Glencore International AG v Selwyn Mines Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Glencore International AG v Selwyn Mines Limited [2005] FCA 801

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – preliminary discovery – not available where sole purpose to enable decision to be made whether judgment likely to be enforceable against respondent – not available against third party but only against the party from whom applicant may have a right to obtain relief – meaning of ‘reasonable cause to believe that the applicant has or may have the right to obtain relief’.

Federal Court Rules O 15A r 6

Hooper v Kirella Pty Ltd (1999) 96 FCR 1 cited
Alphapharm Pty Ltd v Eli Lilly Australia Pty Ltd [1996] FCA 391 cited
Gulf Petroleum (WA) Ltd v Tah Land Pty Ltd [2001] FCA 1531 cited
Minister for Health and Aged Care v Harrington Associates Ltd [1999] FCA 549 cited
C7 Pty Ltd v Foxtel Management Pty Ltd [2001] FCA 1864 cited

GLENCORE INTERNATIONAL AG v
SELWYN MINES LIMITED & ORS

NSD 1811 OF 2004

LINDGREN J
17 JUNE 2005
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 1811 OF 2004

BETWEEN:

GLENCORE INTERNATIONAL AG
APPLICANT

AND:

SELWYN MINES LIMITED
(RECEIVERS AND MANAGERS APPOINTED)
FIRST RESPONDENT

SELWYN OPERATIONS PTY LIMITED
(RECEIVERS AND MANAGERS APPOINTED)
(IN LIQUIDATION)
SECOND RESPONDENT

SELWYN QUEENSLAND PTY LIMITED
(RECEIVERS AND MANAGERS APPOINTED)
(IN LIQUIDATION)
THIRD RESPONDENT

BANK OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA LIMITED
FOURTH RESPONDENT

WILLIAM JAMES HOWE
FIFTH RESPONDENT

GRAEME HOGAN
SIXTH RESPONDENT

JON BERNARD NORTH
SEVENTH RESPONDENT

GAVIN JOHN DANEEL
EIGHTH RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

LINDGREN J

DATE OF ORDER:

17 JUNE 2005

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The proceeding be listed on 22 June 2005 for the purpose of the making of orders including orders as to costs.


2.The parties attempt to agree on the orders, including orders as to costs, to be made, and in default of agreement, they submit to the Associate of Lindgren J by 21 June 2005 the forms of orders, including orders as to costs, for which they will respectively contend, and written submissions in support.

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 1811 OF 2004

BETWEEN:

GLENCORE INTERNATIONAL AG
APPLICANT

AND:

SELWYN MINES LIMITED
(RECEIVERS AND MANAGERS APPOINTED)
FIRST RESPONDENT

SELWYN OPERATIONS PTY LIMITED
(RECEIVERS AND MANAGERS APPOINTED)
(IN LIQUIDATION)
SECOND RESPONDENT

SELWYN QUEENSLAND PTY LIMITED
(RECEIVERS AND MANAGERS APPOINTED)
(IN LIQUIDATION)
THIRD RESPONDENT

BANK OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA LIMITED
FOURTH RESPONDENT

WILLIAM JAMES HOWE
FIFTH RESPONDENT

GRAEME HOGAN
SIXTH RESPONDENT

JON BERNARD NORTH
SEVENTH RESPONDENT

GAVIN JOHN DANEEL
EIGHTH RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

LINDGREN J

DATE:

17 JUNE 2005

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT


INTRODUCTION

  1. The applicant, Glencore International AG (‘Glencore’), applies for preliminary discovery under Order 15A r 6 of the Federal Court Rules.  It seeks discovery of the documents described in Schedule A to its application against all respondents other than the fourth respondent, Bank of Western Australia Limited (‘BankWest’), and of the documents described…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Glencore International AG v Selwyn Mines Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] FCA 801
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Glencore International AG v Selwyn Mines Ltd, the dispute revolves around claims by Glencore against Selwyn Mines Ltd and BankWest for breach of contract and inducing breach of contract, respectively. Glencore alleges that BankWest induced Selwyn Mines Ltd to breach a finance agreement, leading to financial loss for Glencore. The case was heard and decided by Lindgren J of the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The primary legal issues before the court were whether Glencore was entitled to preliminary discovery of documents from Selwyn Mines Ltd and four of its directors, and whether there was reasonable cause to believe that Glencore may have a right to obtain relief from these parties under specific sections of the Corporations Act.

