Burns v Media Options Group Pty Ltd and Ors (No.2)

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BURNS v MEDIA OPTIONS GROUP PTY LTD & ORS (No.2) [2013] FCCA 2016
Catchwords:
HUMAN RIGHTS – Costs – applicant successful ‑ applicant seeking indemnity costs ‑ whether justifying circumstances to make an indemnity costs order – order made.

Legislation:

Federal Circuit Court Act 1999 (Cth) ss.3, 79
Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth) rr.21.02, 21.10
Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr.25.14,
Legal Services Directions 2005 (Cth)
Australian Human Rights Commission Act 1986 (Cth) s.11
Legal Profession Act 2004 (NSW)

Burns v Media Options Group Pty Ltd [2012] FCCA 79
Calderbank v Calderbank [1975] 3 All ER 333
Travers v New South Wales (2001) 163 FLR 9
Shiels v James [2000] FMCA 2
Wiggins v Department of Defence – Navy (No 3) [2006] FMCA 970
Johanson v Blackedge (2001) 163 FLR 58
Hughes v Car Buyers Pty Ltd [2004] FMCA 526
Colgate-Palmolive v Cussons (1993) 46 FCR 225
Wong v Su [2001] FMCA 108
CGU Insurance Ltd v Corrections Corporation of Australia Staff Superannuation Pty Ltd [2008] FCAFC 173
Hazeldene’s Chicken Farm v Victorian Work Cover Authority (No 2) (2005) 13 VR 435
Clark v Commissioner of Taxation [2010] FCA 415
Re Veron: Ex Parte Law Society of New South Wales (1996) 84 WN (Pt 1) (NSW)
Brenner v First Artist’s Management Pty Ltd (1993) 2 VR 221
Fountain Selected Meats (Sales) Pty Ltd v International Produce Merchants Pty Ltd (1988) 81 ALR 397
Minns v State of New South Wales (No.2) [2002] FMCA 197
Tate v Rafin [2000] FCA 1582
Creek v Cairns Post Pty Ltd [2001] FCA 1150
Paramasivam v Wheeler [2001] FCA 231
Jacomb v Australian Municipal Administrative Clerical and Services Union [2004] FMCA 359
Rispoli v Merck Sharpe and Dohme (Australia) Pty Ltd (No.2) [2003] FMCA 516
Hollingdale v North Coast Area Health Service (No.2) [2006] FMCA 585
Clack v Command Recruitment Group Pty Ltd and Anor (No.2) [2010] FMCA 198
Hughes v Western Australian CricketAssn (Inc) [1986] FCA 357; (1986) 19 FCR 10; [1986] ATPR 40-748
Ritter v Godfrey [1920] 2 KB 47
Innesv Rail Corporation of NSW (No.2) [2013] FMCA 36
Cooke v Plauen Holdings [2001] FMCA 91
Howe v Qantas Airways Ltd (No.2) [2004] FMCA 934
Ho v Regulator Australia Pty Ltd & Anor (No.2) [2004] FMCA 402
McBride v State of Victoria (No.2) [2003] FMCA 313
Ruddock & Ors v Vadarlis & Others (No 2) [2001] FCA 1865
Oshlack v Richmond River Council [1998] HCA 11
Latoudis v Casey [1999] HCA 59; (1990) 170 CLR 178
Probiotec Ltd v University of Melbourne [2008] FCAFC 5
Cummings v Lewis (1993) 113 ALR 285
Re Commonwealth; Ex parte Marks [2000] HCA 67
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Hellicar [2012] FCA 17 LVR (WA) Pty Ltd v Administrative Appeals Tribunal [2012] FCAFC 90
Melbourne Steamship Limited v Moorhead (1912) 15 CLR 333
Fetherston v Peninsula Health [2004] FCA 485
Purvis v New South Wales [2003] HCA 62; (2003) 217 CLR 92
King v…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Burns v Media Options Group Pty Ltd and Ors (No.2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCCA 2016
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for costs by the respondents, Media Options Group Pty Ltd and Ors, against the applicant, Burns, following substantive proceedings. The dispute arose from allegations made by the applicant against the respondents, which were ultimately unsuccessful. The application for costs was heard by Judge Nicholls.

The primary legal issue before the Court was whether the respondents were entitled to an order for costs, and if so, on what basis. This involved considering the conduct of the applicant and the respondents during the proceedings, particularly in light of findings made in the substantive judgment regarding the applicant's evidence and the second respondent's admissions about a document provided to the Australian Human Rights Commission. The Court also had to assess whether the applicant's pursuit of the proceedings was "desultory" and based on untruthful allegations, as suggested by the respondents.

