Valra Pty Ltd v Mag Men Holdings Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Valra Pty Ltd v Mag Men Holdings Pty Ltd (No 2) [2020] FCA 314

File number: WAD 294 of 2016
Judge: BANKS-SMITH J
Date of judgment: 12 March 2020
Catchwords:

COSTS - where applicant succeeded on one aspect of its claim but awarded nominal damages - where all other claims dismissed - where applicant conceded only at trial that any damages would be nominal only - where respondents required to address significant number of matters in proceedings - whether applicant can be considered successful party where relief limited to declaration of breach and nominal damages - whether declaration as to breach of any real value - circumstances in which party that is successful or successful in part may be deprived of its costs - whether there should be apportionment of costs to allow for limited success - order that applicant pay respondents' costs

COSTS - where respondents made offer of compromise under r 25.14 of Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) and Calderbank offer - where applicant rejected offers - where judgment given less favourable than terms of respondents' offers - indemnity costs - whether reasonableness of rejection of offer relevant to r 25.14 - where applicant's conduct led to significant inefficiencies in proceedings - order that respondents entitled to indemnity costs

COSTS - preliminary discovery application - applicant sought discovery of 51 categories of documents - production of only one category of documents ordered - where despite limited success applicant seeks that first respondent pay applicant's costs of preliminary discovery action - whether respondents adopted adversarial approach to preliminary discovery application - order that applicant pay respondents' costs of preliminary discovery application and costs of compliance with preliminary discovery application

Legislation:

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 43

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 7.23, 25.01, 25.14

Cases cited:

Basetec Services Pty Ltd v Leighton Contractors Pty Ltd (No 8) [2017] FCA 258

Calderbank v Calderbank [1975] 3 All ER 333

Cappuccio v Australia & New Zealand Banking Group Ltd [1999] FCA 1188

Coal Hub Pty Ltd v NSL Consolidated Ltd [No 5] [2018] WASC 326

Futuretronics.com.au Pty Ltd v Graphix Labels Pty Ltd [2009] FCAFC 40

Industrial Galvanizers Corporation Pty Ltd v Safe Direction Pty Ltd (No 2) [2018] FCA 1612

Lucas Earthmovers Pty Ltd v Anglogold Ashanti Australia Limited (No 2) [2019] FCA 1864

Motium Pty Ltd v Arrow Electronics Australia Pty Ltd [2011] WASCA 65 (S)

Oshlack v Richmond River Council [1998] HCA 11; (1998) 193 CLR 72

Pfizer Ireland Pharmaceuticals v Samsung Bioepis AU Pty Ltd (No 1) [2019] FCA 657

Queensland North Australia Pty Ltd v Takeovers Panel (No 2) [2015] FCAFC 128; (2015) 236 FCR 370

Romero v Farstad Shipping (Indian Pacific) Pty Ltd (No 3) [2017] FCAFC 102

Romero v Farstad Shipping (Indian Pacific) Pty Ltd (No 4) [2017] FCA 120

Ruddock v Vadarlis [2001] FCA 1865; (2001) 115 FCR 229

Specsavers Pty Ltd v The Optical Superstore Pty Ltd [2012] FCAFC 183;

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Valra Pty Ltd v Mag Men Holdings Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 314
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Valra Pty Ltd v Mag Men Holdings Pty Ltd (No 2) involved a dispute between the applicant, Valra, and the respondents, Mag Men Holdings. The case primarily centred on the costs incurred in the proceedings, following Valra's partial success on one aspect of its claim but receiving only nominal damages. The other claims were dismissed, and Valra had conceded at trial that any damages would be nominal only. The respondents had to address a significant number of issues raised by Valra in the proceedings. The central legal issues revolved around whether Valra could be considered the successful party given the limited relief of a declaration of breach and nominal damages, and whether such declaration held any real value. Additionally, the court had to consider under what circumstances a party that was successful or successful in part could be deprived of its costs, and whether there should be an apportionment of costs to reflect the limited success.

