FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Healey v Commissioner of Taxation [2012] FCA 269
Citation: Healey v Commissioner of Taxation [2012] FCA 269 Parties: CARINA HEALEY v THE COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION OF THE COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA File number: WAD 188 of 2010 Judge: MCKERRACHER J Date of judgment: 23 March 2012 Catchwords: INCOME TAX – appeal from income tax assessment and administrative penalty for failure to lodge tax returns – applicant a beneficiary of a discretionary trust – assessment of share transactions concerning trustee of beneficiary trust and whether there was a capital gain – determination of relevant capital gains tax event – assessment of cost base of shares – whether parties dealt at arm’s length in share acquisition – insufficient evidence adduced by applicant to support contention that parties did not deal at arm’s length – whether fair and reasonable for administrative penalty to be remitted – whether fair and reasonable to remit administrative penalty due to history of late and non-lodgement history and public interest grounds
STATUTORY INTERPRETATION – provision defining when capital gains tax event occurs – whether the term ‘transfer’ includes a conveyance by way of sale or confined to a conveyance by way of gift or settlement – consideration of usage of term throughout capital gains tax provisions and at common law – ‘transfer’ held to be construed broadly so as to include a conveyance by way of sale
Words & phrases: ‘transfer’ Legislation: Income Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) ss 160M(3)(a), 160M(3A)
Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) 102-25, 104-5, 104-10, 104-55, 104-60, 109-5, 110-25, 112-20
Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) 284-85(1), 284-90(1), 298-20, 14ZZOCases cited: ACI Operations Pty Ltd v Berri Ltd (2005) 15 VR 312
Re A Debtor (No. 360 of 1951) [1952] 1 All ER 519
Australian Trade Commission v WA Meat Exports Pty Ltd (1987) 7 AAR 248
Braverus Maritime Inc v Port Kembla Coal Terminal Ltd (2005) 148 FCR 68
Case V22 (1988) 88 ATC 244
Coles Myer Ltd v Commissioner of State Revenue (Vic) [1998] 4 VR 728
Danmark Pty Ltd & Forestwood Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1944) 7 ATD 333
Dixon v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (2008) 167 FCR 287
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Dalco (1990) 168 CLR 614
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v AXA Asia Pacific Holdings Ltd (2010) 189 FCR 204
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Burness (2009) 77 ATR 61
Gathercole v Smith (1881) 17 Ch D 1
Granby Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1995) 129 ALR 503
Re Hains; Barnsdall v Commissioner of Taxation (1988) 81 ALR 173
Re Hobart Central Child Care Pty Ltd and Federal Commissioner of Taxation (2005) 60 ATR 1314
Re Hutson and Federal Commissioner of Taxation (2009) 74 ATR 965
Ireland v Hart [1902] 1 Ch 522
Nanney v Morgan (1887) 35 Ch D 603
National Bank of Australia v Falkingham [1902] AC 585
Re Player, Ex p Harvey, No 1 (1885) 54 LJ QB 533
Re Poole Shipping Co [1920] 1 Ch 251
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Healey v Commissioner of Taxation and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2012] FCA 269
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
In addressing these issues, the court found that the term 'transfer' in the capital gains tax provisions should be construed broadly to include a conveyance by way of sale, aligning with common law usage. The court also concluded that Ms Healey had not provided sufficient evidence to support her contention that the parties did not deal at arm's length in the share acquisition. Furthermore, the court determined that it was not fair and reasonable to remit the administrative penalty, considering Ms Healey's history of late and non-lodgement and public interest factors.
As a result of these findings, the appeal was dismissed. The court ordered that the appeal be dismissed and that Ms Healey pay the respondent's costs, to be taxed if not agreed. This ruling effectively upheld the Commissioner's assessment and penalty, rejecting Ms Healey's arguments and ensuring the administrative penalty remained in place.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The appeal be dismissed.
2. The applicant do pay the costs of the respondent, to be taxed if not agreed.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Commissioner accepts that if CGT event A1 is the applicable CGT event, the net capital gain on the disposal of the 1,199,654 JAH shares would be $7,095,250 rather than $14,190,500 as there would be a 50% discount under s 115. In those circumstances, it is accepted that the Court should remit the matter to the Commissioner with directions to vary the 2006 assessment and administrative penalty. That is not the conclusion I reached nor is it the position advanced by the parties. CONSIDERATIONWhich CGT event applies? For determination as to which CGT event applies to Newcode’s acquisition of the JAH shares, there are two possibilities, possibly three. The first is CGT event A1 on disposal of a CGT asset which occurs ‘if you dispose of a CGT asset’, pursuant to s 104-10(1) ITAA 97 on the one hand, or, CGT event E2 – transferring a CGT asset to a trust which occurs ‘if you transfer a CGT asset to an existing trust’ per s 104-60(1) ITAA 97. The reference to ‘you’ (not a particularly common feature of legislative drafting) refers here to the disposer or the transferor, so in the context of Allswan and Jayport as transferors of the JAH shares rather than Newcode as the transferee. It will be recalled that the concept of the ‘CGT event’ is defined by reference to actual events which may themselves result in a capital gain or loss:104‑5 Summary of the CGT events The ‘general acquisition rules’ in s 109-5 ITAA 97 deal with how and when a person acquires a CGT asset as a result of a CGT event. It is significant from s 102-25(1) ITAA 97 that if more than one event can happen, ‘the one you use is the one that is the most specific to your situation’. The relevance of this issue to the appeal is this:·Applying CGT event A1, Newcode acquired the JAH shares when the disposal contract was entered into (pursuant to s 109-5(2) ITAA 97). The date for this purpose was 1 May 2004. It follows, therefore, that the JAH shares were held for at least 12 months and thus the 50% discount capital gain rule would apply. ·On the other hand, if CGT event E2 is appropriate, Newcode acquired the JAH shares when the JAH shares were ‘transferred’ as a result of s 109-5(2) ITAA 97. This date was 9 December 2005 and, accordingly, if CGT event E2 was a relevant event, there would be no discount capital gain under s 115 ITAA 97. ·On the other hand, the cost base for the JAH shares may differ depending on whether the transaction is CGT event A1 or CGT event E2. In this regard, Ms Healey relies on the market value substitution rule under s 112-20(1)(c) ITAA 97 which, it will be recalled, provides as follows:112‑20 Market value substitution rule(1)The first element of your cost base and reduced cost base of a CGT asset you acquire from another entity is its market value (at the time of acquisition) if:…(c)you did not deal at arm’s length with the other entity in connection with the acquisition. Ms Healey contends that as at 9 December 2005, the true cost base for the JAH shares was the same as the subsequent capital proceeds such that there was no capital gain on the eventual sale of the JAH shares to Ascot.Was there a transfer?