Judge Nicholls considered the principles governing costs orders, referencing the decision in *Wong*, which held that an unsuccessful applicant who pursued a case in a "desultory way" and with untruthful allegations should be dismissed with costs and that the court should express its disapproval. The Court noted that the applicant referred to findings in the substantive judgment that the second respondent's evidence was not to be believed and that the second respondent admitted a document sent to the AHRC was "not correct" despite relying on it in the hearing. The Court observed that the respondents' submissions continued an approach of making "counter allegations" against the applicant's conduct rather than directly addressing the applicant's assertions, particularly concerning the second respondent's admissions about the document and its reliance during the hearing. The Court found that some of the respondents' submissions were unhelpful to the consideration of costs and appeared intended to argue that the applicant unnecessarily prolonged the hearing.

Background

Background to the litigation

The facts of this case revolve around an application brought by the applicant against Media Options Group Pty Ltd and others, referred to as the respondents. The applicant sought to pursue allegations against the respondents, which ultimately proved unsuccessful. The proceedings were characterised by the applicant's desultory approach, marked by untruthful allegations that were known to be false. The court's disapproval was strongly expressed, citing the inappropriateness of such an application and its detrimental impact on anti-discrimination legislation. The applicant highlighted the second respondent’s admissions regarding a document sent to the Australian Human Rights Commission (AHRC), which was deemed "not correct" and used in the substantive hearing despite the second respondent's knowledge of its inaccuracies.

During the substantive hearing, the evidence presented by the second respondent was found to be untrustworthy, and the court specifically noted the second respondent's admission that the document sent to the AHRC was "not correct." This document was crucial to the respondents' defence, and its reliance despite known inaccuracies underscores the contentious nature of the proceedings. The respondents' submissions focused on counter-allegations against the applicant's conduct rather than addressing the core assertions made by the applicant. The respondents failed to adequately address the admissions made by the second respondent about the document's inaccuracies and its inappropriate use in the hearing. Additionally, the respondents' submissions included points that were deemed irrelevant or unhelpful in the context of the costs argument, particularly their reference to the "principal issue" and the applicant's points of claim.

The matter of Burns v Media Options Group Pty Ltd and Ors (No.2) has traversed several stages of litigation prior to reaching the current court. Initially, the applicant filed proceedings against the respondents, alleging various breaches of anti-discrimination laws. The case was subsequently determined at the first instance, with the primary judge dismissing the applicant's claims and adjudging that the application was made in bad faith, relying on untruthful evidence. Following this decision, the applicant appealed to this court, challenging the primary judge's findings and seeking a reversal of the dismissal along with costs. The respondents, in turn, filed their own submissions, arguing against the applicant's appeal and asserting that the applicant had unnecessarily extended the time of the hearing by proposing and pursuing irrelevant matters. Throughout the proceedings, key procedural steps included the filing of various applications, the making of interlocutory orders, and the respondents’ attempts to counter the applicant’s allegations with their own counter-allegations. The procedural history reflects a complex interplay of allegations and counter-allegations, with significant focus on the credibility of evidence presented and the manner in which the case was pursued.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The applicant further refers to Wong (per Driver FM, as he then was, at [10]): “The applicant has been wholly unsuccessful in these proceedings. The application was pursued in a desultory way by the applicant and in the knowledge that the allegations made by her were untruthful. Accordingly, the application must be dismissed with costs. In addition, it is appropriate in the circumstances that the Court express its strong disapproval, both of the fact that the application was made at all and also the manner in which it was pursued. Applications of this nature, based upon untruthful evidence, are apt to bring anti-discrimination legislation into disrepute, and do a grave disservice to others wishing to pursue a genuine grievance. The respondents should not be out of pocket in having dealt with this application.”[Emphasis Added] The applicant asks the Court to note, in this regard, various findings in the substantive judgment that the evidence of the second respondent was not to be believed and the second respondent’s admissions that a document sent to the AHRC was “not correct”. The document was sent in “defence” of the claim made against the respondents and was relied upon in the hearing before the Court. This was in circumstances where the second respondent knew the contents of the documents were “not correct” in material matters as at the time of its sending, and that he admitted to this at the hearing (see [18] of the applicant’s initial written submissions). It must be said that in their written submissions, the respondents continue the approach utilised in the conduct of their response during the hearing of the substantive application (see judgment at [17]). This was to seek to “answer” the applicant’s allegations with “counter allegations” against the applicant’s conduct during the hearing. The difficulty however, is that no satisfactory attempt was made by the respondents to counter the actual relevant assertions made by the applicant in this regard (other than in one aspect dealt with below, see “objections”). Importantly, the respondents’ submissions say nothing about the admissions made by the second respondent in relation to the document sent to the AHRC, (with the obvious reference to s 46PN of the Australian Human Rights Commission Act 1986 (Cth) (“the AHRC Act”)), and the conduct of relying on this document during the hearing when on his own evidence the second respondent also knew the document (relevantly) was “not correct”. A number of matters raised by the respondents’ submissions are not helpful to the consideration of costs and in one sense, some are irrelevant. It would appear that the reference to “the principal issue in the proceedings” ([4]–[6] of the respondents’ submissions) and subsequent points under the headings of “Principal matters in the [a]pplicant’s Points of Claim” (at [7] – [8]) and “Principal claims of the applicant” (at [9] ‑ [10]) are intended to assert the basis for an argument that the applicant unnecessarily extended the time of the hearing by proposing and pursuing matters “irrelevant” to his case.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the applicant's conduct in making the application bring anti-discrimination legislation into disrepute?
2. Was the evidence provided by the applicant truthful, and was the application pursued in a desultory manner?
3. Did the second respondent knowingly rely on a document that he knew was not correct in material matters?
4. Did the second respondent's admissions regarding the document sent to the AHRC affect the outcome of the case?
5. Were the respondents' counter allegations against the applicant's conduct relevant to the actual assertions made by the applicant?
6. What was the impact of the respondents' reliance on the incorrect document on the proceedings?
7. Should the respondents be held liable for costs due to their conduct during the hearing and in their written submissions?
8. Did the applicant unnecessarily extend the time of the hearing by proposing and pursuing matters irrelevant to her case?

