Merchant v Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Merchant v Commissioner of Taxation [2024] FCA 498  

File number(s): NSD 907 of 2021
NSD 908 of 2021
NSD 1161 of 2021
Judgment of: THAWLEY J
Date of judgment: 14 May 2024
Catchwords:

TAXATION – s 177D in Part IVA of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) (ITAA 1936) – where tax benefit admitted – where only issue was dominant purpose under s 177D(1) to obtain admitted tax benefit – where vendor sells shares in listed company at market value to related entity such that there was no change in economic ownership – where sale of shares triggered capital loss – where sale occurred in context of predicted capital gains being made by vendor from sale of a company to a third party – held: dominant purpose was one of obtaining the admitted tax benefit

TAXATION – dispute as to market value of future earn-out amounts – market value determined in favour of applicant

TAXATION – s 177E in Part IVA of the ITAA 1936 – dividend stripping – where loans made by related entities to a company the shares in which were going to be sold – whether the loan forgiveness had substantially the effect of a scheme by way of or in the nature of dividend stripping – proper identification of the scheme for the purposes of s 177E – whether consequences of the application of the general anti-avoidance provision taken into account in determining application of s 177E to a related assessment – held: scheme had the effect of a scheme by way of or in the nature of dividend stripping within s 177E(1)(a)(ii)

TAXATION – taxation of financial arrangements (TOFA) – whether certain future payment amounts were financial arrangements under subsection 230-45(1) of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) (ITAA 1997) – if they were, whether future payment rights were excluded by former section 230-460(13) ITAA 1997 – held future earn-out rights were separate financial arrangements, but exception applies

Legislation:

Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) Division 6, Part IVA, ss 44, 177A, s 177CB, 177D, 177E, 177F

Income Tax Administration Act 1997 (Cth) Division 230, ss 110-25, 116-20, 207-155, 230-45(1), 230-50, 230-460(13), 775-30, 974-85

Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1993 (Cth) ss 34, 62, 65, 126A

Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) Part IVC, ss 14ZZ, 14ZZO, 353-10

Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Regulations 1994 (Cth) r 4.09(2)

Cases cited:

B&F Investments Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation [2023] FCAFC 89; 298 FCR 449

BBlood Enterprises Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation [2022] FCA 1112

British American Tobacco Australia Services Limited v Commissioner of Taxation [2010] FCAFC 130; 189 FCR 151

Certain Lloyd’s Underwriters v Cross [2012] HCA 56; 248 CLR 378

CEU22 v Minister for Home Affairs [2024] FCAFC 11

Collis v Commissioner of Taxation (1996) 33 ATR 438

Commissioner of Taxation v Ashwick (Qld) No 127 Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 49; 192 FCR 325

Commissioner of Taxation v Consolidated Press Holdings Ltd (No 1)

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Merchant v Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 498
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Gordon Merchant and the Gordon Merchant Family Trust (MFT) have appealed against the Commissioner of Taxation's disallowance of objections to assessments that were issued in connection with tax consequences of the acquisition of shares in Billabong Global Group (BBG) and Plantic, as well as the Commissioner's decision to disqualify Mr Merchant from acting as a trustee of superannuation entities. The Commissioner disallowed objections on the basis that the transactions in question constituted a scheme that had the dominant purpose of obtaining a tax benefit and that the transactions amounted to dividend stripping. The Commissioner also disallowed objections to an assessment arising from the application of the taxation of financial arrangements provisions in the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (ITAA 1997). The Commissioner also disqualified Mr Merchant as a trustee of superannuation entities on the basis that he had directed contraventions of the Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1993 (SISA) by using the resources of the Gordon Merchant Superannuation Fund (GMSF) to acquire BBG shares. The central issue in this case was whether the dominant purpose of the transactions in question was to obtain a tax benefit. The Commissioner argued that the transactions constituted a scheme that had the dominant purpose of obtaining a tax benefit, while the applicants argued that the dominant purpose of the transactions was to obtain investment opportunities. The court considered the evidence and submissions of both parties and concluded that the dominant purpose of the transactions was to obtain a tax benefit. The court also considered whether the transactions amounted to dividend stripping and whether the future earn-out rights were financial arrangements under the ITAA 1997. The court found that the transactions amounted to dividend stripping and that the future earn-out rights were financial arrangements, but that an exception applied.

