC’s claim that the Respondents contravened the ACL; assist the ACCC in the future in carrying out the duties conferred on it by the CCA; assist in clarifying the law; and act as a deterrent to other persons and corporations from contravening the ACL: see Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 1405 (ACCC v Coles Supermarkets) at [78] (per Gordon J). The proposed declarations contain sufficient indication of how and why the conduct complained of contravenes the ACL: see BMW Australia Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (2004) 207 ALR 452; [2004] FCAFC 167 at [35]. The admissions set out in the Respondents’ concise response and the SoAFA further develop the basis for the making of the declarations and the facts set out in the SoAFA provide a sufficient factual foundation for the making of the declarations: ACCC v Coles Supermarkets at [79]. I will make declarations in the terms sought in the Proposed Orders.Injunctions The ACCC seeks injunctions restraining the Respondents from engaging in conduct, either by publishing material on any website or making other written statements or by making representations to consumers, to the effect that consumers’ rights or remedies for faulty Computer Products or for goods or services purchased from any MSY business are in any way limited, restricted or varied from those conferred on consumers under the ACL for a period of five years. The terms of the injunctions sought are set out in the Proposed Orders. The parties jointly submit that it is appropriate for the Court to order the proposed injunctions.