SZNKV v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2010] FCA 56
Citation:
SZNKV v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2010] FCA 56
Appeal from:
SZNKV v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2009] FMC 1053 (No. 2)
Parties:
SZNKV v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP and REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
File number:
NSD 1306 of 2009
Judge:
KENNY J
Date of judgment:
12 October 2010
Date of hearing:
10 February 2010
Place:
Melbourne (heard in Sydney)
Division:
GENERAL DIVISION
Category:
No Catchwords
Number of paragraphs:
69
Counsel for the Appellant:
The Appellant appeared in person (at hearing) / Mr T Ower (written submissions)
Counsel for the Respondents:
Ms R Graycar
Solicitor for the Respondents:
Clayton Utz
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
NSD 1306 of 2009
ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:
SZNKV Appellant
AND:
MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP First Respondent
REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL Second Respondent
JUDGE:
KENNY J
DATE OF ORDER:
12 OCTOBER 2010
WHERE MADE:
MELBOURNE (HEARD IN SYDNEY)
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.The appeal be dismissed.
2.The parties file and serve their submissions as to costs, if any, on or before 4: 30 pm on 19 October 2010
Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules. The text of entered orders can be located using Federal Law Search on the Court’s website.
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
NSD 1306 of 2009
ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:
SZNKV Appellant
AND:
MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP First Respondent
REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL Second Respondent
JUDGE:
KENNY J
DATE:
12 OCTOBER 2010
PLACE:
MELBOURNE (HEARD IN SYDNEY)
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
This is an appeal from a judgment of the Federal Magistrates Court delivered on 29 October 2009, dismissing an application for judicial review of a decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal (‘the Tribunal’). The second respondent has entered a submitting appearance.
At the hearing of the appeal, the appellant was self-represented and assisted by an interpreter. Before the hearing, the appellant had filed no written submissions and, at the hearing, he stated that he did not wish to make any oral submissions in support of his original grounds. Instead, the appellant applied to amend his notice of appeal, as discussed below. The first respondent did not oppose the grant of leave, and leave to amend was granted. The appellant then made brief oral submissions on the new ground, but indicated that he would have pro bono counsel draft further written submissions in support and, for this, he required additional time. Directions were given allowing for written submissions to be filed at a later date addressing the new ground. These written submissions were later filed.
At the hearing of the appeal, the first respondent appeared by counsel, who relied on her written submissions as to the appellant’s original grounds. The respondent subsequently filed supplementary submissions dealing with the…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read SZNKV v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship and more:
The case involves an appellant from Bangladesh who sought a protection visa in Australia, claiming persecution due to his Christian faith and involvement with the Bangladesh National Party (BNP). The Minister for Immigration and Citizenship dismissed his application, a decision that was upheld by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The appellant subsequently sought judicial review of this decision in the Federal Magistrates Court, which was also dismissed. The Federal Court was then called upon to review the decision of the Federal Magistrates Court.
The primary legal issue before the court was whether the appellant's claims of persecution due to his religious beliefs and political activities were credible and supported by the evidence. This involved assessing the consistency and plausibility of the appellant's testimony and the documentary evidence he provided.
The Federal Court found that the appellant had fabricated his claims from the outset. The court highlighted several inconsistencies in his testimony and evidence, such as his inability to recall details about his religious activities and the fabricated nature of some of the documents he provided. The court also noted that the appellant had a tendency to introduce new facts to address difficulties with his evidence. The court concluded that these issues indicated a lack of credibility and trustworthiness in the appellant's claims. Furthermore, the court found that even if some of the appellant's claims were true, they did not necessarily qualify him for a protection visa under the relevant legislation.
