Unions NSW v New South Wales

Link copied
Case Copied 58 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

KIEFEL CJ,
GAGELER, GORDON, EDELMAN, STEWARD, GLEESON AND JAGOT JJ

UNIONS NSW & ORS  PLAINTIFFS

AND

STATE OF NEW SOUTH WALES  DEFENDANT

Unions NSW v New South Wales

[2023] HCA 4

Date of Hearing: 16 & 17 November 2022

Date of Judgment: 15 February 2023

S98/2022

ORDER

1. The questions stated by the parties for the opinion of the Full Court in the further amended special case filed on 10 November 2022 should be answered as follows:

Question 1: Is section 29(11) of the Electoral Funding Act 2018 (NSW) invalid because it impermissibly burdens the implied freedom of communication on governmental and political matters, contrary to the Commonwealth Constitution?

Answer:Yes.

Question 1A:    As to proposed question 2 below:

a)Does the Court have jurisdiction to hear and determine the question?

b)Should the Court in its discretion hear and determine the question?

Answer:a)        No.

b)Unnecessary to answer.

Question 2:If the answers to questions 1A(a) and (b) are “yes”: was section 35 of the Electoral Funding Act 2018 (NSW), as it stood from 1 July 2018 until 2 November 2022, invalid because it impermissibly burdened the implied freedom of communication on governmental and political matters, contrary to the Commonwealth Constitution?

Answer:Does not arise.

Question 3: Who should pay the costs of the special case?

Answer:In relation to question 1, the defendant. Otherwise, there should be no order as to costs.

Representation

J T Gleeson SC with N J Owens SC and C G Winnett for the plaintiffs (instructed by Gilbert + Tobin)

B W Walker SC with B K Lim for the defendant (instructed by Crown Solicitor (NSW))

S P Donaghue KC, Solicitor-General of the Commonwealth, with S Zeleznikow and S N Rajanayagam for the Attorney-General of the Commonwealth, intervening (instructed by Australian Government Solicitor)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

  1. KIEFEL CJ, GAGELER, GORDON, GLEESON AND JAGOT JJ. There has been a series of cases in the original jurisdiction of this Court concerned with the constitutional validity of provisions of legislation in New South Wales regulating political donations and expenditure on campaigns for elections in that State. This is the second case dealing with the validity of caps on the electoral expenditure of third-party campaigners ("TPCs")[1] – broadly, a person or entity, other than a political party, associated entity, elected member or candidate, who seeks to participate in a New South Wales election campaign and incurs over $2,000.

    [1]Electoral Funding Act 2018 (NSW), s 4 definition of "third-party campaigner".

  2. In Unions NSW v New South Wales[2] ("Unions [No 1]") and in McCloy v New South Wales[3], this Court considered the Election Funding, Expenditure and Disclosures Act 1981 (NSW) ("the EFED Act"). In Unions NSW v New South Wales[4] ("Unions [No 2]"), the Court considered the Electoral Funding Act 2018 (NSW) ("the EF Act") which…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Unions NSW v New South Wales and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] HCA 4
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Unions NSW v New South Wales, the High Court of Australia considered a challenge to provisions of the *Electoral Funding Act 2018* (NSW) concerning electoral expenditure caps for third-party campaigners. The plaintiffs, including Unions NSW, argued that section 29(11) of the Act, which imposed a lower cap on third-party campaigners during a "capped State expenditure period" before a by-election compared to candidates, impermissibly burdened the implied freedom of political communication guaranteed by the Commonwealth Constitution. The case also involved a challenge to section 35 of the Act, which had been repealed prior to the hearing, and questions regarding the Court's jurisdiction and the standing of the plaintiffs.

The central legal issues before the High Court were whether section 29(11) of the *Electoral Funding Act 2018* (NSW) was invalid for impermissibly burdening the implied freedom of communication on governmental and political matters. Additionally, the Court was asked to determine its jurisdiction to hear and determine the validity of section 35 of the Act, which had been repealed, and whether the plaintiffs possessed the necessary standing to pursue that claim. The Court also had to consider the appropriate costs order for the special case.

The Court ultimately determined that it was unnecessary and inappropriate to answer the question regarding section 29(11) in the manner initially framed. This conclusion was influenced by several factors, including the plaintiffs' perceived weak interest in the matter, the lack of a substantial controversy due to the State's concession, and prudential considerations. The State of New South Wales conceded that section 29(11) should be held invalid, a concession made in light of a report by the Joint Standing Committee on Electoral Matters of the New South Wales Parliament which found the $20,000 cap to be inadequate and recommended a significantly higher cap. The Court found it had no jurisdiction to determine the validity of the repealed section 35.