The court dismissed the appeals in relation to the disallowance of objections to the assessments, finding that the dominant purpose of the transactions was to obtain a tax benefit. The court also found that the transactions amounted to dividend stripping and that the future earn-out rights were financial arrangements, but that an exception applied. The court upheld the appeal in relation to the disqualification decision, finding that the Commissioner had not established that Mr Merchant had directed contraventions of the SISA. The court ordered that the parties confer and provide a minute of order giving effect to the reasons and any agreement as to costs within 14 days.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The parties are to confer and provide a short minute of order giving effect to these reasons and any agreement as to costs within 14 days.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

As described below, the MFT ultimately came to hold all of the shares in Plantic.3 THE FACTS What follows is a chronological outline of all of the facts. A number of these facts are repeated later in these reasons, and in some cases expanded upon, where particularly relevant to an issue. This results in some repetition, but it is convenient before addressing the legal issues to understand the facts in some detail and chronologically. Billabong: 1973 to 2000 Mr Merchant and his then spouse Rena started a business manufacturing surf-wear in 1973. It began with them making around 20 pairs of boardshorts per week on their kitchen table. It grew to become the globally recognised surf-wear brand, Billabong. There were significant changes in the ownership of the Billabong business over the years. Initially, Mr Merchant and Rena each owned half of the business. In June 1999, the majority of Rena’s interests were acquired by outside investors (the Perrin family), but a small part was sold to Mr Merchant so that Mr Merchant maintained overall control. BBG was listed on the ASX in August 2000. Immediately after BBG was listed, the Merchant Group (through the MFT and GSM) owned approximately 23% of the issued capital in BBG. Mr Merchant remained on the board as a non-executive director. Ms Paull was also a director until January 2014: T57.The MFT acquires further shares in BBG: 2004 In September 2004, the MFT and GSM acquired further shares in BBG, resulting in the Merchant Group holding approximately 25% of the issued capital. By the end of the 2005 income year, it held approximately 21%. There were only two other shareholders who held over 10% of the issued capital. The MFT acquires 14% of Plantic The MFT acquired 14% of the issued capital in Plantic on 31 March 2005 and Mr Merchant was appointed a director: Merchant at [72]. The Plantic business came to Mr Merchant’s attention by way of his investment advisor, Mr McGrath. Mr Merchant had been looking for his next project after he had ceased day to day involvement in BBG: Merchant at [70]. When Mr Merchant became involved with Plantic, it was in the process of commercialising its technology: Morris at [8]. Over time, Plantic developed a number of different products and also developed different techniques to manufacture those products in a more cost effective way: Morris at [9]. It was researching and developing various types of products that could be manufactured using the technology, building the plant and equipment required to produce the products at scale, and developing relationships with customers and others in the packaging industry, with a view to increasing its sales revenue so as to become profitable. The MFT sells BBG shares: 2006 On 1 March 2006, the MFT sold 13,403,000 BBG shares for about $200 million, leaving the Merchant Group with approximately 15% of the issued capital in BBG. Mr Merchant remained the largest shareholder. The proceeds were invested by the MFT over time. Mr Merchant said that he was “reprimanded” in connection with this sale by BBG’s chairman: Merchant at [75]. The chairman was not happy that Mr Merchant had not told the chairman that he intended to sell the shares before he did so. Mr Merchant stated that this made him cautious about BBG management and about board members selling BBG shares. The GMSF established on 30 June 2006

