Barnes v Forty Two International Pty Limited (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Barnes v Forty Two International Pty Limited (No 2) [2015] FCAFC 19

Citation: Barnes v Forty Two International Pty Limited (No 2) [2015] FCAFC 19
Appeal from: Forty Two International Pty Limited v Barnes [2014] FCA 85
Parties: ALBERT KIM BARNES and LEE HAWKSLEY v FORTY TWO INTERNATIONAL PTY LIMITED (ACN 095 622 889), BLUEFREEWAY LIMITED (ACN 122 262 819) and THE GANG OF 4 PTY LTD (ACN 095 624 678)
File number: NSD 341 of 2014
Judges: SIOPIS, FLICK AND BEACH JJ
Date of judgment: 24 February 2015
Catchwords: COSTS — costs of substantive proceeding following successful appeal — exercise of discretion — claim for indemnity costs based on Calderbank offer and offer of compromise under r 25.01 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) — “walk away” offers — whether costs should be awarded on an indemnity basis
Legislation: Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 25.01, 25.14
Cases cited: Black v Lipovac (1998) 217 ALR 386; [1998] FCA 699
Calderbank v Calderbank [1975] 3 All ER 333
Clark v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (2010) 222 FCR 102
Kooee Communications Pty Ltd v Primus Telecommunications Pty Ltd (No 2) [2011] FCAFC 141
Sagacious Legal Pty Ltd v Wesfarmers General Insurance Ltd [2011] FCAFC 53
Uniline Australia Ltd v SBriggs Pty Ltd (No 2) (2009) 82 IPR 56; [2009] FCA 920
Date of hearing: Heard on the papers
Date of last submissions: 5 December 2014
Place: Melbourne
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Number of paragraphs: 37
Counsel for the Appellant: Mr R Dubler SC with Mr A Shearer
Solicitor for the Appellant: Harris & Company
Solicitor for the Respondent: Mr M Petrucco of Petrucco & Associates Lawyers

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 341 of 2014

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

ALBERT KIM BARNES AND ANOTHER NAMED IN THE SCHEDULE
Appellants

AND:

FORTY TWO INTERNATIONAL PTY LIMITED (ACN 095 622 889) AND OTHERS NAMED IN THE SCHEDULE
Respondents

JUDGES:

SIOPIS, FLICK AND BEACH JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

24 FEBRUARY 2015

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Paragraphs 1 and 2 of the orders made by Griffiths J on 14 March 2014 (as varied on 25 March 2014) be set aside and in lieu thereof it be ordered that:

“The applicants’ originating application (as amended from time to time) be dismissed.”

2.Paragraph 4 of the orders made by Griffiths J on 14 March 2014 (as varied on 25 March 2014) be set aside and in lieu thereof it be ordered:

“4.(a)       Subject to paragraph (c), the applicants pay the respondents’ costs of and incidental to the applicants’ originating application (as amended from time to time).

(b)Subject to paragraph (c), the respondents pay the applicants’ costs of and incidental to the respondents’ cross claim.

(c)There be no order as to costs in relation to:

i)the costs of and in relation to the notice of motion filed by the applicants on 19 November 2009;

ii)the costs…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Barnes v Forty Two International Pty Limited (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] FCAFC 19
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Barnes and Forty Two International Pty Limited, along with other defendants, were involved in a substantial legal dispute that extended through various stages of litigation, including multiple interlocutory applications and a lengthy trial. The primary dispute centred around claims for damages, with Barnes and Hawksley asserting a cross-claim for misleading or deceptive conduct. The Federal Court of Australia was tasked with resolving these claims, and ultimately, Barnes and Hawksley appealed the trial judge’s decision. The appeal was partially successful, leading to the reconsideration of costs issues arising from the extensive litigation process.

The court was required to determine the appropriate allocation of costs following the appeal, particularly focusing on the indemnity costs claim based on the Calderbank offer and the offer of compromise under rule 25.01 of the Federal Court Rules 2011. The central issue was whether the unsuccessful party should be required to pay the other party’s costs on an indemnity basis, particularly in light of the so-called "walk away" offers made during the litigation. The court also needed to assess the reasonableness of the respondents' decision not to accept the second offer and whether this decision warranted indemnity costs.

In its reasoning, the court concluded that the failure to accept the second offer was not unreasonable given the circumstances of the case. The court found that there was no basis to order indemnity costs for the unsuccessful party. Instead, the court decided that the costs should be awarded on the usual party/party basis, reflecting the outcomes of the litigation. The court set aside certain cost orders made by the trial judge and made new orders that provided for the set-off of costs and detailed the costs to be paid by each party in relation to specific proceedings.

The court ultimately ruled that Barnes and Hawksley would not be required to pay indemnity costs, and the costs orders would reflect the standard party/party basis. The new orders specified the costs to be borne by each party, including setting aside certain orders made by the trial judge and modifying others to reflect the outcomes of the appeal. The court also ordered that Barnes and Hawksley's costs of the appeal would be paid by the respondents.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Paragraphs 1 and 2 of the orders made by Griffiths J on 14 March 2014 (as varied on 25 March 2014) be set aside and in lieu thereof it be ordered that:

“The applicants’ originating application (as amended from time to time) be dismissed.”

