Telstra Corporation Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Telstra Corporation Limited v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2009] FCA 757

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – telecommunications industry – 14 arbitrations between Telstra Corporation Limited (Telstra) and access seekers over terms and conditions of access to declared services – Div 8 of Pt XIC of Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (Act) – challenge by Telstra to the final determinations made by Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) in the 14 arbitrations on judicial review grounds that were common to various combinations of the arbitrations –

(A) whether ACCC misconstrued s 152CR(1)(d) of Act by adopting pooling and allocation method in dealing with specific costs –

(B) whether ACCC’s failure to take into account model terms that it had determined under s 152AQB(2) of Act involved procedural ultra vires and failure to take into account a relevant consideration –

(C) whether it was beyond the power conferred on ACCC by s 152CP of Act to make a determination that included a charge for call diversion when call diversion was provided as part of a new connection – whether call diversion when provided in those circumstances was a matter “relating to” access to the declared service within s 152CP(2) of Act –

(D) whether ACCC erred in law by inconsistently using Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM) in order to estimate cost to Telstra of equity capital while rejecting Telstra’s contention that there should be an uplift in the element to be included for Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) to allow for welfare asymmetry connected with overestimating or underestimating the WACC – whether use of CAPM involved acceptance of its underlying assumptions – whether inconsistency established – whether inconsistency in economic methodology an error of law –

(E) whether, by not including in the monthly charge to be paid by access seekers an element for line costs, ACCC erred in law and failed to observe s 152DB(1)(b) of Act – construction of s 152DB(1)(b) of Act –

(F) whether later pricing principles for declared service impliedly revoked earlier ones – whether ACCC erred by taking later ones into account – whether later ones invalid by reason of having been made when earlier ones still in force and not expressly revoked – whether later ones validly backdated into period when earlier ones had been on foot.

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 152AF, 152AQA, 152AQB, 152AR, A52CP, 152CR, 151DB, 152DN, 152DNA


Application by GasNet Australia (Operations) Pty Ltd [2004] ATPR 41-978; [2003] ACompT 6 cited

Associated Provincial Picture Houses Ltd v Wednesbury Corporation [1948] 1 KB 223 cited
Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond (1990) 170 CLR 321 cited
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Narain (2008) 169 FCR 211 cited
Brisbane City Council v The Valuer-General for the State of Queensland (1978) 140 CLR 41 distinguished
Caloundra City Council v Netstar Pty Ltd [2008] 1 Qd R 258 cited
Esber v Commonwealth (1992) 174 CLR 430 cited
Goodwin v Phillips (1908) 7 CLR 1 cited
Hatfield v Health Insurance Commission

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Telstra Corporation Ltd v Australian Competition and Consume... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCA 757
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Telstra Corporation Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission, the primary issue before the court was whether the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) had correctly applied the Unconditioned Local Loop Service (ULLS) Model Terms in making its final determinations regarding the pricing principles for the ULLS. The dispute arose from Telstra's contention that the ACCC failed to observe statutory procedures and take into account relevant considerations when making the final determinations. Specifically, Telstra argued that the ACCC did not have regard to the ULLS Model Terms, which were determined under section 152AQB(2) of the Act. Conversely, the ACCC argued that the ULLS Model Terms were inconsistent with the 2007 ULLS Pricing Principles determined under section 152AQA, thereby rendering the Model Terms ineffective to the extent of the inconsistency.

The court examined the statutory framework and the procedural requirements imposed on the ACCC. It identified that the ACCC was required to have regard to the ULLS Model Terms as per section 152AQB(9) and also needed to consider these terms as a relevant consideration under section 152AQB(10). The court found that the ACCC's failure to have regard to the ULLS Model Terms amounted to procedural ultra vires and an improper exercise of statutory power. The court scrutinized the arguments presented by both parties and concluded that the ACCC's failure to adhere to the Model Terms constituted a breach of statutory obligations. Consequently, the court determined that the proceeding should be dismissed, and Telstra was ordered to pay the respondents' costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The proceeding be dismissed.