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The proceedings in the Supreme Court of Queensland concern the advice given by EY. Those proceedings have been stayed until 40 days after judgment is delivered in these proceedings and a decision is made in the AAT proceedings: Merchant v Ernst & Young (a firm) [2023] QSC 259. Evidence, submissions and definitions Each of the parties to the Federal Court proceedings and the AAT proceedings wanted the proceedings to be heard together with evidence in the Federal Court proceedings being evidence in the AAT proceedings and (subject to limited exceptions) vice versa. This approach was followed, it being conducive both to a significant reduction in costs for the parties and to the more expeditious determination of the various proceedings. The documentary evidence was almost entirely contained in Exhibit 1, being the Court Book. The references in these reasons to “CB” followed by a number are a reference to the relevant tab number of the Court Book. Subject to two qualifications, the evidence from witnesses was given by affidavit. The first qualification is that the Court Book contained two statutory declarations, one from Mr Merchant and one from Ms Paull: CB442 and CB443. The second qualification is that the Court Book contained transcripts of various interviews conducted by the Commissioner pursuant to s 353-10 of Sch 1 to the TAA 1953. The references in these reasons to the relevant affidavits are provided by stating the name of the deponent and the relevant paragraph number of the affidavit. Only two lay witnesses were ultimately required for cross-examination: Mr Merchant and Mr McGrath. In these reasons, the following references are adopted: ·“AOS” is a reference to the applicants’ written opening submissions; ·“ROS” is a reference to the respondent’s written opening submissions; ·“AOCS” is a reference to the applicants’ written outline of oral closing submissions; ·“T” is a reference to the transcript;·“NA” is a reference to the relevant notice of appeal; ·“AFAAS” is a reference to the applicants’ further amended appeal statement, lodged on 19 March 2024; and ·“RAJAS” is a reference to the respondent’s amended joint appeal statement, lodged on 15 March 2024. These reasons concern the three Federal Court proceedings. 2 THE PRINCIPAL PEOPLE INVOLVED IN RELEVANT EVENTSMr Merchant As noted earlier, Mr Merchant was the founder of the Billabong business and the owner of the Merchant Group. His involvement in the relevant events is addressed in detail below. Mr Merchant was cross-examined. His recall of the detail of the relevant events during cross-examination was not good. This was in stark contrast to his detailed affidavit and his statutory declaration. Ms Paull Mr Merchant was assisted for many years in the day-to-day management of various entities in the Merchant Group, including the GMSF, by Ms Colette Paull. Ms Paull initially did part-time bookkeeping work, but her role expanded and she became a close and trusted colleague and friend of Mr Merchant. At the time of the relevant events, Mr Merchant and Ms Paull spoke regularly, typically on a daily basis.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Commissioner disallowed this objection on 10 September 2021 (the TOFA Objection Decision). Secondly, on 21 July 2020, the Commissioner – as regulator under the Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1993 (Cth) (SISA) – made a decision under ss 126A(2) and 126A(3) of the SISA to disqualify Mr Merchant from acting as a trustee or responsible officer of corporate trustees of superannuation entities (Disqualification Decision). Mr Merchant was a director of GSMS, being the trustee of the GSMF at all material times, including at the time of the BBG Share Sale on 4 September 2014. In summary, the Commissioner has taken the view that:(a)GSMS (as trustee of the GMSF), in using the GMSF’s resources to acquire the BBG Shares from the MFT on 4 September 2014, contravened:(i)the requirement to comply with operating standards under s 34(1) of the SISA, in particular to give effect to the investment strategy formulated under sub-reg 4.09(2) of the Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Regulations 1994 (Cth) (SISR);(ii)the sole purpose rule in s 62(1) of the SISA; and(iii)section 65(1) of the SISA, by using the resources of the fund to give financial assistance to a member of the fund or his relatives.