2. Paragraph 4 of the orders made by Griffiths J on 14 March 2014 (as varied on 25 March 2014) be set aside and in lieu thereof it be ordered:

“4. (a) Subject to paragraph (c), the applicants pay the respondents’ costs of and incidental to the applicants’ originating application (as amended from time to time).

(b) Subject to paragraph (c), the respondents pay the applicants’ costs of and incidental to the respondents’ cross claim.

(c) There be no order as to costs in relation to:

i) the costs of and in relation to the notice of motion filed by the applicants on 19 November 2009;

ii) the costs of and in relation to the notice of motion filed by the respondents on 4 December 2009;

iii) the costs of and in relation to the notice of motion for security for costs filed by the respondents on 17 November 2009;

iv) the costs of and in relation to the notice of motion filed by the respondents on 16 February 2011;

v) the costs of the notice of motion filed by the respondents on 8 April 2011;

vi) the costs of the interlocutory application filed by the applicants on 17 November 2011 (relating to the confidentiality of certain documents produced on subpoena by the National Australia Bank);

vii) the costs of and incidental to the interlocutory hearing on 28 February 2012; and

viii) the costs of the applicants' interlocutory application filed on 29 February 2012.

(d) The costs the subject of orders 4(a) and 5 be set-off against the costs the subject of orders 4(b) and 6.”

3. The respondents pay the appellants’ costs of and incidental to this appeal.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

His Honour’s judgment was appealed before us. That appeal was allowed. These reasons concern various costs issues that have arisen between the parties consequential upon our decision.BACKGROUND The pre-trial phase of this matter was extensive. Numerous interlocutory applications were made by various parties. The trial involved substantial claims by both parties. There were 7 witnesses for the respondents and 11 witnesses for the appellants. The evidence filed was voluminous. The respondents to the appeal (the applicants below) initially pursued a claim for approximately $22 million. On 17 February 2012, Barnes and Hawksley (the appellants to the appeal and the respondents below) filed a cross-claim seeking damages for misleading or deceptive conduct in the amount of $41 million. Reasons for judgment were delivered by his Honour on 18 February 2014 ([2014] FCA 85). On 14 March 2014, following the filing of written submissions, his Honour ruled on costs ([2014] FCA 217) and ordered that judgment be entered against the appellants in favour of BlueFreeway in the sum of $3,062,406.93 comprising damages of $2 million together with interest. His Honour described the $2 million as the “quantum of damages [which] reflects the loss of BlueFreeway’s opportunity or chance to negotiate a termination payment with the respondents which [was] less than the $16 million which was actually paid” (at [3]). That damages head and method of calculation applied both to the cause of action based upon the breach of the implied term of the share purchase agreement and the cause of action based upon the misleading or deceptive conduct. The cross-claim was dismissed. Other consequential orders were made. His Honour awarded the respondents to the appeal 75% of their combined costs of the claim and the cross-claim. His Honour stated that the 25% reduction reflected issues on which the respondents had failed at trial or which had been abandoned during the course of the proceedings. His Honour also noted that “the cross claim took up significant time and resources and the respondents [at trial] failed” ([2014] FCA 217 at [15]). Before us, the appellants have submitted that the cross-claim added little by way of additional cost as it was filed late in the proceeding and relied substantially on affidavits already in evidence. But we see no reason to depart from his Honour’s description. On 2 April 2014, the appellants appealed the judgment of Griffiths J on various grounds, some of which they succeeded upon, being:·First, it was said that his Honour was in error in finding the implied term of the share purchase agreement contended for by BlueFreeway (ground 1). Further, it was asserted that he was in error for finding a breach thereof (ground 2). Further, it was said that he should also have found that the loss claimed did not fall within either limb of Hadley v Baxendale (1854) 9 Exch 341; 156 ER 145 (Hadley v Baxendale) (ground 3). Grounds 1-3 were upheld by us. ·Second, it was said that his Honour was in error in various respects in relation to his findings on liability on the misleading or deceptive conduct case (grounds 4-6). Each of those grounds were rejected by us. ·Third, it was said that his Honour erred in finding in favour of BlueFreeway on its claim for damages based upon the value of a lost opportunity or chance to negotiate, which the appellants asserted had not been pleaded, opened or run during the course of evidence (ground 7); further, that his Honour should have dismissed BlueFreeway’s claim for damages (ground 8). Grounds 7 and 8 were upheld. ·Fourth, it was said that in any event his Honour erred in his valuation of the lost opportunity (grounds 9 and 10). Those grounds were rejected. ·Finally, it was said that his Honour erred with respect to his construction and application of a release provision embodied in clause 10 of the exit agreement (grounds 11-14). Those grounds were rejected.The appellants did not appeal against his Honour’s dismissal of their cross-claim.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In all the circumstances, we are not satisfied that it has been shown that the failure to accept the second offer was unreasonable.CONCLUSION We will not make any order for indemnity costs. The costs orders that we make will be on the usual party/party basis. We will make an order for set-off and otherwise make orders in the terms foreshadowed in our earlier reasons with slight modifications.