Commissioner of Taxation v Cooke

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Commissioner of Taxation v Cooke [2004] FCAFC 75

INCOME TAX – prospectus issued by promoters of flower growing and export scheme of fifteen years duration – estimated annual financial returns for first 5 years of scheme projected in prospectus – prospectus provided that proceeds of subscriptions to scheme be applied partly in payment for so-called ‘growth bags’ or plantations partly in payment of license fees in respect of plantation sites and predominantly in payment of management fees – scheme plantation manager corporately related to scheme marketing manager – option to subscribers to obtain guaranteed return of $10,000 per plantation in relation to fifth financial year of scheme operations – option for guaranteed return exercisable at time of subscription for units – promoters procured irrevocable letter of credit from banking corporation to secure guaranteed returns – no reference to means or source of securing guaranteed returns to subscribers made in prospectus nor to that cost – security for guaranteed returns comprised prospectus subscriptions – expert evidence adduced as to horticultural viability of scheme accepted by primary judge – respondents professional persons not previously engaged in horticulture – respondents subscribed for units close to culmination of fiscal year of promotion – further subscription made by one taxpayer midway in following fiscal year – disallowance by Commissioner of entirety of deductions for license fees and management fees – proceedings at first instance contested by Commissioner upon basis as to unavailability of deductibility of entire license and management fees without apportionment in relation to cost of provision of guaranteed returns – claims at first instance contested by Commissioner on ‘all nor nothing’ basis – acceptance by primary judge of credibility of dominant purposes of taxpayers in entering into scheme – finding by primary judge that financial failure of scheme unrelated to prospective viability of scheme as at time of subscriptions of taxpayers – credibility and tax avoidance issues resolved at first instance wholly in favour of taxpayers – tax deductibility wholly allowed at first instance – appeal dismissed

Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 ss 51(1), 82KJ, 82KK, 82KL, 177

Clowes v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1954) 91 CLR 209

Colonial Mutual Life Assurance Society Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1953) 89 CLR 428

Commissioner of Inland Revenue v BNZ Investments Limited (2001) 20 NZTC 17

Commissioner of Taxation of the Commonwealth of Australia v Spotless Services Limited (1996) 186 CLR 404

Commissioner of Taxation v Emmakell Pty Ltd (1990) 22 FCR 157

Commissioner of Taxation v Lau (1984) 6 FCR 202

Commissioner of Taxationv South Australian Battery Makers Proprietary Limited (1978) 140 CLR 645

Eastern Nitrogen Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (2001) 108 FCR 27

Fairway Estates Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (1970) 123 CLR 153

Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Brand (1995) 95 ATC 4633

Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Consolidated Press Holdings Ltd (2001) 207 CLR 235

Ferguson v Commissioner of Taxation (1979) 37 FLR 310

Fletcher v Commissioner of Taxation (1991) 173 CLR 1

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commissioner of Taxation v Cooke and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] FCAFC 75
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal before the court involved the Commissioner of Taxation and two respondents, Mr Cooke and Mr Jamieson. The dispute centred on the disallowance by the Commissioner of objections raised by the respondents regarding their tax assessments for specific fiscal years. These objections pertained to the losses and expenses incurred by the respondents in relation to their involvement in the Australian Horticultural Project Number 1 (AHP No 1). The primary issues for the court to determine were whether the expenses claimed by the respondents were deductible under the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 and whether these expenses related to the carrying on of a business for the purpose of profit. Additionally, the court had to assess whether the respondents were carrying on a business in the fiscal years in question, and if so, whether the losses incurred were deductible under the Act.

The court examined the nature of the respondents' involvement in AHP No 1, the contractual agreements they had entered into, and the expenses they claimed as deductions. The primary judge had previously allowed the respondents' appeals against the disallowance of their objections, and the Commissioner was appealing this decision. The court reviewed the evidence presented, including expert testimony regarding the viability of the project and the reasonableness of the projected yields and production budgets. The court ultimately found that the respondents were not carrying on a business for the purpose of profit during the relevant fiscal years and, therefore, the expenses they incurred were not deductible under the Act.

Consequently, the appeals by the Commissioner were dismissed. The court ordered that the Commissioner pay the respondents' respective costs of the appeals. This decision underscores the importance of establishing that a taxpayer is carrying on a business for the purpose of profit to claim deductions under the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeals be dismissed.

