Clark v Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Clark v Commissioner of Taxation [2010] FCA 415

Citation: Clark v Commissioner of Taxation [2010] FCA 415
Parties: DAVID CLARK v COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION
HELEN CLARK v COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION
File number(s): QUD 500 of 2006
QUD 501 of 2006
Judge: GREENWOOD J
Date of judgment: 30 April 2010
Catchwords:

TAXATION – consideration of whether Order 23 of the Federal Court Rules applies to an appealable objection decision arising under s 14ZZ of the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) – consideration of the application of the Federal Court Rules generally to an appealable objection decision – consideration of Orders 52A and 52B of the Federal Court Rules – consideration of whether an Order 23 offer made by the applicants to the Commissioner of Taxation is a “genuine” offer – consideration of whether an offer to forego significant recoverable costs and walk away from a proceeding is a genuine offer – consideration of the special circumstances said to warrant an Order other than an Order for indemnity costs from the date of the offer – consideration of a Calderbank offer made to the Commissioner – consideration of whether the Commissioner acted unreasonably in electing to reject the offer – consideration of the approach adopted by the Commissioner to putting the taxpayers to proof of an issue concerning the cost base of the acquisition of shares the subject of a claim of capital loss – consideration of whether the Commissioner acted unreasonably in putting the taxpayers to proof and whether an Order for indemnity costs of the proof of the issue is warranted

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – consideration of the application of Order 23 to proceedings under Order 52B of the Federal Court Rules – consideration of the principles governing whether an offer is a genuine offer – consideration of whether an offer by a party to abandon any claim for significant recoverable costs is a genuine offer of settlement – consideration of a Calderbank offer and whether the Commissioner of Taxation acted unreasonably in electing to reject the offer  

Legislation: Federal Court Rules; Orders 4, 23, 52, 52A, 52B
High Court Rules, Order 65, r 1, r 2
Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth); ss 14ZZ, 14ZZO, 14ZZP
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976; ss 43, 59
Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth); ss 185, 187, 196A, 198
Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth), ss 2, 64, 67A
Cases cited: Clark v Commissioner of Taxation [2009] FCA 1401 - cited
CGU Insurance Limited v Corrections Corporation of Australia Staff Superannuation Pty Ltd [2008] FCAFC 173 – cited and quoted
Premier Building & Consulting Pty Ltd v Spotless Group Limited (No 13) [2007] VSC 516 - cited
Calderbank v Calderbank [1975] 3 ALL ER 333 - cited
McDermott Industries (Aust) Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (2003) 52 ATR 423; [2003] FCA 139 - cited
Commissioner of Taxation v Hydrocarbon Products Pty Ltd (1987) 14 FCR 359 – cited and quoted
George v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1952)…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Clark v Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCA 415
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Clark v Commissioner of Taxation, the plaintiffs sought a review of a taxation decision made by the Commissioner of Taxation. The primary issue was whether the Commissioner's assessment was excessive and, if so, what remedial orders should be made. The case involved complex litigation, with the plaintiffs incurring significant costs in presenting their case. The plaintiffs made a formal offer to settle the proceedings under Order 23 of the Federal Court Rules, proposing that the Commissioner accept the taxpayers' objection, withdraw the amended assessment, and that both parties bear their own costs. The Commissioner argued that the offer was not genuine, that the plaintiffs did not achieve a result not less favourable than the offer, and that there were good reasons to not apply the order.

The court had to determine whether the plaintiffs' offer was genuine, whether they obtained a result not less favourable than the terms of the offer, and whether there were good reasons to not apply the order. The court considered the evidence presented by the plaintiffs' solicitor, who estimated that the plaintiffs were foregoing between $123,004 and $184,506 in costs. The Commissioner contended that the offer was not genuine and that the plaintiffs did not achieve a result not less favourable than the terms of the offer. The court needed to assess the validity of the Commissioner's arguments and decide whether the plaintiffs' offer was genuine and whether the conditions of Order 23 were met.

After reviewing the evidence and arguments, the court found that the plaintiffs' offer was genuine and that they obtained a result not less favourable than the terms of the offer. The court held that there were no good reasons to not apply the order, and thus, the plaintiffs were entitled to recover their costs. The court ruled in favour of the plaintiffs, determining that the Commissioner should bear the costs incurred by the plaintiffs in the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