The Federal Court dismissed the appeal, affirming the decisions of the Federal Magistrates Court and the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The court found that the appellant's claims were not credible and did not establish a basis for granting a protection visa. Consequently, the appellant's application for a protection visa was denied.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
At the hearing of the appeal, the first respondent appeared by counsel, who relied on her written submissions as to the appellant’s original grounds. The respondent subsequently filed supplementary submissions dealing with the appellant’s the new ground. Having considered all the grounds in the appellant’s notice of appeal and the submissions made by the parties concerning them, I would dismiss the appeal.BACKGROUND The Tribunal found that the appellant was a citizen of Bangladesh, who arrived in Australia on 17 July 2008 and lodged an application with the first respondent’s Department for a protection visa on 29 August 2008. Essentially, the appellant claimed refugee status on the basis that he would be persecuted on account of his adherence to Christianity and also because of his involvement with the Bangladesh National Party (“BNP”). His claims were outlined in a statement that accompanied his application on 29 August 2008, which is summarised below. As the respondent said in written submissions:Specifically, the appellant claims he is a practising Catholic who has regularly attended Church since childhood (and continued to do so as an adult) and has been heavily involved in spiritual teaching. He claims to have had a long and continuing association with the various Catholic Churches in Bangladesh.The appellant claims that in 2004 he joined the Bangladesh Catholic Party (BCA). He claims to be an active member of the BCA.The appellant also claims he has been a member of the BNP since 1986, and to have been elected to various official positions in the BNP including Secretary. He claims to have organised various political activities, protests and rallies. The appellant claims he was involved in 1986 in student elections which were sabotaged, and that he was attacked and injured. He claims to have been hospitalized for one day and also to have received treatment at home. He also claims that on 19 April 2008 he was going to school and was attacked and spent two days in hospital.The appellant claims that Catholics in Bangladesh are systematically targeted by Muslim members of the community, and if he returned, he would be persecuted for his religious beliefs, as he has been in the past. On 6 November 2008, a delegate of the first respondent refused the appellant’s application. On 2 December 2008, the appellant applied to the Tribunal for a review of the delegate’s decision. The Tribunal affirmed the delegate’s decision on 11 March 2009. The appellant filed an application for judicial review in the Federal Magistrates Court. This application was heard on 10 August 2009 and 19 October 2009. It was dismissed on 29 October 2009.APPELLANT’S CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE In its reasons, the Tribunal reproduced the appellant’s fifteen-page statement in support of his visa application. The statement is not especially easy to follow, but the basic facts of the appellant’s claims can be discerned. In summary, the appellant apparently claimed that: ·He was born into a Roman Catholic family. When he was a child, he learned from his father that his family had been robbed, beaten and shot at by “a group of Muslim people”. Muslims asked his family for bribes during Christmas and Easter and put pressure on them to convert to Islam. At school, Muslim children discriminated against the appellant and his siblings. Muslim students teased Christian students and threatened to kidnap his sisters. ·In college, he joined the student wing of the BNP. He participated in meetings and rallies, and gave speeches. The appellant ran for office in the student union election, but the election was cancelled. The appellant participated in a rally protesting against the cancellation of the election. During the rally, “Nationalist party wing students” threw bricks at the protesters. The appellant was hit on the head by a piece of a brick and lost consciousness. ·From July 1989, he was involved with a credit union named Harbaid Economical Savings Credit Union Limited. While he was president of the credit union, “some Christian people of our community accompanied with Muslims” conspired to remove him from office and force him out of his village. When he ceased to hold office, the new officers filed a case against eleven of the former office holders. As a result, the police raided the appellant’s home and tried to arrest him, and he had to leave his village for several days. ·In 1991, after the BNP took power in national elections, members of the Nationalist and Awami League parties threatened to kill him. The appellant was elected secretary of a BNP committee in his area. ·On 16 December 1991, he joined a Christian organization named World Concern Bangladesh, working as a supervisor on a project called the “Sunflower Education Project”. When this project began, “Muslim villagers” accused the project’s staff of teaching the Bible and converting Muslims to Christianity. In 1997, the appellant was promoted to area organizer at his job with World Concern Bangladesh. In July 1999, the project with which he was involved separated from World Concern Bangladesh, taking the name Basic Development Partners (“BDP”). When the appellant began teaching religion to Christian students, Muslims accused him of teaching the Bible to Muslim students and preaching Christianity to them. Without arguing with the Muslims, the appellant left the area. He returned a few months later and resumed teaching religious classes for Christian students but “Muslim leaders” and “shibir cadres” threatened to kill him with a bomb if he returned to the school. ·In 1996, the Awami League gained power. The party “started to fabricate . . . cases” against various individuals associated with the BNP. As a result, the appellant had to flee for a few days. ·In 2006, the BNP (which it can be inferred had at some prior point regained power) handed power over to a caretaker government. Police thereafter arrested eleven BNP leaders from Pubail Union. After hearing of this, the appellant left his home for a few days to avoid arrest.