Wilson v State of Victoria

Link copied
Case Copied 60 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Wilson v State of Victoria [2023] FCA 111

File number(s): VID 624 of 2021
Judgment of: HESPE J
Date of judgment: 20 February 2023
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – applications for summary dismissal and strike out – pleadings allege invalidity of measures relating to the rollout of COVID-19 vaccines and restrictions on unvaccinated individuals in the State of Victoria based on Constitution, contraventions of Imperial statues, incompatibility with the Charter of Human Rights and Responsibilities Act 2008 (Vic) – whether Applicants enjoy reasonable prospects of success
Legislation:

Constitution ss 51(xxiiiA), 51(xxxvii), 51(xxxviii), 109

Australian Immunisation Register Act 2015 (Cth)

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 31A

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 13.01, 26.01

Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) s 39B

National Health Act 1953 (Cth) s 132G

National Health Amendment (COVID-19) Act 2021 (Cth) Sch 1

Public Governance, Performance and Accountability Act 2013 (Cth) s 65

Statute of Westminster Adoption Act 1942 (Cth) s 2

Charter of Human Rights and Responsibilities Act 2008 (Vic) ss 1, 3, 4, 7, 28, 29, 31, 32, 38, 39

Imperial Acts Application Act 1980 (Vic) Pt II Div 3, Pt II Div 4

Interpretation of Legislation Act 1984 (Vic) s 38

Occupational Health and Safety Act 2004 (Vic)

Public Health and Wellbeing Act 2008 (Vic) ss 165A, 165AB, 165AI, 165AL, 165CR, 198, 200, 204

Public Health and Wellbeing Amendment (Pandemic Management) Act 2021 (Vic) s 12

Subordinate Legislation Act 1994 (Vic) s 3

COVID-19 Mandatory Vaccination (Workers) Directions (Vic)

COVID-19 Mandatory Vaccination (Specified Workers) Order 2022 (No. 6) (Vic)

Pandemic (Workplace) Order 2022 (No. 8) (Vic)

Pandemic COVID-19 Mandatory Vaccination (General Workers) Order 2021 (No. 1) (Vic)

Pandemic COVID-19 Mandatory Vaccination (General Workers) Order 2022 (No. 4) (Vic)

Pandemic COVID-19 Mandatory Vaccination (Specified Workers) Order 2021 (No. 1) (Vic)

Pandemic COVID-19 Mandatory Vaccination (Specified Workers) Order 2022 (No. 6) (Vic)

Victoria, Victoria Government Gazette (Special), No S 705, 10 December 2021 (Vic)

Cases cited:

Ainsworth v Criminal Justice Commission [1992] HCA 10; (1992) 175 CLR 564

Assistant Commissioner Condon v Pompano Pty Ltd [2013] HCA 7; (2013) 252 CLR 38

Burgundy Royale Investments Pty Ltd v Westpac Banking Corporation (1987) 18 FCR 212

Chu Kheng Lim v Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs (1992) 176 CLR 1

Clubb v Edwards [2019] HCA 11; (2019) 267 CLR 171

Cook v Pasminco Limited [2000] FCA 677; (2000) 99 FCR 548

DBE17 v Commonwealth of Australia [2020] FCA 958

Enfield City Corporation v Development Assessment Commission [2000] HCA 5; (2000) 199 CLR 135

Forster v Jododex Aust Pty Ltd (1972) 127 CLR 421

Gerner v Victoria [2020] HCA 48; (2020) 270 CLR 412

Glennan v Commissioner of Taxation [2003] HCA 31; (2003) 198 ALR 250

Hobart International Airport Pty Ltd v Clarence City Council [2022] HCA 5; (2022) 96 ALJR 234

Kassam v Hazzard [2021] NSWCA 299; (2021) 106 NSWLR 520

Kassam v Hazzard [2021] NSWSC 1320

Kerrison…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wilson v State of Victoria and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 111
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Wilson v State of Victoria involves an application for summary judgment brought by the Applicants against the State of Victoria and the Commonwealth of Australia. The Applicants seek relief in relation to measures taken in Victoria in response to the COVID-19 pandemic, specifically the rollout of vaccines and restrictions imposed on the activities of unvaccinated individuals. The Applicants seek a total of 19 declarations, which range from claims that certain acts or activities of the State of Victoria and/or Commonwealth of Australia relating to the COVID-19 vaccine rollout were beyond power because they were contrary to s 51(xxiiiA) of the Constitution, to claims that announcements made by the Premier and directions made by the Chief Health Officer were not made according to the Occupational Health and Safety Act 2004 (Vic).

