Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Optus Internet Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Optus Internet Pty Limited [2019] FCA 2221

File number:

VID 704 of 2019

Judge:

ANASTASSIOU J

Date of judgment:

29 November 2019

Date of publication of reasons:

27 July 2020

Catchwords:

CONSUMER LAW – agreed contraventions of ss 18 and 29(1)(l) Australian Consumer Law, being Schedule 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) – pecuniary, injunctive and compliance program remedies agreed – whether remedies appropriate – remedies granted in form agreed

Legislation:

Australian Consumer Law being Schedule 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), ss 18, 29(1)(l), 34, 224, 232, 246

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), ss 21 and 43(1)

Cases cited:

ACCC v AGL South Australia Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 399; 146 ALD 385

ACCC v MSY Technology Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 1251

ACCC v Origin Energy Limited [2015] FCA 55

ACCC v Optus Internet Pty Limited [2018] FCA 777

ACCC v Optus Mobile Pty Limited [2019] FCA 106

ACCC v Telstra Corporation Limited [2018] FCA 571; (2018) ATPR ¶42–593

ACCC v TPG Internet Pty Ltd (2013) 250 CLR 640

ACCC v Valve Corporation (No 7) [2016] FCA 1553

Commonwealth v Director, Fair Work Building Industry

Inspectorate (2015) 258 CLR 482

Competition and Consumer Commission v Medibank Private Limited [2020] FCA 1030

Singtel Optus Pty Ltd v ACCC [2012] FCAFC 20; 287 ALR 249; (2012) ATPR ¶42–387

Trade Practices Commission v Allied Mills Industries Pty Ltd [1981] FCA 156; 37 ALR 256

Date of hearing:

29 November 2019

Registry:

Victoria

Division:

General Division

National Practice Area:

Commercial and Corporations

Sub-area:

Regulator and Consumer Protection

Category:

Catchwords

Number of paragraphs:

27

Counsel for the Applicant:

Dr O. Bigos SC with Ms A. M. Muhlebach

Solicitor for the Applicant:

Norton Rose Fulbright Australia

Counsel for the Respondents:

Mr P. J. Brereton SC with Mr D. J. Roche

Solicitor for the Respondents:

Clayton Utz

ORDERS

VID 704 of 2019

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION

Applicant

AND:

OPTUS INTERNET PTY LIMITED

First Respondent

OPTUS MOBILE PTY LIMITED

Second Respondent

JUDGE:

ANASTASSIOU  J

DATE OF ORDER:

29 November 2019

NOTICE

TO:     OPTUS INTERNET PTY LIMITED (ACN 083 164 532) and OPTUS MOBILE PTY LIMITED (ACN 054 365 696)

IF YOU (BEING THE PERSON BOUND BY THIS ORDER):

A.       REFUSE OR NEGLECT TO DO ANY ACT WITHIN THE TIME SPECIFIED IN THIS ORDER FOR THE DOING OF THE ACT; OR

B.       DISOBEY THIS ORDER BY DOING AN ACT WHICH THE ORDER REQUIRES YOU NOT TO DO,

YOU WILL BE LIABLE TO IMPRISONMENT, SEQUESTRATION OF PROPERTY OR OTHER PUNISHMENT.

ANY OTHER PERSON WHO KNOWS OF THIS ORDER AND DOES ANYTHING WHICH HELPS OR PERMITS YOU TO BREACH THE TERMS OF THIS ORDER MAY BE SIMILARLY PUNISHED.

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

1.        On 24 May 2018, Optus Internet Pty Limited (Optus Internet) and Optus Mobile Pty Limited (Optus Mobile) (together, Optus), in trade or commerce:

(a) engaged in conduct that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Optus Inter... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCA 2221
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) brought proceedings against Optus Internet Pty Limited (Optus) and Optus Mobile Pty Limited for misleading conduct and contraventions of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL). The court was tasked with determining whether the agreed penalties and remedies were appropriate given the nature and extent of the conduct, and the circumstances in which it occurred. The case revolved around Optus' misleading representations to customers regarding the disconnection of their broadband services. The court found that Optus had indeed engaged in misleading conduct by sending an email to customers indicating their broadband service would be disconnected soon, unless they switched to Optus' NBN services. The parties agreed on a set of penalties and remedies, including declarations of contravention, pecuniary penalties, injunctive relief, and compliance orders.

The court applied the principles outlined in Commonwealth v Director, Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate, which emphasised that the court should accept the parties' proposed remedies if satisfied about the accuracy of their agreement on the facts and consequences, and that the penalty proposed is appropriate. The court considered each remedy in turn, assessing whether it was appropriate given the circumstances. The court found that the declarations of contravention were appropriate to record the court's disapproval of Optus' conduct. The pecuniary penalties were deemed appropriate, considering the nature and extent of the contraventions and the lack of previous similar conduct. The injunctive relief was also appropriate to prevent future similar conduct. Finally, the compliance orders were appropriate to ensure Optus reviewed and improved its compliance program.

