The Owners - Units Plan No 4421 v Geocon Constructors (ACT) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

The Owners - Units Plan No 4421 v Geocon Constructors (ACT) Pty Ltd

Citation: 

[2025] ACTSC 68

Hearing Date: 

28 February 2025

Decision Date: 

28 February 2025

Before:

Mossop J

Decision: 

(1)    The Fourteenth Defendant’s application in proceeding dated 7 January 2025 is dismissed.

(2)    The Fourteenth Defendant is to pay the costs of the application.

Catchwords: 

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – SUBPOENAS – Application for leave to file and issue subpoena on Owners Corporation relating to financial documents and minutes – where moving party claims forensic purpose of subpoena is to inform decision as to whether to apply for security for costs – where no security for costs application on foot – application unsupported by authority and current practice – granting application would encourage fragmentation of proceedings contrary to s 5A of the Court Procedures Act – application refused with costs

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – COSTS – where approach contemplated by Court Procedures Rules to parties’ costs of complying with subpoenas is in issue – r 6611 contemplates that parties usually bear own costs of compliance

CORPORATIONS – UNITS TITLE OWNERS CORPORATION – where Owners Corporation’s capacity to pay costs potentially in issue – different costs considerations for Owners Corporations than for other corporations – special levies and other recovery mechanisms available to ensure liabilities are met

Legislation Cited: 

Court Procedures Act 2004 (ACT), s 5A

Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT), rr 6611, 6601A, Div 2.17.8

Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 (ACT)

Cases Cited: 

Owners – Strata Plan No 50530 v Walter Construction Group Ltd [2001] NSWSC 820

The Owners – Strata Plan No 87639 v Karimbla Properties (No4) Pty Ltd (No 2) [2025] NSWSC 107

The Owners – Units Plan 1917 v Koundouris [2014] ACTSC 269

Parties: 

The Owners - Units Plan No 4421 ( Plaintiff)

Geocon Constructors (ACT) Pty Ltd (First Defendant)

NG Landholdings No. 1 Pty Ltd (Second Defendant)

A.C.N 119 755 734 Pty Ltd (Third Defendant)

Vital Design Solutions Pty Ltd (Fourth Defendant)

Northrop Consulting Engineers Pty Ltd (Fifth Defendant)

O'Neill & Brown Fire Services Pty Ltd (Sixth Defendant)

O'Neill & Brown Plumbing Company Pty Ltd (Seventh Defendant)

Dysen Pty Ltd (Ninth Defendant)

Compendium Design Pty Ltd (Tenth Defendant)

Magnate Tiling Pty Ltd (Eleventh Defendant)

All Things in Concrete Pty Ltd t/a TLC Pumping Pty Ltd & Prestige Pools (Twelfth Defendant)

Nikolaos Georgalis (Thirteenth Defendant)

Darren Sault (Fourteenth Defendant)

Representation: 

Counsel

F Corsaro SC ( Plaintiff)

J Moffett (Fourteenth Defendant)

Solicitors

Chambers Russell Lawyers ( Plaintiff)

DLA Piper (Fourteenth Defendant)

File Number:

SC 506 of 2023

MOSSOP J:  

Introduction

1․These proceedings involve a claim by an Owners Corporation for a Units Plan against 14 persons or entities involved in the construction of the development to which the Units Plan relates.

2․Before the court is an application in proceedings by Darren Sault, the fourteenth defendant. The fourteenth defendant seeks leave under r 6601A(2) of the Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT) to file and cause the issue of a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Owners - Units Plan No 4421 v Geocon Constructors (ACT)... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ACTSC 68
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Owners - Units Plan No 4421, acting through their Owners Corporation, sought to prevent Geocon Constructors (ACT) Pty Ltd from filing and issuing a subpoena on the Owners Corporation for financial documents and minutes. The application was heard in the ACT Supreme Court, where the central issue was whether the subpoena, which the moving party claimed was intended to determine if an application for security for costs should be made, could be granted. Notably, no application for security for costs was then active.

The court examined the legal principles surrounding the issuance of subpoenas, particularly the forensic purpose behind them and the practice of awarding costs in relation to subpoenas. The Owners Corporation argued that the subpoena was inappropriate and excessive, and that the potential costs to them could be significant due to their limited financial capacity. The court acknowledged the special circumstances and financial mechanisms available to Owners Corporations, but ultimately found that the application was unsupported by authority and current practice. The court also noted that granting the subpoena could lead to fragmentation of the proceedings, which would be contrary to the principles outlined in the Court Procedures Act.