The legal issues that the Court was required to decide were whether the Applicants had a reasonable prospect of successfully prosecuting their claims. The Court considered whether the Applicants' claims for relief in respect of both the Commonwealth and the State of Victoria were valid and whether they had a reasonable prospect of success. The Court also considered the public interest and the resources of the Court, and the respondents as government parties, in reaching its decision.

The Court found that the Applicants did not have a reasonable prospect of successfully prosecuting their claims and granted summary judgment in favour of the Respondents. The Court took into account the novelty of some of the allegations and the need to ensure that summary dismissal processes were not used to stultify the development of the law. However, the Court also considered the significant amount of human resources, and public funds, which would be expended on the matter proceeding to a contested trial and the need to direct those resources towards the resolution of controversies in a manner which is proportionate to the nature of the proceeding, to the issues it raises, but also proportionate to its prospects of success. The Court found that the Applicants' claims were unlikely to succeed and that a trial would be a considerable undertaking for all concerned.

The Court ordered that there be summary judgment in the proceeding in favour of the Respondents and that any costs to be awarded in the proceeding be fixed by way of a lump sum. The parties were required to file proposed agreed orders on any orders for lump sum costs in the proceeding or, in the absence of agreement, file written submissions on the appropriate lump sum costs orders to be made in the proceeding.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to s 31A(2) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) and r 26.01 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), there be summary judgment in the proceeding in favour of the Respondents.

2. Any costs to be awarded in the proceeding are to be fixed by way of a lump sum.

3. On or before 4.00 pm on 6 March 2023, the parties:

(a) file proposed agreed orders on any orders for lump sum costs in the proceeding (including reserved costs); alternatively

(b) in the absence of agreement, file written submissions, limited to three (3) pages on the appropriate lump sum costs orders to be made in the proceeding, together with any affidavit material in support of those submissions and a proposed form of order.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Wilson v State of Victoria concerns applications for summary dismissal and strike out by the Applicants against measures taken in Victoria in response to the COVID-19 pandemic. The measures relate to the rollout of COVID-19 vaccines and restrictions imposed on the activities of individuals who were not vaccinated against the virus that causes COVID-19. The Applicants seek 19 declarations regarding the alleged invalidity of these measures based on various grounds including the Constitution, contraventions of Imperial statutes, and incompatibility with the Charter of Human Rights and Responsibilities Act 2008 (Vic). The case arose during the global COVID-19 pandemic, where governments worldwide implemented measures to control the spread of the virus and protect public health.

