Alpine Hardwoods (Aust) Pty Ltd v Hardys Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Alpine Hardwood (Aust) Pty Ltd v Hardys Pty Ltd (No 2) [2002] FCA 224

COSTS – Indemnity costs – Calderbank offer by respondents rejected – Applicants subsequently failed entirely at trial – Whether respondents’ offer reasonable – Whether applicants acted unreasonably or imprudently in rejecting offer – Onus upon respondents to show applicants’ conduct unreasonable – Applicants’ conduct must be viewed in light of circumstances as they existed at time offer rejected

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 43 and 53A
Federal Court Rules O 23, O 41, O 62

Colgate-Palmolive Company v Cussons Pty Ltd (1993) 46 FCR 225 at 232-4 referred to
Messiter v Hutchinson (1987) 10 NSWLR 525 referred to
Maitland Hospital v Fisher (No 2) (1992) 27 NSWLR 721 at 724 referred to
Smith v 600 Machinery Australia Ltd [1996] FCA 1029 referred to
Coshott v Learoyd [1999] FCA 276 at [37] and [47]-[49] followed
Calderbank v Calderbank [1975] 3 All ER 333 referred to
Smallacombe v Lockyer Investment Co Pty Ltd (1993) 42 FCR 97 referred to
Mowie Fisheries Pty Ltd v Switzerland Insurance Australia Ltd [1996] FCA 931 referred to
Henderson v Amadio Pty Ltd [1996] FCA 184 referred to
Flemington Properties Pty Ltd v Raine & Horne Commercial Pty Ltd [1998] FCA 53 referred to
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Amcor Printing Papers Group Ltd [2000] FCA 163 referred to
Black v Tomislav Lipovac BHNF Maria Lipovac [1998] FCA 699 at [217] and [218] applied
Multicon Engineering Pty Ltd v Federal Airports Corporation (1996) 138 ALR 425 referred to

ALPINE HARDWOODS (AUST) PTY LTD (ACN 004 495 761) and THOMAS JOSEPH COURTNEY v HARDYS PTY LTD (ACN 000 071 705) and MICHAEL JAMES EWING

VG722 of 1998

WEINBERG J
8 MARCH 2002

MELBOURNE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VG722 OF 1998

BETWEEN:

ALPINE HARDWOODS (AUST) PTY LTD (ACN 004 495 761)
FIRST APPLICANT

THOMAS JOSEPH COURTNEY
SECOND APPLICANT

AND:

HARDYS PTY LTD (ACN 000 071 705)
FIRST RESPONDENT

MICHAEL JAMES EWING
SECOND RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

WEINBERG J

DATE OF ORDER:

8 MARCH 2002

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The notice of motion, filed on 31 January 2002 by the respondents, be dismissed. 

2.The respondents pay the applicants’ costs of and incidental to that notice of motion.

Note:   Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VG722 OF 1998

BETWEEN:

ALPINE HARDWOODS (AUST) PTY LTD (ACN 004 495 761)
FIRST APPLICANT

THOMAS JOSEPH COURTNEY
SECOND APPLICANT

AND:

HARDYS PTY LTD (ACN 000 071 705)
FIRST RESPONDENT

MICHAEL JAMES EWING
SECOND RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

WEINBERG J

DATE:

8 MARCH 2002

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. On 21 December 2001 I delivered reasons for judgment in this matter.  I ordered that the application be dismissed and that the applicants pay the respondents’ costs.

  2. At the time I pronounced the order of the Court, senior counsel for the respondents…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Alpine Hardwoods (Aust) Pty Ltd v Hardys Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] FCA 224
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Alpine Hardwoods (Aust) Pty Ltd v Hardys Pty Ltd (No 2), the dispute involved issues of costs related to settlement negotiations. The parties had been engaged in litigation with a claim for damages by the plaintiff, Alpine Hardwoods, against the defendant, Hardys. The defendant had made an offer of settlement under the provisions of Order 23 of the Supreme Court Rules, which is designed to encourage settlements by providing protection to the party making the offer. The plaintiff rejected the offer and the case proceeded to trial, after which the defendant applied for indemnity costs pursuant to Order 23 for the plaintiff's rejection of the offer.