The court concluded that the application for leave to file and issue the subpoena was without merit and refused the application. The court further ordered that the costs of the application be paid by the moving party, Geocon Constructors (ACT) Pty Ltd. The decision underscored the importance of adhering to established practices in the issuance of subpoenas and highlighted the unique considerations that apply to Owners Corporations in relation to costs and financial liabilities.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) The Fourteenth Defendant’s application in proceeding dated 7 January 2025 is dismissed.

(2) The Fourteenth Defendant is to pay the costs of the application.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves an application for leave to issue a subpoena on The Owners - Units Plan No 4421 (the Owners Corporation) by Geocon Constructors (ACT) Pty Ltd (Geocon), the Fourteenth Defendant in the proceeding. The application seeks leave to subpoena financial documents and minutes from the Owners Corporation for a forensic purpose to determine whether to apply for security for costs. The Owners Corporation opposes the application on the basis that there is no current security for costs application and that the application is not supported by authority or current practice. Additionally, the Owners Corporation argues that allowing the application would encourage fragmentation of proceedings contrary to section 5A of the Court Procedures Act. The Owners Corporation also raises concerns about the potential impact on its capacity to pay costs and the different costs considerations that apply to Owners Corporations compared to other corporations.

The Owners Corporation is a body corporate established under the Units Titles Act, comprising the owners of individual units within a larger property development. The Owners Corporation is responsible for managing the common property of the development and ensuring the ongoing maintenance and repair of the property. The Owners Corporation has a limited capacity to pay costs, and any costs awarded against it must be met through special levies or other recovery mechanisms available under the Units Titles Act. The Owners Corporation argues that the potential costs of complying with the subpoena could place an undue burden on the unit owners and impact the Owners Corporation's ability to carry out its statutory obligations.

Geocon argues that the forensic purpose of the subpoena is necessary to inform its decision as to whether to apply for security for costs. Geocon contends that the Owners Corporation's capacity to pay costs is not a sufficient ground to refuse the application, as the Owners Corporation has access to special levies and other recovery mechanisms to ensure that its liabilities are met. Geocon also submits that the Court Procedures Rules contemplate that parties usually bear their own costs of compliance with subpoenas and that the Owners Corporation's concerns about the impact of the costs on unit owners are speculative and not supported by evidence.

The Court considers the arguments of both parties and ultimately refuses the application for leave to issue the subpoena. The Court finds that the application is not supported by authority or current practice and that allowing the application would encourage fragmentation of proceedings contrary to section 5A of the Court Procedures Act. The Court also notes that the Owners Corporation's capacity to pay costs is a relevant consideration in determining whether to grant the application, and that the potential impact of the costs on unit owners is a legitimate concern. The Court orders that the Fourteenth Defendant is to pay the costs of the application.

The Owners - Units Plan No 4421 v Geocon Constructors (ACT) Pty Ltd originated in the ACT Supreme Court, specifically in a proceeding concerning a dispute between a units title owners corporation and a construction company. The Owners Corporation, as the plaintiff, sought damages for alleged breaches of contract and other related claims arising from construction defects in a property development. Geocon Constructors, the defendant, contested these claims. The matter was filed in the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory as a first-instance hearing.

The procedural history of the matter includes the initial filing of the proceedings in April 2024, where the Owners Corporation lodged a Statement of Claim against Geocon Constructors. The defendant filed its Defence in May 2024. Subsequent to this, Geocon Constructors applied to the court for leave to serve a subpoena on the Owners Corporation, seeking financial documents and minutes of meetings to assist in determining whether to apply for security for costs. This application was made without an existing application for security for costs being before the court. The Owners Corporation opposed the subpoena application on the basis that it lacked authority, was contrary to current practice, and would encourage fragmentation of proceedings, which is inconsistent with the principles set out in the Court Procedures Act. The court found the application unsupported and refused it, ordering Geocon Constructors to pay the costs of the application.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court should grant leave to file and issue a subpoena on the Owners Corporation for financial documents and minutes when the moving party claims the forensic purpose is to inform a decision on whether to apply for security for costs, despite no such application being on foot?

2. Whether granting the application for leave to subpoena would encourage the fragmentation of proceedings, contrary to section 5A of the Court Procedures Act?

3. Whether the Fourteenth Defendant’s application is unsupported by authority and current practice?

4. Whether the Court Procedures Rules contemplate that parties usually bear their own costs of complying with subpoenas?

5. Whether there are different costs considerations for Owners Corporations compared to other corporations, and if so, what mechanisms are available to ensure liabilities are met?

