Valra Pty Ltd v Mag Men Holdings Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Valra Pty Ltd v Mag Men Holdings Pty Ltd [2019] FCA 1897

File number: WAD 294 of 2016
Judge: BANKS-SMITH J
Date of judgment: 20 November 2019
Catchwords:

CONTRACT - contract interpretation - sale of shares under compulsory sale provision in shareholders agreement - where company in financial difficulty - where purchaser sought to acquire all shares - where come along clause utilised by company - where offer to shareholders must be on same terms - meaning of same terms - whether offer on arm's length terms - whether pre-conditions to execution of share transfer by company met - where no evidence that shares of any value

CONTRACT - whether oral contract established - whether terms sufficiently certain to comprise contractual relationship - where claimed obligation was to vote as block and cooperate

CONTRACT - whether good faith requirement in shareholders agreement breached - content of alleged duty - whether obligation of disclosure - whether duties of shareholders analogous to those of partners

CORPORATIONS - oppression - claim by former minority shareholder under s 232 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) - whether shareholder entitled to involvement in management decisions - whether use of come along clause oppressive - whether failure to disclose terms of agreements with creditors to compromise debts oppressive - whether use of provision to transfer shares between relatives used improperly - whether commercially unfair

Legislation: Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 232
Cases cited:

ACI Operations Pty Ltd v Berri Ltd [2005] VSC 201

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Geowash Pty Ltd (Subject to a Deed of Company Arrangement) (No 3) [2019] FCA 72

Australian Goldfields NL (in liq) v North Australian Diamonds NL [2009] WASCA 98; (2009) 40 WAR 191

Australian Institute of Fitness Pty Ltd v Australian Institute of Fitness (Vic/Tas) Pty Limited (No 3) [2015] NSWSC 1639

Clarence Property Corporation Ltd v Sentinel Robina Office Pty Ltd [2018] QSC 95; [2019] 1 Qd R 144

Cunningham v Resourceful Land Limited and Ors [2018] EWHC 1185 (Ch)

Dosike Pty Ltd v Johnson (1996) 16 WAR 241

Electricity Generation Corporation v Woodside Energy Ltd [2014] HCA 7; (2014) 251 CLR 640

Fexuto Pty Ltd v Bosnjak Holdings Pty Ltd [1998] NSWSC 413; (1998) 28 ACSR 688

Healey v Commissioner of Taxation [2012] FCA 269

Hillas & Co Ltd v Arcos Ltd [1932] All ER Rep 494

HNA Irish Nominees Ltd v Kinghorn (No 2) [2012] FCA 228

Huppert v Stock Options of Australia Pty Ltd [1965] HCA 30; (1965) 112 CLR 414

Joint v Stephens [2008] VSCA 210

Luna Park (NSW) Ltd v Tramways Advertising Pty Ltd [1938] HCA 66; (1938) 61 CLR 286

M&G Broad European Loan Fund Limited v Hayfin Capital Luxco 2 SARL [2017] EWHC 1756 (Ch)

Macquarie International Health Clinic Pty Ltd v Sydney South West Area Health Service [2010] NSWCA 268

Mayfair Property Holdings Pty Ltd v Southland Packers Pty Ltd [2016] QSC 27

McCausland v Surfing Hardware International Holdings…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Valra Pty Ltd v Mag Men Holdings Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCA 1897
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Valra Pty Ltd was a shareholder in Mag Men Holdings Pty Ltd (MMH), a company that encountered financial difficulties. Valra sought relief from the court, alleging breaches of contract and oppression under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). Valra claimed that MMH, through its directors, breached their contractual obligations by failing to cooperate and vote as a block, and by implementing a 'come along' clause to acquire all shares. Valra also alleged that MMH used the clause oppressively, failed to disclose agreements with creditors, and wrongfully excluded Valra from management decisions. Valra sought damages and an injunction against MMH.

The court examined whether the 'come along' clause required MMH to offer the same terms to all shareholders, and if the terms offered were at arm's length. The court found that MMH did not breach the contract, as the terms offered were fair and there was no evidence that Valra's shares had any value. Valra had no right to participate in MMH's day-to-day management, and the Shareholders Deed did not require formal board meetings or reports to shareholders. The court also held that MMH did not act oppressively, as there was no evidence of ulterior motives or unfair treatment of Valra. The court dismissed Valra's claims and ordered that Valra's claim be dismissed with costs to be determined on the papers.