The matter came before the Federal Court of Australia as an application for summary dismissal and strike out. The Respondents, being the State of Victoria and the Commonwealth of Australia, filed applications seeking to dismiss the Applicants' claims. The Court considered the applications and the Applicants' response, ultimately deciding on the applications and making orders regarding the proceedings. This case did not proceed to a full trial as the Court found the Applicants had no reasonable prospect of success.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In case I am wrong on the question of jurisdiction in relation to the Commonwealth actions, I have considered the Applicants’ claims for relief in respect of both the Commonwealth and the State of Victoria further, below.SUMMARY JUDGMENT This Court may give judgment for a party defending a proceeding if the Court is satisfied that the other party has no reasonable prospect of successfully prosecuting the proceeding: Federal Court Act s 31A, Rules r 26.01. This test does not require a Court to definitively determine that a proceeding is necessarily bound to fail: Federal Court Act s 31A(3); Spencer v Commonwealth [2010] HCA 28; (2010) 241 CLR 118 at 140 [56] (Hayne, Crennan, Kiefel and Bell JJ); Pathmanathan v Healthscope Operations Pty Ltd [2020] FCA 65 at [8(1)] (Steward J). The applicable principles under s 31A(2) or rule 26.01(a), (b), (c) and/or (d) have been summarised recently by Mortimer J in Plaintiff M83A/2019 v Morrison (No 2) [2020] FCA 1198 at [46]–‍[48], DBE17 v Commonwealth of Australia [2020] FCA 958 at [50] and Melville on behalf of the Pitta Pitta People v State of Queensland [2022] FCA 387 at [16]– ‍[20]. The essential question is whether the Applicants have a reasonable prospect of prosecuting all or part of the proceeding. In addressing this question, I note the following caution expressed by Mortimer J most recently in Knowles v Commonwealth of Australia [2022] FCA 741 at [28]–[30]:[28]It can be accepted that reasonable judicial minds may differ over whether allegations in a proceeding have no reasonable prospects of success. The contentions made on behalf of the applicants in this proceeding not unsurprisingly urged considerable caution in forming such a view, especially where the allegations have a novelty to them, as some of the allegations in this proceeding do. I accept the cautionary note sounded by the High Court in Spencer v Commonwealth [2010] HCA 28; 241 CLR 118 to this effect, and the need to ensure that summary dismissal processes are not used to stultify the development of the law: see Spencer at [25]. I have borne that factor in mind.[29]However, it is also the case that the resources of the Court, and the respondents as government parties, are public resources, and should be directed towards the resolution of controversies in a manner which is proportionate to the nature of a proceeding, to the issues it raises, but also proportionate to its prospects of success. Where a summary dismissal application is brought, the greater the size and complexity of a proceeding, the more persuaded a Court may need to be about its prospects before forcing respondents to defend a proceeding to trial, and before allocating to such a trial the finite public resources of the Court. Some of the pleadings in this case (such as the allegations about a joint scheme or agreements between the Commonwealth and other government parties, and indeed the negligence case as pleaded) suggest this proceeding will be resource intensive, and drawn out, with significant processes of discovery. The very nature and range of the responding government parties is indicative of the significant amount of human resources, and public funds, which would be expended on this matter proceeding to a contested trial. The applicants have shown some consciousness of the need to comply with their obligations under ss 37M and 37N of the [Federal Court] Act, but nevertheless, their submissions make it clear they wish to advance wide ranging factual and legal arguments, and to invite the Court to closely scrutinise arrangements by and between the government parties concerning, in particular, the requirements for, and implementation of, a scheme of vaccination for COVID-19, and restrictions relating to COVID-19, across many parts of Australia. A trial will be a considerable undertaking for all concerned.[30]On the other hand, the allegations made on behalf of the applicants concern one of the largest domestic and international health crises in the lifetimes of most members of the Australian community. Lives and livelihoods have been profoundly affected. The various government responses to the crisis are a matter of substantial public interest … [T]he subject matter of this proceeding means, in my opinion, the Court should be firmly persuaded that the allegations do not justify a trial. I have taken what I consider to be an appropriately cautious approach to whether the various claims have reasonable prospects of success, and I have borne the High Court’s obiter comments in Spencer steadily in mind in my assessment.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Respondents also sought costs.DECLARATIONS SOUGHT BY THE APPLICANTS By their amended originating application dated 21 January 2022, the Applicants seek relief in relation to measures taken in Victoria in response to the COVID-19 pandemic, being measures that related to the rollout of vaccines and restrictions imposed on the activities of individuals who were not vaccinated against the virus that causes COVID-19. By their amended originating application, the Applicants seek 19 declarations (set out in Annexure A). The declarations fall into the following categories:(a)Declarations that certain acts or activities of the State of Victoria and/or Commonwealth of Australia relating to the COVID-19 vaccine rollout, and Victorian Government measures restricting the activities of unvaccinated people in Victoria, were beyond power because they were contrary to s 51(xxiiiA) of the Constitution (Declarations 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 13).(b)A declaration that Sch 1 of the National Health Amendment (COVID-19) Act 2021 (Cth) was beyond power as it was contrary to s 51(xxiiiA) of the Constitution (Declaration 7).(c)Declarations that certain announcements by the Premier of the State of Victoria and measures introduced by the Victorian Government (by way of directions made by the Chief Health Officer of Victoria or orders made by the Minister) breached the Magna Carta 1297 (Imp) 25 Edw I c. XXIX, as enacted by Pt II Div 3 of the Imperial Acts Application Act 1980 (Vic) (Declarations 1, 8 and 16).(d)A declaration that the State of Victoria and the Commonwealth breached the Monopolies Act 1623–4 (Imp) 21 or 21 and 22 Jac I c. III ss 1 and 6, as enacted by Pt II Div 4 of the Imperial Acts Application Act, by “compounding laws to lock out the Second Applicant from the Vaccinated Economy in favour of vaccinated people” (Declaration 9).(e)A declaration that announcements made by the Premier and directions made by the Chief Health Officer were not made according to the Occupational Health and Safety Act 2004 (Vic) (Declarations 10 and 11).(f)A declaration that announcements made by the Premier and subsequently implemented were “unlawfully incompatible” with the Charter of Human Rights and Responsibilities Act 2008 (Vic) (Declaration 12).(g)A declaration that advice in National Cabinet statements was incorrect (Declaration 14).(h)A declaration that advice provided by the Fair Work Ombudsman was “incompetent” (Declaration 15).(i)A declaration that the State of Victoria breached the Confirmation of Liberties Act 1405–6 (Imp) 7 Henry IV c. I, as enacted by Pt II Div 3 of the Imperial Acts Application Act, by restricting entry to the workplace (Declaration 17).(j)Public health orders restricting the activities of unvaccinated individuals were invalid as they were contrary to the separation of powers under Ch III of the Constitution (Declarations 18 and 19).(k)Public health orders restricting the activities of unvaccinated individuals were invalid as they were contrary to the Charter (Declarations 18 and 19).