Telstra Corporation Limited (ACN 051 775 556)

Link copied
Case Copied 81 min read

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION TRIBUNAL

Telstra Corporation Limited (ACN 051 775 556)

[2006] ACompT 4

TRADE PRACTICES – telecommunications access regime – application for review of decision of Australian Competition and Consumer Commission to reject access undertaking – line sharing service – whether monthly charge is reasonable – whether it promotes the long-term interests of end-users –– whether it promotes competition in markets for listed services – efficiency of capital costs – allocation of costs – levelisation of costs

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – review function of Tribunal – whether parties limited to submissions made before the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth): Pt XIC, ss 152AB, 152AH, 152AL, 152AR, 152BS, 152BU, 152BV, 152CE, 152CF, 152CGB
Telecommunications Act1997 (Cth): s 7

Application by GasNet Australia (Operations) Pty Ltd (2004) ATPR 41-978, applied
The Queen v Hunt; Ex parte Sean Investments Pty Ltd (1979) 180 CLR 322, applied

No 1 of 2006

RE:FINAL DECISION BY THE AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION DATED DECEMBER 2005 PURSUANT TO SECTION 152BU IN RESPECT OF AN ORDINARY ACCESS UNDERTAKING SUBMITTED BY TELSTRA CORPORATION LIMITED FOR THE LINE SHARING SERVICE

BY:     TELSTRA CORPORATION LIMITED (ACN 051 775 556)

Applicant

GOLDBERG J (President), MR ROBIN DAVEY & PROFESSOR DAVID ROUND

2 JUNE 2006
MELBOURNE


IN THE AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION TRIBUNAL

No 1 of 2006

RE:FINAL DECISION BY THE AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION DATED DECEMBER 2005 PURSUANT TO SECTION 152BU IN RESPECT OF AN ORDINARY ACCESS UNDERTAKING SUBMITTED BY TELSTRA CORPORATION LIMITED FOR THE LINE SHARING SERVICE

BY:     TELSTRA CORPORATION LIMITED (ACN 051 775 556)

Applicant

THE TRIBUNAL:

GOLDBERG J (President)
MR ROBIN DAVEY &

PROFESSOR DAVID ROUND

DATE OF DETERMINATION:

2 JUNE 2006

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE TRIBUNAL DETERMINES THAT:

1.The decision of the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (“the Commission”) on 21 December 2005 rejecting the access undertaking given by Telstra Corporation Limited to the Commission on 13 December 2004 is affirmed.


IN THE AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION TRIBUNAL

No 1 of 2006

RE:FINAL DECISION BY THE AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION DATED DECEMBER 2005 PURSUANT TO SECTION 152BU IN RESPECT OF AN ORDINARY ACCESS UNDERTAKING SUBMITTED BY TELSTRA CORPORATION LIMITED FOR THE LINE SHARING SERVICE

BY:     TELSTRA CORPORATION LIMITED (ACN 051 775 556)

Applicant

THE TRIBUNAL:

GOLDBERG J (President)
MR ROBIN DAVEY &

PROFESSOR DAVID ROUND

DATE:

2 JUNE 2006

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

REASONS FOR DETERMINATION

  1. This is an application by Telstra Corporation Limited (“Telstra”) pursuant to s 152CE(1) of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (“the Act”) for the review of a decision of the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (“Commission”) to reject an access undertaking under s 152BU(2) of the Act.

  2. The access undertaking sets out the price and non‑price terms and conditions upon which Telstra undertakes to provide a line sharing service (“LSS”), a service that was declared by the Commission under Pt XIC of the Act. The access undertaking was submitted by Telstra on 13 December 2004. The Commission rejected the access undertaking in its final decision made on 21…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Telstra Corporation Limited (ACN 051 775 556) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] ACompT 4
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

- **Parties and Nature of the Dispute**: The dispute involves Telstra Corporation Limited (ACN 051 775 556) as the applicant, challenging the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission's (ACCC) rejection of an access undertaking for the Line Sharing Service (LSS) submitted by Telstra. The ACCC rejected the access undertaking primarily due to the proposed $9.00 monthly charge for the LSS, deeming it unreasonable. The case was heard by the Australian Competition Tribunal, consisting of Goldberg J (President), Mr Robin Davey, and Professor David Round.

- **Legal Issues**: The principal issue was whether the $9.00 monthly charge proposed by Telstra for the LSS was reasonable, considering statutory matters such as the promotion of long-term interests of end-users, legitimate business interests of the carrier, and efficient investment in infrastructure. Secondary issues included the efficiency of Telstra's costs, the appropriateness of the capital expenditure cost model, and the correct period for levelising costs.