The court granted the orders as agreed by the parties, including declarations of contravention, pecuniary penalties of $3.2 million each for Optus Internet and Optus Mobile, injunctive relief restraining Optus from making similar representations for three years, and compliance orders requiring Optus to review its compliance program and implement any necessary changes. The court also ordered Optus to pay costs of $50,000 to the ACCC. These orders were made to appropriately address the contraventions and ensure compliance with consumer law in the future.

Orders

Orders of the court

2. Optus is restrained for a period of 3 years from the date of this Order, whether by itself, its servants, its agents or otherwise, in trade or commerce in connection with the supply or possible supply of services provided using the NBN (NBN based services), or the promotion of supply or use of NBN based services, from making any representation to the effect that a customer's broadband service would be disconnected within a short period and consequently that the Recipient needs to acquire an NBN based service in the near future in order to continue to receive broadband services in circumstances where:

(a) the customer does not face the prospect of imminent disconnection of their broadband service, and so has no such need; or

(b) Optus does not have reasonable grounds for making that representation.

3. Within 30 days of the date of this Order:

(a) Optus Internet pay to the Commonwealth of Australia a pecuniary penalty of $3.2 million; and

(b) Optus Mobile pay to the Commonwealth of Australia a pecuniary penalty of $3.2 million,

in respect of the contraventions of s 29(1)(l) of the ACL that are the subject of the declaration in paragraph 1.

4. Optus, at its own expense:

(a) within 30 days of the date of this Order, appoint a suitably qualified compliance professional with expertise in consumer law who is independent of the Optus Group and has not previously been engaged by Optus (Reviewer) to review the efficacy of:

(i) Optus’ internal trade practices compliance program insofar as that program is designed to minimise the risk of contraventions of the ACL (Compliance Program);

(ii) the process adopted by Optus for internal legal review of communications by Optus to its customers or potential customers, insofar as that process is designed to minimise the risk of contraventions of the ACL (Legal Process); and

(iii) Optus’ implementation of the Compliance Program and Legal Process;

(b) instruct the Reviewer to prepare a written report to Optus within a period of 3 months of the date of their appointment that makes recommendations which identify:

(i) any revisions to Optus’ Compliance Program and Legal Process, and Optus’ implementation of that program and process, that are reasonably necessary to limit the risk of future contraventions of the ACL of the nature of those the subject of this proceeding; and

(ii) any material deficiencies in the Compliance Program, Legal Process or Optus’ implementation of that program or process that are reasonably necessary to be rectified, and should be rectified, to limit the risk of future contraventions of the ACL of the nature of those the subject of this proceeding;

(c) use best endeavours to provide the Reviewer with access to all sources of information in Optus’ possession, power or control that is relevant to the Reviewer’s review;

(d) within 30 business days of receiving the Reviewer’s written report, provide a copy of that report to the Applicant; and

(e) use best endeavours to implement with due diligence any recommendations made by the Reviewer.

5. Optus serve on the Applicant:

(a) an affidavit verifying that it has carried out its obligations under paragraph 4(b) above, within 10 days of Optus appointing the Reviewer; and

(b) an affidavit verifying that it has carried out its obligations under paragraph 4(e) above, within 8 months of the date of this Order

