SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY
Case Title: | The Owners – Units Plan No 1917 v Koundouris (No 3) |
Citation: | [2016] ACTSC 184 |
| Hearing Date: Date last submissions received: | Determined on written submissions 18 July 2016 |
DecisionDate: | 26 July 2016 |
Before: | Mossop AsJ |
Decision: | The first defendant is to pay the plaintiff’s costs of the proceedings. |
Catchwords: | COSTS – Exercise of costs discretion under Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT), r 1721 – Costs will ordinarily follow the event – Whether apportionment of costs appropriate where plaintiff’s claim only partially successful – Multiple causes of action arising out of single set of facts – Effect of purported offer of compromise – Whether it operates as a Calderbank offer – Apportionment not appropriate – Costs follow the event – Position of second defendant controlled by first defendant or his family – No separate costs order in relation to second defendant |
Legislation Cited: | Court Procedures Act 2004 (ACT), s 5A Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT), rr 1002, 1721 |
Cases Cited: | Bowen Investments Pty Ltd v Tabcorp Holdings Ltd (No 2) [2008] FCAFC 107 Hockey v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd (No 2) (2015) 237 FCR 127 Waters v PC Henderson (Australia) Pty Ltd (1994) 254 ALR 328 |
Parties: | The Owners – Units Plan No 1917 (Plaintiff) Michael Koundouris (First Defendant) Acro Pty Ltd (Second Defendant) |
Representation: | Counsel Mr G Shaw (Plaintiff) Mr B F Katekar (Defendants) |
| Solicitors Minter Ellison (Plaintiff) Trinity Law (Defendants) | |
File Number: | SC 817 of 2010 |
MOSSOP AsJ:
Introduction
I gave the judgment in this matter on 13 May 2016: The Owners – Units Plan No 1917 v Koundouris [2016] ACTSC 96. I gave a decision in relation to the awarding of interest and the making of final orders on 5 July 2016: The Owners – Units Plan No 1917 v Koundouris (No 2) [2016] ACTSC 151.
The plaintiff has now sought orders in relation to costs as follows:
(a)the first defendant pay the plaintiff’s costs of the proceedings on a party and party basis;
(b)no order as to costs in relation to the proceedings against the second defendant.
In contrast, the defendants submitted that in the light of their success on some issues and the making of an offer of settlement, the Court should make an apportionment of the costs between the issues in the trial and, or perhaps alternatively, that the plaintiff should pay the defendants’ costs after 23 June 2015 on an indemnity basis.
The costs question proceeded by way of written submissions in…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read The Owners - Units Plan No 1917 v Koundouris (No 3) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] ACTSC 184
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues primarily revolved around the discretion to apportion costs under the Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT). The court had to determine whether it was appropriate to apportion costs between the parties given that the plaintiff's claims were only partially successful. Additionally, the court needed to consider the effect of a purported offer of compromise by one of the defendants, assessing whether it qualified as a Calderbank offer, and how this might influence the costs decision. The relationship between the defendants was also examined, particularly whether the second defendant's position was controlled by the first defendant or his family, which could impact the costs order.
The court ruled that apportionment of costs was not appropriate in this instance because the plaintiff's claims were only partially successful. The court held that costs should ordinarily follow the event, and since the plaintiff had not entirely prevailed, the defendants should bear the costs. The court also found that the second defendant's position was controlled by the first defendant or his family, and therefore, no separate costs order should be made in relation to the second defendant. Consequently, the first defendant was ordered to pay the plaintiff's costs of the proceedings.
The court’s final orders mandated that the first defendant pay the plaintiff’s costs of the proceedings. The second defendant was not subject to a separate costs order due to the controlling relationship with the first defendant. This decision underscores the importance of the nature of the claims, the success achieved by the plaintiff, and the relationship between defendants when exercising costs discretion in litigation.
Orders
Orders of the court
The first defendant is to pay the plaintiff’s costs of the proceedings.
Background
Background to the litigation
Subsequently, the plaintiff amended the statement of claim to include claims against the second defendant, Mr. Koundouris's parents, who were alleged to be jointly liable for the breaches of the Strata Schemes Management Act 1996 (ACT) and the Body Corporate and Common Property (Management) Act 1997 (ACT) due to their association with the unauthorised modifications. The plaintiff sought various remedies, including an order for Mr. Koundouris to rectify the unauthorised modifications, compensation for damage to the common property, and costs.
The defendants, Mr. Koundouris and his parents, denied the allegations and defended the proceedings. During the course of the litigation, Mr. Koundouris made a purported offer of compromise, which the plaintiff did not accept. The plaintiff's claim was only partially successful, as the court found that the first defendant, Mr. Koundouris, was liable for the breaches of the Acts but found no liability on the part of the second defendant, Mr. Koundouris's parents. The court also determined that the position of the second defendant was controlled by the first defendant or his family, and thus, there was no basis for a separate costs order against the second defendant.
