Tomcsanyi v National Australia Bank Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CHAMBERS

CITATION:   TOMCSANYI -v- NATIONAL AUSTRALIA BANK LTD [2015] WASC 448

CORAM:   ACTING MASTER GETHING

HEARD:   20 & 21 OCTOBER 2015

DELIVERED          :   30 NOVEMBER 2015

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1427 of 2014

BETWEEN:   LEWIS MICHAEL TOMCSANYI

MICHELLE ELIZABETH TOMCSANYI
Plaintiffs

AND

NATIONAL AUSTRALIA BANK LTD
Defendant

Catchwords:

Contract - Mortgage - Whether breach excused innocent party from compliance - Causation of damages - Mitigation of damages - Ejectment

Legislation:

Australian Consumer Law, s 21

Result:

Claim dismissed
Judgment awarded to defendant, including right to possession

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiffs:     In person

Defendant:     Ms E C Hensler

Solicitors:

Plaintiffs:     In person

Defendant:     Allens Linklaters

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) v CG Berbatis Holdings Pty Ltd [2003] HCA 18; (2003) 214 CLR 51

Australian Goldfields NL (in liq) v North Australian Diamonds NL [2009] WASCA 98

Bak v Glenleigh Homes Pty Ltd [2006] NSWCA 10

Brian Fletcher as Trustee of the Brian Fletcher Family Trust v St George Bank Ltd [No 2] [2011] WASC 277

British Westinghouse Electric Co Ltd v Underground Electric Railways Co Ltd [1912] AC 673

Chappel v Hart [1998] HCA 55; (1998) 195 CLR 232

Commercial Bank of Australia v Amadio [1983] HCA 14; (1983) 151 CLR 447

Commonwealth v Amann Aviation Pty Ltd [1991] HCA 54; (1991) 174 CLR 64

Finding v Commonwealth Bank of Australia [2001] 1 Qd R 168

Foran v Wight [1989] HCA 51; (1989) 168 CLR 385

Glew v Frank Jasper Pty Ltd [2010] WASCA 87

Golby v Commonwealth Bank of Australia (1996) 72 FCR 134

Hungerfords v Walker [1989] HCA 8; (1989) 171 CLR 125

Ibrahim v The Honourable Justice Carolyn Martin [2012] WASC 338

Lambert v Lewis [1982] AC 225

Mackinlay v Derry Dew Pty Ltd [2014] WASCA 24; (2014) 46 WAR 247

Mallesons Stephen Jaques v Trenorth Ltd [1999] 1 VR 727

March v E & MH Stramare Pty Ltd [1991] HCA 12; (1991) 171 CLR 506

McKenzie v McKenzie [1971] P 33

McPhail v Persons Unknown [1973] Ch 447

Motium Pty Ltd v Arrow Electronics Australia Pty Ltd [2011] WASCA 65

MTI v SUL [No 2] [2010] WASCA 58

Murphy v Zamonex Pty Ltd (1993) 31 NSWLR 439

Permanent Mortgages Pty Ltd v Vandenbergh [2010] WASC 10; (2010) 41 WAR 353

Reg Glass Pty Ltd v Rivers Locking Systems Pty Ltd [1968] HCA 64; (1968) 120 CLR 516

Robinson v Harman (1848) 1 Exch 850; (1848) 154 ER 363

Sacher Investments Pty Ltd v Forma Stereo Consultants Pty Ltd [1976] 1 NSWLR 5

Schagen v The Queen (1993) 8 WAR 410

Smart v Prisoner Review Board (WA) [2012] WASC 48

Tabcorp Holdings Ltd v Bowen Investments Pty Ltd [2009] HCA 8; (2009) 83 ALJR 390

TC Industrial Plant Pty Ltd v Robert's Queensland Pty Ltd [1963] HCA 57; (1963) 180 CLR 130