The court examined the evidence presented by Glencore, including the affidavits of key individuals involved in the negotiations and the transaction. It considered the financial positions of Selwyn Mines Ltd and the roles of BankWest, Glencore, and the directors in the context of the agreements and alleged breaches. The court concluded that while there was reasonable cause to believe Glencore might have a right to obtain relief from certain directors for misleading or deceptive conduct, there was no such cause for relief against Selwyn Mines Ltd or two of the directors. The court also determined that the preliminary discovery sought by Glencore from Selwyn Mines Ltd and the directors was not intended to establish a claim against them but to aid in determining whether there was a claim against BankWest and the directors. Therefore, the court declined to order preliminary discovery from Selwyn Mines Ltd and two of the directors.

The court ordered the parties to attempt to agree on the form of orders, including those relating to costs, and to submit their proposed orders and written submissions to the Associate of the court by a specified date. If the parties could not agree, the court would make the orders after considering the submissions.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The proceeding be listed on 22 June 2005 for the purpose of the making of orders including orders as to costs.

2. The parties attempt to agree on the orders, including orders as to costs, to be made, and in default of agreement, they submit to the Associate of Lindgren J by 21 June 2005 the forms of orders, including orders as to costs, for which they will respectively contend, and written submissions in support.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The third and last of Glencore’s potential claims against Selwyn Operations would be for breach of contract in the form of breach of the Glencore Finance Agreement. Glencore’s associated claim against BankWest would be for inducing that breach of contract.THE EVIDENCE BEFORE THE COURTGeneral The chief officer of Glencore who was involved in the negotiations and transaction to which the present application relates, was Mr Mueller, the deponent of the affidavit referred to earlier. Mr Mueller resides in Switzerland. Michael O’Keeffe, a Sydney resident, the managing director of Glencore Australia Pty Ltd (‘Glencore Australia’), and Matthew Cleary, a manager employed by Glencore Australia, also played roles on the Glencore side. The officers of Selwyn most involved were Selwyn’s managing director, Mr Howe, and its chief financial officer, Mr Hogan. Glencore, based in Baar, Switzerland, is one of the world’s largest suppliers of a wide range of commodities and raw materials to industrial consumers. It had been purchasing copper concentrate from Selwyn on an ad hoc basis since 1996. The critical events with which the proceeding is concerned occurred in 2002, against the background of Selwyn’s relationships with BankWest and with Glencore. There are certain important general matters against which those events fall to be assessed. As Glencore concedes it knew, Selwyn was not in a strong financial position when seeking a loan of US$8 million from Glencore in 2002. Glencore also knew that Selwyn was obliged to pay to BankWest between $6 million and $7 million in December 2002, $2 million in March 2003, and after that, $1 million every quarter commencing in June 2002. Glencore knew that BankWest was secured. But apparently it was important for Glencore to secure for itself Selwyn’s copper concentrates output. It is impossible for me to know how important, or to know all the considerations which led Glencore to enter into what it understood to be a risky financing arrangement. The importance to Glencore of securing three years’ supply may explain the apparently imprudent aspects of Glencore’s decision to lend US$8 million unsecured to Selwyn.The pre-2002 position BankWest had provided financial accommodation to Selwyn Queensland as borrower under a facility agreement dated 7 June 2000 (which had been amended) (‘BankWest Facility Agreement’). Selwyn Mines and Selwyn Operations were parties to that agreement as guarantors. Clause 13.1 of the BankWest Facility Agreement defined ‘Default’, and cl 13.2 provided that upon or after Default, BankWest was entitled to require immediate repayment of the ‘Secured Monies’. The expression ‘Secured Monies’ was defined to mean all debts and monetary liabilities of Selwyn Queensland and each other ‘Transaction Party’ to BankWest. The expression ‘Transaction Party’ meant Selwyn Queensland and each guarantor, that is, each of Selwyn Mines and Selwyn Operations. Selwyn Mines executed a deed of charge, also dated 7 June 2000 in favour of BankWest. Selwyn Queensland, Selwyn Mines and Selwyn Operations also executed a deed of charge dated 3 July 2000 in favour of BankWest.

