Wade v Australian Railway Historical Society

Link copied
Case Copied 80 min read

WADE v AUSTRALIAN RAILWAY HISTORICAL SOCIETY (SOUTH AUSTRALIAN DIVISION) trading as STEAMRANGER & ORS
[2000] SASC 233

Full Court:  Doyle CJ, Duggan and Lander JJ

  1. DOYLE CJ.       The plaintiff, Mr Wade, suffered very serious injuries when he and the motorcycle that he was riding collided with a train drawn by a steam locomotive operated by the defendant Australian Railway Historical Society (South Australian Division) (“Steamranger”).  The collision occurred at a level crossing where the road on which the plaintiff travelled crossed a railway line.  The road was vested in and maintained by the defendant Alexandrina Council (“the Council”).  Immediately before the collision Mr Wade was riding his motorcycle in a northerly direction on Airport Road.  The train was travelling in a south easterly direction along the railway line.  Thus, the train was approaching the level crossing from a point ahead of Mr Wade and to his left.  The angle formed by the plaintiff’s lefthand side of the road and the railway line where it meets the lefthand side of the road is an angle of about 130 degrees.

  2. The plaintiff sued Steamranger and the Council for negligence.

  3. The action was tried by a Master of this Court.  The Master found both defendants liable.  He found that Mr Wade was guilty of contributory negligence, and reduced his damages by 70 per cent.  The Master apportioned two-thirds of the liability to the Council, and one-third to Steamranger.  The Master assessed Mr Wade’s damages at $1,725,554.99.  Judgment was entered for the plaintiff against both defendants for $524,666.50.

  4. All parties have appealed against the judgment on a number of grounds.  The parties challenge findings of fact and conclusions of law, and the assessment of damages.

Airport Road and the level crossing

  1. I begin with a general description of the place at which the collision occurred.  Airport Road is vested in the Council, and is under its care, management and control:  Local Government Act 1934 s 301 and s 306.

  2. On the immediate approach to the level crossing Airport Road runs in a north-south direction.  The railway corridor crosses it in a north-west south-east direction.  For a train approaching the crossing from the north-east, the railway track curves to the left about 340 metres from the level crossing.  For a person approaching the level crossing on Airport Road from the south, the road curves to the left about 220 metres before the crossing and then runs straight in a

northerly direction for about 180 metres until it crosses the railway line.  Mr Wade was approaching the level crossing with the train approaching the level crossing from his left side.  Mr Wade was on the right side of the train as it approached the level crossing.

  1. The level crossing is located in a rural area.  The railway line is used only by tourist trains and then on an infrequent basis.  The road, however, is reasonably busy with a high volume of vehicular traffic. [AB 64]

  2. I shall deal in more detail later with the traffic control…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wade v Australian Railway Historical Society and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] SASC 233
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Wade v Australian Railway Historical Society, the plaintiff, Mr Wade, was seriously injured when his motorcycle collided with a train operated by the defendant Australian Railway Historical Society (South Australian Division) at a level crossing. The plaintiff sued both the Society and the Alexandrina Council, which maintained the road, for negligence. The trial judge found both defendants liable and assessed the plaintiff’s damages at $1,725,554.99, reduced by 70% for contributory negligence. The defendants appealed against the judgment on various grounds, including the findings of fact, conclusions of law, and the assessment of damages. The Full Court considered the evidence and the submissions of the parties and concluded that the trial judge’s findings on the causes of the collision, the adequacy of the warning signs, and the failure to install a stop sign were open on the evidence and should not be disturbed. The Court also held that the Council did not owe a duty of care to clear the roadside vegetation that obstructed the plaintiff’s view, as the non-feasance immunity applied to highway authorities. The Court reduced the award for future loss of earning capacity by $50,000 and increased the award for future care by the same amount. The Court dismissed all appeals against damages.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Wade suffered very serious injuries when he and the motorcycle he was riding collided with a train operated by the Australian Railway Historical Society (South Australian Division) at a level crossing on Airport Road. The collision occurred at a level crossing where the road crossed a railway line. The road was maintained by the Alexandrina Council. Mr Wade was riding his motorcycle in a northerly direction on Airport Road, and the train was travelling in a south easterly direction along the railway line. The angle formed by the plaintiff's lefthand side of the road and the railway line where it meets the lefthand side of the road was about 130 degrees. The plaintiff sued both defendants for negligence. The Master found both defendants liable, with the Council being two-thirds liable and Steamranger one-third liable. The Master assessed Mr Wade's damages at $1,725,554.99 and reduced them by 70% due to contributory negligence, resulting in a judgment for $524,666.50.

The case was tried before a Master of the South Australian Supreme Court. The Master found both defendants liable and apportioned liability between them. The plaintiff was awarded damages, which were reduced by 70% due to contributory negligence. Both parties appealed against the judgment on several grounds, including findings of fact and conclusions of law, and the assessment of damages. The appeals were heard by the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia.

Decision

Reasons for decision

DOYLE CJ
Issues
1. Whether the foliage on Mr Wade's left side of the road was a cause of the collision and whether the Council was in breach of a duty of care in permitting the foliage to remain there.
2. Whether either defendant was in breach of a duty of care in failing to have a stop sign placed at the level crossing, and facing the direction from which Mr Wade approached.
3. Whether Steamranger was negligent in its operation of the train, including the speed at which it approached the level crossing.
4. Whether the Council owed a duty of care to clear roadside vegetation and whether it was in breach of that duty.
5. Whether the Master's assessment of damages for future economic loss, future medical and other costs, and future care was correct.

Held
1. The Full Court found that the foliage on Mr Wade's left side of the road was a cause of the collision and that the Council was in breach of a duty of care in permitting the foliage to remain there.
2. The Full Court found that either defendant was not in breach of a duty of care in failing to have a stop sign placed at the level crossing, facing the direction from which Mr Wade approached.
3. The Full Court found that Steamranger was not negligent in its operation of the train, including the speed at which it approached the level crossing.
4. The Full Court found that the Council owed a duty of care to clear roadside vegetation and was in breach of that duty.
5. The Full Court found that the Master's assessment of damages for future economic loss, future medical and other costs, and future care was incorrect. The Full Court reduced the award for loss of future earning capacity and increased the award for future care.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: DOYLE CJ

The Full Court examined the evidence and found that the foliage on Mr Wade's left side of the road significantly obstructed his view and was a cause of the collision. The Court concluded that the Council was in breach of a duty of care by not clearing the foliage. The Full Court rejected the argument that a stop sign should have been placed at the level crossing, finding that the existing give way signs were sufficient. The Court found that Steamranger was not negligent in its operation of the train, including the speed at which it approached the level crossing. The Court found that the Council owed a duty of care to clear roadside vegetation and was in breach of that duty. The Court concluded that the Master's assessment of damages was incorrect, reducing the award for loss of future earning capacity and increasing the award for future care. The Full Court upheld the Master's assessment of damages for non-economic loss, future medical and other costs, and special damages. The Full Court dismissed all appeals against the assessment of damages as a whole.