TCN Channel 9 Pty Ltd v Hayden Enterprises Pty…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tomcsanyi v National Australia Bank Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] WASC 448
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Lewis Tomcsanyi, the registered proprietor of the Denmark Farm, brought an action against National Australia Bank Ltd (Bank) seeking damages for breach of a settlement deed. The settlement deed was executed on 21 February 2012 to settle a dispute between the parties. Under the terms of the settlement deed, Mr Tomcsanyi's liability to the Bank was reduced to $765,000. Mr Tomcsanyi claims that the Bank breached the settlement deed by issuing automatically generated bank statements which did not reflect the reduced liability. He contends that this breach impeded his ability to refinance the Denmark Farm and pay the Bank the reduced amount due under the settlement deed. The Bank contends that it is not liable for damages for breach of the settlement deed because Mr Tomcsanyi failed to mitigate his losses by making alternative arrangements to pay the Bank the amount due under the settlement deed.

The court was required to determine whether the Bank breached the settlement deed by issuing automatically generated bank statements which did not reflect the reduced liability owed by Mr Tomcsanyi. If so, the court had to determine whether the Bank was liable for damages for breach of the settlement deed. The court also had to consider whether Mr Tomcsanyi had mitigated his losses by making alternative arrangements to pay the Bank the amount due under the settlement deed.

The court held that the Bank breached the settlement deed by issuing automatically generated bank statements which did not reflect the reduced liability owed by Mr Tomcsanyi. However, the court held that the Bank was not liable for damages for breach of the settlement deed because Mr Tomcsanyi failed to mitigate his losses. The court held that Mr Tomcsanyi had an obligation to make alternative arrangements to pay the Bank the amount due under the settlement deed and that he failed to do so. The court held that Mr Tomcsanyi's failure to mitigate his losses was a breach of his obligation under the settlement deed and that this breach prevented him from recovering damages for breach of the settlement deed by the Bank. The court held that the Bank was entitled to payment of the amount due under the settlement deed and possession of the Denmark Farm. The court ordered that Mr and Mrs Tomcsanyi pay the Bank $765,000 and that the Bank be granted possession of the Denmark Farm.

Background

Background to the litigation

Background Lewis Tomcsanyi is the registered proprietor of three lots of land near Denmark, which I will refer to as 'the Denmark Farm'. In 2009 he borrowed around $4.4 million from the National Australia Bank Ltd (Bank) to acquire another farm and a house in Albany. This loan was secured by mortgages over the Denmark Farm. At some stage prior to 2011 a dispute arose between Mr and Mrs Tomcsanyi, the Bank and a lawyer who had advised Mr Tomcsanyi, Craig Sutherland. The dispute led to Mr and Mrs Tomcsanyi commencing an action in the Supreme Court. This action was ultimately settled at a mediation conference. The parties recorded their settlement in a settlement deed dated 21 February 2012 (Settlement Deed).[1][1] Exhibit D1. A key aspect of the terms of the Settlement Deed was that Mr Tomcsanyi's liability to the Bank was to be reduced to $765,000, which was to be paid to the Bank 12 months after the date of execution of the Settlement Deed. After the Settlement Deed was executed, automatically generated bank statements in respect of the accounts with the Bank the subject of the Settlement Deed were sent to Mr Tomcsanyi which did not reflect the reduction agreed to in the Settlement Deed. Mr Tomcsanyi asserts that the issue by the Bank of these automatically generated bank statements constitutes a breach of the Settlement Deed. He says that the breach caused him to incur significant damages in that it impeded his ability to refinance the Denmark Farm so as to be able to pay out the remaining amount due under the Settlement Deed. The Bank asserts that the automatically generated account statements were no more than internal bank documents. At all times, including in the present action, the Bank has remained committed to the position that the principal amount owing under the Settlement Deed is $765,000. Mr Tomcsanyi did not pay the Bank the $765,000 when due under the Settlement Deed, being 21 February 2013. The Bank asserts that, under the terms of the Settlement Deed, this meant that Mr Tomcsanyi was in default of the relevant finance facility and the mortgage over the Denmark Farm. The Bank then proceeded to attempt to enforce the mortgage. Mr and Mrs Tomcsanyi remain in possession of the Denmark Farm. On 28 March 2014 Mr and Mrs Tomcsanyi commenced this action. They seek damages in the order of $5 million for breach of the Settlement Deed by the Bank. The Bank counterclaimed seeking payment of the money due under the Settlement Deed and possession of the Denmark Farm. All parties accept and purport to abide by the terms of the Settlement Deed. The trial of the action took place before me on 20 and 21 October 2015. Mr and Mrs Tomcsanyi were not represented by a lawyer. They were, however, very ably assisted at the trial by a 'McKenzie friend'[2], Mr Jonas Ferguson. It is appropriate that I express my gratitude to Mr Ferguson for his assistance. His assistance ensured that Mr and Mrs Tomcsanyi's case was put before the court in its most cogent form. Notwithstanding Mr Ferguson's assistance, it is appropriate that I treat Mr and Mrs Tomcsanyi as litigants in person. This means that it is appropriate that I approach the documents in which they articulate their claim (and defence to counterclaim) with some flexibility.[3] They may require, and be given, some leniency in relation to compliance with the rules set out in the Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA) (RSC).[4] I need to be astute to ensure that, in a poorly expressed or unstructured document setting out their claim, there is no claim which, with appropriate amendment or permissible assistance from the court, could be put into proper form.[5]

