Tolich v Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Tolich v Commissioner of Taxation [2007] FCA 1195

TAXATION – avoidance of tax – tax benefit under Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) – where applicants entered into a schemes as defined in s 177A(1) of the Act – where schemes incurred substantial losses and outgoings which were claimed as deductions – whether losses and outgoings fall within s 51(1) of the Act – where schemes operated in part in overseas territories – whether losses and outgoings with respect to overseas territories within s 79D of the Act – whether Part IVA of the Act applies to claimed deductions with respect to losses and outgoings insofar as they relate to overseas territories – whether Part IVA of the Act applies generally to deductions claimed in respect of losses and outgoings of schemes – whether participants obtained tax benefits from schemes – where participants in schemes made some actual cash outlays – whether actual cash outlays claimed as deductions should not be disallowed in any event – whether schemes entered into for dominant purpose of obtaining tax benefit – approach to s 177D(b).

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – where six proceedings before Court – where proceedings arise from same factual matrix – where substantial common issues between proceedings – whether appropriate to hear matters together.

Held: appropriate for matters to be heard together – deductions for losses and outgoings with respect to overseas territories not reduced by s 79D of the Act – Part IVA applicable to schemes – participants obtained tax benefits – to the extent that participants in schemes made actual cash outlays deductions should not be disallowed – schemes entered into and carried out for dominant purpose of obtaining tax benefit.

Bills of Exchange Act 1909 (Cth) s 21
Export Market Development Grants Act 1974 (Cth)
Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) ss 51, 79D, 177D, 177F
Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) s 14ZZ

Australian Trade Commission v Disktravel [1999] FCA 48 considered
Australian Trade Commission v Disktravel (1999) 91 FCR 374 considered
Calder v Commissioner of Taxation (2005) 226 ALR 643 cited
Commissioner of Taxation v Consolidated Press Holdings Ltd (2001) 207 CLR 235 cited
Commissioner of Taxation v Cooke (2004) 55 ATR 183 cited
Commissioner of Taxation v Hart (2004) 217 CLR 216 cited
Commissioner of Taxation v Sleight (2004) 136 FCR 211 considered
Equuscorp Pty Ltd v Glengallan Investments Pty Ltd (2004) 218 CLR 471 cited
Esquire Nominees Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1973) 129 CLR 177 considered
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v French (1957) 98 CLR 398 considered
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Mitchum (1965) 113 CLR 401 cited

Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Spotless Services Ltd (1996) 186 CLR 404 cited
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v United Aircraft Corporation (1943) 68 CLR 525 considered
Nathan v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1918) 25 CLR 183 considered
Peabody v Commissioner of Taxation (1993) 40 FCR 531 cited
Travel Vision International Pty Ltd and Australian Trade Commission AAT No 12540 [1988] AATA…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tolich v Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] FCA 1195
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Tolich v Commissioner of Taxation, the applicants, including Mr Tolich and others, sought to appeal decisions made by the Commissioner of Taxation regarding disallowed deductions under section 177F(1)(b) of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth). These disallowed deductions pertained to their investments in the Travel Vision Projects, which involved the promotion and sale of a Travel Vision system. The applicants argued that the Commissioner had wrongly disallowed their deductions. The legal issues before the court included whether Part IVA of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 applied to the schemes, and if so, whether the deductions were rightly disallowed. The court had to determine the extent to which the applicants were entitled to claim the deductions, given the application of Part IVA.

The court found that Part IVA did apply to each of the schemes. The reasoning was that the schemes resulted in substantial deductions in excess of the funds actually contributed by the applicants, indicating a dominant tax purpose. The court noted that while the applicants stood to benefit from the tax benefits of their continued involvement, the financial projections for the start-up business were not going to be achieved, and the only benefits that would be received were tax benefits. The court concluded that the deductions were rightly disallowed, except to the extent they were reflected by actual cash outlays. The actual cash outlays were identified as $650,000 for the CECK partnership in the 1994 financial year, $232,500 for the applicants other than Mr Sleight in the 1996 financial year, and $155,000 for Mr Sleight in the 1996 financial year.

The court further heard the parties on the actual cash outlays in the 1995 financial year and allowed them to bring in minutes of order reflecting the conclusions expressed in the reasons. The court's decision provided clarity on the application of Part IVA to the schemes and the extent to which the applicants were entitled to claim deductions, subject to the actual cash outlays.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