Decision

Reasons for decision

LINDGREN J
As noted at [79], there is reasonable cause to believe, however, that Glencore may have a right to obtain relief from all four directors under s 188M(3) of the Corporations Act.CONCLUSION I will publish these reasons with a view to the parties agreeing on the form of order to be made for preliminary discovery as against BankWest and Messrs Howe, Hogan, North and Daneel, and the proceeding will be listed for the purpose of the making of orders. Although Glencore has obtained preliminary discovery against BankWest, it is much more limited in scope than what was sought. In addition, BankWest has succeeded on its argument that there should not be discovery against Selwyn. At first blush, it may appear that this is irrelevant to the question of costs as between Glencore and BankWest, but the arguments advanced by BankWest in relation to Selwyn were relevant to the dispute between BankWest and Glencore. My present view is that there should be no order as to the costs of the proceeding, but I will give the parties an opportunity to make written submissions in that respect.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: LINDGREN J

Again, however, the discovery should be limited to documents relating to the imposition of the condition of consent, BankWest’s knowledge of cl 2 of the Glencore Finance Agreement and the payment of the sum of US$8 million by Glencore and the transfer of A$6.9 million as between the bank accounts. Again, it is to be hoped that the parties can agree on the precise description of the documents to be discovered by BankWest.Selwyn Mining, Selwyn Operations and Selwyn Queensland In the last part of the passage from the cross‑examination of Mr Mueller set out at [83] above, Mr Mueller accepted that the purpose of seeking preliminary discovery from Selwyn was not to enable Selwyn to be sued, but rather to see whether Glencore should be suing BankWest and the four directors. Counsel for Glencore seeks to minimise the effect of this evidence, by referring to earlier statements by Mr Mueller in his cross-examination in which he sought to take a more qualified position. It seems to me right to say, however, that on the evidence, Glencore has no intention of suing Selwyn for the purpose of recovery against Selwyn, unless either there is a change of circumstances according to which Selwyn is likely to come into money, or Glencore receives legal advice that it should sue Selwyn in aid of its suing Bank West or the directors or both. The most obvious change to suggest itself is that an action is brought by the liquidators against the directors for insolvent trading. However, although invited by the liquidators to fund further investigations, and, if appropriate, the launching of a proceeding against the directors, Glencore has declined that invitation. Glencore is at liberty itself to launch a proceeding against the directors under s 588M(3) of the Corporations Act. Although there is reasonable cause to believe that Glencore has or may have a right to obtain relief in the Court from the Selwyn companies in respect of misleading or deceptive conduct (it is also entitled to relief from Selwyn Operations in debt under the Glencore Finance Agreement and has proved as an unsecured creditor in the liquidation of that company), I decline to order preliminary discovery against them because Glencore would be using the preliminary discovery by Selwyn, not to enable it to decide whether it has a right to obtain relief against Selwyn, but to decide whether it has a right to obtain relief from BankWest or the directors.Messrs Howe, Hogan, North and Daneel There is reasonable cause to believe that Glencore may have a right to obtain relief against Mr Howe and Mr Hogan in respect of misleading or deceptive conduct by themselves, or being knowingly concerned in misleading or deceptive conduct by Selwyn. I do not accept BankWest’s submission that it is clear that Glencore does not need any further documents from Mr Howe or Mr Hogan in order to determine whether it may have a right to obtain relief from them. There is not reasonable cause, however, to think that Glencore has or may have a right to obtain relief against Mr North or Mr Daneel in respect of misleading or deceptive conduct, either by themselves or by Selwyn.