Held
1. The court concluded that the applicant's conduct in making the application brought anti-discrimination legislation into disrepute. The result was that the court expressed strong disapproval of the application and its manner.
2. The court found that the evidence provided by the applicant was untruthful, and the application was pursued in a desultory manner. The result was that the application was dismissed with costs.
3. The court held that the second respondent knowingly relied on a document that he knew was not correct in material matters. The result was that this was considered in the overall outcome of the case.
4. The second respondent's admissions regarding the document sent to the AHRC affected the outcome of the case, but the court did not provide a specific conclusion on this point.
5. The court found that the respondents' counter allegations against the applicant's conduct were not relevant to the actual assertions made by the applicant. The result was that these allegations did not impact the overall outcome.
6. The impact of the respondents' reliance on the incorrect document on the proceedings was considered, but the court did not provide a specific conclusion on this point.
7. The court held that the respondents should be liable for costs due to their conduct during the hearing and in their written submissions. The result was an order for the respondents to pay costs.
8. The court concluded that the applicant unnecessarily extended the time of the hearing by proposing and pursuing matters irrelevant to her case. The result was that this factor was taken into account in the overall outcome.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered whether the applicant's conduct in making the application brought anti-discrimination legislation into disrepute. The court relied on prior authority from Wong, where it was held that applications of this nature, based on untruthful evidence, can bring the legislation into disrepute. The applicant's evidence was deemed untruthful, and the application was pursued in a desultory manner. The court found that such conduct is inappropriate and does a grave disservice to those genuinely seeking to pursue grievances. The court expressed strong disapproval of both the making and the manner of pursuit of the application.

In assessing the truthfulness of the evidence provided by the applicant, the court found that the application was made with knowledge that the allegations were untruthful. This conclusion was based on the applicant's unsuccessful track record in similar proceedings and the desultory manner in which the application was pursued. The court held that the applicant's conduct was in bad faith and did not merit any favourable consideration.

The court examined whether the second respondent knowingly relied on a document that he knew was not correct in material matters. The second respondent admitted that the document sent to the Australian Human Rights Commission (AHRC) was "not correct" and that he knew this at the time of its sending. Despite this admission, the respondents continued to rely on the document during the hearing, which the court found to be an improper use of the document. The second respondent's conduct in this regard was held against him, as it demonstrated a lack of integrity in the proceedings.

The second respondent's admissions regarding the document sent to the AHRC played a significant role in the outcome of the case. The court noted that the respondents' submissions failed to address these admissions, which highlighted the second respondent's knowledge that the document was incorrect. This failure to counter the applicant's assertions regarding the document further undermined the credibility of the respondents' case.

The court also considered whether the respondents' counter allegations against the applicant's conduct were relevant to the actual assertions made by the applicant. The court found that the respondents primarily focused on the applicant's conduct during the hearing rather than addressing the relevant assertions made by the applicant. This approach was deemed unhelpful and irrelevant to the substantive issues of the case.

Regarding the impact of the respondents' reliance on the incorrect document, the court held that it significantly affected the proceedings. The respondents' continued use of the document despite knowing its inaccuracies demonstrated a disregard for the truth and proper conduct in legal proceedings. This conduct contributed to the overall negative assessment of the respondents' case.

The court addressed whether the respondents should be held liable for costs due to their conduct during the hearing and in their written submissions. The court found that the respondents' conduct, including their reliance on an incorrect document and their failure to address the applicant's relevant assertions, warranted an order for costs against them. The court emphasised that such conduct should not be rewarded and that the respondents should not be out of pocket for dealing with the application.

Finally, the court assessed whether the applicant unnecessarily extended the time of the hearing by proposing and pursuing matters irrelevant to her case. The court found that while some of the matters raised by the applicant were indeed irrelevant, this did not significantly impact the overall outcome of the case. The court held that the primary concern was the respondents' improper conduct and the untruthful nature of the application, which justified the costs order against the respondents.