Caroma Industries Ltd v Technicon Industries Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 54 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Caroma Industries Ltd v Technicon Industries Pty Ltd [2008] FCA 1465

DESIGNS – Infringement of registered design – obvious imitation – fraudulent imitation – unjustified threat of infringement.

COPYRIGHT – Infringement of copyright – innocent infringement – additional damages – unjustified threat of infringement.

Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) ss 10(1), 14, 31(1)(b), 32(2), 32(4), 36(1), 115(3), 115(4), 202
Designs Act 1906 (Cth) ss 4, 30
Designs Act 2003 (Cth) ss 71, 77, 150, 151(2)(a), 151(3), 156(2), 156(3)

Autocaps (Aust) Pty Ltd and Others v Pro-Kit Pty Ltd and Another 46 IPR 339 referred to
D. Sebel & Co. Ltd. v National Art Metal Co. Pty. Ltd. (1965) 10 FLR 224 referred to
Dalgety Australia Operations Ltd v Seeley (FF) Nominees Pty Ltd (1986) 64 ALR 421 cited
Dart Industries Inc and Another v Decor Corporation Pty Ltd (1989) 15 IPR 403 followed
Dunlop Rubber Co. Ld. v Golf Ball Developments Ld. (1931) 48 RPC 268 followed
Elconnex Pty Limited v Gerard Industries Pty Limited (1991) 32 FCR 491 referred to
Fisher & Paykel Healthcare Pty Ltd v Avion Engineering Pty Ltd (1991) 103 ALR 239 referred to
Frank M Winstone (Merchants) Ltd v Plix Products Ltd [1985] 1 NZLR 377 referred to
Futuretronics.com.au Pty Limited v Graphix Labels Pty Ltd (No 2) [2008] FCA 746 referred to
Jones v Dunkel and Another (1959) 101 CLR 298 referred to
Koninklijke Philips Electronics NV and Another v Remington Products Australia Pty Ltd (1999) 91 FCR 167 referred to
LED Builders Pty Ltd v Eagle Homes Pty Ltd (1996) 35 IPR 215 referred to
LJ Fisher & Company Ltd v Fabtile Industries Pty Ltd (1978) 1A IPR 565 referred to
Malleys Limited v J. W. Tomlin Pty. Limited (1961) 180 CLR 120 followed
McCallum & Co Pty Ltd v Allen Manufacturing Co Pty Ltd and Another (2001) 52 IPR 550 referred to
Microsoft Corporation and Others v Goodview Electronics Pty Ltd and Others (2000) 49 IPR 578 referred to
Polyaire Pty Ltd v K-Aire Pty Ltd & Ors [2003] SASC 41 referred to
Polyaire Pty Ltd v K-Aire Pty Ltd and Others (2005) 221 CLR 287 followed
Polygram Pty Ltd and Others v Golden Editions Pty Ltd and Another (1997) 148 ALR 4 referred to
Raben Footwear Pty Ltd v Polygram Records Inc and Another (1997) 75 FCR 88 referred to
Rose v J. W. Pickavant and Co Ltd (1923) 40 RPC 320 referred to
The English and Scottish Mercantile Investment Company, Limited v Brunton [1892] 2 QB 700 referred to
Tu and Another v Pakway Australia Pty Ltd (t/as Pakway Plastics) and Others (2004) 62 IPR 637 referred to
Turbo Tek Enterprises Inc and Another v Sperling Enterprises Pty Ltd and Another (1989) 88 ALR 524 cited
University of London Press Limited v University Tutorial Press Limited [1916] 2 Ch 601 referred to
WanemPty Ltd v John Tekiela and Another (1990) 19 IPR 435 referred to
Wellington Newspapers Ltd v Dealers Guide Ltd [1984] 2 NZLR 66

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Caroma Industries Ltd v Technicon Industries Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FCA 1465
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, Caroma Industries Ltd initiated proceedings against Technicon Industries Pty Ltd, alleging infringement of a registered design and copyright. Caroma claimed that Technicon's pan design unlawfully replicated Caroma's registered design and that Technicon had infringed Caroma's copyright by copying a drawing of the design. Technicon denied these claims and counterclaimed for a declaration that Caroma's design registration was invalid. The primary legal issues before the court were whether Technicon's pan constituted a fraudulent imitation of Caroma's registered design and whether Technicon had infringed Caroma's copyright by reproducing a drawing of the design. The court examined expert evidence on the visual comparison between the registered design and the Technicon pan, focusing on whether the differences were significant enough to avoid infringement. The court concluded that the Technicon pan was an imitation of Caroma's registered design, satisfying the criteria for fraudulent imitation under the Designs Act. The court also found that Technicon had infringed Caroma's copyright by copying the drawing, as the Technicon drawing was a substantial reproduction of Caroma's work.

The court's reasoning centred on the visual comparison between the registered design and the Technicon pan, with expert evidence playing a crucial role. Mr Granger, an expert witness, highlighted the main design features of the registered design, including the overall curvilinear shape of the bowl, the relationship between the bowl and the shroud, and the shape of the shroud itself. The court noted that the absence of the scalloping feature in the Technicon pan did not significantly alter the design's curvilinear shape. Additionally, the court considered the expert's opinion that the minor differences in the rear supporting rib and inlet pipe were insufficient to distinguish the Technicon pan from the registered design. The court further found that copyright subsisted in Caroma's drawing, and that Technicon's drawing was a material reproduction of Caroma's work, thereby infringing copyright. The court concluded that Technicon's pan was a fraudulent imitation of Caroma's registered design and that Technicon had infringed Caroma's copyright.

