Merchant v Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Merchant v Commissioner of Taxation [2025] FCAFC 56  

Appeal from: Merchant v Commissioner of Taxation [2024] FCA 498
File number(s): NSD 746 of 2024
Judgment of: LOGAN, MCELWAINE AND HESPE JJ
Date of judgment: 22 April 2025
Catchwords:

TAXATION – schemes to reduce tax pursuant to Part IVA of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) – where vendor incurs a substantial capital loss on related party share sale but there is no effective alteration of control – whether primary judge erred in considering s 177D matters by considering the subjective intent of the scheme participants – whether primary judge failed to consider all objective purposes in the s 177D(2) analysis –  held no error established.

DIVIDEND STRIPPING – s 177E – whether primary judge erred in concluding that two debt forgiveness schemes entered into between related companies were schemes having substantially the effect of a scheme by way of or in the nature of dividend stripping – whether the schemes had the requisite tax avoidance purpose – whether the schemes had the requisite substantive effect – appeal allowed in part.

TAXATION OF FINANCIAL ARRANGEMENTS (TOFA) – meaning of the expression “contingent only on the economic performance of the business” in s 230-460(13) Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) – application to expired rights to receive certain milestone payments in a share sale agreement – no error demonstrated.

Legislation:

Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) ss 2-10(2), 2-15(2), 230-15(2), 230-45, 230-55, 230-460(13), 294-35, 974-85(1), 974-60, 995-1

Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) ss 44, 177A(5), 177C, 177C(1)(a), 177D, 177D(1), 177D(2), 177E, 177E(1)(a), 177E(1)(a)(ii), 177E(1)(b), 177E(1)(c), 177F, 177F(1)(a), 177F(1)(c), 177F(3)

New Business Tax System (Debt and Equity) Act 2001 (Cth)

New Business Tax System (Thin Capitalisation) Act 2001 (Cth)

Tax Laws Amendment (Taxation of Financial Arrangements) Act 2009 (Cth)

Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) s 14ZZ

Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1993 (Cth) ss 34, 62, 65

Explanatory Memorandum, Income Tax Laws Amendment Bill (No. 2) 1981

Cases cited:

Automotive Invest Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation [2024] HCA 36; 98 ALJR 1245

B&F Investments Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation [2023] FCAFC 89; 298 FCR 449

Bahonko v Sterjov [2008] FCAFC 30; 166 FCR 415

Bblood Enterprises Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation [2023] FCAFC 114

British American Tobacco Australia Services Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation [2010] FCAFC 130;189 FCR 151

Commissioner of Taxation v Bamford [2010] HCA 10; 240 CLR 481

Commissioner of Taxation v Consolidated Press Holdings Ltd [1999] FCA 1199; 91 FCR 524

Commissioner of Taxation v Consolidated Press Holdings Ltd [2001] HCA 32; 207 CLR 235

Commissioner of Taxation v Hart [2004] HCA 26; 217 CLR 21

Commissioner of Taxation v Macquarie Bank Ltd [2013] FCAFC 13; 210 FCR 164

Commissioner of Taxationv News Australia Holdings Pty Ltd [2010] FCAFC 78

Commissioner of Taxation v Peabody [1994] HCA 43; 181 CLR 359

Commissioner of Taxation vSleight [2004]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Merchant v Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FCAFC 56
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Merchant v Commissioner of Taxation, the Federal Court of Australia was tasked with determining whether certain tax avoidance schemes employed by the appellants were valid and whether they complied with the relevant tax laws. The primary judge had previously set aside a disqualification decision related to these tax schemes, and the appellants subsequently appealed this decision. The key legal issues before the court were whether the primary judge had erred in considering certain subjective intentions of the scheme participants under section 177D of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) and whether the primary judge had adequately considered all objective purposes in the section 177D(2) analysis. Additionally, the court had to determine if two debt forgiveness schemes entered into between related companies constituted schemes for dividend stripping under section 177E of the same Act. The court also examined the interpretation of the expression "contingent only on the economic performance of the business" in section 230-460(13) of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) in the context of expired rights to receive certain milestone payments in a share sale agreement.

The court found that the primary judge did not err in considering the subjective intentions of the scheme participants as these were relevant in determining the overall purpose of the schemes. The court emphasised the importance of examining both subjective and objective purposes in the analysis under section 177D(2). Regarding the debt forgiveness schemes, the court held that the primary judge did not err in concluding that the schemes had the effect of dividend stripping. However, the court allowed the appeal in part, finding that the primary judge had not fully considered the tax avoidance purpose and substantive effect of the schemes. Finally, the court determined that there was no error in the primary judge's interpretation of the expression "contingent only on the economic performance of the business," affirming the disqualification decision in this respect.

In light of the findings, the court allowed the appeal in part but dismissed it in relation to the Taxation of Financial Arrangements Provisions (TOFA). The parties were directed to file any agreed short minutes of orders to give effect to these reasons, including as to costs, or, failing agreement, their competing proposed orders and respective submissions. Final orders would be made on the papers, subject to any further orders.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Within 14 days the parties:

(i) Must file any agreed short minutes of orders to give effect to these reasons, including as to costs; or

(ii) Failing agreement, their competing proposed orders and their respective submissions (not exceeding three pages).