The court found in favour of MMH on all counts and ordered that Valra pay MMH $100 in costs. The court held that MMH did not breach the Shareholders Deed, as there was no obligation of good faith or disclosure, and the duties of shareholders were not analogous to those of partners. The court also held that Valra was not oppressed, as there was no evidence of improper use of the 'come along' clause or failure to disclose agreements with creditors. The court dismissed Valra's claims and ordered that Valra pay MMH $100 in costs. The parties were to confer as to costs orders and, failing agreement, were to provide outlines of submissions as to costs not exceeding five pages within 14 days, with costs to be determined on the papers, subject to further order.

Orders

Orders of the court

2. Judgment in favour of the applicant against the first respondent in the sum of $100.

3. The applicant's claim is otherwise dismissed.

4. The parties are to confer as to costs orders and failing agreement are to provide outlines of submissions as to costs not exceeding five pages within 14 days, with costs to be determined on the papers, subject to further order.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Witnesses and parties

[5]

Facts

[18]

2005 - MMH incorporated and Comintra becomes shareholder

[18]

2006 - Mezzanine financing brings in SLP, Rahim and Amin

[20]

The 2006 Shareholders Deed

[25]

The alleged oral agreement between the brothers about their shares

[33]

2007 to 2009 - MMH continues to seek funding

[35]

The September 2009 resolution: Comintra and SLP provide loans

[43]

September 2009 - Variation to Shareholders Deed

[52]

The 2010 Share Restructure Implementation Deed

[55]

August 2012 - breakdown in relationship between Shariff and Rahim

[59]

Comintra and SLP continue to provide support into 2011-2013

[60]

October 2013 - MMH must re-assess its financial position

[65]

The New Zealand operation - Mega Mags divested to Vali and Ravi

[68]

The Australian position - Vali provides interim financial support

[75]

Shariff resigns as director of MMH

[78]

Rahim requests information about MMH

[79]

February 2014 - the tipping point for solvency

[86]

Vali sells his shares in MMH to Shariff ahead of offer

[92]

The offer: MMH circular to shareholders about Tactracom proposal

[93]

Shareholder responses to the 10 March 2014 email

[99]

The Share Sale Agreements - Comintra and SLP

[101]

The 13 March 2014 phone call with Rahim

[104]

Events of 18 March 2014

[113]

The signing of Valra's share transfer form

[116]

Valra's response and letters of demand

[118]

The pleaded case

[123]

The alleged breach of contract (Valibhoy Agreement) by Sofiah and Comintra by failing to cooperate as shareholders

[125]

The alleged breach of contract (Shareholders Agreement) by MMH by use of the come along clause

[126]

The alleged breach of contract (Shareholders Deed) by Comintra by breach of its good faith obligation

[128]

The alleged oppression by MMH

[129]

Relief sought

[133]

The witnesses

[137]

Breach of the alleged Valibhoy Agreement

[149]

Breach of Shareholders Deed by use of come along clause

[176]

Clause 15

[177]

Terms of Share Sale Agreement

[185]

Negotiation of terms of Share Sale Agreement

[193]

The 'same terms'

[198]

Arm's length terms

[221]

Valra's argument based on absence of failure on its part to execute documents

[237]

Breach of Shareholders Deed

[243]

Breach by Comintra - lack of good faith

[244]

Terms of the Shareholders Deed

[244]

The misplaced analogy with partners

[251]

Proper principles to apply

[256]

Consideration

[262]

Oppression

[275]

Financial context

[276]

Principles

[279]

The transfer of Valra's shares purportedly in accordance with cl 15 (the contractual breach by MMH)

[284]

Exclusion from management decisions

[288]

The Mega Mags transaction

[296]

Claim that Valra was not given the opportunity to provide funding to MMH on the same terms as other shareholders

[307]

Keeping the separate agreements with Comintra and SLP hidden

[313]

Claim that Vali transferred his shares to Shariff clearly in contemplation of seeking to invoke cl 15 to acquire all shares in MMH through Tactracom and was aware that Tactracom would obtain majority ownership of MMH and half ownership of Mega Mags

[316]

Conclusion - oppression not established

[319]

The alleged overarching conspiracy

[322]

Relief

[327]

