Bashour v Australian and New Zealand Banking Group Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 73 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Bashour v Australian and New Zealand Banking Group Limited [2017] FCA 163

File number: VID 107 of 2014
Judge: TRACEY J
Date of judgment: 27 February 2017
Catchwords:

COSTS – where applicant brought proceeding in this Court and, later, brought proceeding in Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal – where respondents successfully sought order in VCAT striking out VCAT proceeding and referring it to this Court – where VCAT’s order subsequently quashed – application by applicant for leave to discontinue on basis that respondents pay her costs for entire proceeding or from various dates in the alternative, or on the basis that there be no order as to costs – consideration of whether costs incurred prior to 1 April 2015 “thrown away” because of respondents’ acts or omissions – consideration of whether available to applicant, as self-represented litigant, to recover costs prior to 1 April 2015 in any case – consideration of exception, established in London Scottish Benefit Society v Chorley (1884) 13 QBD 872, to prohibition on such recovery – whether respondents engaged in “unreasonable act or omission” within meaning of s 570(2)(b) of Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) – unreasonable act said to be making of application to VCAT with fundamentally misconceived legal basis –discussion of “associated jurisdiction” compared with “accrued jurisdiction” of this Court – respondents’ conduct not unreasonable – applicant given leave to discontinue on basis that there be no order as to costs

COSTS – application by respondents that applicant pay their costs for entire proceeding or from various dates in the alternative – submitted that either applicant discontinuing in order to replicate proceeding in VCAT, in which case respondents exposed to duplicated costs, or applicant discontinuing due to unavailability of principal relief, in which case discontinuance should have occurred when that became clear – whether unreasonable act or omission by applicant – no unreasonable act or omission – consideration whether Calderbank principles applicable where no determination of proceeding on merits – rejection of offers by applicant not unreasonable, nor demonstrative of unreasonable approach more generally – application refused

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application to use in VCAT affidavits lodged in this proceeding – respondent consented to use by applicant of her own affidavits – consideration whether proper basis shown for use of respondents’ affidavits in VCAT – proper basis not shown

Legislation:

Australian Consumer Law (Cth)

Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth), s 13

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), ss 570, 570(1), 570(2)(b), 725‑733

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), s 32

Sex Discrimination Act 1984 (Cth), s 10

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), r 26.12(7)

Equal Opportunity Act 2010 (Vic)

Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 1998 (Vic), ss 77, 77(1), 77(3), 109

Cases cited:

Ashby v Slipper (No 2) (2014) 314 ALR 84

Atlas v Kalyk [2001] NSWCA 10

Australian and International Pilots Association v Qantas Airways Ltd (No 3) (2007) 162 FCR 392

Australian Rail, Tram and Bus Industry Union v Railway Employment Company Pty Ltd (2015)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bashour v Australian and New Zealand Banking Group Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] FCA 163
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Bashour v Australian and New Zealand Banking Group Limited, the primary issue before the Court was whether the applicant, Ms Bashour, could recover costs incurred before 1 April 2015, following a dispute that spanned both the Federal Court and the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT). Ms Bashour sought orders to discontinue the Federal Court proceeding, requesting that the respondents pay her costs from various dates, or alternatively, that there be no order as to costs. The respondents, in turn, applied for an order that Ms Bashour pay their costs for the entire proceeding or from various dates. A secondary issue was whether the Court could permit the use of affidavits filed in the Federal Court proceeding in the VCAT proceeding.

The Court considered whether the respondents’ actions were unreasonable within the meaning of s 570(2)(b) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), which would allow for the recovery of costs incurred prior to 1 April 2015. The Court found that the respondents’ application to VCAT, though based on a fundamentally misconceived legal basis, did not constitute an unreasonable act or omission. Similarly, the Court determined that Ms Bashour's rejection of Calderbank offers did not constitute unreasonable conduct. Given that neither party's conduct triggered s 570(2), the Court was prohibited from awarding costs under s 570(1). Consequently, Ms Bashour was granted leave to discontinue the proceeding with no order as to costs. Regarding the use of affidavits, while Ms Bashour could use her own affidavits in the VCAT proceeding, the Court found no proper basis for allowing the use of the respondents’ affidavits.

The Court's decision hinged on the interpretation of "unreasonable act or omission" and the applicability of the prohibition on awarding costs prior to 1 April 2015. The Court held that neither party's actions were unreasonable, and therefore, the costs incurred before that date could not be recovered. The Court granted Ms Bashour leave to discontinue the proceeding on the condition that there be no order as to costs. Additionally, the Court permitted the use of certain affidavits in the VCAT proceeding, specifying which ones could be used based on the corrected list provided by the respondents.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Applicant have leave to discontinue the proceeding on the basis that there be no order as to costs.

2. The parties be granted leave to use the following affidavits sworn by Katherine Bashour and filed in the Federal Court proceeding VID107/2014, for the purposes of the VCAT proceeding H245/2014 and any other VCAT proceeding instituted by the Applicant and involving one or more of the Respondents, including for the purpose of tendering such affidavits and/or cross-examination in relation to the same:

(a) Affidavit of service of Katherine Bashour filed on 24 February 2014.

(b) Affidavit of Katherine Bashour filed on 12 August 2014.

(c) Affidavit of Katherine Bashour filed on 4 September 2014.

(d) Affidavit of Katherine Bashour in reply to the Affidavit of Sara Van Vliet filed on 1 December 2014.

(e) Affidavit of Katherine Bashour in reply to the Affidavit of Mark Shaw filed on 1 December 2014.

