Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Morild Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 61 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Morild Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 1308

File number: WAD 436 of 2016
Judge: MCKERRACHER J
Date of judgment: 10 November 2017
Catchwords: CONSUMER LAW – contraventions of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) and Competition and Consumer (Industry Codes – Franchising) Regulation 2014 (Cth) (Franchising Code) – breaches of cl 8(1) and cl 9(1) of the Franchising Code for failing to create a complying disclosure document and for the distribution of that non complying disclosure document – where contraventions admitted – where parties agree that the insolvency of two predecessor franchisors was “relevant business experience” which pursuant to the Franchising Code must be disclosed – principles applicable to imposition of a pecuniary penalty, declarations and injunctive relief – appropriateness of agreed orders and declarations
Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) ss 51ACB , 75B(1)(c), 76, 76(1)(a)(iv), 76(1)(e), 76(1A)(ca), 76(1B)(aaa), 80, 80(1)(a)(ii), 80(1)(e), 80(5), 155, 155(1)

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 191

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 21

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) s 80

Competition and Consumer (Industry Codes - Franchising) Regulation 2014 (Cth) Sch 1, cll 8(1), 9(1)

Cases cited:

Australian Communications and Media Authority v FHT Travel Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 550

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Acquire Learning & Careers Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 602

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited (2016) 118 ACSR 124

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Breast Check Pty Ltd (No 2) [2014] FCA 1068

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Ltd (2015) 327 ALR 540

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Dataline.Net.Au Pty Ltd (2006) 236 ALR 665

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Dataline.Net.Au Pty Ltd (2007) 161 FCR 513

Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2007] ATPR 42-140

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Hillside (Australia New Media) Pty Ltd trading as Bet365 (No 2) [2016] FCA 698

Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Leahy Petroleum Pty Ltd (No 3) (2005) 215 ALR 301

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Mailpost Australia Ltd [2010] FCA 369

Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Midland Brick Co Pty Ltd (2004) 207 ALR 329

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v MSY Technology Pty Ltd (2012) 201 FCR 378

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Real Estate Institute of Western Australia Inc (1999) 161 ALR 79

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Reckitt Benckiser (Australia) Pty Ltd (2016) 340 ALR 25

Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Sampson [2011] ATPR 42-374

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Snowdale Holdings Pty Ltd (No 2) [2017] FCA 834

Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Target Australia Pty Ltd (2001) ATPR 41-840

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Telstra CorporationLimited (2010) 188 FCR 238

Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Virgin Mobile Australia Pty Ltd (No 2) [2002] FCA 1548

Australian Ophthalmic Supplies Pty Ltd v McAlary-Smith (2008) 165 FCR 560

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Morild Pty... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] FCA 1308
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Morild Pty Ltd, the ACCC pursued legal action against Morild Pty Ltd for contraventions of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) and the Competition and Consumer (Industry Codes – Franchising) Regulation 2014 (Cth). The ACCC alleged that Morild Pty Ltd breached clauses 8(1) and 9(1) of the Franchising Code by failing to create and distribute a compliant disclosure document that included the relevant business experience of Morild's director, Mr Bernstein, who had been a director of two predecessor companies that had gone into winding up by reason of insolvency. Both parties admitted the contraventions and agreed on the appropriate relief. The court had to determine the appropriate declarations, injunctive relief, pecuniary penalties, and costs.

The court held that Morild Pty Ltd contravened cl 8(1) of the Franchising Code by failing to create a disclosure document that disclosed Mr Bernstein's relevant business experience. It also contravened cl 9(1) of the Franchising Code by distributing a disclosure document that did not include this information. The court further found Mr Bernstein to be knowingly concerned in these contraventions. The agreed orders included declarations of contraventions, injunctive relief requiring the inclusion of specific information in disclosure documents, and pecuniary penalties for Morild Pty Ltd and Mr Bernstein. The respondents were also ordered to pay the ACCC's costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Injunctions

4. The first respondent, until 6 December 2023, in any franchise disclosure document provided to a prospective franchisee, under the business experience of each officer of the first respondent who was as at 6 December 2013 an officer of SSP Holdings Pty Ltd, must include the following (with the officer's name to be inserted in the place of "[Name]"):

[Name] was an officer of SSP Holdings Pty Ltd, a previous franchisor of the Pastacup franchise system, which on 6 December 2013 resolved to be wound up voluntarily as it was unable to pay its debts as and when they fell due.

5. The first respondent, until 21 October 2024, in any franchise disclosure document provided to a prospective franchisee, under the business experience of each officer of the first respondent who was as at 21 October 2014 an officer of Pastacup Australia Pty Ltd (ACN 150 392 340), to must include the following (with the officer's name to be inserted in the place of "[Name]"):

[Name] was an officer of Pastacup Australia Pty Ltd, a previous franchisor of the Pastacup franchise system, which on 21 October 2014 was ordered to be wound up in insolvency and was deregistered on 12 June 2016.

