Castel Electronics Pty Ltd v TCL Air Conditioner (Zhongshan) Co Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 81 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Castel Electronics Pty Ltd v TCL Air Conditioner (Zhongshan) Co Ltd (No 2) [2012] FCA 1214

Citation: Castel Electronics Pty Ltd v TCL Air Conditioner (Zhongshan) Co Ltd (No 2) [2012] FCA 1214
Parties: CASTEL ELECTRONICS PTY LTD v TCL AIR CONDITIONER (ZHONGSHAN) CO LTD
File numbers: VID 218 of 2011
VID 224 of 2011
VID 317 of 2011
Judge: MURPHY J
Date of judgment: 2 November 2012
Catchwords:

INTERNATIONAL ARBITRATION – arbitration pursuant to the International Arbitration Act 1974 – domestically made Model Law award - setting aside an award –– recognition and enforcement of award – meaning of “public policy” in International Arbitration Act 1974 (Cth) - whether arbitral award is in conflict with or otherwise contrary to public policy – whether “public policy” relates to procedural as well as substantive issues - importance of international uniformity to interpretation of “public policy” - whether “public policy” has the same or similar meaning in relation to grounds for setting aside an award as grounds for refusing enforcement of an award – requirement for natural justice in connection with the making of awards – seriousness of the breach of the rules of natural justice required to be in conflict with public policy - principles governing the proper exercise of the discretion to set aside or refuse enforcement - the extent of the review warranted when an award is challenged for breach of natural justice – whether a distinction exists between the award and the reasons underpinning it - whether arbitral tribunal breached the rules of natural justice in making the award – whether findings regarding the quantification of loss were made in breach of the no evidence rule and the hearing rule – whether tribunal was required to adopt expert’s quantification of loss

Legislation: Arbitration (Foreign Awards and Agreements) Act 1974 (Cth)
Arbitration Act 1996 (NZ)
Explanatory Memorandum to the International Commercial Arbitration Bill 1988
International Arbitration Act 1974 (Cth)
International Arbitration Amendment Act 1989 (Cth)
Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth)
Cases cited: AJT v AJU [2010] 4 SLR 649
Amaltal Corporation Ltd v Maruha (NZ) Corporation Ltd [2004] 2 NZLR 614
Atkinson v Hastings Deering (Queensland) Pty Ltd (1985) 71 ALR 93
Attorney General of Canada v SD Myers Inc [2004] 3 FCR 368
Biggin & Co Ltd v Permanite [1951] 1 KB 422
Callaghan v William C Lynch Pty Ltd [1962] NSWR 871
Castel Electronics Pty Ltd v TCL Air Conditioner (Zhongshan) Co Ltd [2012] FCA 21
Collins v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1981) 58 FLR 407
Corvetina Technology Ltd v Clough Engineering Ltd [2004] NSWSC 700
Corvetina, Denmark Skibstekniske Konsulenter A/S I Likvidation v Ultrapolis 3000 Investments Ltd [2010] SGHC 108
Deutsche Schachtbau-und Tiefbohrgesellschaft mbH v Shell International Petroleum Co Ltd [1990] 1 AC 295
Downer Connect Ltd v Pot Hole People Ltd (High Court, Christchurch, CIV 2003-409-2878, 19 May 2004)
Downer-Hill Joint Venture v Government of Fiji [2005] 1 NZLR 554
Enzed Holdings v Wynthea (1984) 57 ALR 167
F (Orse…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Castel Electronics Pty Ltd v TCL Air Conditioner (Zhongshan)... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] FCA 1214
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Castel Electronics Pty Ltd brought proceedings against TCL Air Conditioner (Zhongshan) Co Ltd in the Federal Court of Australia seeking to enforce an arbitral award made in Hong Kong. The award was made pursuant to a distribution agreement that granted Castel the exclusive right to distribute TCL-branded air conditioners in Australia. TCL argued that the award should not be enforced because it was made in breach of natural justice and was in conflict with or contrary to the public policy of Australia. The court had to decide whether the arbitral award was made in breach of natural justice and whether it was in conflict with or contrary to the public policy of Australia. The court held that the award was not made in breach of natural justice and was not in conflict with or contrary to the public policy of Australia. The court held that the tribunal was not required to adopt the expert’s quantification of loss and that the tribunal’s findings were not made in breach of the no evidence rule and the hearing rule. The court held that the public policy exception to enforcement of arbitral awards should be interpreted narrowly and consistently with international standards of arbitral practice. The court held that the public policy exception should not be invoked to permit a re-hearing of the merits of the case or to permit a court to substitute its own judgment for that of the tribunal. The court held that the tribunal’s findings were not in conflict with or contrary to the public policy of Australia because they did not involve any fundamental breach of the rules of natural justice. The court made an order enforcing the arbitral award and directing the parties to file draft orders and submissions as to costs within seven days.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The parties are to confer and provide draft orders to the Court giving effect to these reasons within seven days.