2. The Appellant Commissioner pay the Respondents’ respective costs of the appeals.

Background

Background to the litigation

The appellant (‘the Commissioner’) appeals from judgments of the primary judge, given on 29 October 2002, whereby her Honour allowed appeals by the respective respondents against disallowance of their objections to notices of assessment issued by the Commissioner in respect of the fiscal years ended 30 June 1988 and 1989 in the case of Mr Cooke, and 30 June 1988 in the case of Mr Jamieson. The appeals concern the Commissioner’s treatment of losses and expenses incurred by the respondents pursuant to their participation in a project known as the Australian Horticultural Project Number 1 (‘AHP No 1’), promoted to the public by Growth Industries Pty Limited (‘Growth Industries’). The proceedings at first instance and the appeals were heard together. Background circumstances Information about AHP No 1 was set out in a prospectus dated 16 May 1988, which was lodged and registered with the Corporate Affairs Commission of New South Wales as delegate for the National Companies and Securities Commission. The prospectus offered to the public subscription in units in a unit trust known as the Australian Horticultural Trust Number 1 (‘the Trust’). The function and purpose of the Trust was said to be to use the funds subscribed pursuant to the prospectus on behalf of persons who wished to conduct a business of growing proteas and Australian native flowers for domestic and overseas consumption. The sum payable for a unit in the Trust was $10,000. The minimum subscription stipulated in the prospectus was 500 units. That was satisfied by 2,500 units being underwritten by well-known Australian stockbrokers. In fact approximately 3,314 units were subscribed. Of the sum payable for each unit in the Trust, $250 was to be paid to Growth Industries Management Limited (‘the Plantation Manager’), for what was described in the prospectus, firstly, as a ‘service fee’ and later as ‘establishment costs’. On an acquisition of units, an investor (called therein and hereafter a ‘Grower’) would enter into a plantation agreement, in the form annexed to the prospectus, with the Plantation Manager and the trustee of the Trust, namely A.T.A. Services Limited (called therein and hereafter ‘the Trustee’ and referred to in certain of the documentation as the ‘Grower’s Representative’). For that purpose, the application form for units contained a power of attorney in favour of each director of the Trustee to execute a plantation agreement on a Grower’s behalf. Clause 10 of the trust deed provided for the so-called redemption of the units, once the minimum subscription was attained. The sum of $9,750 payable on redemption of each unit was to be paid to the Plantation Manager on behalf of the Grower. AHP No 1 had an estimated life of 15 years. Projected returns per unit in the first five years of operation ending 30 June 1993 were set out in the prospectus as follows:On the basis of On the basis of 2,500 units 3,500 units1989$1,996 1989 $2,0061990$2,380 1990 $2,4221991$4,424 1991 $4,4661992$4,938 1992 $4,7991993$5,641 1993 $5,681These projected returns were based on assumptions set out in the prospectus.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The expenses or outgoings incurred pursuant to the plantation agreements and claimed by the respondents as deductions were as follows:(i) as to Mr Cooke in relation to the year ended 30 June 1988: (a) $425,475 for management fees; (b) $2,025 for licence fees; and (c) $2,250 for the guaranteed income return fee;(ii) as to Mr Cooke in relation to the year ended 30 June 1989: (a) $94,550 for management fees; (b) $450 for licence fees; and (c) $500 for the guaranteed return fee; and(iii) as to Mr Jamieson in relation to the year ended 30 June 1988: (a) $236,375 for management fees; (b) $1,125 for licence fees; and (c) $1,250 for the guaranteed return fee.On 20 February 1995 and 18 July 1995, by notices of amended assessments, the Commissioner disallowed Mr Cooke’s claims for management, licence and guaranteed return fees for the fiscal years ending 30 June 1988 and 30 June 1989, and on 9 March 1995 the Commissioner did likewise in relation to Mr Jamieson’s management, licence and guaranteed return fees for the fiscal year ended 30 June 1988.The expert evidence The expert evidence adduced at the hearing before the primary judge was given on behalf of the respondents, with the exception of evidence given by a Mr Geurtsen on behalf of the Commissioner. The first expert witness was Mr Flude, the managing director of the Trustee. He had qualifications in agricultural and biological sciences, and had long experience in consulting in agricultural management. Mr Flude established the Trustee in order to provide agricultural consultancy, production and management services. As summarised by the primary judge, he addressed the following matters in chief and under cross-examination:(i)the history of AHP No 1 and the difficulties the project encountered;(ii)the breakdown of the relationship between the Plantation Manager and VCAH, and the eventual appointment of a liquidator to Growth Industries in 1991;(iii)the agreed circumstance that the new technology involved in AHP No 1, including the use of growth bags, meant that the project involved risks beyond those affecting more conventional horticultural projects;(iv)it was not unusual to cultivate Australian natives and proteas, although cultivation for export was unusual; and(v)the scale of the project created risk, and expert opinion in Australia was divided as to the applicability to Australian conditions of the technology adopted for AHP No 1. The next expert witness was Mr Hunter, the Associate Director (Curriculum Business Development and Head of Department (Management Studies)) at the Dalby Agricultural College in Queensland. In 1988, he was the manager of Agri Valuers Australia, the technical consultant to AHP No 1, and he addressed the viability of the VCAH report and the Plantation Manager’s marketing report contained in the prospectus, and the overall viability of the project. The primary judge summarised his conclusions as supporting the following propositions:(i) the reasonability of the projected yields set out in the prospectus;(ii) the suitability of the production sites for the project; and(iii) the appropriateness of the production budgets and the flower varieties selected.Mr Hunter stated that based on his examination of those reports and further documentation provided by the Plantation Manager, he was of the opinion that AHP No 1 was a viable project as conceived or planned.

Decision

Reasons for decision

LEE, SUNDBERG AND CONTI JJ

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: LEE, SUNDBERG AND CONTI JJ