Echo Tasmania Pty Ltd v Imperial Chemical Industries PLC

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Echo Tasmania Pty Ltd v Imperial Chemical Industries PLC [2008] FCAFC 58

JUDGMENTS – whether primary Judge failed to give adequate reasons for making orders on application for preliminary discovery

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for leave to appeal from orders for preliminary discovery – whether sufficient evidence to establish that the respondent had reasonable cause to believe that it may have a right to obtain relief 

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), s 24(1A)
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), s 52
Federal Court Rules, O 15A r 6

Beale v Government Insurance Office of New South Wales (1997) 48 NSWLR 430 followed
Bourke v Beneficial Finance Corporation Ltd (1993) 47 FCR 264 discussed
Décor Corporation Pty Ltd v Dart Industries Inc (1991) 33 FCR 397 cited
St George Bank Ltd v Rabo Australia Ltd (2004) 211 ALR 147 followed
Malouf v Malouf (1999) 86 FCR 134 cited
Mount Lawley Pty Ltd v Western Australian Planning Commission [2004] WASCA 149 referred to
Paxus Services Ltd v People Bank Pty Ltd (1990) 90 ALR 728 cited
Public Service Board v Osmond (1986) 159 CLR 656 followed

ECHO TASMANIA PTY LTD v IMPERIAL CHEMICAL INDUSTRIES PLC & ANOR
NSD 2291 OF 2007

BLACK CJ, SACKVILLE & EMMETT JJ
11 APRIL 2008
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 2291 OF 2007

BETWEEN:

ECHO TASMANIA PTY LTD
Applicant

AND:

IMPERIAL CHEMICAL INDUSTRIES PLC
First Respondent

DELOITTE GROWTH SOLUTIONS PTY LTD
Second Respondent

JUDGES:

BLACK CJ, SACKVILLE & EMMETT JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

11 APRIL 2008

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The applicant be granted leave to appeal from the judgment of Graham J given on 13 November 2007.

2.The appeal be allowed in part.

3.The first respondent, within seven days, bring in short minutes of order consistent with these reasons.

4.If the applicant objects to the form of the short minutes of order, it should file, within a further seven days, brief written submissions outlining its grounds of opposition. 

5.If either party wishes to contend for costs orders otherwise than those foreshadowed in paragraph 71 of the judgment, they should file written submissions in accordance with the timetable outlined in orders 3 and 4.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 2291 OF 2007

BETWEEN:

ECHO TASMANIA PTY LTD
Applicant

AND:

IMPERIAL CHEMICAL INDUSTRIES PLC
First Respondent

DELOITTE GROWTH SOLUTIONS PTY LTD
Second Respondent

JUDGES:

BLACK CJ, SACKVILLE & EMMETT JJ

DATE:

11 APRIL 2008

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

BLACK CJ and SACKVILLE J:

APPLICATION FOR LEAVE TO APPEAL

  1. This is an application for leave to appeal from orders made by a Judge of this Court requiring the applicant for leave (‘Echo’) to make preliminary discovery of ten categories of documents identified in Schedule A to the orders.  The orders were made by the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Echo Tasmania Pty Ltd v Imperial Chemical Industries PLC and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FCAFC 58
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Echo Tasmania Pty Ltd was the subject of an application by Imperial Chemical Industries PLC for discovery of documents, which led to a legal dispute in the Federal Court of Australia. The primary issues involved the adequacy of the reasons provided by the primary judge for the discovery orders and whether Echo was required to produce specific documents for inspection by ICI. Echo argued that the lack of adequate reasons constituted substantial injustice, as it was required to produce documents without understanding the basis of the orders. Moreover, Echo contended that the interlocutory orders were final in effect because they would permanently deprive Echo of the right to prevent third parties from examining its documents.