6. Subject to paragraph 7 below, the second respondent must ensure that, until 21 October 2024, in any disclosure document provided to a prospective franchisee by a company of which he is an officer, the summary of the relevant business experience of the second respondent includes the following:

Stuart Ian Bernstein was a director of SSP Holdings Pty Ltd, a previous franchisor of the Pastacup franchise system, which on 6 December 2013 resolved to be wound up voluntarily as it was unable to pay its debts as and when they fell due. Also, Stuart Ian Bernstein was a director of Pastacup Australia, a previous franchisor of the Pastacup franchise system, which on 21 October 2014 was ordered to be wound up in insolvency and was deregistered on 12 June 2016.

7. After 6 December 2023, the following words are not required to be included in the passage in quotation marks in paragraph 6 above:

Stuart Ian Bernstein was a director of SSP Holdings Pty Ltd, a previous franchisor of the Pastacup franchise system, which on 6 December 2013 resolved to be wound up voluntarily as it was unable to pay its debts as and when they fell due.

Pecuniary Penalties

8. The first respondent pay to the Commonwealth of Australia a penalty of $100,000 with payment to be made in 24 monthly instalments, with the first payment occurring on the first day of the month following the date that this order is made and each subsequent next payment occurring on the first day of each subsequent month.

9. The second respondent pay to the Commonwealth of Australia a penalty of $50,000 with payment to be made in 24 monthly instalments, with the first payment occurring on the first day of the month following the date on which the second respondent is discharged from bankruptcy and each subsequent next payment occurring on the first date of each subsequent month.

