Starkey v State of South Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application for Judicial Review)

STARKEY & ANOR v STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA & ORS

[2011] SASC 34

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Sulan

17 March 2011

ABORIGINALS - HERITAGE PROTECTION - SOUTH AUSTRALIA

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - JUDICIAL REVIEW - REVIEWABLE DECISIONS AND CONDUCT - REVIEW OF PARTICULAR DECISIONS

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - JUDICIAL REVIEW - GROUNDS OF REVIEW - PROCEDURAL FAIRNESS - HEARING - NATURE OF HEARING - DISCLOSURE OF EVIDENCE AND MATERIAL FACTORS

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - JUDICIAL REVIEW - GROUNDS OF REVIEW - PROCEDURAL FAIRNESS - CONSEQUENCE OF FAILURE TO ACCORD PROCEDURAL FAIRNESS

Judicial review of Minister's grant of authorisation to damage, disturb or interfere with Aboriginal site - third defendant applied for authorisation - unanimous request for delegation of Minister's powers made by Aboriginal people at consultation meeting - Act mandates Minister to delegate when requested by "traditional owners" - Minister not satisfied those at meeting were "traditional owners" - Minister reserved decision on delegation - Minister granted third defendant's application for authorisation - whether authorisation was contrary to law - whether Minister was required to delegate her powers - whether consultation engaged in by Minister was contrary to law.

Held:  Authorisation was not contrary to law - Minister was not required to delegate her powers - Minister did not accord procedural fairness to those requesting delegation - Minister did not act for an improper purpose in refusing to delegate - failure to accord procedural fairness did not invalidate authorisation - the Minister sufficiently discharged her consultation obligations under the Act.

Aboriginal Heritage Act 1988 (SA) s 3, s 6, s 9, s 11, s 12, s 13, s 23, s 35; Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 (SA) r 200, referred to.
Kioa v West (1985) 159 CLR 550; Mobil Oil Australia v FCT (1963) 113 CLR 475, applied.
Straits Exploration (Australia) Pty Ltd v The Kokatha Uwankara Native Title Claimants [2011] SAERDC 2, distinguished.

STARKEY & ANOR v STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA & ORS
[2011] SASC 34

Civil

SULAN J

Introduction

  1. This is an action for judicial review of an authorisation made by the second defendant, the Minister for Aboriginal Affairs and Reconciliation, under section 23 of the Aboriginal Heritage Act 1988 (SA). The authorisation gave the third defendant, Straits Exploration (Australia) Pty Ltd (“Straits”), permission to damage, disturb or interfere with any Aboriginal sites, objects or remains that may exist on Lake Torrens and a portion of Andamooka Island (“the Lake Torrens site”) designated for mining exploration activity.

  2. Pursuant to Rule 200 of the Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006, the plaintiffs require the permission of this Court to proceed for judicial review. It was agreed between the parties at the interlocutory stage that the application for permission to seek judicial review would be heard with the substantive action.

  3. The plaintiffs are members of their respective Aboriginal communities. The first plaintiff, Robert John Starkey, is Kokatha Wati and the second plaintiff, Vince Coulthard, is chairperson of the Adnyamathanha…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Starkey v State of South Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] SASC 34
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Starkey v State of South Australia, the plaintiffs challenged the Minister for Aboriginal Affairs' decision to grant authorisation for the third defendant to damage, disturb, or interfere with an Aboriginal site at Lake Torrens. The plaintiffs argued that the Minister failed to properly delegate her powers to the traditional owners as required by the Aboriginal Heritage Act 1988 (SA). The court had to determine whether the authorisation was contrary to law, whether the Minister was required to delegate her powers, and if the consultation process complied with the requirements of procedural fairness.

The legal issues centered on the interpretation of the Aboriginal Heritage Act 1988 (SA) and the obligations of the Minister under sections 6 and 23. The plaintiffs contended that the Minister was required to delegate her powers to the traditional owners as requested at a consultation meeting, and that failure to do so rendered the authorisation invalid. The Minister argued that she was not satisfied that those present at the meeting were the "traditional owners" as defined by the Act, and therefore, she was not obliged to delegate her powers. The court needed to determine whether the Minister's decision not to delegate her powers was lawful and whether the consultation process complied with procedural fairness.

The court held that the authorisation granted by the Minister was not contrary to law and that the Minister was not required to delegate her powers. The Minister did not act for an improper purpose in refusing to delegate, and her failure to accord procedural fairness did not invalidate the authorisation. The court found that the Minister sufficiently discharged her consultation obligations under the Act. The court noted that the Minister must be satisfied that the persons seeking delegation are indeed the traditional owners and that it is incumbent upon her to ensure that the traditional owners are fit and capable of exercising the Executive power of the State. The court also held that the Minister's failure to accord procedural fairness did not render the authorisation invalid as the Minister's consultation obligations were otherwise met.

The court's final orders were that the authorisation granted by the Minister for the third defendant to damage, disturb, or interfere with the Aboriginal site at Lake Torrens was valid. The Minister was not required to delegate her powers to the traditional owners, and her failure to do so did not invalidate the authorisation. The court found that the Minister sufficiently complied with her consultation obligations under the Aboriginal Heritage Act 1988 (SA).

