OFFICIAL NOTICE
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF DESIGNS
Design: No. 131967 in the name of MINING EQUIPMENT (MINQUIP) PTY LTD.
Article: A Coupling
Action: Application by Mining Equipment (Minquip) Pty Ltd for extension of the period of registration; and notice, under S.27A(4), by Mining Supplies Australia Pty Ltd, of material relevant to newness or originality of the design.
Decision: Issued .
Abstract:The present design for a coupling differs from all prior designs exhibited in evidence by more than immaterial details. The present design is also distinct from features commonly used in the trade.
On the other hand the design is an obvious adaptation of a design in respect to another type of coupling previously known in the industry.
The application to extend the period of registration of the present design was refused.
DESIGNS ACT 1906
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF DESIGNS
Re:Design No. 131967 by MINING EQUIPMENT (MINQUIP) PTY LTD, application for extension of the period of registration; and notice, under S.27A(4) by MINING SUPPLIES AUSTRALIA PTY LTD, of material relevant to newness or originality of the design.
BACKGROUND
Mining Equipment (Minquip) Pty Ltd ("Minquip") applied to register design 131967 on 15th April 1997. The design related to a coupling. The application proceeded to registration on 6th November 1997. The initial period of registration ceased on 6th November 1998. Prior to this date Minquip filed an application for an extension of the period of registration of the design and paid the corresponding fee.
Mining Supplies Australia Pty Ltd ("Minsup") filed a notice, under S.27A(4) of the Designs Act, against the registered design on 6th October 1998. Minsup's notice lists several Australian patents and designs, and Minsup product catalogues and drawings, that they consider relevant to the newness or originality of Minquip's design. Concurrently with the notice Minsup filed supporting declarations by Mr Craig Laurence Vinall, Mr Brian Albert Ginger, Mr Neville Frank Howse and Mr Sergio Robert Faggionato. Mr Vinall is the attorney for Minsup. Mr Ginger is the chief executive officer of Minsup. Mr Howse is the company's technical sales representative and Mr Faggionato is the manufacturing manager.
Minquip filed a partial response to Minsup's notice and supporting declarations on 16th November 1998. This response contained a declaration by Mr David Byrne, the design's author, and the managing director and founder of Minquip. On 26th November 1998 the deputy registrar of designs allowed an extension of time for Minquip to file the remainder of their response. Minquip filed that response on 15th January 1999. The latter response contained declarations by Mr Peter Butcher and Mr Nigel Wotton. Mr Butcher is a mining superintendent at Pasminco Pty Ltd in Broken Hill, New South Wales. Mr Wotton is an employee of Adelaide Technical Rubber.
On 18th March 1999 Minsup filed a further declaration. This declaration is by Mr Donald Nixon, a retired factory manager of Minsup. His evidence largely responds to…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Mining Equipment (Minquip) Pty Ltd v Mining Supplies Austral... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1999] ADO 3
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter began with Minquip's application to register design 131967, which was approved and registered on 6 November 1997. Minquip applied for an extension of the registration period before the initial period ended on 6 November 1998. Minsup filed a notice under S.27A(4) of the Designs Act against the registered design on 6 October 1998, supported by several Australian patents, designs, and product catalogues. Minquip responded with partial and full submissions, to which Minsup replied with further evidence. The registrar of designs recommended against extending the registration period, prompting Minquip to request a hearing. The hearing took place on 10 June 1999, where both parties presented evidence and arguments.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Is the design 131967 for the coupling new or original as per the Designs Act 1906?
2. Does the design 131967 for the coupling differ only in immaterial details or in features commonly used in the relevant trade from a design that was registered, published, or used in Australia before the priority date of the application for registration?
3. Is the design 131967 for the coupling an obvious adaptation of a design that was registered, published, or used in Australia in respect of any other article before the priority date of the application for registration?
Held
1. The design 131967 for the coupling is new and original as per the Designs Act 1906.
2. The design 131967 for the coupling differs in more than immaterial details and is distinct from features commonly used in the relevant trade from a design that was registered, published, or used in Australia before the priority date of the application for registration.
3. The design 131967 for the coupling is an obvious adaptation of a design that was registered, published, or used in Australia in respect of any other article before the priority date of the application for registration.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The decision-maker first considered the scope of the registered design, concluding that it was a type A coupling with the head shape as shown by the solid lines and a tail shape from any of the common trade variants. The decision-maker relied on the Re Porcelain Products Pty Ltd decision to conclude that couplings with type A head portions but variable tail portions are articles all of the same general character, commonality of design, and would ordinarily be on sale together. The design-maker then assessed the newness or originality of design 131967 by comparing it with the eyes of one who knows what was common trade knowledge and usage. The decision-maker noted that the appearance of a toroidal cavity in a type A coupling would be easily noticed by a person in the coupling field, and thus the variation of cavity structure for the type A coupling was more than a variation in an immaterial detail. The decision-maker also concluded that the design 131967 differed from features commonly used in the trade because there was insufficient evidence that people in the coupling field apply similar variations of cavity configuration with any particular coupling type. Finally, the decision-maker found that the design 131967 was an obvious adaptation of a known design in respect to a Surelock coupling. The decision-maker relied on the UK Court of Appeal guidance in Phillips v Harbro Rubber Co to conclude that a skilled but unimaginative person in the trade would readily redesign the type A coupling in shape and dimension to adapt a toroidal cavity, known for the Surelock coupling, to the type A coupling without exercising any real mental activity. The decision-maker thus refused to extend the period of registration of design 131967. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a design that differs from prior designs in more than immaterial details and is distinct from features commonly used in the trade but is an obvious adaptation of a known design may not be considered new or original under the Designs Act 1906.