Calder v FCT

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Calder v Commissioner of Taxation [2005] FCAFC 254

TAXATION –  income tax – deductions - tax avoidance – Tea Tree oil plantation scheme – interlocking agreements – Farm Management and Loan Agreements – limited recourse loan – management fees, interest and associated costs – whether taxpayer to be treated as having dominant purpose of obtaining a tax benefit – objective assessment – relevance of commercial purposes – factors to be considered – primary facts largely undisputed – challenge to trial judge’s evaluation on whether factors indicated purpose of obtaining tax benefit – role of appellate court – no error disclosed on part of trial judge – appeal dismissed

Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) s 177

Calder v Commissioner of Taxation [2005] FCA 911 cited
Commissioner of Taxation v Cooke (2004) 55 ATR 183 cited
Commissioner of taxation v Sleight (2004) 136 FCR 211 cited
Poulet Frais Pty Ltd v The Silver Fox Company Pty Ltd (2005) 220 ALR 211 cited
Branir Pty Ltd v Owston Nominees (No 2) Pty Ltd (2001) 117 FCR 424 cited
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Peabody (1994) 181 CLR 359 cited
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Spotless Services Ltd (1996) 186 CLR 404 cited
Peabody v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1993) 40 FCR 531 cited
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Hart (2004) 217 CLR 216 cited
CC(NSW) Pty Ltd (In liq) v Commissioner of Taxation (Cth) (1997) ATC 4123 cited
Eastern Nitrogen Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (2001) 108 FCR 27 cited

MICHAEL CALDER v COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION
WAD 181 OF 2005

FRENCH, STONE AND SIOPIS JJ

7 DECEMBER 2005
PERTH

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

WAD181 OF 2005

On Appeal from a Single Judge of the Federal Court of Australia

BETWEEN:

MICHAEL CALDER
APPELLANT

AND:

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION
RESPONDENT

JUDGES:

FRENCH, STONE AND SIOPIS JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

7 DECEMBER 2005

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.        The appeal be dismissed.

2.        The appellant pay the respondent’s costs of the appeal.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

WAD181 OF 2005

On Appeal from a Single Judge of the Federal Court of Australia

BETWEEN:

MICHAEL CALDER
APPELLANT

AND:

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION
RESPONDENT

JUDGES:

FRENCH, STONE AND SIOPIS JJ

DATE:

7 DECEMBER 2005

PLACE:

PERTH

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

THE COURT:
Introduction

  1. In June 1994 Michael and Rosemary Calder invested in a Tea Tree oil plantation project at Rappville, near Casino in New South Wales.  Their investment involved the acquisition of seeds for 10,000 trees to be grown and managed in common with trees acquired by other investors for the purpose of producing and selling Tea Tree oil.  They entered into a Farm Agreement with the Land Owner for the use of the land on which their trees would be planted, a Management Agreement with another entity to manage their interest in the Farm…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Calder v FCT and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] FCAFC 254
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Calder v FCT involved Michael Calder, who appealed against a decision of the primary judge concerning the applicability of Part IVA of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) to certain deductions he claimed. The primary issue before the court was whether the Tea Tree oil project constituted a scheme under Part IVA, which could be used to deny tax benefits otherwise allowable. The court had to determine whether the primary judge's evaluation of the facts and the applicability of Part IVA was correct.

The court reviewed the evidence and found that the primary judge's evaluation of the relevant factors to determine whether the Tea Tree oil project was a scheme under Part IVA was valid and did not disclose any error. The court emphasised that in cases where the primary judge's evaluation is based on undisputed facts, the court will give significant weight to that evaluation and will only interfere if the primary judge is shown to be incorrect. The court considered the nature of the Tea Tree oil project, the agreements involved, and the economic viability of the project. The court found that the primary judge had appropriately considered the evidence and the statutory framework in reaching his conclusion.

The court held that the primary judge's evaluation of the factors relevant to whether the Tea Tree oil project was a scheme under Part IVA was open to him on the facts before him and did not disclose error. Therefore, the appeal should be dismissed, and the appellant should pay the respondent's costs of the appeal. The court's decision affirmed the primary judge's findings and maintained the status quo concerning the tax benefits claimed by Michael Calder.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed.

