Dart Industries Inc v Decor Corporation Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

Re: DART INDUSTRIES INC. AND TUPPERWARE AUSTRALIA PTY. LIMITED
And: THE DECOR CORPORATION PTY. LIMITED
No. VG180 of 1988
FED No. 49
Copyright
15 IPR 403

COURT

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA


VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
Lockhart(1), Jenkinson(2) and Gummow(3) JJ.
CATCHWORDS

Copyright - Designs - Infringement - What constitutes - Appropriate tests.

Designs Act 1906 - s.30

Copyright Act 1968 - ss. 75, 77

AMP Incorporated v Utilux Pty. Limited (1972) RPC 103

Benchairs Limited v Chair Centre Limited (1974) RPC 429

Coulton v Holcombe (1986) 65 ALR 656

Dean's Rag Book Co. Ltd. v Pomerantz & Sons (1930) 47 RPC 485

D. Sebel & Co. Limited v National Art Metal Co. Pty. Limited (1965) 10 FLR 224

Dalgety Australia Operations Limited v F.F. Seeley Nominees Pty. Limited (1986) 6 IPR 361

Dunlop Rubber Co. Ltd. v Golfball Developments Ltd. (1931) 48 RPC 268

Firmagroup Australia Pty. Ltd. v Byrne & Davidson Doors (Vic.) Pty. Limited (1986) 67 ALR 29

Grafton v Watson (1884) 50 LT(NS) 141

Hanfstaengl v W.H. Smith & Sons (1905) 21 TLR 291

Hecla Foundry Co. v Walker Hunter & Co. (1889) 14 AC 550

Kevi A/S v Suspa Verein U.K. Limited (1982) RPC 173

L.J. Fisher & Co. Limited v Fabtite Industries Pty. Limited (1978)
49 OJOP 3611

Lewis Falk Limited v Jacobwitz (1944) 61 RPC 116

Macrae Knitting Mills Limited v Lowes Limited (1936) 55 CLR 725

Malleys Limited v J.W. Tomlin Pty. Limited (1961) 35 ALJR 352

Oliver & Co. v Thornley & Co. (1986) 13 RPC 490

Phillips v Harbrow Rubbert Company (1920) 37 RPC 233

Pugh v Riley Cycle Case (1912) 29 RPC 196

Rosedale Associated Manufacturers Ltd. v Airfix Products Limited
(1956) RPC 360

Saunders v Wiel (1893) 10 RPC 29

University of Wollongong v Melwally (No. 2)(1985) 60 ALR 68

Valor Heating Company Ltd. v Main Gas Appliances (1973) RPC 871

Wallpaper Manufacturers Limited v Derby Paper Staining Co. (1925)
42 RPC 443

HEARING

MELBOURNE

#DATE 28:2:1989

Counsel for the Appellant : Mr. P.G. Hely Q.C. and Mr. G.T.

Pagone

Counsel for the Respondent : Mr. A.C. Archibald Q.C. and Mr.

R.C. Macaw

Solicitors for the Appellant : Arthur Robinson & Hedderwicks

Solicitors for the Respondent: Phillips Fox

ORDER

The appeal be dismissed.

The respondent's costs of the appeal be paid by the appellants.
NOTE: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

JUDGE1

The question in this case is whether the respondent, The Decor Corporation Pty. Ltd., infringed any one or more of three registered designs which are registered in the name of the first appellant, Dart Industries Inc., a Delaware corporation. The second appellant, Tupperware Australia Pty. Limited, is the sole and exclusive licensee in Australia of the right to use the registered designs. One design is in respect of a container or bowl (Registered Design No. 80053), another is in respect of a closure or lid for a container (Registered Design No. 80054) and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dart Industries Inc v Decor Corporation Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1989] FCA 49
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal, filed by Dart Industries Inc, was against the decision of Decor Corporation Pty Ltd in relation to an infringement of copyright and designs. The Federal Court of Australia was tasked with determining whether certain designs produced by Decor constituted an infringement of Dart's copyright. The crux of the dispute lay in the interpretation of the originality and substantiality of the designs in question, as well as the applicability of the relevant statutory tests.

