The Owners - Units Plan No 1917 v Koundouris (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

The Owners – Units Plan No 1917 v Koundouris

Citation:

[2016] ACTSC 96

Hearing Dates:

29-30 June 2015, 1-3 and 6-8 July 2015

Date last submissions received:

19 August 2015

DecisionDate:

13 May 2016

Before:

Mossop AsJ

Decision:

See [616]

Catchwords:

STATUTORY INTERPRETATION – BUILDING CONTRACTS – Building Act 1972 (ACT) s 58C – warranties implied into contracts for the sale of a residential building and contract to carry out residential building work to which the builder is a party – consideration of the two categories of contracts to which the section applies – comma in s 58C(1) cannot be read out – meaning of “has been or will be” – whether warranties involve ongoing or one off obligation on builder – rights of successors in title – meaning of “expire at the end of the prescribed period” – period within which a claim may be commenced varies according to category of contract the warranties are implied into

BUILDING CONTRACTS – Building Act 2004 (ACT) s 88 – warranties implied into “every contract for the sale of a residential building” – changes to “prescribed period” – end date for warranties in contracts of sale – period varies depending on whether defect is in “non-structural elements” or “structural elements” – “structural element” broadly defined

UNIT TITLES – entitlement of owners corporation to bring proceedings for breach of warranties under Building Act 1972 (ACT) and Building Act 2004 (ACT) – entitlement of unit owners to recover as damages proportional share of amounts paid by owners corporation

UNIT TITLES – maintenance obligations of owners corporation under Unit Titles Act 1970 (ACT) and Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 (ACT) – significance of boundaries of units – boundary runs along the centre of the relevant floor, wall or ceiling –– expansion of obligations of owners corporation to “defined parts” of the building – extent of obligation – whether that includes waterproofing to slabs

STATUTORY INTERPRETATION – Limitation Act 1985 (ACT) s 40 – extension of limitation period for action in relation to latent damage to property – provision not limited to cases in tort – section permits extension of time for causes of action in contract

LIMITATION PERIODS – Limitation Act 1981 (ACT) s 40 – extension of limitation period for action in relation to latent damage to property – whether damage latent – extent of latency – assessment of matters in s 40(2) – case where defects were known for some time – significance of owners’ failure to investigate defects and obtain independent advice – not fair and reasonable to extend time

NEGLIGENCE – whether builder owed a duty of care to the owners to carry out and supervise building work with reasonable care to ensure that the building work was carried out in a proper and workmanlike manner and in accordance with the statutory warranties – no duty of care arose with respect to defects in the original construction due to existence of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Owners - Units Plan No 1917 v Koundouris (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] ACTSC 151
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, the Owners Corporation for Units Plan No 1917 and the Unit Owners (the plaintiff) commenced proceedings against the builder of the building, Mr Koundouris (the first defendant), and the developer, Koundouris Projects (the second defendant) (the defendants). The plaintiffs alleged that the defendants were liable in damages for a series of breaches of statutory warranties implied into the contracts for the sale of the residential units and for carrying out the building work. The plaintiffs further pleaded that the defendants were liable for negligence in failing to carry out the building work with reasonable care and skill. The defendants denied liability and pleaded, among other things, that the plaintiffs' claims were statute-barred. The plaintiffs sought damages in relation to the breach of statutory warranties, the failure to carry out the building work with reasonable care and skill, and for misleading and deceptive conduct in relation to the rectification of defects in the building. The court was required to determine a number of issues. The first was the proper interpretation of s 58C of the Building Act 1972 (ACT). The section implied warranties into contracts for the sale of a residential building and contracts to carry out residential building work. The court had to determine the meaning of the comma in s 58C(1), whether the warranties involved an ongoing or one off obligation on the builder, the meaning of the phrase “expire at the end of the prescribed period” and the period within which a claim may be commenced varied according to the category of contract the warranties were implied into. The court also had to determine the proper interpretation of s 88 of the Building Act 2004 (ACT) and the effect of changes to the “prescribed period” on the end date for warranties in contracts of sale. The court further had to determine the meaning of “structural element” under that section. The court was also required to determine the entitlements of the Owners Corporation and Unit Owners in relation to breaches of statutory warranties, including whether the Owners Corporation could bring proceedings for breach of warranties and whether Unit Owners could recover as damages a proportional share of amounts paid by the Owners Corporation. The court also had to determine the extent of the maintenance obligations of the Owners Corporation under the Unit Titles Act 1970 (ACT) and the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 (ACT). The court also had to determine whether the Limitation Act 1985 (ACT) permitted an extension of the limitation period for an action in relation to latent damage to property and whether, in the circumstances of this case, the limitation period should be extended. The court was also required to determine whether the builder owed a duty of care to the owners to carry out and supervise building work with reasonable care to ensure that the building work was carried out in a proper and workmanlike manner and in accordance with the statutory warranties. The court further had to determine whether there was misleading and deceptive conduct under the Fair Trading Act 1992 (ACT) and Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth). Finally, the court was required to determine whether an estoppel arose to prevent reliance on limitation defences.