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

A person is, therefore, prohibited from interfering with an Aboriginal site or damaging an Aboriginal object unless they obtain an authorisation from the Minister. Before granting an authorisation, the Minister must consult. The Minister is empowered to delegate her powers and must delegate her powers under section 23 to the traditional owners, if they make a request.Background The plaintiffs allege, and it is accepted that, the Lake Torrens site is significant to their respective communities for reasons which are protected from being divulged by section 35, which provides that a person must not, in contravention of Aboriginal tradition, divulge information relating to an Aboriginal site, object or remains or Aboriginal tradition. In early 2008, the Minister received the Lake Torrens Aboriginal Site Record, to which Mr Starkey was an informant. The Minister was provided with a revised site card on 29 April 2008, which sets out the significance of the Lake Torrens site to Kokatha people. The site was not, and has never been, “registered” in the Register of Aboriginal Sites and Objects established under section 9. It is not disputed that Lake Torrens is an Aboriginal site within the meaning of the Act. On 27 November 2009, Straits applied to the Minister for authorisation under section 23 in respect of the Lake Torrens site. The specified areas of the Lake Torrens site that were the subject of the application were generally described:·seven circular drill target zones (radius 500m), of size 0.78km2 each – total area of 5.46km2·new access tracks needed to service the target zones – total area 0.083km2·maintenance and utilization of existing tracks from the boundary of the Recorded Site to the mesh runway for access to the lake – total area 1.16km2·maintenance and utilization of existing camp and buffer zone – total area 0.22km2·maintenance and utilization of existing drill hole disturbance areas (TD4, TD6 and WMC water bore) for recovery of drilling water and for rehabilitation purposes – total area 0.11km2·new emergency evacuation and helicopter support routes from the new drill target zones to camp – total area 0.051km2·non-ground disturbing activity of 148 extension and infill gravity survey stations. A section 13 consultation meeting was held in respect of the section 23 application on 19 December 2009, at Port Augusta. The meeting was publicly notified in the Adelaide Advertiser and the Port Augusta Transcontinental newspapers on or around 5 December 2009. Notice of the meeting was also sent to Mr Osker Linde of South Australian Native Title Services Ltd on 14 December 2009. This letter invited Aboriginal people and Aboriginal organisations who wished to comment to attend the meeting, or to make telephone or written submissions. It was not disputed that Mr Linde acted as Mr Starkey’s legal advisor at all relevant times. Mr Starkey and Mr Coulthard both allege that they were not personally invited to take part in the meeting. The Minister disputes this. A mailing list for the letter sent to notify potentially interested parties of the meeting was produced. The mailing list includes Mr Starkey, as well as Mr Graham Harbord of Johnston Withers, Mr Coulthard’s legal counsel at the relevant time.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Minister’s section 23 authorisation is therefore not invalid for being too broad to be of meaningful application. The reservation of the section 6 delegation decision Mr Hayes submits that under what is referred to as the “Lake Torrens arrangement”, the Kokatha and Adnyamathanha recognise each other’s interest in the cultural heritage of Lake Torrens and consider each other as being traditional owners of the site. It is submitted that the unanimous support of the request for delegation by the Aboriginal persons present at the Port Augusta consultation meeting is consistent with the Lake Torrens arrangement, as was the unanimous opposition to the Minister granting a section 23 authorisation to Straits. Mr Hayes and Mr Llewellyn-Jones, who appeared for Mr Coulthard, submit that the Minister was expressly obliged by section 6(2) of the Act to delegate her powers in these circumstances. They submit that the Minister’s failure to delegate can only be justified if the Aboriginal persons who requested the delegation are not to be considered traditional owners. Mr Hayes contends that the Minister’s failure to delegate her authority to the traditional owners of the Lake Torrens site was contrary to section 6(2) of the Act. It is also submitted that no lawful section 23 authorisation could be made by the Minister before the request for delegation had been conclusively determined, and therefore the Minister had no relevant power to grant Straits’ application. In response to the issue of section 6 delegation, the Solicitor-General contends that the operation of section 6(2) is subject to the provisions of sections 6(3) and 6(4). He contends that several implications arise from the combined reading of subsections 6(2) and 6(3). The first such implication is that the Minister must be satisfied, on the basis of information provided to support the request under section 6(2), that the persons seeking a delegation are in fact “the traditional owners”. The Solicitor-General also contends that it is incumbent upon the Minister to satisfy herself that the traditional owners are fit and capable persons to exercise the Executive power of the State. He contends that it is implied that all of the traditional owners must be identified and given the opportunity to advise as to whether they wish to be included in the delegation. He contends that to do otherwise would result in those first in time enjoying a superior position to those who subsequently request a delegation. It could result in competing claims of persons who seek a delegation. Mr Hoffman makes a related submission that there was no request of delegation to “the traditional owners”, as defined under section 3 and required under section 6(2). He makes reference to the motion passed at the Port Augusta consultation meeting, which sought a delegation to the “relevant traditional owners” and contends that in a context where there is uncertainty as to who “the traditional owners” are, this construction is inherently vague and could not be given effect.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established