2. The applicant pay the respondents’ costs.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Telstra Corporation Ltd, an Australian telecommunications company, faced a dispute with the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) regarding the determination of model terms and conditions for access to the Unconditioned Local Loop Service (ULLS) and Local Service Switch (LSS). The dispute arose after the ACCC published the ULLS Model Terms in October 2003 under section 152AQB(2) of the relevant Act. The ULLS Model Terms were developed to provide model terms and conditions for access to core services, with the ULLS being classified as a core service. The ACCC subsequently determined the 2007 ULLS Pricing Principles under section 152AQA in November 2007. Telstra argued that the ULLS Model Terms were inconsistent with the 2007 ULLS Pricing Principles, and as such, the latter should prevail to the extent of the inconsistency. Telstra further contended that the ACCC failed to observe the procedures required by law when making the final determinations for the ULLS, specifically failing to have regard to the 2003 ULLS Model Terms.

The case involved multiple proceedings brought by various access seekers, including Optus, XYZed, PowerTel, Request, Primus, and Macquarie, against Telstra. The proceedings were consolidated for the purpose of determining common issues. The ULLS Model Terms ground was pressed as Ground 3 in the Optus, XYZed, PowerTel, and Request ULLS proceedings and as Ground 4 in the Primus and Macquarie ULLS proceedings. The Chime ULLS proceeding was identified as the representative proceeding for all other grounds of review concerning the ULLS. However, Telstra no longer pressed the ULLS Model Terms ground in the Chime proceeding. The court considered the arguments made in the various proceedings, including those submitted by Chime, which were prepared before Telstra abandoned the ground in the Chime proceeding.

Decision

Reasons for decision

LINDGREN J
In addition to what I have said above, I adopt, mutatis mutandis, the Earlier Reasons at [300]-[314].Conclusion For the above reasons and for those which I gave at [300]-[314] of the Earlier Reasons, the Pooling and Allocation Method ground is not established.B – ULLS MODEL TERMSGeneral In October 2003 ACCC published the ULLS Model Terms. As can be seen from its title, this determination is relevant to the ULLS but not to the LSS. The ULLS Model Terms were determined under s 152AQB(2) of the Act which requires ACCC to make a written determination setting out model terms and conditions relating to access to each “core service”. The ULLS is a core services but the LSS is not: see s 152AQB(1). Section 152AQB(9) provides that ACCC must have regard to a determination under s 152AQB if it is required to arbitrate an access dispute under Div 8 in relation to a core service covered by the determination. Telstra relies on this provision. Section 152AQB(10), however, provides that a determination made under s 152AQB has no effect to the extent that it is inconsistent with, relevantly, any determination by ACCC under s 152AQA of principles relating to the price of access to a declared service. The ULLS access seekers contend that the ULLS Model Terms are inconsistent with the 2007 ULLS Pricing Principles) determined by ACCC under s 152AQA in November 2007, with the result that s 152AQB(10) causes the latter to prevail to the extent of the inconsistency. Telstra, on the other hand, submits that in making the relevant ULLS FDs, ACCC:(a)failed to observe procedures which were required by law to be observed in connection with the making of the final determinations in respect of the ULLS, in that it failed to have regard to the ULLS Model Terms…; and(b)failed to take into account a relevant consideration it was bound to take into account, in that it failed to have regard to the ULLS Model Terms. The first form of the complaint ((a) above) is procedural ultra vires that is reflected in s 5(1)(b) of the ADJR Act – “that procedures that were required by law to be observed in connection with the making of the decision were not observed”. The procedure which ACCC is alleged to have failed to observe is the requirement in s 152AQB(9), that ACCC have regard to a determination made under s 152AQB, in this case, the 2003 ULLS Model Terms. The second form of the complaint ((b) above) is a failure to take into account a relevant consideration, that is reflected in s 5(1)(e) coupled with s 5(2)(b) of the ADJR Act – improper exercise of a statutory power in the form of a failure to take into account a relevant consideration. The relevant consideration is again that specified in s 152AQB(9), namely, the 2003 ULLS Model Terms. The ULLS Model Terms ground is pressed as Ground 3 in the Optus, XYZed, PowerTel and Request ULLS proceedings, and as Ground 4 in the Primus and Macquarie ULLS proceedings. As noted at [12] above, although the Chime ULLS proceeding is the representative proceeding in respect of all other grounds of review concerning the ULLS, it is the Optus proceeding that is the representative proceeding in respect of the ULLS Model Terms ground. Telstra no longer presses this ground in the Chime ULLS proceeding. Notwithstanding this, the parties’ submissions frequently refer to “Chime”. In fact, Chime’s written submissions include submissions relating to the ULLS Model Terms ground, apparently because they were prepared before Telstra abandoned that ground in the Chime proceeding. For convenience I will also from time to time refer to certain submissions as having been made by Chime, but it will be understood that they are in fact made on behalf of PowerTel, Request, Primus and Macquarie, and that Telstra no longer presses the present ground in the Chime proceeding.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: LINDGREN J