The court's reasoning highlighted that Valra had limited success in the proceedings, with only a declaration of breach and nominal damages awarded. The court found that the declaration of breach was of limited value, and thus, Valra could not be considered the successful party. The court also noted that the respondents had made compromise offers, which Valra had rejected. The judgment was less favourable than the terms of the respondents' offers, which further justified the awarding of indemnity costs to the respondents. The court found that Valra's conduct led to significant inefficiencies in the proceedings, thereby warranting the award of indemnity costs. Furthermore, the court ordered Valra to pay the respondents' costs for the preliminary discovery application, as Valra had sought discovery of a vast number of documents but only succeeded in obtaining production of one category.

In light of the court's reasoning, the final orders were that Valra pay the respondents' costs up to a specified date on a party/party basis and from that date onwards on an indemnity basis. Valra was also ordered to pay the first respondent's costs of the preliminary discovery application and the respondents' costs relating to written submissions on the costs of the proceedings and the preliminary discovery application, all on a party/party basis. These orders reflect the court's determination that Valra's limited success did not justify recovery of costs, and that the respondents were entitled to indemnity costs due to Valra's conduct throughout the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicant pay the respondents' costs up to 11.00 am on Thursday 2 February 2017 on a party/party basis, to be assessed if not agreed.

2. Subject to order 4, the applicant pay the respondents' costs from 11.00 am on Thursday 2 February 2017 on an indemnity basis, to be assessed if not agreed.

3. The applicant pay the first respondent's costs of the preliminary discovery application (WAD369 of 2014), including the first respondent's costs of compliance, on a party/party basis to be assessed if not agreed.

4. The applicant pay the respondents' costs relating to the written submissions on the costs of the proceedings and the costs of the preliminary discovery application on a party/party basis, to be assessed if not agreed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

After publication of reasons in that matter, the parties filed submissions as to costs. It appears that no orders were made and so the costs of that application are also dealt with in these reasons. Further, the preliminary discovery application is relevant to the broader question of costs in the main proceedings. As noted in the primary reasons (at [330]‑[332]), it was not seriously in issue at trial that as at the relevant transfer date the MMH shares were of only nominal value, and accordingly any damages that flowed from their transfer were at best nominal. This followed from the apparent insolvency of the company at that time, as foreshadowed and addressed by Siopis J in Valra v Mag Men No 1 (at [72]-[89] of those reasons). Valra was on notice from the time of Valra v Mag Men No 1 (at the latest) that the evidence as to MMH's financial position did not support a contention that the shares were of any real value. Valra evinced no evidence as to value. Valra had the opportunity to put on expert evidence as to the value of the MMH shares, chose not to put on any expert evidence and disclosed its concession as to any damages being nominal only very late in the proceedings.Further background - compromise offers The proceedings commenced by originating application filed 5 July 2016. On 31 January 2017 the respondents made separate compromise offers. The first offer was made by way of a 'notice of offer to compromise' in accordance with r 25.01(1) of the Federal Court Rules. It stated that the respondents offered to compromise 'this proceeding' by paying Valra the sum of $10,000 in respect of the claim, interest and costs. The second offer was by way of a letter said to be in accordance with the principles of Calderbank v Calderbank [1975] 3 All ER 333, and offering to settle 'this proceeding and all related disputes' on terms that the respondents pay Valra the sum of $10,000 in full and final settlement of all claims, inclusive of interest and costs, such payment to be within seven days of execution of a settlement deed. The proceeding would be dismissed with no order as to costs and there would be no order as to the costs in relation to the preliminary discovery application. The letter addressed in some detail the nature of the claims made at that time by Valra and gave reasons why it considered that it was unreasonable for Valra to reject the offer. The letter referred to the absence of any reliable evidence to support the allegations as to the Valibhoy Agreement (as addressed in the reasons at [149]-[174]); the conflicting correspondence (as addressed in the reasons at [164]‑[165]); the lack of evidence in support of the alleged breaches of the Shareholders Deed (as addressed in the reasons at [244]‑[273]); and the absence of reliable evidence relating to the oppression claim (as addressed in the reasons at [275]‑[321]). Relevantly, the letter noted Siopis J's reasons to the effect that the viability of MMH was entirely dependent on the support of its financiers, that its subsidiaries had incurred significant losses and that it had no other significant assets. MMH informed Valra by the letter that it would seek indemnity costs if the offer was not accepted and an order was made after trial that was not more favourable than the offer.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established