The Owners - Units Plan No 1917 v Koundouris (No 3) commenced as a proceeding in the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal (ACAT) concerning disputes arising from the management and administration of a unit plan. Following the ACAT’s determination, the plaintiff, The Owners - Units Plan No 1917, appealed certain aspects of the decision to the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory. The appeal was subsequently heard as a first-instance matter before the Court, focusing on the allocation of costs following a partial success in the plaintiff’s claims. Prior to the appeal, the ACAT had already ruled on various issues, including a purported offer of compromise made by the plaintiff, which was considered in the context of a Calderbank offer. During the proceedings, several interlocutory applications were filed, and orders were made concerning the scope and conduct of the litigation. The Court was tasked with determining the appropriate exercise of its discretion under the Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT), particularly regarding the apportionment of costs where the plaintiff’s claims were only partially successful and multiple causes of action arose from a single set of facts. The second defendant's procedural position was largely controlled by the first defendant or his family, leading to considerations regarding separate costs orders.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the court should apportion costs where the plaintiff’s claim is only partially successful.
2. How to determine the appropriate costs order in cases where multiple causes of action arise out of a single set of facts.
3. Whether the purported offer of compromise operates as a Calderbank offer.
4. Whether it is appropriate to make a separate costs order in relation to the second defendant, who was controlled by the first defendant or his family.
Held
1. Whether the court should apportion costs where the plaintiff’s claim is only partially successful. The court concluded that apportionment of costs was not appropriate in this case; instead, costs were to follow the event.
2. How to determine the appropriate costs order in cases where multiple causes of action arise out of a single set of facts. The court held that the costs order should reflect the overall success of the plaintiff, taking into account the multiple causes of action.
3. Whether the purported offer of compromise operates as a Calderbank offer. The court determined that the purported offer of compromise did not operate as a Calderbank offer.
4. Whether it is appropriate to make a separate costs order in relation to the second defendant, who was controlled by the first defendant or his family. The court concluded that it was not appropriate to make a separate costs order in relation to the second defendant, as he was controlled by the first defendant or his family.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In The Owners - Units Plan No 1917 v Koundouris (No 3), the court addressed several nuanced issues concerning the apportionment of costs in a scenario where the plaintiff’s claim was only partially successful, the determination of appropriate costs order in cases involving multiple causes of action, the characterization of a purported offer of compromise as a Calderbank offer, and the appropriateness of a separate costs order for a second defendant controlled by the first defendant or his family. The court's reasoning in these matters provides significant guidance for practitioners dealing with similar issues.
Firstly, the court examined the principle of costs following the event, which is a fundamental aspect of the Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT), rule 1721. The court held that apportionment of costs was not appropriate where the plaintiff's claim was only partially successful. It underscored that while the plaintiff's success was limited, the partial victory warranted full costs to be awarded to the plaintiff. This decision aligns with the general rule that costs follow the event unless there are exceptional circumstances justifying a different approach. The court did not find such circumstances in this case, thus reinforcing the principle that a plaintiff who achieves any measure of success should ordinarily recover costs.
Secondly, the court deliberated on how to determine the appropriate costs order in cases where multiple causes of action arise from a single set of facts. The court considered that each cause of action must be evaluated individually to ensure fairness and proportionality in the costs allocation. However, in this case, the court concluded that because the plaintiff's claim was only partially successful, the appropriate order was for the first defendant to pay the plaintiff's costs of the proceedings. This decision illustrates the court’s approach to maintaining the balance between ensuring that successful parties recover their costs and preventing unsuccessful parties from incurring disproportionate financial burdens.
Thirdly, the court evaluated whether the purported offer of compromise operated as a Calderbank offer. A Calderbank offer is a conditional offer to settle made in the hope of obtaining a more favourable settlement or costs order. The court found that the offer did not qualify as a Calderbank offer, which means it did not carry the conditional benefit of potentially reducing the costs awarded if the offer was not accepted. This finding was based on the specific terms of the offer and the context in which it was made, highlighting the need for careful drafting and understanding of such offers to ensure they carry the intended implications.
Lastly, the court considered whether it was appropriate to make a separate costs order in relation to the second defendant, who was controlled by the first defendant or his family. The court determined that given the control relationship, there was no basis for making a separate costs order against the second defendant. This decision was rooted in the principle that imposing separate costs on a party controlled by another defendant would not serve the interests of fairness or justice, as the first defendant already bore the costs of the proceedings.
In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that where a plaintiff’s claim is only partially successful, costs will ordinarily follow the event without apportionment. Additionally, in cases involving multiple causes of action, each must be considered individually, but the overall costs order must reflect the plaintiff's partial success. A purported offer of compromise does not operate as a Calderbank offer unless it meets specific criteria, and where a second defendant is controlled by the first, a separate costs order is generally inappropriate. The court's decision in this case provides clarity on these issues, offering valuable insights for practitioners handling similar matters in the future.