The court held that the comma in s 58C(1) of the 1972 Act could not be read out, as that would alter the meaning of the section. The court held that the warranties implied into contracts for the sale of a residential building involved an ongoing obligation on the builder. The court held that the phrase “expire at the end of the prescribed period” meant that the period within which a claim may be commenced varied according to the category of contract the warranties were implied into. The court held that s 88 of the 2004 Act provided that the end date for warranties in contracts of sale varied depending on whether the defect was in “non-structural elements” or “structural elements”. The court held that “structural element” was broadly defined. The court held that the Owners Corporation was entitled to bring proceedings for breach of warranties under the 1972 Act and 2004 Act. The court held that Unit Owners were entitled to recover as damages a proportional share of amounts paid by the Owners Corporation. The court held that the Owners Corporation had maintenance obligations under the Unit Titles Act 1970 (ACT) and Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 (ACT) and that the boundary between units ran along the centre of the relevant floor, wall or ceiling. The court held that the owners corporation’s obligations extended to “defined parts” of the building and that this included waterproofing to slabs. The court held that the Limitation Act 1985 (ACT) permitted an extension of the limitation period for an action in relation to latent damage to property and that section was not limited to cases in tort. The court held that the period within which a claim may be commenced varied according to the category of contract the warranties were implied into. The court held that in the circumstances of this case it was not fair and reasonable to extend the time. The court held that the builder did not owe a duty of care to the owners to carry out and supervise building work with reasonable care to ensure that the building work was carried out in a proper and workmanlike manner and in accordance with the statutory warranties. The court held that the builder did owe a duty of care in relation to attempts to repair original defective work. The court held that this duty was not one which required bringing the building works up to standard required by the statutory warranties but was a duty to avoid foreseeable loss to the owners arising from undertaking the repair work. The court held that there was no misleading and deceptive conduct under the Fair Trading Act 1992 (ACT) and Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth). The court held that no estoppel arose to prevent reliance on limitation defences.

ORDERS:
The court dismissed the claims of the plaintiff.

Orders

Orders of the court

See [616]

Background

Background to the litigation

The Owners Corporation for Units Plan No 1917 (Owners Corporation) commenced proceedings against the builder, Mr Koundouris, and the developer, Koundouris Projects, concerning defects in a residential building known as the Lagani Apartments. The building was completed in December 2000, and a Certificate of Occupancy was issued. Shortly after completion, unit owners began reporting leaks and water penetration issues. Mr Koundouris, the builder, engaged with the Owners Corporation and individual unit owners in an attempt to rectify these problems over the years from 2001 to 2009, but his efforts were largely ineffective. The Owners Corporation and unit owners eventually sought independent advice to properly address the defects and sought a financial contribution from the defendants towards the cost of the necessary work. When no agreement was reached, the proceedings were commenced.

The Owners Corporation's Amended Statement of Claim outlines five causes of action against one or both of the defendants. The first cause of action alleges a breach of statutory warranties by Mr Koundouris in relation to the Building Contract and Further Building Work. The Building Contract refers to the agreement between Mr Koundouris and Koundouris Projects for the construction of the Lagani Apartments, and the Building Work refers to the actual construction. The Further Building Work relates to the efforts Mr Koundouris made from March 2001 to investigate and repair defects in the Building Work. The plaintiff claims that statutory warranties were implied into the Building Contract by the Building Act 1972 (ACT) and the Building Act 2004 (ACT), and that the Further Building Work was to be undertaken in accordance with specified statutory requirements.

The remaining causes of action concern various statutory and common law claims, including issues related to the statutory interpretation of warranties implied into building contracts, the entitlements of the Owners Corporation and unit owners under the Building Act 1972 (ACT) and Building Act 2004 (ACT), maintenance obligations of the Owners Corporation under the Unit Titles Act 1970 (ACT) and the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 (ACT), the extension of limitation periods for actions related to latent damage under the Limitation Act 1985 (ACT) and the Limitation Act 1981 (ACT), the duty of care owed by the builder, and claims of misleading and deceptive conduct under the Fair Trading Act 1992 (ACT) and the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth). The proceedings also address whether an estoppel arose to prevent the defendants from relying on limitation defences.

