The Owners - Units Plan No 1917 v Koundouris & Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

The Owners – Units Plan No 1917 v Koundouris & Anor

Citation:

[2014] ACTSC 269

Hearing Date(s):

30 June, 5 and 6 August 2014

DecisionDate:

28 October 2014

Before:

Mossop M

Decision:

See [175]

Category:

Interlocutory application

Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Strike out applications – various grounds – whether pleadings defective – whether claims unarguable – applications dismissed

BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION – Statutory warranties under s 58C of the Building Act 1972 (ACT) – whether entitlement to sue upon them ends when they “expire”

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Destruction of documents prior to commencement of proceedings – test to be applied

LIMITATION OF ACTIONS – Limitation Act 1985 (ACT) s 40 – latent damage – whether confined to claims in tort or extends to claims in contract

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Security for costs – body corporate established under the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 (ACT) – late application for security of costs – no reason to believe that the corporation will be unable to pay the costs of the defendants

PLEADINGS – Amended reply – whether amendments to reply going beyond matters responsive to amendments to defence required leave

Legislation Cited:

Building Act 1972 (ACT)

Building Act 2004 (ACT)
Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT)
Civil Law (Property) Act 2006 (ACT)
Civil Law (Wrongs) Act 2002 (ACT)
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
Criminal Code 2002 (ACT)
Fair Trading Act 1992 (ACT)
Interpretation Ordinance 1967 (ACT)
Legislation Act 2001 (ACT)
Limitation Act 1985 (ACT)
Limitation Ordinance 1985 (ACT)
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth)
Unit Titles Act 1970 (ACT)
Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 (ACT)

Cases Cited:

Allen v Tobias (1958) 98 CLR 367

Allianz v Waterbrook [2009] NSWCA 224
Bittania Pty Ltd & Anor v Parkline Constructions Pty Ltd (2006) 67 NSWLR 9
Beach Petroleum NL & Anor v Johnson & Ors (1992) 7 ACSR 203
Bowes v Chaleyer (1923) 32 CLR 159
Bridges v Pelly [2001] NSWCA 31
Brikom Investments Ltd v Carr & Ors [1979] 2 All ER 753
British American Tobacco Australia Services Limited v Cowell [2002] 7 VR 524
Brookfield Multiplex Ltd v Owners Corporation Strata Plan 61288 (2014) 88 ALJR 911
Building Insurers’ Guarantee Corporation v The Owners – Strata Plan No. 57504 [2010] NSWCA 23
Carlisle v Filaria Pty Ltd [2002] ACTSC 33
Christopoulos v Angelos [1996] 41 NSWLR 700
Clark v State of New South Wales (2006) 66 NSWLR 640
Clark v State of New South Wales [2012] NSWCA 139
Concerned Citizens of Canberra Inc v Chief Planning Executive (Planning and Land Authority) [2014] ACTSC 24
Council of the Shire of Sutherland v Heyman (1985) 157 CLR 424
Cyril Smith & Associates Pty Ltd v The Owners-Strata Plan No 64970 [2011] NSWCA 181
Fuji Xerox Australia Pty Ltd v Lee & Anor [2003] QSC 303
General Steel Industries Inc v Commissioner for Railways (NSW) (1964) 112 CLR 125
Hawkins v Clayton (1988) 164 CLR 539
Davey & Anor v Herbst & Anor [2011] ACTSC…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Owners - Units Plan No 1917 v Koundouris & Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] ACTSC 269
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Owners - Units Plan No 1917 brought an action against Koundouris and another, seeking various remedies for alleged breaches of statutory warranties under the Building Act 1972 (ACT). The case was heard by the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory, where a number of procedural applications and legal issues were raised by the defendants. These included the defectiveness of the plaintiffs' pleadings, the validity of claims after the expiration of statutory warranties, the admissibility of documents destroyed before the action was initiated, and the application of limitation periods to latent damage claims in contract. Additionally, the defendants sought security for costs, and the plaintiffs sought leave to amend their reply beyond the scope of matters responsive to the amended defence.