The legal issues the court had to address included whether the rejection of a settlement offer made under Order 23 warranted an order for indemnity costs and whether the offer was reasonable enough to merit such a consideration. The court had to weigh the purpose of Order 23, which is to encourage settlements, against the circumstances of the case, including the timing and nature of the offer, and whether the plaintiff had a reasonable basis for rejecting the offer.

The court reasoned that while non-acceptance of an Order 23 offer should be given considerable weight, it is not automatically determinative of indemnity costs. The court must consider the entire context of the litigation, including the stage of the proceedings, the strength of the parties' respective cases, and any counter-offers made. In this case, the court found that the defendant's offer, while not extremely favourable, was reasonable, given the stage of the litigation and the opportunity provided to the plaintiff to assess their case. However, the court concluded that the plaintiff had a reasonable basis for rejecting the offer, as evidenced by their subsequent willingness to settle for a higher amount. Therefore, the application for indemnity costs was dismissed.

The final orders of the court were that the notice of motion filed by the defendant be dismissed and that the defendant pay the plaintiff's costs of and incidental to that notice of motion.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The notice of motion, filed on 31 January 2002 by the respondents, be dismissed.

2. The respondents pay the applicants’ costs of and incidental to that notice of motion.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

WEINBERG J

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: WEINBERG J

His Honour then discussed a number of the relevant authorities, some of which have been referred to earlier in this judgment. He referred to the difference between the approach taken by Rolfe J in Multicon Engineering Pty Ltd v Federal Airports Corporation (supra), and that taken by the Full Court in Black v Lipovac. He continued at pars [47]-[49]:“Where an offer is made pursuant to Order 23, with the safeguards to the offeree that are thereby imported, it seems to me its non-acceptance should be given considerable weight; otherwise, there is not much point in offerors using the Order. And the purpose of the Order is a salutary one; it is to enable a party to “raise the stakes” in the litigation, and thereby encourage the opposing party to give more anxious consideration to the desirability of a settlement. This was the point made by the Full Court in Black, in adopting the comments of Byrne J in Mutual Community Ltd v Lorden Holdings Pty Ltd and rejecting the standard “plainly unreasonable”.As Black itself demonstrates, it does not follow that non-acceptance of a Calderbank offer (or even an Order 23 offer) must lead to an order for indemnity costs; the Court must still consider the whole of the circumstances. However, whether or not it is correct to talk about a “prima facie presumption”, non-acceptance of an Order 23 offer should at least be regarded as providing to the offeror a good start in the task of persuading the Court to award more than party-party costs.The offer made in the present case was for a nominal amount; … it can hardly be described as “extremely favourable” to the applicants. Nonetheless, the offer involved payment by the respondents of the applicants’ costs incurred to that date, which would have included the fees paid to its expert witnesses. The hearing was imminent. And, as a direction had been made for the evidence in chief of all parties to be in affidavit form, and all affidavits had then been filed and served, the applicants were in a position to assess the strength of their case against the respondents. By the terms of the offer they had three weeks to make that assessment.”CONSIDERATION It is plain that this Court encourages parties to undertake genuine settlement negotiations. This is in part a consequence of O 23, but may also be regarded as a reflection of s 53A of the Act empowering the Court to refer proceedings to mediation. Indeed, there was a mediation in the present case shortly before the respondents made their offer of 2 July 1999. The applicants’ case, as pleaded, sought damages in the sum of approximately $1.2 million. The Calderbank offer made by the respondents on 2 July 1999 of $400,000 plus costs was made at a relatively early stage in the proceeding. By then the pleadings had closed, and each side had given discovery. However, given that there had been no affidavits or witness statements filed, the trial was a long way off. The respondents’ offer was, on any view, a reasonable one. Although it was rejected, it was followed by a counter offer to settle the case for $554,000 plus costs. The fact that the applicants were prepared to settle for that sum demonstrates that the initial offer had at least been reasonable. It is clear that the respondents made a genuine attempt to resolve the case without there being a need for a trial which would inevitably be lengthy and expensive.