The Owners Corporation for Units Plan No 1917, acting on behalf of the current and former owners of the units in the Lagani Apartments, brought this action against the builder, Mr Koundouris, and the developer, Koundouris Projects. The case initially came before the court following complaints from unit owners about defects in the building, particularly water penetration into the units and basement carpark. The Owners Corporation and individual unit owners sought to hold Mr Koundouris and Koundouris Projects responsible for these defects, claiming breach of statutory warranties implied into the original building contract and further building work to rectify the defects. The proceedings were initiated after attempts to negotiate a financial contribution towards the cost of rectifying the defects failed. The case involved substantial pleadings, with the Owners Corporation asserting five causes of action against the defendants. These included claims for breach of statutory warranties, negligence, misleading and deceptive conduct, and estoppel. The case proceeded through several stages, including interlocutory applications and procedural rulings, before reaching the final hearing.

On appeal from the first instance decision, the defendants challenged the trial judge's interpretation of the statutory warranties implied into the building contract, the rights of the Owners Corporation to bring proceedings on behalf of the unit owners, and the applicability of various limitation periods. The defendants also contested the Owners Corporation's claims for damages and the extent of their own obligations under the statutory warranties and related legislation. The appeal focused on the interpretation of statutory provisions, the procedural rights of the parties, and the application of limitation periods to the claims brought by the Owners Corporation. The appeal court considered these issues in the context of the extensive factual background provided in the trial judgment and the arguments advanced by both parties.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the comma in s 58C(1) of the Building Act 1972 (ACT) signify a distinction in the application of warranties between contracts for the sale of a residential building and contracts to carry out residential building work?

2. What is the meaning of "has been or will be" in s 58C of the Building Act 1972 (ACT) and does it denote an ongoing or one-off obligation on the builder?

3. How should the phrase "expire at the end of the prescribed period" in s 58C of the Building Act 1972 (ACT) be interpreted in relation to the rights of successors in title?

4. What is the period within which a claim may be commenced for breach of statutory warranties under the Building Act 1972 (ACT) and Building Act 2004 (ACT) and does it vary according to the category of contract?

5. Does the Building Act 2004 (ACT) s 88 imply warranties into "every contract for the sale of a residential building"?

6. What are the end dates for warranties in contracts of sale under the Building Act 2004 (ACT) s 88 and how do they vary depending on the type of defect?

7. What is the definition of a "structural element" under the Building Act 2004 (ACT) s 88?

8. Do owners corporations have the entitlement to bring proceedings for breach of warranties under the Building Act 1972 (ACT) and Building Act 2004 (ACT)?

9. Are unit owners entitled to recover as damages their proportional share of amounts paid by the owners corporation?

10. What are the maintenance obligations of owners corporations under the Unit Titles Act 1970 (ACT) and Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 (ACT) and do they extend to waterproofing to slabs?

11. Does s 40 of the Limitation Act 1985 (ACT) permit the extension of the limitation period for actions in relation to latent damage to property in cases involving contract, not limited to cases in tort?

12. In the context of s 40 of the Limitation Act 1981 (ACT), what factors should be considered when determining whether to extend the limitation period for latent damage to property and is it fair and reasonable to do so in this case?

13. Did the builder owe a duty of care to the owners to carry out and supervise building work with reasonable care to ensure that the building work was carried out in a proper and workmanlike manner and in accordance with the statutory warranties?

14. Did the builder owe a duty of care to the owners to avoid foreseeable loss arising from attempts to repair original defective work?

15. Are the representations made under the Fair Trading Act 1992 (ACT) and Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) operative at the point where the plaintiff acted or failed to act as a result of them and do they amount to representations that there were no defects?

16. Did estoppel arise to prevent reliance on limitation defences and did the defendant's conduct generate a reasonable expectation on the part of the plaintiff?

Held
1. The comma in s 58C(1) of the Building Act 1972 (ACT) does not signify a distinction in the application of warranties between contracts for the sale of a residential building and contracts to carry out residential building work.

2. The phrase "has been or will be" in s 58C of the Building Act 1972 (ACT) denotes an ongoing obligation on the builder.

3. The phrase "expire at the end of the prescribed period" in s 58C of the Building Act 1972 (ACT) should be interpreted as meaning that the rights of successors in title are contingent upon the expiry of the prescribed period.