2. The appellant pay the respondent’s costs of the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

The appeal to this Court is largely by way of a challenge to evaluative findings made by the learned primary judge on undisputed primary facts. In such a case the Court will give weight to the primary judge’s evaluation of the facts and will not interfere with such assessment unless the primary judge is shown to be wrong. For the reasons that follow, the primary judge’s evaluation of the factors relevant to whether the Tea Tree oil project was a scheme to which Pt IVA applied was open on the facts before him and does not disclose error. The appeal should be dismissed with costs.Factual Background Michael Calder served in the Royal Australian Navy from 31 January 1945 until 1 February 1982 when he retired. He served mainly as a hydrographer. Following his retirement he and his wife set up a business together teaching offshore sailing and navigation. He also acted as a consultant on hydrographic matters. In March 1994 Mr Calder and his wife sold a yacht which they owned. They decided to invest the proceeds to provide additional income in their retirement. They were already what Mr Calder described as ‘long term investors in Australian shares’. While considering a range of possible investments Mr Calder saw a newspaper advertisement for a Tea Tree oil investment project. He obtained a copy of a prospectus for what was described as the ‘Main Camp Tea Tree Oil Project No 3’. It was dated 20 April 1994. Main Camp was described in the prospectus as ‘a large rural holding at Rappville near Casino, in Northern New South Wales’. The prospectus proposed the establishment of a commercial Tea Tree plantation on the property. The object of the project would be ‘to capitalise on the demand for Tea Tree oil both domestically and internationally’. The prospectus offered investors what it described as ‘a prescribed interest in Main Camp Tea Tree Oil Project No 3’. In a Basic Information page it explained that the investors would ‘… engage in the business of growing Tea Trees on land at Rappville near Casino, NSW for a period of 15 years unless the relevant agreements are terminated earlier.’ The ‘relevant agreements’ were identified. Each investor would enter into a Farm Agreement with the Land Owner and would engage a manager, under the terms of a Management Agreement, to manage the investor’s interest in the farm business for 15 years. Management fees would be payable in the amount of $27,000 for year one, reducing to $23,450 if a prepayment were made. Year 1 fees could be borrowed under a Loan Agreement from an entity designated the ‘Lender’. Management fees for year two would be $3,133, discounted to $2,725 if prepaid, plus a production fee of $12.50 per kilogram of oil produced. The fixed fee component could be borrowed under the Loan Agreement. Management fees for years 3 to 15 would be paid out of the proceeds of Tea Tree oil. If the proceeds were insufficient the unpaid fees would accrue, but the manager would have no recourse against the investors personally for those fees.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Loan Agreement was between the Lender and the Borrower named in the Principal Agreement and provided as follows: (a)the Lender advanced to the Borrower the Principal Sum referred to in the Principal Agreement and being: (i)$23,500 per Farm in Year 1; (ii)$2,775 per Farm in Year 2.(b)the term of the loan was eight years from the date of the Loan Agreement and deemed to commence on 30 June 1994 for the purpose of calculating principal and interest; (c)as consideration for the Lender discounting the interest rate by 2 per cent per annum, the Borrower agreed to pay upon execution of the Loan Agreement the first year’s interest at the rate of 15 per cent per annum; (d)as consideration for the Lender reducing the rate of interest during the second year of the Loan Agreement to 12.66 per cent, the Borrower agreed to pay the Lender on 30 June 1995 interest for 12 months in advance on the principal then outstanding; (e)as consideration for the Lender reducing the rate from and including year 3 onwards to 6.5 per cent per annum, the Borrower agreed to pay the Lender interest monthly in advance on the principal sum outstanding subject to such payment being due from the sale of oil and payable from the income there from after payment of all farm fees and all management fees and charges; (f)the Borrower was to make one principal repayment to the Lender on 1 October 1994 of $8,500 per Farm; (g)the balance of the principal sum and interest was to be repaid to the Lender by direct deduction from the income from the business (as defined) and by executing the Loan Agreement the Borrower authorised the Manager to pay the Lender all such monies; (h)the Borrower could elect to have the income of the Farmer available for repayment of principal calculated as either:(A)the balance of the gross income of the farm (a term not defined in the Loan Agreement) after payment in order of priority of all farm fees, all management fees and interest due and payable; or (B)$250 plus 50 per cent of the balance of the gross income of the farm (a term not defined in the Loan Agreement), after payment in order of priority of all farm fees, all management fees and interest due and payable.(i)subject to the Borrower making the specified principal and interest payments by the due dates and performing his obligations under the Farm Agreement, the Borrower would have no other liability for payment of the balance of the principal sum or interest thereon other than out of the income from the Project, provided that should the Borrower’s income from the Project be insufficient to pay the principal sum and interest by the expiration of eight years from the date of the Loan Agreement then the term of the loan was to be extended for no more than 15 years from the date of the Loan Agreement until the principal and interest is paid from such income; (j)at the expiry of 15 years from the date of the Loan Agreement, the Loan Agreement and the Borrower’s obligations to repay any outstanding principal and interest were to cease; (k)the Borrower authorised the Lender to remit the Principal Sum to the Trustee to be applied by the Trustee towards the obligation of the Borrower to pay management fees and farm fees, and the Lender irrevocably agreed to remit such funds in satisfaction of the Borrower’s obligations under the Farm Agreement and the Management Agreement.The Evidence before the Trial Judge