·The appellant became secretary of the Harbaid Gazipur branch of the Bangladesh Christian Association. The Association organized many rallies protesting violence against Christians. Muslim extremists threatened to kill the appellant and kidnap his children because of his involvement with one protest. ·In April 2008, the appellant taught a religious class to Christian students at the Boshugaon project school. Afterwards, as the appellant was returning home on his motorbike, four or five Islamic religious leaders stopped him and accused him of teaching the Bible. They threatened to kill him if he did not quit his job. On his return to the school a few days later, he saw five to seven Islamic religious leaders with beards standing in front of him, and these men began beating him with their hands. They told the appellant they would kill him if they saw him again. A few days later, on 19 April 2008, ten to twelve people beat the appellant with sticks as he was travelling to another school on his motorbike. The appellant lost consciousness and awoke in Dhaka Medical College Hospital. His nose and mouth were bandaged and his backbone was stitched. The next day, while still in the hospital, the appellant “saw some boys . . . looking at [him] with big eyes and [he] understood that they wanted to kill [him]”. The appellant escaped to a relative’s house in Monipuripara, where he remained in hiding. After recovering from his injuries, the appellant returned to his job. He received a letter on the letterhead of the JMB, an Islamic extremist group, threatening to kill him, and received an anonymous phone call at the same time. The appellant’s family tried to file a case at the police station but the police would not take the case. The applicant himself could not go to the police station because “JMB cadres” had threatened to kill him if he went to the police. After these events, the appellant had the opportunity to travel to Australia for World Youth Day with the help of a local parish priest. After arriving in Australia, the appellant received a phone call from Bangladesh informing him that if he returned JMB cadres would kill him.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
On 6 November 2008, a delegate of the first respondent refused the appellant’s application. On 2 December 2008, the appellant applied to the Tribunal for a review of the delegate’s decision. The Tribunal affirmed the delegate’s decision on 11 March 2009. The appellant filed an application for judicial review in the Federal Magistrates Court. This application was heard on 10 August 2009 and 19 October 2009. It was dismissed on 29 October 2009.APPELLANT’S CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE In its reasons, the Tribunal reproduced the appellant’s fifteen-page statement in support of his visa application. The statement is not especially easy to follow, but the basic facts of the appellant’s claims can be discerned. In summary, the appellant apparently claimed that: ·He was born into a Roman Catholic family. When he was a child, he learned from his father that his family had been robbed, beaten and shot at by “a group of Muslim people”. Muslims asked his family for bribes during Christmas and Easter and put pressure on them to convert to Islam. At school, Muslim children discriminated against the appellant and his siblings. Muslim students teased Christian students and threatened to kidnap his sisters. ·In college, he joined the student wing of the BNP. He participated in meetings and rallies, and gave speeches. The appellant ran for office in the student union election, but the election was cancelled. The appellant participated in a rally protesting against the cancellation of the election. During the rally, “Nationalist party wing students” threw bricks at the protesters. The appellant was hit on the head by a piece of a brick and lost consciousness. ·From July 1989, he was involved with a credit union named Harbaid Economical Savings Credit Union Limited. While he was president of the credit union, “some Christian people of our community accompanied with Muslims” conspired to remove him from office and force him out of his village. When he ceased to hold office, the new officers filed a case against eleven of the former office holders. As a result, the police raided the appellant’s home and tried to arrest him, and he had to leave his village for several days. ·In 1991, after the BNP took power in national elections, members of the Nationalist and Awami League parties threatened to kill him. The appellant was elected secretary of a BNP committee in his area. ·On 16 December 1991, he joined a Christian organization named World Concern Bangladesh, working as a supervisor on a project called the “Sunflower Education Project”. When this project began, “Muslim villagers” accused the project’s staff of teaching the Bible and converting Muslims to Christianity. In 1997, the appellant was promoted to area organizer at his job with World Concern Bangladesh. In July 1999, the project with which he was involved separated from World Concern Bangladesh, taking the name Basic Development Partners (“BDP”). When the appellant began teaching religion to Christian students, Muslims accused him of teaching the Bible to Muslim students and preaching Christianity to them. Without arguing with the Muslims, the appellant left the area. He returned a few months later and resumed teaching religious classes for Christian students but “Muslim leaders” and “shibir cadres” threatened to kill him with a bomb if he returned to the school. ·In 1996, the Awami League gained power. The party “started to fabricate . . . cases” against various individuals associated with the BNP. As a result, the appellant had to flee for a few days. ·In 2006, the BNP (which it can be inferred had at some prior point regained power) handed power over to a caretaker government. Police thereafter arrested eleven BNP leaders from Pubail Union. After hearing of this, the appellant left his home for a few days to avoid arrest.