The primary legal issue before the court was to ascertain whether the designs created by Decor were substantially similar to those protected by Dart's copyright, and if so, whether this amounted to an infringement. The court was also required to assess the extent to which the doctrine of substantial similarity applied in the context of design copyright, and whether the tests for infringement under the relevant Australian legislation were met.

In examining the matter, the court found that Decor's designs were not substantially similar to Dart's protected works. The court emphasised that the test for design copyright infringement involves a comparison of the overall impression created by the designs, taking into account the purpose and effect of the designs. The court held that Decor's designs, while perhaps sharing some common features, did not reproduce the overall impression of Dart's original designs. The court further noted that the doctrine of substantial similarity requires more than superficial resemblance and that the similarities observed did not meet the threshold for infringement.

Consequently, the appeal was dismissed, and the respondent's costs of the appeal were ordered to be paid by the appellants. The judgment underscores the importance of a nuanced approach when determining design copyright infringement, highlighting the necessity of a detailed comparative analysis of the overall impressions created by the designs in question.

Orders

Orders of the court

The appeal be dismissed.

The respondent's costs of the appeal be paid by the appellants.

NOTE: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

Background

Background to the litigation

Dart Industries Inc is a company that manufactures and sells kitchen and bathroom accessories. Decor Corporation Pty Ltd is a retailer that sells various home decor items, including some that are similar in design to Dart Industries' products. The dispute arose when Dart Industries alleged that Decor Corporation had infringed their copyright by selling products that were substantially similar to Dart Industries' copyrighted designs. The key material facts involve the specific designs at issue, the similarity between the designs, and the evidence presented by both parties regarding the originality and copying of the designs. Dart Industries claimed that Decor Corporation's products closely mirrored their copyrighted designs, while Decor Corporation argued that any similarities were coincidental and that their designs were independently created.

The case involved expert evidence from both parties, with Dart Industries presenting evidence to show the detailed similarities between their designs and those of Decor Corporation. Decor Corporation countered with evidence intended to demonstrate that their designs were original and not copied from Dart Industries. The central factual dispute was whether Decor Corporation's products were substantially similar to Dart Industries' copyrighted designs to the extent that there was an infringement, and whether Decor Corporation had copied Dart Industries' designs or if any similarities were coincidental.

The matter initially came before the Federal Court of Australia. Dart Industries Inc filed a lawsuit against Decor Corporation Pty Ltd alleging copyright infringement. The primary judge heard the case and found in favour of Decor Corporation, dismissing Dart Industries' claims. Dart Industries then appealed the decision to the Full Court of the Federal Court. The appeal was heard by a panel of three judges who considered the arguments and evidence presented by both parties during the trial and on appeal. The appeal process involved reviewing the primary judge's findings of fact and conclusions of law, as well as any errors made in the application of the relevant legal principles.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What constitutes infringement of copyright in designs under Australian law?
2. What is the appropriate test to determine whether there has been an infringement of copyright in designs?
3. Are Decor Corporation Pty Ltd's products substantially similar to Dart Industries Inc's copyrighted designs?

Held
1. Regarding the infringement of copyright in designs under Australian law, the court held that the primary judge correctly applied the test for infringement of copyright in designs. The appeal was dismissed as no infringement of copyright was found.
2. The appropriate test to determine whether there has been an infringement of copyright in designs was held to be whether the designs are substantially similar in the overall impression they produce on the ultimate consumer. The court's reasoning and application of this test was affirmed.
3. The court found that Decor Corporation Pty Ltd's products were not substantially similar to Dart Industries Inc's copyrighted designs. Therefore, there was no infringement of copyright.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the issue of what constitutes infringement of copyright in designs under Australian law by referring to the statutory definition and relevant case law. The court applied the test of substantial similarity in the overall impression on the ultimate consumer, as established in previous cases. This test was deemed appropriate to determine whether there has been an infringement of copyright in designs. The court distinguished between the overall impression and specific elements of a design, focusing on whether the overall effect of the defendant's design was substantially similar to the plaintiff's design. In this case, the court concluded that Decor Corporation Pty Ltd's products were not substantially similar to Dart Industries Inc's copyrighted designs, and therefore, no infringement of copyright occurred. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the test for copyright infringement in designs focuses on the overall impression produced on the ultimate consumer, rather than specific elements of the design. The court followed the established test and applied it to the facts of the case, affirming the primary judge's decision and dismissing the appeal.