4. The period within which a claim may be commenced for breach of statutory warranties varies according to the category of contract; it is shorter for contracts for the sale of a residential building than for contracts to carry out residential building work.

5. The Building Act 2004 (ACT) s 88 does imply warranties into "every contract for the sale of a residential building".

6. The end dates for warranties in contracts of sale under the Building Act 2004 (ACT) s 88 vary depending on the type of defect, with a shorter period for non-structural elements and a longer period for structural elements.

7. The definition of a "structural element" under the Building Act 2004 (ACT) s 88 is broad and includes significant components of the building.

8. Owners corporations do have the entitlement to bring proceedings for breach of warranties under the Building Act 1972 (ACT) and Building Act 2004 (ACT).

9. Unit owners are entitled to recover as damages their proportional share of amounts paid by the owners corporation.

10. The maintenance obligations of owners corporations under the Unit Titles Act 1970 (ACT) and Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 (ACT) extend to waterproofing to slabs.

11. Section 40 of the Limitation Act 1985 (ACT) permits the extension of the limitation period for actions in relation to latent damage to property in cases involving contract, not limited to cases in tort.

12. When determining whether to extend the limitation period for latent damage to property under s 40 of the Limitation Act 1981 (ACT), factors such as the extent of latency and the owners' failure to investigate defects should be considered; it was not fair and reasonable to extend the time in this case.

13. The builder did not owe a duty of care to the owners to carry out and supervise building work to ensure compliance with statutory warranties, but did owe a duty of care in relation to attempts to repair original defective work.

14. The builder owed a duty of care to the owners to avoid foreseeable loss arising from attempts to repair original defective work.

15. The representations made under the Fair Trading Act 1992 (ACT) and Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) were operative at the point where the plaintiff acted or failed to act as a result of them and did amount to representations that there were no defects.

16. Estoppel did not arise to prevent reliance on limitation defences and the defendant's conduct did not generate a reasonable expectation on the part of the plaintiff.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The plaintiff is the Owners Corporation for Units Plan No 1917 (Owners Corporation), created shortly after the building was completed. The plaintiff also had assigned to it the rights of the current owners of the units in the units plan (the Unit Owners). The first defendant is the builder of the building. The second defendant is the developer, that is, the owner of the land on which the building was built. A Certificate of Occupancy for the building was issued on 20 December 2000 and the units in the building were sold to incoming purchasers. The present owners of the units are a mix of those who originally purchased the units and those who have bought from original or subsequent purchasers in the period since then. Shortly after the building was completed, owners started making complaints, most particularly in relation to leaks into the units and into the basement carpark. When responding to these complaints the first defendant, Mr Koundouris, continued to engage in a friendly and apparently helpful way with the Owners Corporation and individual unit owners. Over the period from 2001 until 2009, he continued to attempt to rectify or repair problems with the units arising, principally, from water penetration. The steps he took to rectify the underlying causes of water penetration were ineffective. Finally, when the owners and Owners Corporation decided to seek independent advice as to how to properly remedy defects, they sought a financial contribution to the cost of that work from the first or second defendant. No agreement could be reached and these proceedings were commenced. In the reasons that follow I will refer to the plaintiff as the Owners Corporation. I will refer to the second defendant as “Koundouris Projects”, the name under which the company traded. The pleadings in the case are substantial. The following summary of the pleadings is an attempt to highlight the significant issues that arise out of them rather than to recapitulate them in detail. In its Amended Statement of Claim (ASOC) the plaintiff pleads five causes of action against one or other or both of the defendants. The plaintiff identifies that it sues not only in its own capacity, but also as an assignee of the rights of the individual unit owners to take legal action for the recovery of loss and damage suffered by each: ASOC [8]. The first cause of action is an action for breach of statutory warranties by Mr Koundouris. It is alleged that he entered into a contract with Koundouris Projects to construct the Lagani Apartments. This is referred to as the Building Contract. He then constructed the building. This is referred to as the Building Work. It is then alleged that from March 2001, Mr Koundouris undertook further residential building work to investigate and repair defects in the Building Work. This was referred to as the Further Building Work: ASOC [11A]. The plaintiff pleads that the Building Contract had various statutory warranties implied into it by the Building Act 1972 (ACT) (1972 Act) and the Building Act 2004 (ACT) (2004 Act). These are referred to as the Statutory Warranties. Further, the plaintiff pleads that the Further Building Work was to be undertaken in accordance with certain specified statutory requirements. These are referred to as the Statutory Requirements.