·The appellant became secretary of the Harbaid Gazipur branch of the Bangladesh Christian Association. The Association organized many rallies protesting violence against Christians. Muslim extremists threatened to kill the appellant and kidnap his children because of his involvement with one protest. ·In April 2008, the appellant taught a religious class to Christian students at the Boshugaon project school. Afterwards, as the appellant was returning home on his motorbike, four or five Islamic religious leaders stopped him and accused him of teaching the Bible. They threatened to kill him if he did not quit his job. On his return to the school a few days later, he saw five to seven Islamic religious leaders with beards standing in front of him, and these men began beating him with their hands. They told the appellant they would kill him if they saw him again. A few days later, on 19 April 2008, ten to twelve people beat the appellant with sticks as he was travelling to another school on his motorbike. The appellant lost consciousness and awoke in Dhaka Medical College Hospital. His nose and mouth were bandaged and his backbone was stitched. The next day, while still in the hospital, the appellant “saw some boys . . . looking at [him] with big eyes and [he] understood that they wanted to kill [him]”. The appellant escaped to a relative’s house in Monipuripara, where he remained in hiding. After recovering from his injuries, the appellant returned to his job. He received a letter on the letterhead of the JMB, an Islamic extremist group, threatening to kill him, and received an anonymous phone call at the same time. The appellant’s family tried to file a case at the police station but the police would not take the case. The applicant himself could not go to the police station because “JMB cadres” had threatened to kill him if he went to the police. After these events, the appellant had the opportunity to travel to Australia for World Youth Day with the help of a local parish priest. After arriving in Australia, the appellant received a phone call from Bangladesh informing him that if he returned JMB cadres would kill him.
Decision
Reasons for decision
After the hearing, the appellant submitted an additional written statement to the Tribunal, stating amongst other things, that he was nervous during the interview and forgot to mention things at the hearing. TRIBUNAL DECISION Overall, the Tribunal concluded that “the available evidence supports a conclusion” that the appellant had fabricated his claim for refugee status “from the outset” and that “none of his evidence can be relied upon”. In reaching this conclusion, the Tribunal relied on the matters raised with the appellant at the hearing: see para [9] above. First, the Tribunal reasoned that “the applicant’s inability to recall the names of Priests associated with the Churches with which he has claimed a long and continuing association indicates both that the documentation which he has provided cannot be relied upon, and furthermore that he is not being truthful in his claims”. The Tribunal concluded that the Pubail Union Council letter was fabricated, as it was identical to a letter submitted in support of a different application. In particular, the Tribunal considered it unlikely that phrases such as “he falls into the livid eye of forbidden religious organisation . . .” would be duplicated by chance. Based on the appellant’s presentation of a letter it considered fabricated, the Tribunal concluded that the appellant was “prepared to organise and present obviously manufactured and false material to support his claim”. The Tribunal also found that the letter regarding the appellant’s association with the Bangladesh Christian Association was “not genuine”, noting that the letter contradicted the appellant’s oral evidence regarding his role in the organisation. The Tribunal expressed the view that the appellant exhibited a “tendency to introduce new facts to explain difficulties with the evidence”. In this regard, the Tribunal cited the appellant’s evidence regarding the “false case” against him and his claim that he no longer supported the BNP. The Tribunal did not accept that the appellant had experienced threats and attacks by the JMB as a result of work as a teacher. In the Tribunal’s view, the problems it identified with the appellant’s evidence were “so serious, and so obviously indicate[d] that the appellant [was] prepared to be to be untruthful in supporting his claim” that the appellant’s account of these attacks had to be regarded as “just another example of fabricating a claim”. For the same reason, the Tribunal concluded that even letters provided by the appellant which were not obviously fabrications could not be relied on. The Tribunal therefore rejected the appellant’s request that it attempt to verify the documents. Regarding the status of Catholics in Bangladesh, the Tribunal noted that, according to country information, extremist groups such as the JMB operated in the country, but that “Catholics are able to practise their faith through established churches in Bangladesh”. The Tribunal concluded that converts to Catholicism and Catholics who were perceived as attempting to convert others might be at risk, but found that the appellant was not among either group. Further, although the Tribunal found the appellant to be a practising Catholic, it suggested that he might have exaggerated the extent of his religious activity. The import of these findings is central to the resolution of the appellant’s new appeal ground, and they are discussed in detail below.