Decision

Reasons for decision

In cross-examination Mr Langridge said he did not review ‘in enormous detail’ the material annexed to Mr McClymont’s affidavit dealing with expert views as to future markets for Tea Tree oil. Nor did he consider the other material annexed to that affidavit. He said he was not required to give an expert opinion in terms of overall price and yield. That was outside his expertise. As to projected price increases for Tea Tree oil from 1994 onwards, he agreed that his evidence on that point was that, based simply on the material in the prospectus, it was possible that at some time in the future supply might equal demand or exceed it. Equally it was possible, based on material in the prospectus, that in the 15 year life of the Project the supply might fall uncomfortably short of demand. He agreed that his experience as an accountant did not extend to forecasting commodity prices but said it did extend to an understanding of the economics of supply, demand and pricing in a general sense. The Reasons for Judgment of the Learned Primary Judge After reviewing the factual background, the relevant agreements and identifying the statutory framework, the learned primary judge observed that Pt IVA of the ITAA can only apply to disallow deductions otherwise allowable. However the Commissioner did not concede that the deductions claimed by Mr Calder were allowable. The essence of the Commissioner’s submission to his Honour was that the expenses were not incurred in gaining or producing assessable income or necessarily incurred in carrying on a business for the purpose of gaining or producing such income. He submitted this was the case because the purpose of the expenditure was to obtain a tax advantage. The Commissioner contended that although the amounts incurred as expenses were, on their face, applied in payment of Project expenses they were, in reality, directed to obtaining a tax benefit and not for the purpose of actually funding the Project. Mr Calder came to the hearing on the assumption that the Commissioner was not challenging the proposition that the amounts in question were all allowable deductions. This was founded on the fact that the Commissioner was out of time for amending the assessments so as to disallow the claimed expenses under s 51(1) and had not previously done so. Mr Calder pointed out that if the Commissioner were correct in his preliminary submission and the expenses were not allowable deductions, there was no scope for the application of Pt IVA on which the bulk of the Commissioner’s case was based. The learned primary judge found that from the nature of each of the payments the prima facie position arose that they were allowable deductions. He was not satisfied that position had been rebutted by the Commissioner’s submissions. He therefore proceeded on the basis that the amounts paid were allowable. His Honour then considered the application of Pt IVA of the ITAA to the claimed deductions. He discussed the proper approach to the application of s 177D. It was common ground that the making and implementation of the prospectus, the Principal Agreement, the Farm Agreement, the Management Agreement, the Loan Agreement and the Investment Deed constituted a scheme within the meaning of s 177A(1) of the ITAA. The Commissioner had formulated alternative schemes in terms set out by his Honour. Mr Calder conceded that it was possible to frame those alternative schemes but denied that he could be said to have obtained tax benefits in connection with either of them in the relevant years. His Honour said that he would consider the alternative schemes should it prove necessary to do so.