Eastern Nitrogen Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 58 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Eastern Nitrogen Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation [2001] FCA 366

TAXATION – income tax – sale and lease-back of industrial plant – whether items of plant were fixtures – deductibility of outgoings of rent – whether any part of outgoings on capital account – whether taxpayer sought a “collateral advantage” – whether Pt IVA applied to the arrangement.

Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) Pt IVA, ss 51, 51(1), 67, 177A-177G, 177A(1), 177A(5), 177C(1)(b), 177D(b), 177D(b)(ii)
Taxation Administration Act 1953 Cth) s 14ZZO(b)(i)

Commissioner of Taxation of the Commonwealth of Australia v Spotless Services Ltd (1996) 186 CLR 404 applied
Melluish (Inspector of Taxes) v MBI (No 3) Ltd [1996] AC 454 applied
Kay’s Leasing Corp Pty Ltd v CSR Provident Fund Nominees Pty Ltd [1962] VR 429 referred to
Re Samuel Allen & Sons Ltd [1907] 1 Ch 575 referred to
Re Morrison, Jones & Taylor Ltd [1914] 1 Ch 51 referred to
Waltons Stores (Interstate) Ltd v Maher (1988) 164 CLR 387 referred to
Commonwealth v Verwayen (1990) 170 CLR 394 referred to
Industrial Properties (Barton Hill) Ltd v Associated Electrical Industries Ltd [1977] 1 QB 580 (C.A.) referred to
Stern v McArthur (1988) 165 CLR 489 referred to
Chow Yoong Hong v Choong Fah Rubber Manufactory [1962] AC 209 referred to
Prime Wheat Association Ltd v Chief Commissioner of Stamp Duties (1996) 42 NSWLR 505 referred to
Australia and New Zealand Savings Bank Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (1993) 42 FCR 535 referred to
N.M. Superannuation Pty Ltd v Young (1993) 113 ALR 39 referred to
Sun Newspapers Ltd & Associated Newspapers Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1938) 61 CLR 337 applied
G P International Pipecoaters Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1990) 170 CLR 124 applied
Chandler Investment (No 5) Co Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (1993) 47 FCR 588 applied
Commissioner of Inland Revenue v Europa Oil NZ Ltd [1971] AC 760 considered
Europa Oil NZ Ltd v Inland Revenue Commission [1976] 1 WLR 464 considered
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Email Ltd (1999) 99 ATC 4,868 considered
CC (New South Wales) Pty Ltd (In Liq) v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1997) ATC 4,123 considered
Peabody v Commissioner of Taxation (1993) 40 FCR 531 considered

Butt P, “Conveyancing and Property” (2000) 74 ALJ 130

EASTERN NITROGEN LTD v COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION
Q285 OF 1999
Q286 OF 1999

LEE, CARR and SUNDBERG JJ
PERTH (HEARD IN SYDNEY)
3 APRIL 2001


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY

Q285 OF 1999
Q286 OF 1999

ON APPEAL FROM A JUDGE OF THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BETWEEN:

EASTERN NITROGEN LTD
APPELLANT

AND:

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION
RESPONDENT

JUDGES:

LEE, CARR & SUNDBERG JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

3 APRIL 2001

PLACE:

PERTH (HEARD IN SYDNEY)

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Each of the appeals in these matters be allowed with costs.

2.The orders of Drummond J made 5 and 25 November 1999 be set aside and in their place it be ordered:

(a)The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Eastern Nitrogen Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] FCA 366
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Eastern Nitrogen Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation, the taxpayer, Eastern Nitrogen Ltd, appealed against the Commissioner of Taxation's disallowance of certain income tax deductions. The primary judge had previously dismissed Eastern Nitrogen's appeals, but this decision was now under review. The crux of the dispute was whether Eastern Nitrogen was entitled to allowable deductions for payments made under a lease of its ammonia plant and whether the Commissioner could disallow part of these deductions under Part IVA of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth). The factual background reveals that Eastern Nitrogen entered into a sale and lease-back transaction for its ammonia plant with two financiers in August 1989. The plant remained a fixture on Eastern Nitrogen's land, and the lease payments were central to the dispute over tax deductions.

The legal issues before the court were twofold: the characterisation of the lease payments as either revenue or capital in nature and the validity of the Commissioner's disallowance of certain deductions under Part IVA of the Act. The court had to determine whether these lease payments constituted allowable deductions under section 51(1) of the Act or if they should be considered capital expenditures not deductible under the tax legislation. Additionally, the court needed to assess whether the Commissioner's disallowance of part of these deductions was justified under section 177F of the Act.

The court found in favour of Eastern Nitrogen, concluding that the lease payments were indeed allowable deductions under section 51(1) of the Act. The reasoning was that the payments were made for the right to use the plant, which was a contractual benefit and not for the acquisition of the plant itself. Furthermore, the court held that the Commissioner's disallowance of part of these deductions under Part IVA of the Act was not justified. The court set aside the primary judge's orders and allowed the appeals, ordering the Commissioner to reassess Eastern Nitrogen's taxation liability according to law. The costs of the appeals were also awarded to Eastern Nitrogen.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Each of the appeals in these matters be allowed with costs.

2. The orders of Drummond J made 5 and 25 November 1999 be set aside and in their place it be ordered:

(a) The decisions of the respondent disallowing the appellant’s objections to the amended assessments issued to the appellant for the years of income ending 30 September 1989, 1990 and 1991 be set aside and in lieu thereof the objections be allowed.