There are six proceedings in this Court and each proceeding is an appeal under s 14ZZ(a) of the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) (“Administration Act”) against an appealable objection decision made by the Commissioner of Taxation of the Commonwealth of Australia. The Commissioner is the respondent in each proceeding.Background In each proceeding the applicant claims that deductions were wrongly disallowed by the respondent under s 177F(1)(b) of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) (“ITAA 1936”). The details in relation to each applicant are as follows: Mr Dorn made a similar claim to that made by Mr Tolich, Mr Domenic Princi and Mr Vincenzo Princi in relation to the financial year ended 30 June 1996, but his challenge to the respondent’s decision in relation to that claim is not before me. I was told that Mr Dorn has made an application in relation to that year to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. Mr Prince did not claim a relevant deduction in the financial year ended 30 June 1996 and Mr Sleight made a claim for a relevant deduction only in that year. The “applicants” in relation to the financial year ended 30 June 1994 (“1994 FY”) means Mr Tolich, Mr Vincenzo Princi, Mr Dorn, Mr Domenic Princi and Mr Prince. Those persons were members of the CECK partnership. The “applicants” in relation to the financial year ended 30 June 1995 (“1995 FY”) means the same persons. The “applicants” in relation to the financial year ended 30 June 1996 (“1996 FY”) means Mr Tolich, Mr Vincenzo Princi, Mr Domenic Princi and Mr Sleight. A company called Civil and Earthmoving Contractors of Kwinana Pty Ltd (“Civil and Earth”) was a member of the TVA partnership and Mr Tolich, Mr Vincenzo Princi and Mr Domenic Princi were beneficiaries under a trust declared by Civil and Earth. Mr Sleight was a member of the TVA partnership. On occasions it will be necessary for me to refer to him separately from the other applicants in relation to the 1996 FY. Mr Tolich, Mr Domenic Princi, Mr Dorn and Mr Vincenzo Princi were the owners and operators of Civil and Earth. The company provided earthmoving and associated services to the construction and earthmoving industry. Mr Allen Prince was the company’s accountant. Mr Sleight was a financial or investment adviser and he had dealings with the owners and operators of Civil and Earth and with Mr Prince. The deductions claimed by each applicant relate to their investment in projects which were referred to in the evidence as the Travel Vision Projects. The Projects concerned the promotion and sale of the Travel Vision system. That system involved the electronic storage on CD-ROMs of travel information such as holiday destinations, accommodation prices and so on, and the provision of that information to travel agents. The fact that the information was stored electronically was said to mean that information as to matters such as price could be changed far more quickly and at a lesser cost than in the case of the printed brochure. The success of the system was said to depend on a sufficient number of advertisers advertising on the system and a sufficient number of travel agents using the system. The system was to be promoted and sold within Australia and overseas.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

BESANKO J
As I have said, the actual cash outlays were as follows:CECK partnership in the 1994 FY $650,000 TVA partnership in the 1996 FY $232,500 Mr Sleight in the 1996 FY $155,000I will hear the parties further on the actual cash outlays in the 1995 FY.Conclusions The respondent was right to conclude that Part IVA of the ITAA 1936 applied to each of the schemes. The deductions were rightly disallowed, save and except to the extent they were reflected by actual cash outlays. The actual cash outlays in the 1994 FY totalled $650,000 and, in the case of the applicants other than Mr Sleight in the 1996 FY totalled $232,500 and, in the case of Mr Sleight in the 1996 FY totalled $155,000. I will hear the parties further on the actual cash outlays in the 1995 FY. Otherwise the parties are at liberty to bring in minutes of order reflecting the conclusions expressed in these reasons.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BESANKO J

The reason the licence agreements were only for one year with options to extend is unclear, particularly when the large borrowing obligations undertaken by the applicants are considered. However, those obligations were somewhat illusory. Once the applicants had made their cash contributions, any further liability was limited to their share of the revenue of the venture. The non-renewal or extension of the licences left the promoters in the same position they were in before the licences had been granted to the applicants.Section 177D(b)(iv) – the result in relation to the operation of this Act that, but for this Part, would be achieved by the scheme The result that would be achieved by the schemes but for Part IVA is that each of the applicants would be entitled to substantial deductions in excess of funds actually contributed by them. That points to a dominant tax purpose: Sleight at 234 [84] per Hill J. However, it must be borne in mind that simply because a taxpayer pays less tax if one form of transaction rather than another is made does not demonstrate that Part IVA applies: Hart at 240 [53] per Gummow and Hayne JJ.Section 177D(b)(v) – any change in the financial position of the relevant taxpayer that has resulted, will result, or may reasonably be expected to result, from the scheme It should be noted that, in relation to the activities of the CECK partnership in the 1994 FY and the 1995 FY, Civil and Earth, which owned 54 per cent of the partnership, would have benefited and, through their ownership of Civil and Earth, the applicants (other than Mr Prince) would also have benefited. Subject to one qualification, the applicants received no sub-licence fees or advertising revenue as a result of their involvement in the TVI Project or the TVA Project. The one qualification is the receipt by the CECK partnership in the 1996 FY of a sub-licence fee. As I have said, the CECK partnership also received a development grant which it declared as income in the 1995 FY. After time passed, it became clear that the only benefit which would be received by investors in the schemes were tax benefits. The losses were mounting. Once the TVA partnership had entered into the scheme in the 1996 FY the losses totalled $5,942,000. By some time in late 1995 (if not before) it must have been clear that the financial projections for what was a start-up business were not going to be achieved and it seems to me that the applicants’ continued involvement in the Projects can only be explained by the fact that as a result of the tax benefits their respective cash positions were significantly improved. Furthermore, even if the Projects generated commercial returns, it is difficult to see how the applicants would greatly benefit from that fact. To take the 1994 FY as an example, any revenue payable to investors would be reduced as follows:1.For a licence, 5 per cent of the advertising royalty in year one and 12.5 per cent in subsequent years was to be paid to TVI.2.For a licence, 50 per cent of any initial (or up-front consideration) fee was to be paid to TVI.3.Under the management agreement, in addition to the specified fee, 20 per cent in year one and 40 per cent in subsequent years of “all gross income received or receivable by the licensee under the Advertising Agreements or otherwise in respect of the exploitation of the Software Program” was to be paid to Plutora.4.Under the Marketing Agreement, in addition to the specified fee, 30 per cent of all initial sub-licence fees received or receivable by the Licensee under any sub-licences was to be paid to Plutora.5.Under the limited recourse loan agreement, 50 per cent of all gross income receivable by the licensee from the exploitation of all the licences, after certain specified deductions, was to be paid to Plutora on an indefinite basis.Whilst it is true that some of these figures were reduced for the TVA partnership in the 1996 FY, it was still the case that even if the Projects had generated commercial returns it is difficult to see how the applicants would have greatly benefited from that fact.