official notice
decision of a delegate of the registrar of designs
Design: No. 117582 in the name of Keith Henry Polglase
Title: Section
Action: Application for extension of the period of registration; notice under S.27A(4); hearing.
Decision: Issued .
Abstract: Design not new or original; extension of term refused. Differences immaterial or workshop variations.
designs act 1903
decision of a delegate of the registrar of designs
Re:Design No. 117582 to Keith Henry Polglase, application for extension of the period of registration, and notice under S.27A(4) by BTR Indeng Pty Ltd (trading as BTR Hufcor).
background
Application number 2882/92 for registration of a design applicable to a section of movable wall track was lodged by Mr K H Polglase on 15 October 1992. For the purposes of section 17 of the Designs Act the priority date is also 15 October 1992.
The application proceeded to registration on 6 July 1993. The initial period of registration thus expired on 6 July 1994.
For the purposes of s27A(4) of the Designs Act an informant had until 6 June 1994 to lodge a Notice of matter material to newness or originality (form 8). A form 8 and supporting documentation was lodged by BTR INDENG PTY LTD trading as BTR HUFCOR on 6 June 1994. The registered owner lodged a statutory declaration in reply on 6 July 1994.
On 25 August 1994 both parties were advised that the Deputy Registrar of Designs proposed not to extend the period of registration and that he was of the opinion that the design had been prior published by the information provided by the informant. The reasons were set out in a written opinion of the Deputy Registrar dated 23 August 1994.
The matter was heard in Melbourne on 15 February 1995; the registered owner was present at the hearing and was represented by Mr Charles Sandercock, patent attorney.
At the hearing I requested that Mr Polglase file a sample exhibit of his track. (The Registered Design is the important consideration with regard to novelty and originality, but it is also accepted practice to regard an article incorporating the design as a visual representation of the subject matter of the design; see Lusty & Sons v Morris Wilkinson (1954) 71 RPC 169 at 179 and Benchairs v Chair Centre [1974] RPC 429 at 442). A sample track was filed on 8 March 1995.
The abovementioned opinion of the Deputy Registrar reads as follows:
"Scope of registered design no. 117582
In accordance with the authorities, in determining the scope of a registered design I must consider:
(1) the name of the article to which the design is applied
(2) the representations
(3) the presence or absence of a statement of monopoly and/or a statement of novelty
The title of the article is "Section". The representations show an isometric view of an extruded section of indefinite length but of constant cross-section. The section is characterised by the form of an inverted U. At first glance…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Polglase v BTR Indeng Pty Ltd (Trading as Btr Hufcor) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1995] ADO 2
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court's reasoning focused on a visual comparison of the registered design and the prior art, highlighting the fundamental similarities in configuration between the two designs. The differences, such as the positioning of dowel slots and the width-to-height ratio of the track, were found to be immaterial or common workshop variations. The court concluded that these differences did not confer novelty or originality on the registered design. The decision was based on the lack of significant individuality in the design when compared to the prior art, and the absence of any inventive step over the known designs. As a result, the court upheld the Deputy Registrar's decision not to extend the registration period for the design.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case involved an application for the extension of the period of registration for a design registered under the Designs Act 1903. The application for registration was made by Mr Keith Henry Polglase on 15 October 1992, and the design was registered on 6 July 1993. BTR Indeng Pty Ltd lodged a Notice of matter material to newness or originality on 6 June 1994. Polglase responded with a statutory declaration on 6 July 1994. The Deputy Registrar of Designs proposed not to extend the period of registration on 25 August 1994. The matter was heard on 15 February 1995, with Polglase represented by Mr Charles Sandercock. The decision on the extension of the registration period was made by John Welsh, the Delegate of the Registrar of Designs.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Is the registered design new or original, or does it differ only in immaterial details or in features commonly used in the trade from a design that was registered, published, or used in Australia before the priority date?
2. Are the differences between the registered design and the prior art mere workshop variations?
3. Does the registered design possess the necessary "individuality of appearance" to be considered a new or original design under the Designs Act 1903?
Held
1. The registered design was not new or original, or did it differ only in immaterial details or in features commonly used in the trade from a design that was registered, published, or used in Australia before the priority date. Therefore, the extension of the period of registration was refused.
2. The differences between the registered design and the prior art were considered mere workshop variations.
3. The registered design did not possess the necessary "individuality of appearance" to be considered a new or original design under the Designs Act 1903.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined the registered design in question and compared it to the prior art presented by BTR Indeng Pty Ltd. The primary issue was whether the registered design was new or original, or if it differed only in immaterial details or in features commonly used in the trade from the prior art. The court considered the visual appearance of the design, the relative size of the features in relation to the whole design, and the common practice in the trade to vary certain features. The court found that the differences between the registered design and the prior art were immaterial details or workshop variations and did not confer novelty or originality on the registered design. Furthermore, the registered design did not possess the necessary "individuality of appearance" to be considered a new or original design under the Designs Act 1903.
In determining the scope of the registered design, the court considered the representations, the absence of a statement of novelty, and the statement of monopoly. The court also looked at the submissions made by both parties, including the registered owner's attempt to highlight the functional advantages associated with the differences between the registered design and the prior art. However, the court found that these differences were not significant enough to confer novelty or originality on the registered design.
The court relied on several authorities in reaching its decision, including Sebel & Co. v National Art Metal Co., Le May v Welch, Re Aluminium Specialities' Application, and Malleys v Tomlin. The court also took into account the fact that precise mathematical comparisons or matters of measurements or ratios should not be applied as the test of infringement. The court ultimately concluded that the registered design was not new or original, and therefore, the term of registration should not be extended. No award of costs was made as neither party made submissions on costs, and the informant was not represented at the hearing.