The court addressed each issue in turn. It found that the plaintiffs' pleadings, though not perfect, were not so defective as to warrant dismissal. Regarding the expiry of statutory warranties, the court held that a cause of action accrues when the defect is discovered or ought to have been discovered, not when the warranty expires. The court also established that the destruction of documents prior to litigation does not automatically bar their admission if their contents can be reliably reconstructed. As for limitation periods, the court ruled that latent damage claims in contract are subject to the same principles as those in tort. The application for security for costs was dismissed due to the absence of evidence that the plaintiffs would be unable to pay the defendants' costs. Lastly, the court granted the plaintiffs leave to amend their reply, albeit with conditions, because the amendments went beyond matters responsive to the defence.

The final orders of the court included the admission of certain exhibits, the dismissal of various applications by the defendants, and the granting of leave to the plaintiffs to file their reply with specific conditions. The proceedings were scheduled for further directions and cost arguments, with the parties required to attempt to agree on necessary directions and hearing estimates beforehand.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. MFI B and C are admitted as Exhibits 4 and 5 respectively.

2. The application in proceeding dated 8 May 2014 filed by the defendants is dismissed.

3. The amended application in proceedings dated 23 May 2014 filed by the defendants is dismissed.

4. In relation to the amended application in proceedings filed by the plaintiff on 5 August 2014:

(a) the application is dismissed in so far as it seeks orders 1 to 4;

(b) leave is granted to the plaintiff, nunc pro tunc, to file the reply in fact filed by the plaintiff on 2 April 2014;

(c) the application is otherwise adjourned to the date set in order 5.

5. The proceedings are listed on 7 November 2014 at 10:00am for directions and any argument in relation to costs.

6. The parties are to consult and attempt to agree on the directions that are needed to have the matter ready for hearing and an estimate of the length of any hearing. The parties are to provide any agreed or competing directions and hearing estimates to my associate by email no later than 5 November 2014.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Owners - Units Plan No 1917 commenced proceedings against the first and second respondents, who are the owners of two residential units, in respect of alleged breaches of statutory warranties under section 58C of the Building Act 1972 (ACT). The plaintiff claimed that the respondents had breached the statutory warranties by failing to provide a good quality building and by failing to complete the works in accordance with the approved plans and specifications. The plaintiff sought damages and an order for the respondents to remedy the alleged breaches. The respondents filed a defence and a strike-out application seeking to dismiss the plaintiff's claims on various grounds. The respondents argued that the claims were unarguable, that the plaintiff's pleadings were defective, and that the plaintiff had failed to comply with the statutory requirements for making claims under section 58C of the Building Act 1972 (ACT). The respondents also sought an order for the plaintiff to pay their costs.

In response to the strike-out application, the plaintiff filed an amended statement of claim and a reply to the defence. The plaintiff argued that the claims were arguable and that the pleadings were sufficient. The plaintiff also sought to amend the reply to address new matters raised by the respondents in their defence. The plaintiff claimed that the respondents had destroyed documents that were relevant to the proceedings prior to the commencement of the proceedings. The plaintiff sought an order for the respondents to pay their costs. The respondents opposed the plaintiff's application to amend the reply, arguing that the amendments went beyond matters responsive to the amendments to the defence and that the plaintiff had failed to provide a sufficient reason for the delay in filing the amended reply. The respondents also sought to strike out the plaintiff's claim for costs on the basis that the plaintiff had not provided sufficient evidence to support the claim.

The proceedings were adjourned to allow the parties to file further material and to attempt to agree on directions for the hearing of the matter. The parties were required to provide any agreed or competing directions and hearing estimates to the court by email before the adjourned date.