2. The parties to file short submissions as to costs within seven days.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In relation to the degree of substitutability the Tribunal noted:Substitutability and product differentiation205Another contested issue that affects the determination of Castel’s lost sales was the extent to which the OEM products were directly competitive with TCL-branded products. It was common ground between the parties that the air conditioning market is highly differentiated. Mr Williams gave a helpful summary definition of the two forms of differentiation: vertical differentiation means differences in the quality of the product, and horizontal differentiation means differences in the physical characteristics of units while they may be identical in their power and functioning. There is a range of styles and types of units available and customers make choices based on their particular needs. 206Castel’s claim was that the TCL OEM products were marketed in the same areas of the market, and had the same essential features, as the TCL-branded products so that they had a direct impact on whether TCL-branded products were bought. Mr Francis’s evidence was that he inspected a range of units and found them similar or identical to models which Castel was selling. He also gave evidence that they were perceived by number of Castel customers as so similar to the TCL-branded products that they were an acceptable and cheaper substitute for them.207Mr Acton did not purport to give expert evidence as to the substitutability of OEM products for branded products. He made his calculations on the basis of Castel’s evidence that there was a high degree of similarity.208TCL produced evidence in the form of pictures that compared TCL-branded units to OEM units. It is submitted on the basis of that evidence that the two types of units were insufficiently similar to be true substitutes. This evidence was somewhat undermined by other evidence from Mr Shi that one reason to make OEM products was that spread the product and development costs which would otherwise be wholly attributable to the TCL-branded products. Mr Zhang also gave evidence that TCL-branded products and OEM products were in effect the same units, with different trademarks. Castel submitted that the differences were purely a matter of form and that in functional matters the TCL-branded units and the OEM units were close substitutes for each other.209TCL’s expert Mr Williams proceeded on the basis that TCL would not have been likely to cannibalise its own sales and TCL was therefore engaged in ‘versioning’ - the sale of different versions of its products to different sections of the market - so that TCL’s OEM products would not have directly competed with TCL-branded products because they would have been sold in different places. Castel submitted that TCL’s own evidence showed that this was not the case and that TCL took no interest in where and how its OEM products were sold. While there is no evidence that OEM product and a TCL branded product were ever side by side in a store, or even in adjoining stores, we accept that TCL was not taking active steps to protect its TCL-branded products from OEM products.…211One key element of the TCL-branded products that was said to differ from the OEM products was the after sales service offered by Castel. Level 4 brands tended to offer this service where level 5 brands did not. Mr Williams’ evidence was that this was an indicator of a vertical differential; customer services are an important element of quality and a reason for customers to prefer a higher level brand such as TCL. Mr Williams saw this as a sign that the OEM products would not be directly competitive with the TCL-branded products which offered that degree of support. He agreed in cross examination that sales staff have a high degree of influence on what a customer buys and that they would urge customers towards products which offered the best profit margin for them, regardless of after-sales service.212Having considered all of the evidence the Tribunal does not propose, and nor was it invited, to consider model by model whether there was direct substitutability between TCL-branded products and OEM products. It accepts the evidence of Mr Francis as to his observations and the perceptions of customers as conveyed to him. It accepts that for sections of Castel’s actual and potential customer base the OEM products were regarded as just as good and led those customers to choose the OEM products instead of the TCL-branded products.213At the lower end of the market where the TCL brand and the OEM brands were competing it appears that functionality rather than form was the important issue. The TCL-branded products and the OEM branded products served in the similar part of the market and offered the same types of units.214The Tribunal cannot find as a fact that every OEM units sold was directly substitutable for a designated TCL-branded unit. However for the purposes of estimating the loss of sales to Castel brought about by the presence of TCL OEM products we proceed on the basis that the OEM products were sufficiently similar to be a direct competitor of, and replacement for, a line of TCL-branded products, at least insofar as they were perceived in that way by the customer base. It is important to note that Castel did not sell directly to end-users but rather to retailers who bought in bulk and who were well informed about the market and about the available brands.(Emphasis added.)