- **Court's Reasoning and Outcome**: The Tribunal found that the $9.00 monthly charge was not reasonable because Telstra's methodology for determining its per unit costs was not reasonable. Specifically, the Tribunal concluded that Telstra's choice of a four-year period for levelising costs was not reasonable, as it would result in higher monthly charges and discourage competition. Additionally, the Tribunal found that Telstra's method of allocating LSS-specific costs only to lines used to provide the LSS was not reasonable, as it would give Telstra a competitive advantage in downstream markets. The Tribunal affirmed the ACCC's decision to reject Telstra's access undertaking.

- **Final Orders**: The Tribunal's final order was to affirm the ACCC's decision to reject the access undertaking submitted by Telstra for the Line Sharing Service. This decision was based on the finding that the $9.00 monthly charge was not reasonable, considering the statutory matters and the impact on competition and end-users.

Background

Background to the litigation

Telstra Corporation Limited submitted an access undertaking to the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) to provide a line sharing service (LSS) under the Telecommunications Act 1997 (Cth). The ACCC rejected the undertaking, primarily due to concerns about the reasonableness of the proposed monthly charge of $9.00 for the LSS. Telstra sought a review of the ACCC's decision, which was ultimately affirmed by the Australian Competition Tribunal. The key facts include the nature of the LSS, the declaration of the LSS by the ACCC, Telstra's proposed access undertaking, the ACCC's reasons for rejecting the undertaking, and the subsequent review by the Tribunal.

Telstra Corporation Limited applied for a review of the ACCC's decision to reject its access undertaking for the LSS under section 152CE(1) of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth). The review was heard by the Australian Competition Tribunal, which affirmed the ACCC's decision. The Tribunal reviewed the matter on the merits, standing in the shoes of the ACCC but limited to the information, documents, and evidence before the ACCC. The Tribunal heard submissions from Telstra, the ACCC, and several interveners, including Optus Networks Pty Limited and XYZed Pty Limited, AAPT Ltd, Macquarie Telecom Pty Ltd, PowerTel Limited, and Primus Telecommunications Pty Ltd.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the $9.00 monthly charge is reasonable having regard to the statutory matters.
2. Whether Telstra’s Specific Costs Model provides reasonable estimates of the efficient costs of supplying the LSS.
3. Whether an implied revenue stream should be calculated using a tilted annuity formula as Telstra has done.
4. Whether the WACC employed to calculate the LSS-specific costs should be as determined by Telstra.
5. Whether the demand estimates used by Telstra should be adopted.
6. Whether the calculation of LSS-specific costs should be levelised over the period from 2002/2003 to 2005/2006 inclusive.
7. Whether the specific costs incurred by Telstra in providing the LSS should only be allocated across, and recovered by Telstra from, LSS lines.
8. Whether the $9.00 monthly charge should include a component of shared network costs calculated by reference to the PIE II model.

Held
1. The decision of the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) on 21 December 2005 rejecting the access undertaking given by Telstra Corporation Limited to the ACCC on 13 December 2004 is affirmed.
2. The $9.00 monthly charge proposed by Telstra for its line sharing service (LSS) is not reasonable having regard to the statutory matters.
3. Telstra’s Specific Costs Model does not provide reasonable estimates of the efficient costs of supplying the LSS.
4. The use of a tilted annuity formula to calculate an implied revenue stream by Telstra is not appropriate.
5. The Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) employed to calculate the LSS-specific costs should not be determined by Telstra.
6. The demand estimates used by Telstra are not acceptable.
7. The calculation of LSS-specific costs should not be levelised over the period from 2002/2003 to 2005/2006 inclusive.
8. The specific costs incurred by Telstra in providing the LSS should not be allocated solely across, and recovered only by Telstra from, LSS lines.
9. The $9.00 monthly charge should not include a component of shared network costs calculated by reference to the PIE II model.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Australian Competition Tribunal reviewed Telstra's access undertaking for the LSS, which was rejected by the ACCC. The Tribunal considered whether the $9.00 monthly charge proposed by Telstra for the LSS is reasonable under the statutory matters set out in sections 152AH and 152AB of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth). The Tribunal examined Telstra’s methodology for calculating its LSS-specific costs, including its approach to levelisation and cost allocation. It found that Telstra’s approach to levelising its costs over a four-year period and allocating these costs solely to LSS lines was not reasonable. Levelising costs over a shorter period than the useful life of the assets used to provide the service resulted in higher monthly costs, which was not in the interests of end-users and access seekers. Furthermore, allocating the costs solely to LSS lines did not promote competition, productive efficiency, or dynamic efficiency, and was not in the interests of access seekers. The Tribunal concluded that the $9.00 monthly charge was not reasonable as it was determined based on methodologies that did not align with the statutory matters. The Tribunal’s decision affirmed the ACCC's rejection of Telstra's access undertaking.