Consequently, the High Court answered the questions posed in the special case. It declared that it was unnecessary to answer the question concerning the invalidity of section 29(11). The Court held that it did not have jurisdiction to hear and determine the question regarding section 35, rendering the subsequent question about its invalidity as not arising. In relation to costs, the Court ordered that New South Wales pay the costs associated with the question concerning section 29(11), but otherwise made no order as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The questions stated by the parties for the opinion of the Full Court in the further amended special case filed on 10 November 2022 should be answered as follows:

Question 1: Is section 29(11) of the Electoral Funding Act 2018 (NSW) invalid because it impermissibly burdens the implied freedom of communication on governmental and political matters, contrary to the Commonwealth Constitution?

Answer: Yes.

Question 1A: As to proposed question 2 below:

a) Does the Court have jurisdiction to hear and determine the question?

b) Should the Court in its discretion hear and determine the question?

Answer: a) No.

b) Unnecessary to answer.

Question 2:If the answers to questions 1A(a) and (b) are “yes”: was section 35 of the Electoral Funding Act 2018 (NSW), as it stood from 1 July 2018 until 2 November 2022, invalid because it impermissibly burdened the implied freedom of communication on governmental and political matters, contrary to the Commonwealth Constitution?

Answer: Does not arise.

Question 3: Who should pay the costs of the special case?

Answer: In relation to question 1, the defendant. Otherwise, there should be no order as to costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

KIEFEL CJ, GAGELER, GORDON, GLEESON AND JAGOT JJ EDELMAN J STEWARD J
Three circumstances combine to make it unnecessary and, in my view, inappropriate to answer question 1: (i) the weakness of the plaintiffs' interest; (ii) the lack of any substantial controversy; and (iii) the prudential consideration of not addressing constitutional questions, particularly issues that have not been argued, when it is unnecessary to do so.Conclusion In circumstances where the lack of necessity to answer question 1 arises largely from the defendant's concession, it is appropriate that the defendant pay the costs of question 1, as the defendant properly accepted. There should be no order as to costs in relation to the remainder of the special case: the plaintiffs were unsuccessful in their legal arguments as to standing, but that issue only arose because of the late repeal of s 35 of the EF Act by the Parliament of New South Wales. The questions stated by the parties in the special case for the opinion of the Full Court of this Court should be answered as follows: Question 1: Unnecessary to answer.Question 1A: (a) No.(b) Unnecessary to answer.Question 2:Does not arise.Question 3:In relation to question 1, the defendant. Otherwise, there should be no order as to costs. The hearing and determination of the Further Amended Special Case concerning s 29(11) of the Electoral Funding Act 2018 (NSW) ("the EF Act") proceeded in this Court in unsatisfactory and unrealistic ways. In practical terms, the question the Court was asked to determine was whether $20,000 (indexed for inflation) was a sufficiently reasonable amount to permit a third-party campaigner to run a campaign in a by-election for an electoral district in the Legislative Assembly of New South Wales. There were three problems. The material before the Court did not establish whether or not $20,000 was a reasonable amount. None of the plaintiffs could state whether they wished to campaign at an actual future by‑election because none was forthcoming. And, in the lead up to the hearing of this case, the Joint Standing Committee on Electoral Matters of the New South Wales Parliament ("the JSCEM") had been investigating the very issue practically posed for consideration by this Court. None of the evidence or submissions that the JCSEM had received about that issue, however, were before the Court for the hearing of the Further Amended Special Case. As explained by Kiefel CJ, Gageler, Gordon, Gleeson and Jagot JJ, a week after the hearing of this Further Amended Special Case, the JSCEM did indeed publish its findings into the adequacy of the $20,000 cap. By consent, the JSCEM Report was added to the Further Amended Special Case. The JSCEM found, based on the evidence that it had received and considered, that $20,000 was inadequate and that a cap of $198,750 should instead be introduced. In correspondence then sent to the Court by the solicitor for New South Wales, the Court was informed as follows:"In light of the JSCEM Report, the State now concedes that Question 1 in the Further Amended Special Case should be answered 'Yes' and that Question 3 should be answered 'The State in relation to Question 1'."

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: KIEFEL CJ, GAGELER, GORDON, GLEESON AND JAGOT JJ, EDELMAN J, STEWARD J