The court addressed the argument that the primary judge failed to provide adequate reasons for the discovery orders, which Echo argued constituted substantial injustice. The court found that ICI was entitled to discovery of the documents in categories 9 and 10 of Schedule A to the orders made by the primary judge. The court granted leave to Echo to appeal from the interlocutory judgment and orders made by the primary judge on 13 November 2007. The appeal was allowed in part, and the court directed ICI to bring in short minutes of order consistent with the reasons provided. Echo was given the opportunity to object to the form of the short minutes of order and to file written submissions outlining its grounds of opposition. The court also outlined the costs orders, stating that Echo should pay 50 per cent of ICI's costs of the proceedings at first instance, and each party should bear its own costs of the application for leave to appeal and of the appeal.

In conclusion, the court granted leave for Echo to appeal from the interlocutory judgment and orders made by the primary judge. The appeal was allowed in part, and the court directed ICI to bring in short minutes of order consistent with the reasons provided. The court also outlined the costs orders, which required Echo to pay 50 per cent of ICI's costs of the proceedings at first instance, and each party to bear its own costs of the application for leave to appeal and of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicant be granted leave to appeal from the judgment of Graham J given on 13 November 2007.

2. The appeal be allowed in part.

3. The first respondent, within seven days, bring in short minutes of order consistent with these reasons.

4. If the applicant objects to the form of the short minutes of order, it should file, within a further seven days, brief written submissions outlining its grounds of opposition.

5. If either party wishes to contend for costs orders otherwise than those foreshadowed in paragraph 71 of the judgment, they should file written submissions in accordance with the timetable outlined in orders 3 and 4.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Rich, who appeared for Echo, put at the forefront of his submissions what he submitted was the failure of the primary Judge to give adequate reasons. Mr Rich contended that the absence of adequate reasons involved substantial injustice to Echo, since the orders required it to produce for inspection documents without knowing why the orders were made. Moreover, so Mr Rich argued, although the orders were interlocutory in form, they were final in effect because Echo would lose irrevocably its right to prevent third parties examining its own documents. It was therefore appropriate for this Court to grant leave and to address the substantive issues raised by ICI’s application to the primary Judge.BACKGROUNDRemediation Proposal From 1948 until 1996, a subsidiary of ICI (‘TAPL’) owned and operated a titanium dioxide pigment manufacturing plant at Heybridge, on the north-west coast of Tasmania. The plant was closed in July 1996. TAPL then demolished the plant and undertook remediation of the site in accordance with an Environmental Decommissioning and Rehabilitation Plan (‘EDRP’) and certain Environment Protection Notices (‘EPNs’) issued by the relevant State department. By 2002, TAPL was no longer generating revenue and was entirely occupied with remediation work at the site. In July 2002, the board of ICI approved a proposal whereby:·a new company was to be incorporated (‘Echo’), with Mr Hartley, a senior officer of ICI, to be the sole shareholder and director;·TAPL would be sold to Echo for $1 and Echo would be responsible for remediation work at the site using TAPL’s funds, which totalled about $24 million; and·ICI would procure a bank guarantee from Westpac Banking Corporation (‘Westpac’) to cover certain kinds of expenses and ICI’s interests would be protected by a ‘probity auditor’. On 16 August 2002, Echo was incorporated and one ordinary share was allotted to Mr Hartley. The remainder of the proposal approved by ICI was implemented by a series of agreements, as follows:·a ‘Share Purchase Agreement’ between TAPL and Echo dated 1 October 2002;·a ‘Deed of Appointment of Probity Auditor’, between Echo and Ernst & Young, dated 1 October 2002 (‘Probity Auditor Deed’);·a ‘Banker’s Undertaking’, executed by Westpac in favour of Echo, dated 26 September 2002; and·an ‘Indemnity’ executed by ICI in favour of Westpac on 26 September 2002.Indemnity DocumentationBanker’s Undertaking Westpac’s Banker’s Undertaking was in the following terms:‘In consideration of [Echo] accepting this undertaking and subject to satisfaction of the conditions below, [Westpac] undertakes to pay any sum or sums which may from time to time be demanded by [Echo] up to a maximum aggregate sum of [$15 million] (the Sum)…Westpac agrees to pay to [Echo] the whole or any part or parts of the Sum provided the following conditions are satisfied:(I)Westpac receives a certificate which in Westpac’s reasonable opinion is substantially in the form annexed hereto as Schedule 1 (the Certificate); and(ii) The Certificate:(a)is duly notarised … confirming that it has been signed by a partner…from an Australian office of Messrs Ernst & Young (or any authorised signatory of any successor Probity Auditor from time to time thereof); and(b)purports to be signed by two authorised signatories of [Echo] …Westpac agrees that other than as set out above, payments claimed in accordance with this undertaking will be made to [Echo] forthwith without reference to any third party. …’