As to the question of whether the offer is genuine, the applicants on 9 December 2008 offered to settle the proceedings on the footing that the objection of the taxpayers be allowed (with a consequential variation of the objection decision); the notice of amended assessment for the income year ending 30 June 2001 be withdrawn; and the parties bear their own costs of the proceeding (with the applicants foregoing any costs orders in their favour at that date). That offer amounted to the Commissioner accepting that the objection taken by the applicants was good and the applicants would not claim the recovery of any costs incurred in the proceeding. The evidence The solicitor for the applicants, Mr Damien Bourke, swore an affidavit on 2 February 2010 in which he deposes to these things:17.I have calculated the quantum of the costs which had been incurred (solicitor/client) by the Applicants as at 25 November 2008. The Applicants at this time had filed a significant body of evidence including affidavits from each of the Applicants Mr/s Clark (filed 29 August 2008 and 15 September 2008 respectively); an Affidavit of Mr Denoon (filed 29 August 2008); a further Affidavit of Mr Scott (filed 15 September 2008); an Affidavit of Mr Anthony Lovett (filed 1 September 2008) and an affidavit of Mr Roxborough (filed 26 September 2008). 18.The Respondent was fully informed by 25 November 2008 of the nature of the case it was to meet – a fortiori since it had the benefit of the sworn evidence of Mr Denoon as well as the Judgment which was given in the Carringbush proceedings [Carringbush Corporation v ASIC (2008) FCA 474]. 19.The investigations which were carried out with witnesses as well as the history of the matter (including the Respondent’s shifting of position), resulted in costs totalling $307 510 (solicitor/client – including Counsel). 20.I am a solicitor having been admitted to practice in 1987. I have conducted and been engaged on numerous “Taxations/Assessments” of costs – within both the State and Federal Courts. I have during my career been primarily involved in commercial litigation type matters and have knowledge of the likely recovery of costs in different types of matters. In my opinion the likely percentage recovery of costs in general ranges between 40‑60%. Taxation matters are generally more expensive to conduct due (in my respectful view) to the onus of proof being cast upon the Applicant/Appellant. 21.Of the above total (which, for the avoidance of doubt) does not include costs associated with the application by the Carringbush companies for approval of the disposal of the Rothbury shares) I would estimate that on a party/party basis the Applicants were foregoing between $123 004 and $184 506 at the date the “Calderbank” offer was made. In a further affidavit sworn 9 March 2010, Mr Bourke at para 2 said this:I also refer to paragraph 21 of my affidavit filed 5 February 2010 [sworn 2 February 2010]. Between the date of making of the “Calderbank” offer and the date of the formal offer made under Order 23 of the Federal Court Rules … there was no significant addition to the costs of the applicants as no additional steps were taken. At the date of making of the Order 23 offer on 9 December 2008, I consider that there would be no change to the applicants’ costs – either on a solicitor/client basis or on a party/party basis.The timing of the offer

Decision

Reasons for decision

For these reasons the other Orders of the Federal Court Rules apply unless specifically modified. Conclusions as to Order 23 An appeal proceeding under s 14ZZ of the TA Act is a proceeding in the Court’s original jurisdiction commenced by an application in accordance with Order 4, r 1(1) using Form 55D in which the moving party is an applicant and the Commissioner is a respondent party. Such an application is a proceeding for the purposes of s 4 of the Federal Court Act and Order 23 of the Federal Court Rules. The Federal Court Rules apply to such a proceeding except to the extent that any particular rule is expressly excluded or expressly modified in its application to the proceeding. Order 52B, r 3 provides for those modifications by adopting modifications reflected in Order 52A, rr 1, 2(2), 2(3), 4, 5, 10, 13, 14 and 17 to 24. Order 52B, r 4 provides for commencement of applications and Order 52B, r 5 and r 5A provide for document filing and service of material specific to the subject matter of the proceeding. There is nothing in the nature of the proceeding which limits the application of Order 23 to the proceeding. A proceeding in the Federal Court arising under s 14ZZ involving questions of fact and law is only a proceeding “of its own kind”, that is, sui generis, in the sense that it concerns an examination of whether the respondent party’s decision as to a taxpayer’s objection is sustainable rather than a contention that a respondent has engaged in conduct in contravention of a statutory norm or prescription giving rise to a remedial order directed to loss, damage, a pecuniary penalty, or threatened conduct. Nor is the subject matter of the proceeding in the nature of a suit between citizens asserting or resisting claims to relief arising out of orthodox causes of action. However, that said, the very subject matter of the proceeding is whether the Commissioner’s assessment is excessive and whether the Commissioner is seeking to obtain, from the citizen, taxation for which the citizen is not liable. The expressly chosen method of testing those questions is by a proceeding in the Court by application between parties who are an applicant and a respondent, governed by the Federal Court Rules. The resolution of the questions in issue in the application may result in a determination that an assessment is excessive with remedial orders directed to the Commissioner as the Court thinks fit. The subject matter of the proceeding is specific but the procedural mechanism for dealing with the matters in issue is by an application under and in accordance with the rules of Court. The application of Order 23, r 11(4)(c) and (d) The Commissioner contends that if Order 23 applies, three further issues arise. First, the offer is not a genuine offer. Secondly, the applicants did not obtain judgment “not less favourable than the terms of the offer” and thirdly, there are good reasons why the Court should, in any event, make Orders otherwise than in terms of Order 23, r 11(4)(c) and (d). Is the offer a genuine offer?

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established