The Owners - Units Plan No 1917 v Koundouris & Anor originated as an action in the ACT Supreme Court, with the plaintiff seeking various remedies under the Building Act 1972 (ACT), including statutory warranties and damages for breaches. The defendants filed an application to strike out the plaintiff’s claims, arguing that they were defective and unarguable. This application was subsequently amended, which led to further procedural challenges regarding the admissibility of certain evidence and the timing of the plaintiff’s reply. The plaintiff also filed a reply that sought leave to amend beyond matters directly responsive to the amended defence, which required judicial approval. Both the initial and amended strike-out applications by the defendants were dismissed by the court. The court granted the plaintiff leave to file its reply nunc pro tunc and adjourned further consideration of the plaintiff’s application to a later date. The matter is now scheduled for a directions hearing to facilitate further progression towards a final hearing.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the defendants' pleadings are defective and whether their claims are unarguable, justifying a strike out application.
2. Whether the entitlement to sue under statutory warranties under s 58C of the Building Act 1972 (ACT) ends when they “expire”.
3. What test should be applied to a situation where documents have been destroyed prior to the commencement of proceedings.
4. Whether the limitation period under s 40 of the Limitation Act 1985 (ACT) for latent damage is confined to claims in tort or extends to claims in contract.
5. Whether a body corporate established under the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 (ACT) is eligible for security for costs, particularly when the application is late and there is no reason to believe that the corporation will be unable to pay the defendants’ costs.
6. Whether an amended reply that goes beyond matters responsive to amendments to the defence requires leave.

Held
1. The court concluded that the defendants' pleadings were not defective and their claims were arguable, resulting in the dismissal of the strike out application.
2. The court held that the entitlement to sue under statutory warranties under s 58C of the Building Act 1972 (ACT) does not end when they “expire”.
3. The court determined that a balancing test should be applied to a situation where documents have been destroyed prior to the commencement of proceedings.
4. The court found that the limitation period under s 40 of the Limitation Act 1985 (ACT) for latent damage extends to claims in contract, not confined to claims in tort.
5. The court decided that a body corporate established under the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 (ACT) is not eligible for security for costs, particularly when the application is late and there is no reason to believe that the corporation will be unable to pay the defendants’ costs, resulting in the dismissal of the security for costs application.
6. The court held that an amended reply that goes beyond matters responsive to amendments to the defence does not require leave, and granted leave to the plaintiff to file the amended reply nunc pro tunc.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The case of The Owners - Units Plan No 1917 v Koundouris & Anor deals with a variety of procedural and substantive issues, all of which were considered by the court in a detailed and methodical manner. The court first dismissed the defendants' strike-out application, finding that the pleadings were not defective and that the claims were arguable. In examining the defendants' contention that the statutory warranties under s 58C of the Building Act 1972 (ACT) expire, the court concluded that the entitlement to sue does not necessarily end when the warranties “expire,” emphasizing that statutory warranties may continue to provide a basis for legal action beyond their expiry date. This interpretation aligns with the broader legislative intent to protect purchasers from defects in the building and construction process.

Regarding the destruction of documents prior to the commencement of proceedings, the court applied a test that balances the rights of the parties with the need to ensure a fair trial. The court held that the destruction of documents must be assessed in the context of the specific circumstances of the case, and the consequences of such destruction should not unfairly prejudice either party. This nuanced approach ensures that justice is served while maintaining the integrity of the judicial process. The court also addressed the limitation period under s 40 of the Limitation Act 1985 (ACT), ruling that the limitation period for latent damage applies to both claims in tort and claims in contract. This decision broadens the scope of the limitation period, providing a more comprehensive framework for addressing latent damages.

In the context of security for costs, the court examined whether a body corporate established under the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 (ACT) was eligible for such security, particularly in light of the late application and the absence of any indication that the corporation would be unable to pay the defendants’ costs. The court found that the application was untimely and that there was no reasonable basis to believe the corporation would be unable to meet its financial obligations. Consequently, the court denied the application for security for costs. Finally, the court dealt with the issue of whether an amended reply that goes beyond matters responsive to amendments to the defence required leave. The court granted leave for the amended reply, nunc pro tunc, to be filed, indicating that such amendments could be permissible if they do not introduce new matters that were not responsive to the defences. This decision provides clarity on the scope of amendments permissible in pleadings and the conditions under which they can be made.