Decision

Reasons for decision

I will make an order in the terms of the Award, and Castel may then enforce by the usual Court processes.F. CONCLUSION I require that within seven days the parties prepare and file draft orders reflecting these reasons and file submissions as to costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

TCL contends that three findings made by the Tribunal are made in breach of the rules of natural justice. TCL describes the three findings as the 14% Starting Point Finding, the Uplift Finding, and the Lost Sales Finding, and I will adopt those descriptions. It says that because the Tribunal made these three findings the Award is in conflict with or contrary to the public policy of Australia, and should be set aside pursuant to art 34 of the Model Law in the IAA. D.1 The Arbitration The Distribution Agreement between Castel and TCL was made on 29 December 2003, and varied in a meeting on 29 May 2007 (“the Variation Agreement”). It contained a clause which provided for arbitration of disputes to be held in Australia. No question as to the proper construction of the Distribution Agreement or the Variation Agreement arises in the applications to set the awards aside or in the application to enforce them. It is accordingly unnecessary to set out their terms. Castel referred a dispute for arbitration on 25 July 2008 and the Tribunal was then duly constituted. There was an initial dispute as to the extent of the Tribunal’s jurisdiction under the arbitration clause which was resolved in an application to the Supreme Court of Victoria: TCL Airconditioner (Zhongshan) Co Ltd v Castel Electronics Pty Ltd [2009] VSC 553. Both parties participated fully in the arbitration and were represented by senior and junior counsel and solicitors. Procedural hearings leading to directions by the Tribunal were held in February, July and September 2010, and rulings were given on contested discovery issues. The substantive hearing was held in Melbourne for 10 days between 13 and 24 September 2010. Both parties’ expert witnesses provided detailed reports, lay witnesses provided signed statements, and both were subject to cross-examination. Detailed opening and closing submissions were made by both parties. It is unnecessary for me to set out all aspects of the arbitral hearing as no question arises as to the bulk of the 95 page Award. It is only in the approach taken by the Tribunal to the assessment of Castel’s loss arising from TCL’s sales of OEM products that TCL complains of breaches of the no evidence rule and the hearing rule. Castel claimed that it was appointed as TCL’s exclusive distributor in Australia for TCL-manufactured air conditioners, whether TCL-branded products or OEM products. It said that the Variation Agreement came about as a result of extensive complaints by it concerning, amongst other things, TCL’s breaches of its obligations not to sell air conditioners that competed with the TCL-branded products that Castel had the exclusive right to sell. Castel contended that in breach of its obligations TCL supplied a large volume of OEM products under a variety of brand names to purchasers in Australia. TCL accepted that it had sold 52,878 OEM products over the period of the Distribution Agreement and up to 31 December 2008 but denied that this was in breach of the agreement. It contended that the distributorship and exclusivity granted to Castel was confined to TCL-branded products and did not relate to OEM products. That is, TCL’s obligation to Castel with regard to selling competing air conditioners in Australia was limited to an obligation not to sell TCL-branded products other than through Castel.