6. Within 30 days of the date of this Order, Optus Internet pay the Applicant $50,000 in respect of the Applicant’s costs of the proceeding.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The parties also reached an agreed position on the appropriate penalties. In support of the agreed position, the parties filed a statement of agreed facts and admissions, joint submissions and an agreed minute of proposed orders containing penalties and costs. I have included the statement of agreed facts as annexure A to this judgment for reference, though I shall set out below a brief summary of the salient aspects of the agreed facts. On 29 November 2019 the parties’ application for the agreed penalties came before me for consideration. I allowed the application and gave brief ex tempore remarks setting out the conclusions I had reached. I imposed a penalty of $6.4 million to be paid in equal shares by each of the Optus entities. I made orders restraining Optus from engaging in certain prescribed conduct for three years and requiring it to conduct an independent review of its consumer law compliance practices (as set out in the orders above, together, the penalties). The penalties mirrored those agreed between the parties. What follows is a fuller explanation for making the above orders in accordance with the agreement between the parties. Optus is wholly owned by Singtel Optus Pty Limited, which also owns Optus Internet, Optus Mobile and a number of other corporate entities (together, the Optus Group). Optus is the second largest supplier of telecommunications services in Australia. Optus has over 1.1 million broadband customers. Optus provides multiple forms of telecommunications services. Relevant to the present, are NBN services and mobile telecommunications services. The NBN is a wholesale broadband access network being built, owned and operated by NBN Co Limited. ‘NBN services’ are those provided to customers to access the NBN. NBN Co provides wholesale access to the NBN to retail and other telecommunications providers such as Optus, who then provide products to consumers. When the NBN is complete in a given area it is considered ‘ready for service’. This begins a transition period during which time retail providers such as Optus continue to supply services to customers in the ready for service area using the existing fixed-line network, while also offering customers access to NBN based services. After the initial transition period has passed certain pre-NBN infrastructure that is owned by the retail provider in the area may be decommissioned. Provided certain preconditions are met, retail providers may then disconnect remaining pre-NBN services. The representations in issue in the present proceeding were made by Optus to a subset of its customers. The subset comprised those customers who at the time received mobile telecommunications services from a member of the Optus Group, but who were receiving NBN services from a provider other than from the Optus Group (referred to as the Switch Cohort Customers). On 24 May 2018, Optus sent a marketing email to the Switch Cohort Customers which included the following text (referred to as the Disconnection Email):Switch to our lightning fast Optus nbnTM nowYour broadband will be disconnected very soon, make the switch before it’s too late.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether declarations under section 21 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 that Optus had contravened sections 18 and 29(1)(l) of the ACL by the conduct described above are appropriate.
2. Whether orders under section 224(1)(a)(ii) of the ACL requiring Optus to pay $6.4 million by way of pecuniary penalty are appropriate.
3. Whether orders under sections 232 and 233 of the ACL enjoining Optus for three years from engaging in conduct similar to the above are appropriate.
4. Whether orders under section 246(2)(b) of the ACL requiring Optus to undertake an independent review of its compliance program, for the reviewer to provide a report with recommendations, and to put on affidavit evidence that it has carried out its obligations as such are appropriate.

Held
1. The court granted declarations under section 21 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 that Optus had contravened sections 18 and 29(1)(l) of the ACL by the conduct described above.
2. The court granted orders under section 224(1)(a)(ii) of the ACL requiring Optus to pay $6.4 million by way of pecuniary penalty.
3. The court granted orders under sections 232 and 233 of the ACL enjoining Optus for three years from engaging in conduct similar to the above.
4. The court granted orders under section 246(2)(b) of the ACL requiring Optus to undertake an independent review of its compliance program, for the reviewer to provide a report with recommendations, and to put on affidavit evidence that it has carried out its obligations as such.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The parties have agreed certain penalties be imposed under ss 232, 224 and 246 of the ACL, and ss 21 and 43(1) of the FCA Act. The following forms of relief were agreed to be appropriate in this case:(1) Declarations under s 21 of the FCA Act that Optus had contravened ss 18 and 29(1)(l) of the ACL by the conduct described above (declarations);(2) Orders under s 224(1)(a)(ii) of the ACL requiring Optus to pay $6.4 million by way of pecuniary penalty (pecuniary penalties);(3) Orders under ss 232 and 233 of the ACL enjoining Optus for three years from engaging in conduct similar to the above (injunctions); and(4) Orders under s 246(2)(b) of the ACL requiring Optus to undertake an independent review of its compliance program, for the reviewer to provide a report with recommendations, and to put on affidavit evidence that it has carried out its obligations as such (compliance orders). The proper approach to civil regulatory orders sought on an agreed basis was discussed by the High Court in Commonwealth v Director, Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate (2015) 258 CLR 482 (see a recent consideration of this case in Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Medibank Private Limited [2020] FCA 1030 at [10]-[15] per Anderson J). In Commonwealth v Director the plurality judgment of French CJ, Kiefel, Bell, Nettle and Gordon JJ stated (at [58]):… Subject to the court being sufficiently persuaded of the accuracy of the parties' agreement as to facts and consequences, and that the penalty which the parties propose is an appropriate remedy in the circumstances thus revealed, it is consistent with principle and, for the reasons identified in [Trade Practices Commission v Allied Mills Industries Pty Ltd [1981] FCA 156; 37 ALR 256 at 259 per Sheppard J], highly desirable in practice for the court to accept the parties' proposal and therefore impose the proposed penalty.(Emphasis added) I will consider each remedy in turn against the High Court’s dictum in Commonwealth v Director that such remedy must be ‘an appropriate remedy in the circumstances’. It is plain from the facts and admissions stated in the statement of agreed facts that Optus has engaged in the contraventions alleged. It is appropriate the Court’s disapproval of such conduct should be recorded by way of declaration of contravention. Pursuant to s 224(1)(a)(ii) of the ACL, if the Court is satisfied a person has contravened a provision of Part 3-1 of the ACL, which relevantly includes s 29, the Court may order that person pay an appropriate penalty. Section 224(2) provides: In determining the appropriate pecuniary penalty, the court must have regard to all relevant matters including:(a) the nature and extent of the act or omission and of any loss or damage suffered as a result of the act or omission; and(b) the circumstances in which the act or omission took place; and(c) whether the person has previously been found by a court in proceedings under Chapter 4 or this Part to have engaged in any similar conduct.