MMD Design and Consultancy Limited v Camco Engineering Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

MMD Design and Consultancy Limited v Camco Engineering Pty Ltd [2019] FCA 1803

File number: VID 563 of 2019
Judge: O'BRYAN J
Date of judgment: 7 November 2019
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for preliminary discovery – possible patent infringement – whether prospective applicants held reasonable belief that they may have had right to obtain relief – whether, after making reasonable enquiries, the prospective applicants did not have sufficient information to decide whether to start a proceeding – whether the Court’s discretion under subrule 7.23(2) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) should be exercised – application granted
Legislation: Federal Court Rules2011 (Cth) r 7.23(1), 7.23(2)
Cases cited:

Alphapharm Pty Ltd v Eli Lilly Australia Pty Ltd [1996] FCA 391

Glencore International AG v Selwyn Mines Limited (2005) 223 ALR 238

Pfizer Ireland Pharmaceuticals v Samsung Bioepis AU Pty Ltd (2017) 257 FCR 62

SmithKline Beecham Plc v Alphapharm Pty Ltd [2001] FCA 271

Date of hearing: 3 October 2019
Date of last submissions: 14 October 2019
Registry: Victoria
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Intellectual Property
Sub-area: Patents and Associated Statutes
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 66
Counsel for the Prospective Applicants: Ms C Cunliffe
Solicitor for the Prospective Applicants: Wrays
Counsel for the Prospective Respondent: Mr D Thompson
Solicitor for the Prospective Respondent: Watermark Intellectual Property Pty Ltd

ORDERS

VID 563 of 2019
BETWEEN:

MMD DESIGN AND CONSULTANCY LIMITED

First Prospective Applicant

MMD AUSTRALIA PTY LTD ACN 002 446 835

Second Prospective Applicant

AND:

CAMCO ENGINEERING PTY LTD ACN 067 041 641

Prospective Respondent

JUDGE:

O'BRYAN J

DATE OF ORDER:

7 NOVEMBER 2019

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The parties file, within 14 days, draft short minutes containing any agreed orders proposed by the parties to give effect to the reasons of O’Bryan J published on 7 November 2019 or, in the absence of agreement, each of the parties file draft short minutes containing the orders proposed by that party and accompanying submissions in support of no more than 2 pages in length.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

O’BRYAN J:

Introduction

  1. By originating application filed on 28 May 2019, the prospective applicants, MMD Design and Consultancy Limited (MMD UK) and MMD Australia Pty Ltd (MMD Australia) (collectively referred to herein as MMD), sought an order for preliminary discovery under rule 7.23 of the Federal Court Rules2011 (Cth) (Rules) from the prospective respondent, Camco Engineering Pty Ltd (Camco).  In general terms, MMD seeks preliminary discovery of engineering drawings prepared by Camco in the course of repairing, since 1 January 2016, the “tooth” component of mineral breakers used:

    (a)at the Solomon Hub iron ore mine site operated by Fortescue Metals Group (FMG) in the Hamersley Range in Western Australia;

    (b)at the BHP Yandi mine in the Pilbara region of Western Australia; and

    (c)at any other location or mine…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MMD Design and Consultancy Limited v Camco Engineering Pty L... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCA 1803
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of MMD Design and Consultancy Limited v Camco Engineering Pty Ltd, MMD Design and Consultancy Limited sought an order for preliminary discovery of documents from Camco Engineering Pty Ltd. The application was predicated on the possibility of patent infringement. The central issue was whether MMD Design and Consultancy Limited had a reasonable belief that they might have a right to seek relief and if, after making reasonable inquiries, they did not have sufficient information to decide whether to initiate a proceeding. The court had to decide whether its discretion under subrule 7.23(2) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) should be exercised. The court found that the conditions in subrule 7.23(1) of the Rules were met and granted the application.

The court considered the nature of the dispute and the background of the parties. MMD Design and Consultancy Limited is a group of companies involved in the design, manufacture, and supply of mineral processing solutions and associated machinery. MMD UK, a member of the MMD group, is the owner of Australian patent number 2004289510 (the 510 patent). The dispute centred on the tooth construction on the drum assembly of a mineral breaker, which is the subject of the 510 patent. The court examined the details of the patent and the allegations of infringement by Camco Engineering Pty Ltd.

The court concluded that the application for preliminary discovery was appropriate. The court was satisfied that MMD Design and Consultancy Limited had a reasonable belief that they might have a right to seek relief and that, after making reasonable inquiries, they lacked sufficient information to decide whether to initiate a proceeding. The court exercised its discretion under subrule 7.23(2) and ordered Camco Engineering Pty Ltd to provide preliminary discovery of certain categories of documents, subject to a confidentiality regime. The court also ordered that inspection of the discovered documents be limited initially to MMD Design and Consultancy Limited's external Australian solicitor, patent attorney, and counsel, who would have to execute a confidentiality undertaking in favour of Camco Engineering Pty Ltd. The court further proposed an order regarding the costs of the application, similar to the order made by Finkelstein J in SmithKline Beecham.