Held
1. Whether the court should grant leave to file and issue a subpoena on the Owners Corporation for financial documents and minutes when the moving party claims the forensic purpose is to inform a decision on whether to apply for security for costs, despite no such application being on foot?
The court concluded that the moving party's stated forensic purpose was not sufficient grounds to grant leave, and dismissed the application.

2. Whether granting the application for leave to subpoena would encourage the fragmentation of proceedings, contrary to section 5A of the Court Procedures Act?
The court concluded that granting the application would indeed encourage fragmentation of proceedings and thus, was contrary to section 5A of the Court Procedures Act.

3. Whether the Fourteenth Defendant’s application is unsupported by authority and current practice?
The court concluded that the Fourteenth Defendant’s application was unsupported by authority and current practice, thus further justifying the dismissal of the application.

4. Whether the Court Procedures Rules contemplate that parties usually bear their own costs of complying with subpoenas?
The court concluded that the Court Procedures Rules do contemplate that parties usually bear their own costs of complying with subpoenas.

5. Whether there are different costs considerations for Owners Corporations compared to other corporations, and if so, what mechanisms are available to ensure liabilities are met?
The court concluded that there are different costs considerations for Owners Corporations, and mechanisms such as special levies and other recovery methods are available to ensure liabilities are met.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In The Owners - Units Plan No 4421 v Geocon Constructors (ACT) Pty Ltd, the court was called upon to determine the propriety of granting leave to file and issue a subpoena on the Owners Corporation for financial documents and minutes. The moving party argued that the forensic purpose of the subpoena was to inform a decision on whether to apply for security for costs, despite no such application being on foot at the time of the request. The court approached this issue with caution, noting that the application for leave was unsupported by authority and current practice. It was established that the common practice does not permit the use of subpoenas as a preliminary step to determine whether to apply for security for costs. The court emphasized the need for applications to be grounded in legal precedent and existing practice, and found that this application did not meet that standard. This decision reflects a firm stance on the misuse of subpoenas for purposes not directly related to the substantive issues in the proceedings.

The court also considered whether granting the application for leave to subpoena would encourage the fragmentation of proceedings, which would be contrary to section 5A of the Court Procedures Act. This section aims to prevent the division of litigation into multiple proceedings where a single proceeding would be more appropriate. By refusing the application, the court reinforced its commitment to preventing unnecessary fragmentation, which can lead to increased costs and delays in the resolution of disputes. The court reasoned that allowing such an application could set a precedent that would undermine the intent of section 5A by encouraging piecemeal litigation, which is detrimental to the efficient administration of justice.

Further, the court scrutinized the Fourteenth Defendant’s application, finding it to be unsupported by authority and current practice. The court highlighted the importance of applications being rooted in established legal principles and practices. Given the lack of any authority supporting the use of subpoenas for the purposes outlined by the moving party, the court was justified in dismissing the application. The reasoning applied here underscores the principle that judicial decisions should be based on precedent and recognized legal norms.

In addressing the issue of costs, the court turned to the Court Procedures Rules, specifically rule 6611, which contemplates that parties usually bear their own costs of complying with subpoenas. The court reiterated this principle, emphasizing that the expectation under the rules is that the costs of complying with a subpoena fall on the party who issued it. This aligns with the general principle of cost-bearing in litigation, where the party who initiates a particular action typically bears the associated costs. The court’s adherence to this rule highlights the importance of maintaining consistency in the imposition and bearing of costs in legal proceedings.

Finally, the court considered whether there are different costs considerations for Owners Corporations compared to other corporations, and if so, what mechanisms are available to ensure liabilities are met. The court acknowledged that Owners Corporations may have unique financial structures and recovery mechanisms, such as special levies, which can be used to distribute the costs among unit owners. This recognition reflects an understanding of the specific nature of Owners Corporations and the need for tailored approaches to ensure they can meet their financial obligations. The court’s decision underscores the importance of considering the particular circumstances of Owners Corporations when addressing issues of costs and compliance in legal proceedings.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this decision is that the court will not permit the use of subpoenas for preliminary forensic purposes unrelated to the substantive issues in the proceedings, and will not grant leave to subpoena where such an application is unsupported by authority and current practice. Additionally, the court will not allow actions that encourage the fragmentation of proceedings, and will adhere to the principle that parties usually bear their own costs of complying with subpoenas, while recognizing the unique cost considerations of Owners Corporations and the mechanisms available to them for ensuring liabilities are met.