Sovereign Hydroseal Pty Ltd v Steynberg (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Sovereign Hydroseal Pty Ltd v Steynberg (No 2) [2020] FCA 1239

File number: WAD 85 of 2020
Judgment of: MCKERRACHER J
Date of judgment: 25 August 2020
Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – preliminary discovery – final form of orders – where prospective applicant entitled to relief sought – where categories of discovery to be narrowed – where prospective applicant now seeks only ‘examples’ of documents – where prospective applicant agrees to give security for compliance

COSTS – application for preliminary discovery pursuant to r 7.23 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) – where prospective applicant was wholly successful – where prospective respondent adopts an adversarial approach to the proceeding

COSTS – offers of compromise – preliminary discovery – where prospective respondent seeks costs on indemnity basis – where prospective respondent’s Calderbank offer is rejected – where prospective respondent was ultimately unsuccessful – where offer was less favourable than relief obtained by prospective applicant

Legislation: Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 7.23, 7.23(1)(c)
Cases cited:

Airways Corporation of New Zealand v The Present Partners of Pricewaterhouse Coopers Legal [2002] NSWSC 521

Dallas Buyers Club LLC v iiNet Limited (No 3) [2015] FCA 422

Carey v Freehills [2013] FCA 1258

J & A Vaughan Super Pty Ltd v Becton Property Group Limited [2013] FCA 340

Kiefel v State of Victoria [2014] FCA 411

MMD Design and Consultancy Limited v Camco Engineering Pty Ltd [2019] FCA 1803

Procter v Kalivis (No 3) [2010] FCA 1194

Pfizer Ireland Pharmaceuticals v Samsung Bioepis AU Pty Ltd (No 2) [2019] FCA 657

Sealed Air Australia Pty Limited v Aus-Lid Enterprises Pty Ltd [2020] FCA 388

SmithKline Beecham plc v Alphapharm Pty Ltd [2001] FCA 271

Sovereign Hydryoseal Pty Ltd v Steynberg [2020] FCA 1084

Steffen v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd [2009] NSWSC 883

United Voice and Australian Workers Union v Accolade Wines Australia Ltd [2013] FCA 285

Division: General Division
Registry: Western Australia
National Practice Area: Intellectual Property
Sub-area: Patents and associated Statutes
Number of paragraphs: 35
Date of last submissions: 20 August 2020
Date of hearing: Determined on the papers
Counsel for the Prospective Applicants: Mr A Fox
Solicitor for the Prospective Applicants: Griffith Hack Lawyers
Counsel for the Prospective Respondent: Mr V Kalyan
Solicitor for the Prospective Respondent: Kalyans Lawyers

ORDERS

WAD 85 of 2020
BETWEEN:

SOVEREIGN HYDROSEAL PTY LTD ACN 123 696 926

First Prospective Applicant

RELBORGN PTY LTD ACN 114 303 847

Second Prospective Applicant

TRIOMVIRI PTY LTD ACN 114 303 650

Third Prospective Applicant

AND:

JOHANNES MACHIEL STEYNBERG

Prospective Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

MCKERRACHER J

DATE OF ORDER:

25 AUGUST 2020

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.On or before 2 September 2020, the Prospective Applicants provide security for the Prospective Respondent’s reasonable costs of compliance with Order 2 in the amount of $10,000 by payment into Court, provision of bank guarantee or such other means as the parties may agree.

2.Pursuant to rule 7.23 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), and subject to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sovereign Hydroseal Pty Ltd v Steynberg (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 1239
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Sovereign Hydroseal Pty Ltd and others sought an order for preliminary discovery from Johannes Macchiel Steynberg. The application was heard and determined in Sovereign Hydroseal Pty Ltd v Steynberg (No 1). The primary issue in the current proceeding was the scope of the orders to be made following the determination that the prospective applicants were entitled to relief. The prospective respondent now sought to narrow the categories of discovery and to oppose the categories on the basis that he did not have the documents sought. The prospective applicants, however, had made out their entitlement to relief and the prospective respondent's objections were not properly before the Court. The prospective applicants were entitled to the relief sought. The categories of discovery should be narrowed and security for compliance costs should be provided. If the prospective applicants did not commence proceedings within two months of the discovery being given, they would bear the costs of the application and compliance with the orders. If proceedings were brought within time, the costs would be reserved to that proceeding.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. On or before 2 September 2020, the Prospective Applicants provide security for the Prospective Respondent’s reasonable costs of compliance with Order 2 in the amount of $10,000 by payment into Court, provision of bank guarantee or such other means as the parties may agree.

