ED Oates Pty Ltd v Edgar Edmondson Imports

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

E D Oates Pty Ltd v Edgar Edmondson Imports [2012] FCA 356

Citation: E D Oates Pty Ltd v Edgar Edmondson Imports [2012] FCA 356
Parties: E D OATES PTY LTD (ACN 004 329 462) v EDGAR EDMONDSON IMPORTS PTY LTD (ACN 002 921 888)
File number: VID 721 of 2011
Judge: KENNY J
Date of judgment: 5 April 2012
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Preliminary discovery – to ascertain whether right to obtain relief – possible action for design infringement and associated actions – competitors in mop bucket market – applicant’s product the subject of registered design – whether reasonable cause to believe right to relief – obvious imitation – fraudulent imitation – whether all reasonable enquiries made – whether insufficient information to make a decision about commencing proceedings– whether reasonable cause to believe that respondent have relevant documents – criteria for preliminary discovery satisfied – costs considered
Legislation: Federal Court Rules 1979 (Cth)
Designs Act 1906 (Cth)
Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)
Cases cited: Rosebank Plastics Pty Ltd v Duncan & Wigley Pty Ltd (1988) 11 IPR 413
St George Bank Ltd v Rabo Australia Ltd (2004) 211 ALR 147
Echo Tasmania Pty Ltd v Imperial Chemical Industries PLC [2008] FCAFC 58
Apache Northwest Pty Ltd v Newcrest Mining Ltd (2009) 182 FCR 124
Henley Arch Pty Ltd v McDonald Jones Homes Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 687
East Grace Corporation v Xing (No 2) [2005] FCA 1266
Guy Carpenter & Company Pty Ltd v Grove [2011] FCA 708
Austrack Operations Pty Ltd (In Liquidation) v State of New South Wales [2003] FCA 1013
Glencore International AG v Selwyn MinesLtd (2005) 223 ALR 238
Technicon Industries Pty Ltd v Caroma Industries Ltd (2009) 81 IPR 465
Malleys Ltd v J.W. Tomlin Pty Ltd (1961) 180 CLR 120 Polyaire Pty Ltd v K-Aire Pty Ltd (2005) 221 CLR 287 Fisher & Paykel Healthcare Pty Ltd v Avion Engineering Pty Ltd (1991) 22 IPR 1
Lewis v Hall (2005) 68 IPR 89
Turbo Tek Enterprises Inc v Sperling Enterprises Pty Ltd (1989) 23 FCR 331
Wanem Pty Ltd v John Tekila (1990) 19 IPR 435
D Sebel & Co Ltd v National Art Metal Co Pty Ltd (1965) 10 FLR 224
C7 Pty Ltd v Foxtel Management Pty Ltd [2001] FCA 1864 Anglo Coal (Dawson) Management Pty Ltd v Greig [2011] FCA 941
Optiver Australia Pty Ltd v Tibra Trading Pty Ltd (2008) 249 ALR 495
Lynx Engineering Consultants Pty Ltd v The ANI Corporation Limited [2007] FCA 578
Quanta Software International Pty Ltd v Computer Management Services Pty Ltd (2000) 49 IPR 25
Wundowie Foundry Pty Ltd v Milson Foundry Pty Ltd (1993) 27 IPR 202
Wellcome Foundation Ltd v VR Laboratories (Aust) Pty Ltd (1981) 148 CLR 262
Date of hearing: 20 October 2011
Date of last submissions: 6 October 2011
Place: Melbourne
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 59
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr R J L McCormack
Solicitor for…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ED Oates Pty Ltd v Edgar Edmondson Imports and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] FCA 356
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

ED Oates Pty Ltd initiated proceedings against Edgar Edmondson Imports seeking a preliminary discovery order to ascertain whether it had a right to relief from alleged design infringement and related causes of action. The Federal Court was tasked with determining if the criteria for granting preliminary discovery under Order 15A Rule 6 of the Federal Court Rules 1979 were satisfied. The applicant needed to demonstrate that there was reasonable cause to believe it had a right to obtain relief, that it lacked sufficient information to decide whether to commence proceedings, and that the respondent had or was likely to have documents that could assist in making that decision.