Virtually the entire argument took place by reference to the Adam LSS proceeding ACCC’s Statement of Reasons accompanying its FD in relation to the Adam LSS arbitration (Adam LSS FD Statement of Reasons) was, relevantly, mutatis mutandis, identical to the Chime ULLS FD Statement of Reasons. As noted in Telstra’s submissions (para 3.42):The factual background and legal issues in the relevant proceedings concerning the ULLS are in all relevant respects the same as … in the proceedings concerning the LSS.Telstra therefore relied on the same argument in relation to both the LSS and ULLS proceedings. Accordingly, I will refer to the Adam LSS proceeding as representative of all 13 proceedings in which an access seeker relies upon the present ground.Prior considerations of a pooling and allocation approach by ACCC and the Tribunal ACCC’s DFD Consultation Papers had proposed the Pooling and Allocation Method; see the Adam LSS DFD Consultation Paper, section 4.1.8 on “Specific costs” and the Chime ULLS DFD Consultation Paper, section 4.1.6 on “Specific costs”. Both DFD Consultation Papers referred to previous considerations of this issue. Until 2005, ACCC dealt with specific costs by using the cost allocation method for which Telstra contends. Indeed, at [80] of the Adam LSS FD Statement of Reasons ACCC acknowledged that it could be argued that ACCC’s 2002 LSS Pricing Principles were inconsistent with the pooling methodology. However, in its Telstra’s Undertakings for the Unconditioned Local Loop Service – Discussion Paper of March 2005 (ULLS Undertakings Discussion Paper), ACCC noted that the approach that it had been following had been called into question. Over a period from October 2004 to March 2007 ACCC embraced the Pooling and Allocation Method. I outlined the history in the Earlier Reasons at [292] ff. Adam (and Chime) submitted to ACCC that it should adhere to the Pooling and Allocation Method as proposed in section 4.1.6 of the Adam LSS DFD Consultation Paper (section 4.1.8 of the Chime ULLS DFD Consultation Paper). In its present submissions (to the Court) Chime also refers to the Request LSS FD Statement of Reasons dated 1 August 2007 (the subject of consideration in the Earlier Reasons), and the more recent Tribunal decision in relation to ULLS annual charges, Re Telstra Corporation Ltd (No 3) [2007] ACompT 3 at [387]-[413]. The 2007 LSS Pricing Principles, determined by ACCC on 24 October 2007, were as follows: · … TSLRIC + pricing principles should be applied to the LSS· a specific cost component should be included in the LSS monthly price, calculated by combining ‘LSS specific costs’ with ‘ULLS specific costs” and Telstra’s internal equivalent costs for ADSL, and allocating those costs across the number of active ULLS, LSS and ADSL lines· a contribution for line costs will not be recovered in the LSS monthly price· connection and disconnection charges should be set with reference to the amounts charged by third party contractors to Telstra for jumpering work in exchanges, indirect costs and back-of-house costs.[My emphasis]