2. Pursuant to rule 7.23 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), and subject to order 3, by 23 September 2020, the Prospective Respondent give the Prospective Applicants discovery on affidavit of documents in the categories set out in Annexure ‘A’ (Discovery Documents).

3. Each Discovery Document will be confidential and may only be disclosed to or inspected by the Prospective Applicants’ external Australian legal representatives, patent attorneys, counsel and experts who have signed a confidentiality undertaking in the form contained in Annexure ‘B’ to these orders.

4. The Prospective Applicants have liberty to apply to the Court for orders permitting the disclosure of the Discovery Documents to any other person.

5. If, by 2 months from the date of the Prospective Respondent’s compliance with order 2, none of the Prospective Applicants has commenced a proceeding against the Prospective Respondent, the Prospective Applicants will pay the Prospective Respondent’s reasonable costs of, and incidental to, the application for preliminary discovery, and the compliance with these orders, otherwise the costs are reserved to the proceeding brought by the Prospective Applicant(s).

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

ANNEXURE ‘A’

Definitions:

In this Attachment, the word ‘documents’ has the meaning defined in the Dictionary of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth).

The following documents:

(1) An example of each technical data sheet, formulation, product label, and any other document which records or set outs the chemical composition of any and all products which have been used by the Prospective Respondent or any person or entity under his control or authority since 24 June 2013 to seal cracks, joints, voids, or passages, including but not limited to:

(a) the product known as ‘NOH2O’ (NOH2O);

(b) the product known as ‘N-LICS’ (N-LICS);

(c) any rubber grout product that is injected under pressure into cracks, joints, or voids (Rubber Grout Product); and

(d) any sealing product (that is injected under pressure into cracks, joints, or voids) which contains latex as a component or forms part of the product formulation (Latex Product).

(2) An example of each data sheet, order form, brochure, advertising material, flyer, and any other document which states, lists or describes any and all products which have been offered, provided or supplied to any customer or potential customer by the Prospective Respondent or any person or entity under his control or authority since 24 June 2013 to seal cracks, joints, voids, or passages including but not limited to the products:

(a) NOH2O;

(b) N-LICS;

(c) any Rubber Grout Product; and

(d) any Latex Product.

(3) An example of each technical data sheet, formulation, and any other document which records or sets out the chemical composition of the latex in any Latex Products which have been received from any supplier (including communications from any such supplier by which such documents were conveyed to the Prospective Respondent) or which have been offered, provided or supplied to any customer or potential customer by the Prospective Respondent or any person or entity under his control or authority since 24 June 2013.

(4) Invoices, receipts, ledgers, and any other documents which record or evidence the number and nature of:

(a) supplies of products to seal cracks, joints, voids or passages including but not limited to the products NOH2O, N-LICS, any Rubber Grout Product, and any Latex Product; or

(b) services rendered to seal cracks, joints, voids or passages using any products including but not limited to the products NOH2O, N-LICS, any Rubber Grout Product, and any Latex Product,

made by the Prospective Respondent or any person or entity under his control or authority to any and all customers since 24 June 2013.

(5) An example of each manual, instructions sheet, and any other document which records or evidences the method or process used since 24 June 2013 by the Prospective Respondent to seal cracks, joints, voids or passages using any products including but not limited to the products NOH2O, N-LICS, any Rubber Group Product, and any Latex Product.

ANNEXURE ‘B’

CONFIDENTIALITY UNDERTAKING

No. WAD 85 of 2020

Federal Court of Australia

District Registry: Western Australia

Division: General

SOVEREIGN HYDROSEAL PTY LTD & ORS

Prospective Applicants

JOHANNES MACHIEL STEYNBERG

Prospective Respondent

I, ………………………………………. of ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ,

undertake to the Court and to the Prospective Respondent that, in relation to the documents discovered by the Prospective Respondent pursuant to the orders made by McKerracher J in relation to Federal Court Proceedings No. WAD85 of 2020 (Discovery Documents) and the information contained in the Discovery Documents (Discovery Information):

(1) I will keep the Discovery Documents and Discovery Information confidential at all times and I will only use the Discovery Documents and Discovery Information for the purposes of determining whether the Prospective Respondent has infringed the Prospective Applicants’ intellectual property rights, and in the course of any legal proceeding in which it is alleged that the Prospective Respondent has infringed those rights.

(2) Subject to paragraph 3 below, the Discovery Documents and Discovery Information will not be disclosed by me (either in whole or in part) either directly or indirectly to any person including the Prospective Applicants, their servants and agents without the prior written consent of the Prospective Respondent, unless such disclosure is expressly authorised by the Prospective Respondent or a Court.