The Court found that ED Oates had presented a compelling case for preliminary discovery. Expert evidence from Dr Bruce Field and Mr Robert Kelson indicated that the mop bucket designs in question exhibited a high degree of similarity, raising suspicions of infringement. However, the exact nature and intent behind the design choices were unclear. The documents sought by Oates, which detailed the development and design process of the respondent’s product, were deemed essential for Oates to make an informed decision on whether to proceed with litigation. The Court concluded that the criteria for preliminary discovery were met, as Oates had a reasonable cause to believe it might have a right to relief, it lacked sufficient information to make a decision, and the respondent likely held documents that could provide the necessary insight. Consequently, the Court granted the preliminary discovery application, ordering the respondent to provide specified documents by a set deadline and allowing Oates to apply for further examination of the respondent if needed. The application was adjourned pending the outcome of any substantive proceedings that might be initiated by Oates.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. On or before 20 April 2012, the respondent make discovery, verified on oath, of any documents in its possession, custody or control, including letters, emails, notes and memoranda, which record or evidence the development of Australian Design Registration 330806 (“Design 330806”) and the article that is marked BWF-6 to the affidavit of Bruce William Field sworn on 24 June 2011 (“the Enduro wringer bucket”) filed in this proceeding, in the following categories:

(a) initiating instructions, directions or information provided to any person, including (but not limited to) any patent attorney involved or in respect of whom a request was made to investigate, consider or otherwise devise Design 330806 and/or the Enduro wringer bucket;

(b) communications with, and responses from any third party, in respect of the application made by or on behalf of the Respondent, for what has issued as Design 330806, including:

(i) correspondence with or from IP Australia;

(ii) correspondence with any third party involved in the design of the Product; and or

(iii) communications with any patent attorney involved in the application for Design 330806.

2. There be liberty to apply in relation to the implementation of Order 1.

3. There be liberty to the applicant to apply on or before 4 May 2012 for an order for the examination of the respondent under Order 15A Rule 3(2)(a) of the Federal Court Rules 1979 (Cth).

4. The application for preliminary discovery dated 4 July 2011 be adjourned to a date to be fixed before 31 May 2012; and, if no date be fixed by 31 May 2012 (and no other date be directed in lieu thereof) the application for preliminary discovery dated 4 July 2012 stand dismissed with effect from 31 May 2012.

5. The applicant pay the costs of the respondent unless, on or before 31 May 2012, or such other date as may be directed, the applicant commences substantive proceedings substantially as described in the letter from Arcadia Lawyers to the respondent dated 11 May 2011 seeking preliminary discovery, and the further letter from Arcadia Lawyers to Piper Alderman dated 6 June 2011. In the event that such action is commenced, the costs of this application will be costs in that action.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Having regard to the attack made by Edmondson on Oates’ application and Mr Kelson’s analysis at the hearing of the application, it is important to note that Mr Kelson specifically described how he sought to determine whether an infringement proceeding was justified in such a case as this. Mr Kelson stated as follows:As a matter of practice, I have, and continue to adhere to the view that there is a significant overlap between obvious and fraudulent imitation. As a matter of practice, I have endeavoured, wherever possible, to ascertain from the available evidence, what the intention of the designer of the alleged infringing article, was attempting to achieve for the subject article, considered by reference to matters including:(a)assessing the scope of the registered design against the background of the prior art at the priority date … (emphasis added);(b)by looking at the alleged infringing article and assessing its features of shape or configuration, and comparing that to the registered design and the representations of the article therein …;(c)I also consider the method of construction, as well as the materials used, and the purpose and object of the article, considered from a commercial and manufacturing perspective, as such matters are directly relevant to cost of manufacture … Having done this analysis, Mr Kelson concluded:[I]n the case of the Edmondson’s Mop Bucket [], when I look at the features and compare those to the [Oates Registered Design], although I can readily identify features apparent to my eye of similarity … I am not able to satisfy myself that the test for either obvious or fraudulent imitation … is at a sufficient level of similarity which would justify my recommending to the applicant that there is sufficient evidence to warrant commencement of an infringement action. Referring to the features noted by Dr Field (see [15] above), Mr Kelson added that he considered that access to the documents described in the Schedule was necessary in order to have information as to “the intention or motive of the designer”, being the information that, in his view, was essential to determine whether Oates was justified in proceeding against Edmondson. Mr Kelson’s position was, in summary, that, whilst the similarities between Edmondson’s Product and the Oates Registered Design were sufficient “to arguably meet the requirements of … the elements of the cause of action based on an obvious imitation, as well as a claim for fraudulent imitation, the critical evidence necessary … to be able to reasonably assist [Oates] to make a determination as to whether to commence legal proceedings against [Edmondson] would be resolved” only if the documents in the Schedule were made available. According to Mr Kelson, these documents would enable him to consider the extent of any infringements and the defences that might be open to Edmondson. Mr Kelson noted that there were related causes of action that might also be pursued in an infringement proceeding (e.g., pursuant to ss 18 and 29 of Schedule 2 of the CCA).CONSIDERATION