The court directed the parties to propose a form of orders to give effect to the reasons within 14 days. The orders would include the conditions for inspection of the discovered documents and the proposed cost orders. The court's decision was based on the specific circumstances of the case and the application of the relevant legal principles. The outcome of the case was that the court granted the application for preliminary discovery and imposed conditions to protect the confidentiality of the documents.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The parties file, within 14 days, draft short minutes containing any agreed orders proposed by the parties to give effect to the reasons of O’Bryan J published on 7 November 2019 or, in the absence of agreement, each of the parties file draft short minutes containing the orders proposed by that party and accompanying submissions in support of no more than 2 pages in length.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons that follow, I am satisfied that it is appropriate to make an order that Camco give discovery of certain categories of documents, subject to a confidentiality regime.Factual Background The MMD group of companies conducts business in the design, manufacture and supply of mineral processing solutions and associated machinery serving the mining, quarrying and recycling industries. MMD UK is the member of the MMD group of companies responsible for the administration of the intellectual property of the group and is the registered proprietor of patents, trademarks and registered designs worldwide relating to MMD’s business. It grants other members of the MMD group the right to use its intellectual property rights and has granted MMD Australia the right to use those rights in Australia. Relevantly, MMD UK is the owner of Australian patent number 2004289510 (the 510 patent) and has granted MMD Australia the exclusive right to use that patent in Australia. The 510 patent relates to a method of constructing a drum assembly for a mineral breaker and to the drum assembly per se, and particularly to the tooth construction on the drum assembly. Mineral breakers (also known as “sizers”) are used in the mining sector to break up large rocks that have been retrieved from the ground into smaller pieces as part of the process of extracting the minerals in those rocks. The type of mineral breaker with which the 510 patent is concerned has a number of rotating drum assemblies (also referred to as shaft assemblies). The drum assemblies are affixed to a drive shaft which rotates the drum assemblies. The drum assemblies have a number of “teeth” affixed to the assembly that make contact with the rocks as the drum assembly is rotated. A drum assembly with affixed teeth typically utilises a tooth constructed of a support body (or “horn”) to which is affixed one or more covers (also called “shells” or “caps”) and a tip (or “pick”) at the front of the tooth. The teeth, like other components of a mineral breaker, wear down and crack after prolonged use and require repair. The central matter in dispute between the parties, for the purposes of this application, concerns the tooth construction on the drum assembly. The 510 patent describes this aspect of the invention, the subject of the patent, in the following terms:In order to enable each tooth to withstand the breaking forces without snapping it is desirable to construct each tooth so as to have a core formed of a ductile metal which is covered with a tooth shell of a wear resistant material, which in itself can be relatively brittle. In order to be capable of breaking particularly hard minerals, such as for example granite, it is necessary to be able to transmit, from the drive shaft, relatively large forces. These large forces, in turn, exacerbate the securance of a tooth shell on the tooth core or horn and also require the core or horn construction to be robust enough to transmit the relatively high forces required.According to one aspect of the present invention there is provided a tooth construction for a mineral breaker, the tooth construction including a tooth shaped support body covered by a shell which defines the outer shape of the tooth construction, the shell being composed of a plurality of covers which are fixedly secured to one another and/or to the support body by welding to define a unitary tooth construction the support body having a front face and an opposed rear face and the plurality of covers including at least a front cover weldingly secured to and seated in face to face contact with the front face of the support body and a separate rear cover weldingly secured to and seated in face to face contact with the rear face of the support body.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I also consider it appropriate that an order be made that, until further order, inspection of the discovered documents be limited to MMD’s external Australian solicitor, patent attorney and counsel and upon them executing a confidentiality undertaking in favour of Camco in a form agreed between the parties or, failing agreement, determined by the Court. If MMD subsequently considers it necessary to consult with any other external expert, it can apply to the Court for an extension of the orders for inspection to such a person.Conclusion In conclusion, I am satisfied that the conditions set out in subrule 7.23(1) of the Rules have been met. I am further satisfied that it is appropriate in the exercise of my discretion under subrule 7.23(2) to order Camco to give preliminary discovery to MMD of the documents described in paragraph 62 above. Inspection of discovered documents will be limited in the first instance to MMD’s external Australian solicitor, patent attorney and counsel, who will have a right to inspect the documents under a confidentiality regime. With respect to the costs of the application, I propose to make an order in the same form as that made by Finkelstein J in SmithKline Beecham at [32]. If MMD commences an action for patent infringement against Camco within a period of six months from the date of the order for discovery, the costs of the application for preliminary discovery will be at the discretion of the Court in that proceeding. If no such action is brought within that period, then MMD should pay the costs of Camco on this application. I will direct the parties to propose a form of orders giving effect to these reasons within 14 days.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.