(f) Affidavit of Katherine Bashour in reply to the Affidavit of Daniel Zeman filed on 1 December 2014.

(g) Affidavit of Katherine Bashour in reply to the Affidavit of Liana Edelman filed on 1 December 2014.

(h) Affidavit of Katherine Bashour in reply to the Affidavit of Glenn Haslam filed on 1 December 2014.

(i) Affidavit of Katherine Bashour in reply to the affidavit of Peter Harman filed on 1 December 2014.

(j) Affidavit of Katherine Bashour filed on 1 December 2014.

(k) Affidavit of Katherine Bashour filed on 17 March 2015.

(l) Affidavit of Katherine Bashour filed on 16 April 2015.

(m) Affidavit of Katherine Bashour filed on 28 October 2016.

(n) Affidavit of Katherine Bashour filed on 9 December 2016.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ms Bashour’s reflection on the genuineness of the respondents’ concerns regarding the duplication of costs is not to the point. Whether the respondents are put to the cost of filing the same evidence in two proceedings, and whether Ms Bashour should be able to tender in her own case evidence that the respondents would have relied upon in this proceeding, are different issues. It is worth noting, however, that I doubt that the extent of duplicated cost will be as great as the respondents appear to fear. In respect of matters in issue in this proceeding that come to be in issue in the VCAT proceeding, no doubt there will be some duplication of effort, but, to a large degree, work already done in this Court will be useful. It is not necessary to dwell further on these points.Conclusion In my opinion, none of the conduct relied upon by Ms Bashour in her application enlivens s 570(2) of the Act. Similarly, none of the conduct relied upon by the respondents in their application attracts the operation of that subsection. Neither does Ms Bashour’s rejection of the Calderbank offers made by the respondents, whether standing alone or in combination with the other conduct upon which the respondents rely. That being the case, the proscription in s 570(1) prevents this Court from awarding costs. Ms Bashour will be given leave to discontinue the proceeding on the basis that there be no order as to costs. I will make an order consistently with that proposed by the respondents to enable the use of some affidavits filed in this proceeding to be used in the VCAT proceeding. The proposed order refers to an annexure, and the respondents proposed that the annexure should list those affidavits identified in a form of order provided by the respondent dated 11 November 2016. Ms Bashour did not contest the accuracy of that list. However, some of the filing dates were wrong and have been amended. I will add to the list Ms Bashour’s 9 December 2016 affidavit.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Ms Bashour resisted the respondents’ application.Consideration—Ms Bashour’s application Ms Bashour seeks the following orders:“1.Leave to discontinue VID107/2014.2.The [Bank] pay [Ms Bashour’s] costs of the entire proceeding on an indemnity basis.3.In the alternative to Order 2 above:(i)the [Bank] pay [Ms Bashour’s] costs on an indemnity basis from 1 April 2015; and(ii)the [Bank] pay [Ms Bashour’s] costs on an ordinary basis for the period prior to 1 April 2015.4.In the alternative to Orders 2 and 3 above, the [Bank] pay [Ms Bashour’s] costs of the entire proceeding on an ordinary basis.5.In the alternative to Orders 2, 3, and 4 above:(i)the [Bank] pay [Ms Bashour’s] costs on an ordinary basis from 1 April 2015; and(ii)there be no order as to costs in respect of the period prior to 1 April 2015.6.In the alternative to Orders 2, 3, 4 and 5 above, there be no order as to costs.7.Interest on costs.8.Leave be granted to use the evidence filed by the parties in VID107/2014 in the VCAT proceeding H245/2014, and/or any related VCAT proceeding involving one or more of the Respondents in H245/2014 and/or VID107/2014” It is convenient to commence by setting out (in very broad terms) the rationale underpinning Ms Bashour’s application. It is this: while these Federal Court proceedings were on foot, Ms Bashour determined to bring a new proceeding in the VCAT. That VCAT proceeding, as she saw it, was unrelated to her existing Federal Court proceeding. The respondents saw things differently. Their view was that the two proceedings were interrelated and should be heard in the same place at the same time. With a view to procuring that outcome, they applied to the VCAT for an exercise of its s 77 power which (it was thought) would permit all aspects of the dispute to be resolved in this Court. Ms Bashour resisted that application, which (it must be supposed) involved a desire on her part for the two proceedings to continue. At some point after the VCAT made the s 77 order, however, Ms Bashour determined to seek to have all issues determined in the same forum. This change in approach was detailed in her affidavit dated 28 October 2016, at [23(b)] and [23(f)]:“(b)… had the Strike Out Application and Strike Out Order not been pursued and made, I would have been prepared to proceed to final hearing in VID107/2014, with [it] being run as a damages case. In particular, I would have run VID107/2014 and then run the VCAT proceeding in respect of post-VID107/2014 conduct; …(f)since on or about 31 March 2015, in light of the derailment of both VID107/2014 and the VCAT proceeding, I have been willing to have the two proceedings proceed in the one forum, per the instigation and invitation of the Respondents … .” As her representative sought to impress upon Mukhtar AsJ, of necessity (in light of the VCAT’s order) that involved in the first place an investigation of whether that single forum could be this Court. Having come to the view, over time, that the issues the subject of the VCAT proceeding could not be replicated in the Federal Court, Ms Bashour embarked upon judicial review of the VCAT’s order so as to re‑enliven her proceeding in that forum. Heraim, as it was put to Mukhtar AsJ, was as follows:“HIS HONOUR: So reinstate means reinstate the pre-existing VCAT case and add to it a replication under State law of the Federal law case. Correct?MR HARMER: That’s correct, Your Honour. …”