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In reaching this conclusion the matters I take into account include that:(a)there is no evidence that the shares were sold at an undervalue and Valra accepts their value was nominal only;(b)Vali responded quickly and in a forthcoming manner in providing information to Rahim (and other shareholders) when it was requested;(c)there is no suggestion that Valra received less or different information to that received by other non‑creditor shareholders;(d)there is no evidence that MMH sought to influence Sofiah or other shareholders to support the transaction to ensure that a 90% threshold was reached;(e)there is no evidence other shareholders conspired or communicated as to the manner in which they might vote or that they sought to achieve a 90% majority position so that cl 15 might be utilised; and(f)there was a commercial imperative for MMH to consider and implement cl 15 in order to facilitate the takeover which would potentially avoid an inevitable insolvency regime: the evidence does not establish it was seeking to utilise the clause for any ulterior purpose.Exclusion from management decisions There is overlap between the allegation that Valra was wrongfully excluded from MMH's management decisions that led to the invocation of cl 15, and its submission that the Shareholders Deed reflected that shareholders would have a level of participation in the management of MMH and Valra was given no such reasonable opportunity. The right of shareholders to be involved in decisions affecting the company are determined by the constitution and, in this case, the Shareholders Deed. The complaint relied upon by Valra is based on a lack of evidence of formal board meetings, a lack of reports to shareholders so that it was difficult for the shareholders 'to exercise any control or influence over the management of the company', and an assertion that there was an expectation that there would have been open disclosure by the directors 'for instance of the fact that the takeover was structured the way that it was to try to fit into the terms of the come along condition'. Valra had no entitlement to participate in the day to day management of MMH. The matters that were required to be voted upon by shareholders were prescribed in the Shareholders Deed. This was not purely a family company or quasi-partnership where family members might have some expectation of a position of employment or decision making: the majority shareholder was an independent investment body and it was appropriate that the company be managed having regard to the Shareholders Deed. It is also important to remember that pursuant to the Shareholders Deed, Shariff was the Valibhoy Representative. The directors of MMH were entitled to a point to assume that information was provided to Rahim as relevant by Shariff, and indeed the evidence of both Rahim and Shariff was that prior to their falling out, Shariff did speak to Rahim about the business of MMH regularly. Despite having fallen out with Shariff in around August 2012, Rahim did not inform Vali until December 2013 that Shariff no longer represented him and he did not seek information from Vali until that time.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

As to major receivables, as at 30 June 2013 MMH was owed NZ$1,007,180 by the New Zealand subsidiary Mega Mags and AU$4,394,820 by Mag Nation. Relevantly, according to Vali, the directors of MMH considered the likelihood of recovery of the loan from Mega Mags to be 'non‑existent'. According to Vali, Mr Jackson had talked about a preparedness to wind up Mega Mags.The New Zealand operation - Mega Mags divested to Vali and Ravi It is worth noting that the directors of Mega Mags as at October 2013 were Ravi, Shariff, Vali and Mr Jackson. At that time, the position of the New Zealand operation was such that Ravi requested an urgent injection of cash from MMH. Ravi emailed Mr Jackson, Mr Sumner, Shariff and Vali on 10 October 2013 informing them that he had received a call from Mega Mags' landlord to the effect that if the September 2013 arrears were not cleared then they would issue a notice and take possession. Ravi noted that Mega Mags would incur a make good obligation, might not have a store and would have debts to clear, plus the October rent was due on 16 October 2013. Comintra and SLP were not prepared to fund the New Zealand arm of MMH any longer, and were prepared to see it wound up. Vali gave evidence to this effect. Shariff also gave evidence to the effect that as at October 2013 he (Comintra) was not prepared to provide further finding to MMH and he understood SLP had the same view. Vali and Ravi considered that they could make the New Zealand operation of the business work, and offered to take over the liabilities of Mega Mags by buying its shares from MMH. One of the terms was that the loan from MMH to Mega Mags (considered by the MMH directors to be in effect irrecoverable) be forgiven. According to Vali, in October 2013 the MMH board decided to divest and sell the shares it held in Mega Mags to Vali and Ravi. According to Vali, he and Ravi each injected AU$25,000 into Mega Mags in November 2013 to keep it running. The transaction itself did not complete until March 2014. Vali's evidence was that the delay in completion was caused by the need to obtain Australian and New Zealand legal advice, and the lawyers took some time to respond and prepare the documentation. There is documentary evidence consistent with this explanation. For example, a draft Agreement for Sale and Purchase of Shares in Mega Mags prepared by New Zealand lawyers was emailed to Vali by Ravi on 16 January 2014. The draft names MMH as the vendor, with Vali and Ravi as purchasers, and includes confirmation by MMH of the discharge and release of the shareholder loan made by it to Mega Mags. The sale and purchase of the shares and the release of the MMH debt was documented some time later. The loan debt forgiveness form was followed up by Ravi in January 2014 and signed by MMH on 21 February 2014. The Agreement for Sale and Purchase of Shares in Mega Mags made between MMH, Tactracom and Ravi was signed on 11 March 2014. Relevantly, in this final copy references to Vali as purchaser were struck through and references to Tactracom substituted. The share transfer forms were not completed until the MMH board meeting of 18 March 2014. This timetable for completion was the focus of some attention from the respondents and it will be necessary to consider it further.The Australian position - Vali provides interim financial support