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Put simply, Oates claimed that, in order to determine whether it is entitled to relief against Edmondson for design infringement, Oates requires access to the documents relating to the development of Edmondson’s Product, in particular those documents that record steps taken in the design and development of Edmondson’s Product. Hence, Oates has brought this application for preliminary discovery. EVIDENCE In support of its preliminary discovery application, Oates relied on the affidavits of Bruce William Field sworn on 24 June 2011 and 29 August 2011, the affidavits of Virginia Ann Beniac-Brooks sworn on 14 July 2011, 15 August 2011 and 25 August 2011, and the affidavits of Robert Charles Kelson sworn on 16 August 2011 and 26 August 2011 (including all annexures or exhibits). In opposing Oates’ application, Edmondson relied on the affidavit of its solicitor, Timothy Ewart Clark, sworn on 26 August 2011. It is unnecessary here to refer in detail to any save the first affidavits of Dr Field and Mr Kelson. Dr Field gave an expert’s opinion that further information in the nature of that sought was necessary before a determination could be made as to whether or not to recommend to Oates that Oates institute a proceeding against Edmondson for design infringement. In his capacity as a patent and trade mark attorney experienced in designs, Mr Kelson gave evidence to the same effect. Evidence of this kind has been relied on in a similar context to this and no objection to its admissibility was made on this application: compare Rosebank Plastics Pty Ltd v Duncan & Wigley Pty Ltd (1988) 11 IPR 413 (“Rosebank Plastics”) at 416-417, 419 per Ryan J. To explain why I would grant Oates’ preliminary discovery application, it is necessary to refer briefly to the evidence of Dr Field and Mr Kelson. Dr Field was a mechanical engineer, with teaching and research experience in machine design, industrial innovation and invention and, more recently, with experience as an engineering consultant in product development and engineering design. Dr Field stated that, to compare the features of shape and configuration of the Oates Registered Design with Edmondson’s Product, he would need the documents recording the design development pathway for Edmondson’s Product. Dr Field said that these documents would be likely to show the extent of design changes and the reasons for them. Dr Field deposed:I have specifically in mind that a change may well have been made, or a design feature of shape and configuration adopted in the:(a) Edgar Edmondson mop bucket []; and/or(b) Edgar Edmondson Registered Design [],for the purposes of differentiating such designs away from the features of the article the subject of the Oates Registered Design, rather than for a genuine design purpose consistent with innovation. Dr Field stated that, after considering the features of shape and configuration in the Oates Registered Design and Edmondson’s Product, he had formed the view that “the nature and extent of similarities appears to be exceptionally high, including the following features”:(i) the mop-wringing assembly affixed to or associated with the bucket;(ii)wheels affixed to the base of the bucket to assist in movement over the surface to be cleaned; and(iii)a foot-engagable member or stabilising pedal, which is an integral part of the bucket.Dr Field added that “[a] particular matter which I have taken into account in forming my opinion in this regard, is that the compass of possible expression of design alternatives is reasonably large, rather than being very limited or a small compass”. Dr Field continued:In my mind, this is a strong indicator that the person responsible for the design of the:(a) Edgar Edmondson mop bucket []; and/or(b)article the subject of the Edgar Edmondson Registered Design [],appears to have gone as close as possible to replicating the design features of shape and configuration of the article the subject of the Oates Registered Design [], whilst, at the same time, introducing modest changes, but which changes amount, to my eye, as being no more than slight differences, alternatively, where differences are apparent to my eye and not so slight as to be insubstantial, that these have been made with the object of disguising the fact of copying.