2. Subject to any further order, final orders will be made on the papers.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 16 May 2024, the primary judge, in his capacity as Deputy President of the AAT, set aside the disqualification decision: Merchant and Commissioner of Taxation [2024] AATA 1102.BACKGROUND FINDINGS The appellants do not contend that the primary judge erred in making relevant background findings of fact. His Honour set out a detailed chronology of relevant events at PJ [1]-[240]. We summarise the material findings as follows. The primary judge commenced by identifying the Merchant Group of companies and the key players at PJ [1]–[4]. Mr Merchant co-founded the business which became Billabong Holdings Australia Ltd in 1973. Following a name change to Billabong International Ltd, it was listed on the Australian Stock Exchange (ASX) in August 2000. Mr Merchant at all times was the director and controlling mind of each company in the Merchant Group. GM2 as trustee of the MFT held 100% of the issued shares in Plantic. It first acquired 14% of the Plantic shares in 2005, and then acquired the balance of the Plantic shares in November 2010 pursuant to a scheme of arrangement. The cost base of the MFT’s entire Plantic shareholding was approximately $26.9 million. Mr Merchant at all material times was one of the directors of Plantic together with Ms Colette Paull, his management assistant and Mr Luke McGrath, an investment adviser. Plantic was established as a start-up company to develop technologies in the manufacture and distribution of plant-based packaging materials as a substitute for oil based products. Mr Merchant held all of the issued shares in Tironui, GSM, Kahuna Pty Ltd as trustee of the Angourie Trust and GSMS as trustee of the GMSF. The primary judge set out the history of the Merchant Group shareholdings in BBG at PJ [42]–[50], [62]–[79], [86]–[90], [101]–[102], [126]–[129]. The effect of the transactions was that by March 2014, the Merchant Group held approximately 10% of the voting power in BBG and was no longer the largest shareholder: PJ [129]. On 2 September 2014, Mr Merchant transferred 10,344,828 BBG shares from the MFT to the GMSF, in consideration of $5,844,827, a price of 56.5 cents per share: PJ [185]–[186]. Mr Merchant’s evidence, which the primary judge accepted, was that for many years he sought to maintain a controlling shareholder interest in BBG. When BBG was listed on the ASX in August 2000, the Merchant Group owned approximately 23% of the issued capital and Mr Merchant remained on the board as a non-executive director: PJ [43]. The Global Financial Crisis in 2008 badly affected the retail operations of BBG, but Mr Merchant remained optimistic that the corporate fortunes would improve and, to that end, continued to purchase BBG shares despite his concern that the business had moved from its core area as a wholesaler: PJ [50]. In February 2012, BBG announced that it had received a proposal from TPG Capital to acquire all of its issued shares at a price of $3 per share. Mr Merchant did not agree with the offer price and responded by causing the GMSF to purchase approximately 2.5 million BBG shares at a price of $3.13 per share. He did so because of his belief that BBG would trade out of its difficulties: PJ [70]-[78]. His Honour, contrary to the evidence of Mr Merchant, found that these shares were also acquired to maintain the position of the Merchant Group as a substantial shareholder: PJ [79]. The TPG Capital proposal did not proceed.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

I have had the benefit of reading in draft the reasons for judgment to be delivered by McElwaine and Hespe JJ (joint judgment). The thoroughness with which the facts of this case, the reasons of the primary judge and the issues on the appeal are rehearsed in the joint judgment enables me to state relatively briefly why I would allow this appeal, except insofar as it relates to the Taxation of Financial Arrangements Provisions (TOFA) in the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) (ITAA 1997). I would dismiss so much of the appeal as relates to the TOFA. I refer to the facts only to the extent necessary to explain my conclusions.SECTIONS 177D AND 177C OF THE INCOME TAX ASSESSMENT ACT 1936 (CTH) In his youth, Mr Gordon Stanley Merchant was a surfer and a maker and repairer of surfboards. He travelled the world undertaking these activities. By the early 1970’s, when he was in his late twenties, Mr Merchant had settled in rented farmhouse accommodation in Springbrook in the Gold Coast hinterland. There he continued his business of building surfboards. During this time and through surfing, he met his future wife, Rena. Rena also then had a business serving the surfing community. She made bikinis and simple boardshorts, selling them to other surfers on the Gold Coast. In 1973, they decided to start making boardshorts at home and sell them to local surf shops on the Gold Coast. Together, they made about 20 pairs of boardshorts a week on their kitchen table. Over time, the business so founded grew and evolved into the successful “Billabong” brand of surf ware. Billabong Limited (BBG), which came to conduct that business, was listed on the Australian Securities Exchange (ASX) on 11 August 2000. Even before the listing of BBG on the ASX, there had been challenges for Mr Merchant in the conduct and direction of the Billabong business. These were created by the introduction of external shareholders (notably entities controlled by the Perrin brothers) and related tensions in corporate decision-making. These continued after the listing. A principal source of tension was Mr Merchant’s view that the Billabong business should continue to concentrate on wholesale, rather than, as more recently introduced shareholders wished, retail, operations. In about August 2002, Mr Matthew Perrin, who was CEO of BBG at the time, sold a large block of BBG shares. This was controversial and caused a fall in BBG’s share price. Mr Perrin eventually stood down as CEO of BBG because of these events. As at 1 March 2006, the Merchant Group, via Gordon Merchant No. 2 Pty Ltd (GM2) as trustee for the Merchant Family Trust (MFT), an entity controlled by Mr Merchant, held about 25% of the issued capital in BBG. This was significantly more than the next largest shareholder. The Merchant Group shareholding of BBG Shares represented a large proportion of Mr Merchant’s wealth. He was concerned about having such wealth concentration in BBG shares. So he decided to sell down the Merchant Group’s BBG shareholding. To this end, on 1 March 2006, MFT sold 13,403,000 BBG shares to Citigroup Global Markets Australia Pty Ltd for total consideration of $199,838,730. After that sale, the Merchant Group held approximately 15% of the issued capital in BBG. That share parcel meant that the Merchant Group remained the largest single shareholder in BBG. Retention of that status was important to Mr Merchant both as a founder of BBG and for the influence it gave him in BBG.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established