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the breach of the Settlement Deed by the Bank excused Mr Tomcsanyi from compliance with its terms.
2. Whether the damages claimed by Mr Tomcsanyi were caused by the Bank's breach of the Settlement Deed.
3. Whether Mr Tomcsanyi mitigated his damages in response to the Bank's breach.
4. Whether the Bank was entitled to eject Mr and Mrs Tomcsanyi from the Denmark Farm.

Held
1. The court held that the breach of the Settlement Deed by the Bank excused Mr Tomcsanyi from compliance with its terms.
2. The court held that the damages claimed by Mr Tomcsanyi were not caused by the Bank's breach of the Settlement Deed.
3. The court held that Mr Tomcsanyi did not mitigate his damages in response to the Bank's breach.
4. The court held that the Bank was not entitled to eject Mr and Mrs Tomcsanyi from the Denmark Farm.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered whether the breach of the Settlement Deed by the Bank excused Mr Tomcsanyi from compliance with its terms. The Settlement Deed provided that Mr Tomcsanyi's liability to the Bank was to be reduced to $765,000, which was to be paid to the Bank 12 months after the date of execution of the Settlement Deed. The court found that the Bank's breach in issuing automatically generated bank statements that did not reflect the reduction agreed to in the Settlement Deed excused Mr Tomcsanyi from compliance with the terms of the Settlement Deed. This was because the breach had the effect of preventing Mr Tomcsanyi from being able to refinance the Denmark Farm and pay out the remaining amount due under the Settlement Deed.

The court also considered whether the damages claimed by Mr Tomcsanyi were caused by the Bank's breach of the Settlement Deed. The court found that Mr Tomcsanyi's failure to pay the $765,000 when due under the Settlement Deed was not caused by the Bank's breach, but rather by Mr Tomcsanyi's own decision not to pay the amount due. The court found that Mr Tomcsanyi had not taken any steps to mitigate his damages in response to the Bank's breach.

Finally, the court considered whether the Bank was entitled to eject Mr and Mrs Tomcsanyi from the Denmark Farm. The court found that the Bank was not entitled to eject Mr and Mrs Tomcsanyi from the Denmark Farm because they were not in default of the relevant finance facility and the mortgage over the Denmark Farm. The court found that the Bank had remained committed to the position that the principal amount owing under the Settlement Deed was $765,000, and that Mr Tomcsanyi had not paid this amount when due.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that a breach of a settlement deed by one party can excuse the other party from compliance with the terms of the deed if the breach has the effect of preventing the other party from being able to comply with the terms of the deed. However, if the party who has been excused from compliance with the terms of the deed fails to take steps to mitigate their damages, they will not be entitled to damages for the breach. Additionally, if the party who has breached the settlement deed is not entitled to eject the other party from property secured by a mortgage, they will not be able to enforce the mortgage.