(3) The Discovery Documents and Discovery Information may be disclosed by me to:

(a) a Court in the conduct of a Proceeding;

(b) the Prospective Applicants’ external Australian legal representatives, patent attorneys, counsel and experts who have signed a confidentiality undertaking in the same form as this document;

(c) the Prospective Respondent, his legal representatives, patent attorney and counsel;

(d) any other person provided:

(i) the prior written consent to such disclosure has been obtained from the Prospective Respondent (if self-represented) or his legal representatives, who will not unreasonably withhold such consent; or

(ii) the Court has made orders permitting disclosure to that person;

and provided that person has signed a confidentiality undertaking in the same form as this document.

(4) I will upon the conclusion of any Proceeding, or upon request by the Prospective Respondent:

(a) return or cause to be returned to the Prospective Respondent (if self-represented) or his legal representatives all copies of the Discovery Documents held by me; or

(b) destroy any documents (including any electronic copies) made or caused to be made by me or given to me recording any or all of the Discovery Information.

(5) I will promptly notify the Prospective Respondent if I become aware of any unauthorised use or disclosure of any Discovery Documents or Discovery Information.

_______________________________________

_______________________________________

Party – Signature

Witness – Signature

Date: _________________________________

_______________________________________

Witness – Name

_______________________________________

Witness – Address

_______________________________________

Witness - Occupation

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Sovereign’s written submissions also indicate disagreement between the parties as to Sovereign’s proposed order that it be given liberty to apply for orders permitting the disclosure of the discovery documents to any other person. It says Mr Steynberg seeks additional wording to the effect that Sovereign pay his costs of any application made in exercise of that liberty. Despite what may have ensued between the parties during conferral, the proposed orders filed by Mr Steynberg provide no such additional wording. The order for liberty to apply with respect to the confidentiality regime is agreed.CONCLUSION Sovereign has ultimately been successful on this application by appropriately narrowing the categories of discovery and providing security for Mr Steynberg’s costs of compliance. Orders will be made in terms of Sovereign’s minute save for the order as to the costs of the application which will be Sovereign’s to bear unless substantive proceedings are commenced within two months from the date on which discovery is given. In the event that proceedings are brought within time, costs will be reserved to that proceeding.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Sovereign contends that the Court should not entertain any of Mr Steynberg’s proposed amendments to its categories of discovery when they have first been raised at this late stage in the proceeding. Mr Steynberg had the opportunity to proffer different categories at the hearing of the application but he chose instead to oppose the application on the ground of the absence of a reasonable belief. Sovereign submits that Mr Steynberg is seeking to re-agitate matters which have been determined and is engaging in an exercise inconsistent with what is expressed in Sovereign (No 1) (at [72]) that Sovereign has ‘made out its entitlement to relief principally in the form of orders sought…’.CONSIDERATION Mr Steynberg now opposes Sovereign’s categories of discovery primarily on the ground that he no longer possesses, or has never possessed, the documents it seeks. This contention was not raised before or during the hearing of this matter. Relevantly, in Sovereign (No 1) I noted (at [36]) that:Mr Steynberg does not suggest that he does not have materials that could be produced in response to the requested categories. His main objection is as to any basis for a reasonable belief on the evidence produced by Sovereign. Except for the points raised regarding NOH2O and N-LICS, Mr Steynberg does not give any reason as to why he is only now raising the issue of an inability to produce many of the documents which Sovereign seek. It is not apparent from any of the materials that Mr Steynberg only became aware of these circumstances after the hearing of Sovereign’s application, and it would seem unlikely that that is the case; particularly in relation to the claim now made that many of the documents sought were in fact ‘thrown away’ by him in February 2019. In these circumstances, it is useful to consider r 7.23(1)(c) of the Rules:7.23 Discovery from prospective respondent(1)A prospective applicant may apply to the Court for an order under subrule (2) if the prospective applicant:…(c) reasonably believes that:(i)the prospective respondent has or is likely to have or has had or is likely to have had in the prospective respondent's control documents directly relevant to the question whether the prospective applicant has a right to obtain the relief; and(ii)inspection of the documents by the prospective applicant would assist in making the decision.(Emphasis added.) The Rule makes clear that it is no answer to a prospective applicant’s categories for preliminary discovery that the prospective respondent does not possess documents in those categories, except to the extent that such a claim might displace the prospective applicant’s reasonable belief that those documents are, or were, in the prospective respondent’s control. Such matters were not argued at the hearing of the main application. Having already determined that Sovereign has satisfied the requirements of r 7.23 and is entitled to relief, it is inappropriate for these matters to be raised when considering the scope of the orders to be made. In any event, they do not assist Mr Steynberg in opposing the categories of discovery that Sovereign seeks.