The final orders of the court were that Caroma's application be upheld, Technicon's cross-claim be dismissed, and the proceedings be listed for directions at 9:30 am on 15 October 2008. The court's decision affirmed Caroma's rights in both the registered design and the copyright, providing a clear victory for Caroma in its claims against Technicon.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Applicant’s application be upheld.

2. The Respondent’s cross claim be dismissed.

3. The proceedings be listed for directions at 9:30 am on 15 October 2008.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In view of such finding Technicon must demonstrate a greater degree of difference between the Technicon pan and the registered design to establish that there has been no design infringement: see Dart v Decor at 409.Expert evidence – infringement of the registered design Although expert evidence is not to supplant the role of the Court (see Dart v Decor at 408-409), the Court has considered the expert witnesses’ evidence regarding their respective visual comparisons of the registered design with the Technicon pan. Mr Granger said in relation to the registered design:In my view the main “design features” of the Registered Design is the overall curvilinear shape of the bowl [A] (on annexure ‘C’ and ‘D’) its relationship to the shroud [B] (on annexure ‘C’ and ‘D’) and the shape of the shroud itself. Aspects of this design include the concealing by the shroud of the waste pipe (an “S” trap) and the balanced proportions of these two inter-related elements, being the bowl and the shroud. The design conveys a “clean” overall impression which harmonises the separate elements of bowl and shroud in a simple yet elegant way. Mr Granger considered that the absence of the scalloping feature in the Technicon pan did not alter the curvilinear shape of the overall design and in fact emphasised such curvilinear shape. He noted that the scalloping feature incorporated in the registered design was visible from a side view only, and said:[t]he designer has given minimal visual impact to the scalloping feature by ensuring that it is recessed at the rear of the pan where the consumer is unlikely to perceive it, or perceive it as of visual significance having regard to the whole pan/shroud combination. Accordingly, in my view the ribbed voids are not characteristic of the design and are not readily observable or of visual significance from a design perspective. The Court observes that its visual comparison of the registered design with the alleged infringing object is not to be made by reference to the perspective of the consumer: see Dart v Decor at 409. It follows that no particular perspective should be valued above another, in that the appearance of the relevant pans when viewed in situ in a showroom or bathroom should not be prioritised over any other angle of viewing or perspective of such pans. Mr Granger considered other visual differences between the registered design and the Technicon pan. He opined that the rear supporting rib of the Technicon pan was of a slightly different curvature in side profile only when compared to the registered design and that the inlet pipe of the Technicon pan had a smooth transition into the rear of the bowl when compared to the registered design. However, Mr Granger considered that such differences were insufficient to detract from the main design features of the registered design incorporated in the Technicon pan, namely the overall curvilinear shape of the bowl, the bowl’s relationship to the shroud and the shape of the shroud itself.

Decision

Reasons for decision

COWDROY J
The Court is satisfied that the Technicon pan is an imitation or copy of the registered design for the purposes of a finding of fraudulent imitation under s 30 of the 1906 Act.Conclusion – fraudulent imitation It follows from the above findings that the Technicon pan is a fraudulent imitation of the registered design.COPYRIGHT INFRINGEMENT Caroma submits that copyright subsists in the Caroma drawing and that it is the owner of the copyright in such drawing. The Caroma drawing in respect of which copyright is claimed was allegedly drawn by Mr Farid Shahidi, a former employee of Caroma. Caroma submits that a comparison between the Caroma drawing and the Technicon drawing demonstrates that the latter is a material reproduction of the former. Mr Shahidi was employed by Caroma as a production artist responsible for Caroma’s desktop publishing system from June 1990 to June 2000. Mr Shahidi’s drawings were used in Caroma’s product brochures and Caroma’s handbooks for plumbers, including a plumber’s technical manual which was tendered as evidence (‘the Plumber’s Technical Manual’). Mr McCallum acknowledged that he had a copy of the Plumber’s Technical Manual. The representation of the Trident suite in respect of which copyright is claimed is not the original work, but is a published version of Mr Shahidi’s drawing. The original drawing no longer exists, but Caroma claims that such drawing has been reproduced in Caroma brochures, the Plumber’s Technical Manual and on Caroma’s website. Test for copyright infringement Section 32(2) of the Copyright Act sets out the types of published work and the particular circumstances in which copyright subsists and relevantly provides:Subject to this Act, where an original literary, dramatic, musical or artistic work has been published: (a)copyright subsists in the work; or (b)if copyright in the work subsisted immediately before its first publication--copyright continues to subsist in the work; if, but only if: (c)the first publication of the work took place in Australia; (d)the author of the work was a qualified person at the time when the work was first published; …A qualified person means an Australian citizen or a person who is resident in Australia: see s 32(4) of the Copyright Act. Section 10(1) of the Copyright Act relevantly defines an ‘artistic work’ as: (a) a painting, sculpture, drawing, engraving or photograph, whether the work is of artistic quality or not; … Section 31(1)(b) of the Copyright Act identifies the nature of the exclusive rights provided to the owner of copyright in an artistic work. Such rights include the right to reproduce the work in a material form, to publish the work and to communicate the work to the public. Section 36(1) of the Copyright Act provides that copyright in an artistic work is infringed where a person who, not being the owner of the copyright, and without the licence of the owner of the copyright, does in Australia, or authorises the doing in Australia of, any act comprised in the copyright. Substantial reproduction of the artistic work is sufficient for a finding of infringement: see s 14 of the Copyright Act.Copyright infringement – the evidence

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: COWDROY J

Full text does not contain this section.