(b) The matters be remitted to the respondent for reassessment of the appellant’s taxation liability according to law.

(c) The respondent pay the appellant’s costs of the “appeals” under s 14ZZ of the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth).

Background

Background to the litigation

These are two appeals by the appellant taxpayer from judgments of a judge of this Court, given on 5 November 1999, dismissing appeals against objection decisions of the respondent Commissioner of Taxation. The Commissioner disallowed objections to assessments of income tax for substituted accounting periods in respect of the years of income ended 30 September 1989, 1990 and 1991. Appeal No Q 285 is in respect of the 1990 and 1991 years and Appeal No Q 286 is in respect of the 1989 year. One of the two principal issues in the appeals is whether the appellant was entitled to allowable deductions in respect of certain payments made under a lease of its ammonia plant. The deductions were claimed under s 51(1) of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) (“the Act”). The other principal issue is, assuming that the lease payments were allowable deductions under that section, whether the Commissioner was entitled to make a determination under Part IVA (s 177F) of the Act to disallow part of those deductions. The deductions in issue in the appeals are, in round terms, about $20 million. FACTUAL BACKGROUND The appellant manufactures fertiliser and for that purpose produces ammonia. It owns an ammonia plant, which was commissioned in 1968, on an island known as Kooragang Island in New South Wales. The appellant became the registered proprietor of the land at Kooragang Island in 1978. It is common ground in the appeal (although that was not the case at first instance) that the ammonia plant was at all material times a fixture to the appellant's land. In August 1989 the appellant entered into a sale and lease-back transaction with two financiers, BBL Australia Ltd (“BBL”) and State Bank of South Australia (“SBSA”) in respect of the ammonia plant. I shall refer to those two companies as "the financiers". Under an Instalment Purchase Agreement dated 2 August 1989 the appellant agreed to sell the ammonia plant to the financiers. Under an Agreement for Lease, also dated 2 August 1989, the appellant agreed to lease the plant back from the financiers for a period of five years. The land to which the ammonia plant was affixed was not part of the sale and lease-back transaction. The sale price for the ammonia plant was $71.4 million, which the financiers paid to the appellant by two instalments. Under the terms of the Agreement for Lease, assuming that it ran for its full term and that the appellant (as it did) repurchased the ammonia plant at the agreed residual value, the appellant was to pay to the financiers amounts which included $71.4 million together with an agreed “packaging fee” and an amount calculated by way of interest on those two sums. The appellant paid the rental payments during the currency of the Agreement for Lease. By agreement, the term of the lease was extended by one year. The rent for that year was fixed by reference to an interest calculation relating to the then unrecouped balance of the amounts payable to the financiers. On the expiration of the extended term the appellant paid the financiers the agreed residual value of the plant and they in turn resold their interest in that plant to the appellant. Throughout the period of the lease, the ammonia plant remained affixed to the appellant's land and was operated and maintained by it for the purposes of its business of producing ammonia.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

In the 1990 year the appellant claimed as a deduction under s 51(1) of the Act the sum of $30,991,471.84. The respondent disallowed as a deduction the sum of $12,048,711 of that amount. The corresponding figures for the 1991 year were $13,506,196 claimed by the appellant and $8,054,778 disallowed by the respondent. In respect of the 1989 year the appellant claimed deductions, under s 51(1), for valuation fees (in respect of the ammonia plant) and an establishment fee all of which totalled about $96,000. The respondent allowed deductions amounting to one-fifth of that total in each of the three years of income with which these appeals are concerned, as borrowing expenses under s 67 of the Act, but disallowed the claimed deduction for the balance of the fees. THE DECISION AT FIRST INSTANCE The learned primary judge held that the ammonia plant was a fixture and that no legal title to it passed under the Instalment Purchase Agreement or the Agreement for Lease. His Honour reasoned that: “The nature of the interest that arises where a fixture is sold that is not contemplated for severance can only be equitable since the entire legal title to a fixture not agreed to be severed remains with the owner of the freehold.” His Honour then referred to what he described as “... the contingent right to enter and remove the plant” conferred by the Agreement for Lease on the financiers. He held that that contingent right was: “... incapable of amounting to the kind of right to deny Eastern Nitrogen access to the plant upon execution of the agreement for lease that would be necessary before it could be said that the rental payments were paid by Eastern Nitrogen to obtain access to and use of the plant.” His Honour rejected the appellant's submission that the advantage which it sought by assuming the obligation to pay the rental instalments was to protect itself from what might happen if it failed to pay those instalments. The appellant, for tax characterisation purposes, had to be taken to have sought some other advantage. His Honour found that the appellant could not: “... sensibly be regarded as having assumed a new obligation to pay rental instalments in order to obtain the advantage of protecting itself against a detriment capable only of arising if it were to fail to pay one or more of those same instalments.” Furthermore, so his Honour held, the Agreement for Lease, on its proper construction, showed that the appellant undertook to pay the rental instalments in return for possession of the ammonia plant during the term of the lease, not for freedom from disruption of that possession by the financiers. His Honour held that the appellant never needed to pay the instalments to acquire possession of the plant. It had, so his Honour held, “... never lost that right.” In case he was wrong in those conclusions, his Honour then turned to the respondent’s argument that a portion of the rental was to be characterised as having been made on capital account. His Honour rejected that argument on the basis that the advantage which the appellant sought to achieve from the rental payments was the contractual benefit it obtained in return for those payments, namely the right to use the plant.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established