(b)The contraventions were serious and made at the direction of the guiding mind and responsible officer of GSMS, namely Mr Merchant.The related proceedings The events summarised above have ultimately resulted in proceedings in this Court, in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) and in the Supreme Court of Queensland. There are three proceedings in this Court, each of which is a proceeding under Part IVC of the TAA 1953 in which the relevant person or entity appeals the decision of the Commissioner to disallow an objection to an assessment and each of which is the subject of these reasons for decision:(1)GSM Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (NSD 908/2021): GSM’s appeal from the objection decision which relates to the assessment arising from the cancelling of the capital loss in the MFT in reliance on s 177D(1) applying in respect of a person who entered into or carried out a scheme (the s 177D Proceeding);(2)Gordon Merchant v Commissioner of Taxation (NSD 907/2021): Mr Merchant’s appeal from the objection decision which relates to the assessment arising from the Commissioner’s conclusion that s 177E(1)(a)(ii) applied (the 177E Proceeding); and(3)Gordon Merchant v Commissioner of Taxation (NSD 1161/2021): Mr Merchant’s appeal concerning the applicability of the TOFA Provisions (the TOFA Proceeding). There are three proceedings in the AAT:(1)Gordon Merchant No 2 Pty Ltd as trustee for Merchant Family Trust v Commissioner of Taxation (AAT Case 2021/6296): The Commissioner issued a notice of assessment of scheme shortfall penalties to GM2 as trustee of the MFT for 50% of a scheme shortfall of $12,877,000.90, being $6,438,500.45. This proceeding is GM2’s application for “review” of the Commissioner’s disallowance of its objection.(2)Gordon Merchant v Commissioner of Taxation (AAT Case 2021/6294): The Commissioner issued a notice of assessment of scheme shortfall penalties to Mr Merchant in connection with the s 177E assessment. Mr Merchant was assessed as having a scheme shortfall of $26,659,429.97 and was assessed to a 25% penalty, being $6,664,857.24. This proceeding is Mr Merchant’s application for “review” of the Commissioner’s disallowance of his objection.(3)Gordon Merchant v Commissioner of Taxation (AAT Case 2020/6932): This is Mr Merchant’s application for review of the Disqualification Decision.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The GMSF did not take up an entitlement in the offer: Merchant at [135]. The GMSF General Ledger for the year end 30 June 2013 records that the GMSF acquired BBG shares by four payments totalling $2,176,000 on 13 and 16 July 2012 and received a refund in relation to those shares on 2 August 2012: CB590. Mr Merchant was taken to these entries but it did not assist his recollection about why the GMSF did not acquire shares: T80-81.Consideration given to accessing cash from the GMSF: July 2012 On 20 July 2012, Mr McGrath sent an email to Mr Burgess which relevantly stated (CB106):Gordon just rang about getting some of the cash out of the Super Fund when the redemption of the MSSits money comes through at the end of September / beginning of OctoberIt should be around US$7.4m or so and I was wondering if it was possible for Gordon to retire from a position at that point and turn the Fund into pension phase and withdraw a lump sum?The idea would be to pay down part of the margin loan with NAB with the proceedsCould you please advise your thoughts? Mr Merchant stated that he did not recall the conversation referred to by Mr McGrath in this email: Merchant at [144]. The reference to “MSSits” is a reference to the Macquarie Special Situations Fund (MSSF): Merchant at [144]. Mr Burgess replied the same day stating:Luke, there are no restrictions on Gordon accessing the funds in the super given he is over age 65. He could take it either as a tax free lump sum or tax free pension – I think we did start him on a pension so that would probably be the form) – another option which might be preferable and which I have discussed with Sue is to have the fund acquire some of the BBG shares from MFT (fund is able to acquire these as listed shares) – in this way the ‘value’ stays protected in the concessionally taxed super environment. I will give you a call to discuss a little later. Mr Merchant stated that he did not recall any discussion with Mr McGrath about Mr Burgess’ response: Merchant at [144]. Plantic negotiations: July and August 2012 In July 2012, Winpak Ltd and Bemis Company, Inc expressed interest in the possibility of equity participation in Plantic: Merchant at [145]. In August 2012, Kuraray expressed interest in potential cooperation with Plantic: Merchant at [146]. By January 2013, discussions with Bemis turned to potential exclusive technology license agreements: Merchant at [166]. Consideration to GMSF acquiring BBG shares: October 2012 In around October 2012, Mr Merchant became aware that a consortium involving a former BBG director, Mr Paul Naude, was looking to announce an offer to acquire BBG shares: Merchant at [159]. TPG had earlier (on 24 July 2012) announced a proposal to acquire all of BBG’s shares for $1.45 per share. Mr Merchant gave evidence that he did not believe that this correctly reflected BBG’s value: Merchant at [153]. On 14 October 2012 at 4.51pm Mr Merchant emailed Ms Paull asking: “Do you know if I’m able to buy BBG shares using funds in my super fund?”: CB115. Ms Paull replied at 9.36pm stating:Yes, you can, and you have around $2 mil that you could use, we have to keep some in there.The $15 mil won’t be in the account until early November.Our trading window looks like it will be open until December, so that might still be o.k. but you wouldn’t want to use it all for BBG shares as it wouldn’t leave you any if things go pear shaped.