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

BLACK CJ
ICI has made out its entitlement to discovery of the documents in categories 9 and 10 of Schedule A to the orders made by the primary Judge.CONCLUSION We would grant leave to Echo to appeal from the interlocutory judgment given and orders made by the primary Judge on 13 November 2007. The appeal should be allowed in part. We would direct ICI within seven days to bring in short minutes of order consistent with these reasons and, if appropriate, to file brief written submissions explaining the terms of the short minutes of order. If Echo objects to the Court making orders in accordance with the proposed short minutes, it should file brief written submissions outlining the grounds of its opposition within a further seven days. Our present view is that Echo should pay 50 per cent of ICI’s costs of the proceedings at first instance and that each party should bear its own costs of the application for leave to appeal and of the appeal. If either party wishes to contend for different costs orders, it should file written submissions in accordance with the timetable already outlined. I have had the benefit of considering the reasons for judgment of Black CJ and Sackville J in draft form. The circumstances in which the application for leave to appeal arises are set out in appropriate detail in those reasons. Accordingly, I will not repeat them. I agree with their Honours’ conclusions concerning Categories 1 to 7 and 9 and 10. However, I have reached a different conclusion concerning Category 8, which covers any other documents relating to the extent to which each event referred to in the Probity Audit Notices was a Payment Event falling within clause 3.1 of the Probity Deed and not excluded by clause 3.2 of the Probity Deed. CATEGORY 8 Clause 3.2(a)(i) of the Deed Appointing Probity Auditor of 1 October 2002 (‘Probity Deed’) defined the term ‘Excluded Liability’ as including a liability arising under the EPN or any liability for works required to be undertaken to comply with the EPN or any Environmental Law (as defined) with respect to the Site, except when it arises directly out of an event referred to in clause 3.1(a). ‘EPN’ was defined to mean three specified Environmental Protection Notices issued by the Tasmanian Department of Primary Industries, Water and Environment and relating to the Site. The three Environmental Protection Notices were EPN 40/1, EPN 41/1 and EPN 323/1. Each of EPN 40/1 and EPN 41/1 was concerned with the activity of ‘decommissioning and rehabilitation works’ at the Site. EPN 323/1, which replaced earlier EPN 39/1, was concerned with the activity of ‘Environmental management of decommissioned and rehabilitated leach residue dams and landfills’ at the Site. EPN 40/1 related to identified parcels of land, which are assumed to constitute the Site, and required that the Site be decommissioned and rehabilitated in accordance with the EDRP. EPN 40/1 also required that those areas of the Site required to undergo remediation in accordance with the Environmental Decommissioning and Rehabilitation Plan (‘EDRP’) and be remedied to acceptance criteria prescribed in a table attached to EPN 40/1. Next, EPN 40/1 required, at the completion of the remediation works, that Tioxide Australia Pty Limited (‘TAPL’) carry out a program to validate that the levels of contamination remaining in soil and waters across the Site meet the acceptance criteria in the table. Finally, EPN 40/1 required that TAPL submit a site validation report to the Director of Environmental Management (‘the Director’) describing the remediation works, how they proceeded and the outcomes of the works.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BLACK CJ