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Kelson’s position was, in summary, that, whilst the similarities between Edmondson’s Product and the Oates Registered Design were sufficient “to arguably meet the requirements of … the elements of the cause of action based on an obvious imitation, as well as a claim for fraudulent imitation, the critical evidence necessary … to be able to reasonably assist [Oates] to make a determination as to whether to commence legal proceedings against [Edmondson] would be resolved” only if the documents in the Schedule were made available. According to Mr Kelson, these documents would enable him to consider the extent of any infringements and the defences that might be open to Edmondson. Mr Kelson noted that there were related causes of action that might also be pursued in an infringement proceeding (e.g., pursuant to ss 18 and 29 of Schedule 2 of the CCA).CONSIDERATION At the commencement of the hearing, with the parties’ agreement, the Court ordered that the 1979 Rules (as in force immediately before 1 August 2011) should apply. As already indicated, for preliminary discovery, Oates relied on O 15A r 6 of the 1979 Rules. In these circumstances, O 15A r 6 would apply where a prospective respondent has, or is likely to have, possession of documents relating to the question whether the applicant has a right to obtain relief. Order 15A r 6 confers a discretion on the Court to order that discovery be given by a prospective respondent to a proceeding. Order 15A rule 6 of the 1979 Rules states:Where: (a)there is reasonable cause to believe that the applicant has or may have the right to obtain relief in the Court from a person whose description has been ascertained; (b)after making all reasonable inquiries, the applicant has not sufficient information to enable a decision to be made whether to commence a proceeding in the Court to obtain that relief; and (c)there is reasonable cause to believe that that person has or is likely to have or has had or is likely to have had possession of any document relating to the question whether the applicant has the right to obtain the relief and that inspection of the document by the applicant would assist in making the decision; the Court may order that that person shall make discovery to the applicant of any document of the kind described in paragraph (c). Before the Court can exercise the discretion to order discovery against a prospective respondent under O 15A r 6 of the 1979 Rules, three conditions must be satisfied. The first condition, set out in par (a) above, requires an applicant to demonstrate that there is “reasonable cause to believe that the applicant has or may have the right to obtain relief in the Court from a person whose description has been ascertained”. The objective character of the condition “reasonable cause to believe” requires the Court to be satisfied that a reasonable person could form a belief, on the basis of the material before the Court, that the applicant “has or may have the right to obtain relief”’. The applicant does not have to make out a prima facie case. See St George Bank Ltd v Rabo Australia Ltd (2004) 211 ALR 147 (“St George”) at 153-154 per Hely J, which was applied in Echo Tasmania Pty Ltd v Imperial Chemical Industries PLC [2008] FCAFC 58 at [43] per Black CJ and Sackville J; Apache Northwest Pty Ltd v Newcrest Mining Ltd (2009) 182 FCR 124 at 126 [2]-[3] per Moore, Gilmour JJ and 131 [26] per Flick J; and Henley Arch Pty Ltd v McDonald Jones Homes Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 687 (“Henley Arch”) at [11] per Tracey J.