Costs

10. The respondents must pay the applicant's costs, fixed at the sum of $12,000.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In light of these considerations, Morild will be permitted to pay the fine sought in instalments over the period of 24 months.CONCLUSION Orders are made in accordance with the agreed minute:THE COURT DECLARES THAT:(1)Morild contravened cl 8(1) of Schedule 1 to the Franchising Code and thereby contravened s 51ACB of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) (CCA) by failing, between 1 January 2015 and at least 8 January 2016 (both dates inclusive), to create a franchise disclosure document concerning the Pastacup franchise system that disclosed that the relevant business experience of Morild's director, Mr Bernstein, included that he was previously a director of two companies who had acted as franchisors of the same franchise system and went into winding up by reason of insolvency.(2)Between 18 March 2015 and 25 September 2015, Morild contravened cl 9(1) of the Franchising Code and thereby contravened s 51ACB of the CCA by giving a franchise disclosure document dated 18 November 2014 concerning the Pastacup franchise system to prospective franchisees which document did not disclose that the relevant business experience of Morild's director, Mr Bernstein, included that he was previously a director of two companies who had acted as franchisors of the same franchise system and went into winding up by reason of insolvency.(3)Mr Bernstein was a person knowingly concerned:(a)within the meaning of s 75B(1)(c) of the CCA in Morild's contraventions of s 51ACB of the CCA referred to in paragraphs 1 and 2 above;(b)within the meaning of s 76(1)(e) of the CCA in Morild's contraventions of cl 8(1) and cl 9(1) of the Franchising Code referred to in paragraphs 1 and 2 above; and(c) within the meaning of s 80(1)(e) of the CCA in Morild's contraventions of s 51ACB of the CCA referred to in paragraphs 1 and 2 above.THE COURT ORDERS THAT:Injunctions(4)Morild, until 6 December 2023, in any franchise disclosure document provided to a prospective franchisee, under the business experience of each officer of Morild who was as at 6 December 2013 an officer of SSP Holdings, must include the following (with the officer's name to be inserted in the place of "[Name]"):[Name] was an officer of [SSP Holdings], a previous franchisor of the Pastacup franchise system, which on 6 December 2013 resolved to be wound up voluntarily as it was unable to pay its debts as and when they fell due.(5)Morild, until 21 October 2024, in any franchise disclosure document provided to a prospective franchisee, under the business experience of each officer of Morild who was as at 21 October 2014 an officer of Pastacup Australia Pty Ltd (ACN 150 392 340), to must include the following (with the officer's name to be inserted in the place of "[Name]"):[Name] was an officer of Pastacup Australia Pty Ltd, a previous franchisor of the Pastacup franchise system, which on 21 October 2014 was ordered to be wound up in insolvency and was deregistered on 12 June 2016. (6)Subject to paragraph 7 below, Mr Bernstein must ensure that, until 21 October 2024, in any disclosure document provided to a prospective franchisee by a company of which he is an officer, the summary of the relevant business experience of Mr Bernstein includes the following:[Mr] Bernstein was a director of [SSP Holdings], a previous franchisor of the Pastacup franchise system, which on 6 December 2013 resolved to be wound up voluntarily as it was unable to pay its debts as and when they fell due. Also, [Mr] Bernstein was a director of Pastacup Australia, a previous franchisor of the Pastacup franchise system, which on 21 October 2014 was ordered to be wound up in insolvency and was deregistered on 12 June 2016. (7)After 6 December 2023, the following words are not required to be included in the passage in quotation marks in paragraph 6 above:[Mr] Bernstein was a director of [SSP Holdings], a previous franchisor of the Pastacup franchise system, which on 6 December 2013 resolved to be wound up voluntarily as it was unable to pay its debts as and when they fell due.Pecuniary Penalties(8)Morild must pay to the Commonwealth of Australia a penalty of $100,000 with payment to be made in 24 monthly instalments, with the first payment occurring on the first day of the month following the date that this order is made and each subsequent next payment occurring on the first day of each subsequent month.(9)Mr Bernstein must pay to the Commonwealth of Australia a penalty of $50,000 with payment to be made in 24 monthly instalments, with the first payment occurring on the first day of the month following the date on which Mr Bernstein is discharged from bankruptcy and each subsequent next payment occurring on the first date of each subsequent month.Costs(10)The respondents must pay the applicant's costs, fixed at the sum of $12,000.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In those circumstances, the parties agree that the appropriate relief is as follows:Declarations(1)A declaration that Morild contravened cl 8(1) of Sch 1 to the Franchising Code and thereby contravened s 51ACB of the CCA by failing, between 1 January 2015 and at least 8 January 2016 (both dates inclusive), to create a franchise disclosure document concerning the Pastacup franchise system that disclosed that the relevant business experience of Morild’s director, Mr Bernstein, included that he was previously a director of two companies who had acted as franchisors of the same franchise system and went into winding up by reason of insolvency.(2)A declaration that between 18 March 2015 and 25 September 2015, Morild contravened cl 9(1) of the Franchising Code and thereby contravened s 51ACB of the CCA by giving a franchise disclosure document dated 18 November 2014 concerning the Pastacup franchise system to prospective franchisees which document did not disclose that the relevant business experience of Morild’s director, Mr Bernstein, included that he was previously a director of two companies who had acted as franchisors of the same franchise system and went into winding up by reason of insolvency.(3)A declaration that Mr Bernstein was a person knowingly concerned:(a)within the meaning of s 75B(1)(c) of the CCA in Morild’s contraventions of s 51ACB of the CCA referred to in paragraphs (1) and (2) above;(b)within the meaning of s 76(1)(e) of the CCA in Morild’s contraventions of cl 8(1) and cl 9(1) of the Franchising Code referred to in paragraphs (1) and (2) above; and(c)within the meaning of s 80(1)(e) of the CCA in Morild’s contraventions of s 51ACB of the CCA referred to in paragraphs (1) and (2) above.Injunctions(4)In the following paragraphs (5), (6) and (7) “officer” has the same meaning as in the Code.(5)An order requiring Morild, until 6 December 2023, in any franchise disclosure document provided to a prospective franchisee, under the business experience of each officer of Morild who was as at 6 December 2013 an officer of SSP Holdings, to include the following (with the officer’s name to be inserted in the place of “[Name]”):[Name] was an officer of [SSP Holdings], a previous franchisor of the Pastacup franchise system, which on 6 December 2013 resolved to be wound up voluntarily as it was unable to pay its debts as and when they fell due.(6)An order requiring Morild, until 21 October 2024, in any franchise disclosure document provided to a prospective franchisee, under the business experience of each officer of Morild who was as at 21 October 2014 an officer of Pastacup Australia Pty Ltd (ACN 150 392 340), to include the following (with the officer’s name to be inserted in the place of “[Name]”):[Name] was an officer of Pastacup Australia Pty Ltd, a previous franchisor of the Pastacup franchise system, which on 21 October 2014 was ordered to be wound up in insolvency and was deregistered on 12 June 2016.(7)Subject to paragraph (8) below, an order requiring Mr Bernstein to ensure that, until 21 October 2024, in any disclosure document provided to a prospective franchisee by a company of which he is an officer, the summary of the relevant business experience of Mr Bernstein include the following:[Mr] Bernstein was a director of SSP Holdings, a previous franchisor of the Pastacup franchise system, which on 6 December 2013 resolved to be wound up voluntarily as it was unable to pay its debts as and when they fell due. Also, [Mr] Bernstein was a director of Pastacup Australia Pty Ltd, a previous franchisor of the Pastacup franchise system, which on 21 October 2014 was ordered to be wound up in insolvency and was deregistered on 12 June 2016.(8)After 6 December 2023, the following words are not required to be included in the passage in quotation marks in paragraph (7) above:[Mr] Bernstein was a director of SSP Holdings, a previous franchisor of the Pastacup franchise system, which on 6 December 2013 resolved to be wound up voluntarily as it was unable to pay its debts as and when they fell due.Pecuniary penalties(9)An order that Morild pay to the Commonwealth of Australia a penalty of $100,000 with payment to be made in 24 monthly instalments, with the first payment occurring on the first day of the month following the date that this order is made and each subsequent next payment occurring on the first day of each subsequent month.(10)An order that Mr Bernstein pay to the Commonwealth of Australia a penalty of $50,000 with payment to be made in 24 monthly instalments, with the first payment occurring on the first day of the month following the date on which Mr Bernstein is discharged from bankruptcy and each subsequent next payment occurring on the first date of each subsequent month.Costs(11)The respondents pay the Applicant’s costs, fixed at the sum of $12,000.CONSIDERATION