Samuel v Sebel Furniture Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

WORKERS COMPENSATION COMMISSION

DETERMINATION OF APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY AN ARBITRATOR

REPORTED DECISION: Samuel v Sebel Furniture Limited (2006) 5 DDCR 482

CITATION:Samuel v Sebel Furniture Limited [2006] NSWWCCPD 141

APPELLANT:  Emad Samuel

RESPONDENT:  Sebel Furniture Limited

INSURER:NRMA Workers Compensation (NSW) (No 2) Pty Ltd

FILE NUMBERS:  WCC2378-05 & WCC5282-02

DATE OF ARBITRATOR’S DECISION:          29 June 2005

DATE OF APPEAL DECISION:  7 July 2006

SUBJECT MATTER OF DECISION: Reconsideration; section 350(3) Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998; Anshun Estoppel

PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER:  Acting Deputy President Bill Roche

HEARING:On the papers

REPRESENTATION:  Appellant:      Watson Stafford

Respondent:   Moray & Agnew

ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL:  The decision of the Arbitrator of 29 June 2005 is revoked and the following orders are made in its place:

“1. Pursuant to reconsideration under section 350(3) of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 the order made in Certificate of Determination dated 29 November 2003 is rescinded.

2.    The Commission finds that on 7 January 2002 the Appellant Worker suffered injury to his lower abdomen in the nature of bilateral hernias in the course of his employment with the Respondent Employer and to which his employment was a substantial contributing factor.

3.    The matter is remitted to a different Arbitrator to determine the Appellant Worker’s entitlement to compensation in accordance with this decision.

4.The evidence in matter 5285 of 2002 is to be evidence in matter 2378 of 2005.

5.The Respondent Employer is to pay the Appellant Worker’s costs.”

The Respondent Employer is to pay the Appellant Worker’s costs of the appeal.

BACKGROUND TO THE APPEAL

  1. On 26 July 2005 Emad Samuel (‘the Appellant Worker/Mr Samuel’) sought leave to bring an ‘Appeal Against Decision of Arbitrator’ in the Workers Compensation Commission (‘the Commission’) against a decision, dated 29 June 2005.

  1. The Respondent to the Appeal is Sebel Furniture Limited (‘the Respondent Employer/Sebel’).

  1. Mr Samuel alleges that on 7 January 2002 he suffered a strain injury to his left abdomen and groin whilst lifting a table and other objects in the course of his employment with Sebel.  He attended that morning at Sebel’s first aid office complaining of groin pain and later that day at Bankstown Hospital but did not receive any treatment.  He then attended Fairfield Hospital where he was admitted and came under the care of Dr Durmush, consultant surgeon.  He remained in Fairfield Hospital from 7 January 2002 until 11 January 2002.  The hospital notes record that Mr Samuel presented with a one day history of “LIF pain + lump in Lt groin”.  The diagnosis was balanitis (inflammation of the glans penis) with left inguinal lymphadenitis.  He was treated with bed rest and antibiotics.  His groin pain continued and his attempted return to work late January 2002 was unsuccessful. 

  1. On 16 December 2002 Mr Samuel filed an Application to Resolve a Dispute (Application 5282-02) (‘the First Application’) in the Commission seeking weekly compensation and medical expenses. That application was opposed by Sebel. The issue…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Samuel v Sebel Furniture Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] NSWWCCPD 141
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Emad Samuel sought reconsideration of a decision by the Workers Compensation Commission (the Commission) which had found that he had not suffered a work-related injury. The Commission's decision had been made pursuant to a Medical Assessment Certificate (MAC) from an Approved Medical Specialist (AMS). Mr Samuel had surgery for bilateral hernias in 2004, and sought reconsideration on the basis of the surgical findings and evidence from his surgeon. The Commission had refused to reconsider the earlier decision, and Mr Samuel sought to appeal the Commission’s decision. The appeal was allowed. The Commission had erred in failing to properly consider the medical evidence and in applying Anshun estoppel. The Appellant Worker was entitled to have his claim reconsidered in light of the new evidence. The Commission’s earlier decision was revoked, and the matter was remitted to a different arbitrator to determine the Appellant Worker’s entitlement to compensation. The Respondent Employer was ordered to pay the Appellant Worker’s costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Emad Samuel, the appellant, alleges that he suffered a strain injury to his lower abdomen, specifically in the nature of bilateral hernias, on 7 January 2002 while lifting a table and other objects during his employment with Sebel Furniture Limited, the respondent. Samuel attended the first aid office of Sebel that morning and later visited Bankstown Hospital but did not receive treatment. He was subsequently admitted to Fairfield Hospital where he was under the care of Dr Durmush, a consultant surgeon. Samuel remained in the hospital from 7 January until 11 January 2002. Medical notes indicate that Samuel presented with a one-day history of left groin pain and lump, diagnosed as balanitis and left inguinal lymphadenitis, treated with bed rest and antibiotics. Despite treatment, his groin pain persisted, leading to an unsuccessful attempt to return to work in late January 2002. Samuel filed an Application to Resolve a Dispute in December 2002, seeking weekly compensation and medical expenses. The issue of whether Samuel suffered a hernia or any other work-related injury was referred to an Approved Medical Specialist, Dr Endrey-Walder, who concluded that Samuel did not have a hernia or any work-related injury. Following this, a Certificate of Determination was issued on 24 November 2003, awarding the respondent based on the agreement to be bound by Dr Endrey-Walder's opinion. Despite the earlier determination, Samuel continued to experience groin pain and underwent surgery in May 2004, revealing bilateral direct inguinal hernias. A further Application to Resolve a Dispute was filed in February 2005, leading to the Arbitrator's decision on 29 June 2005, which Samuel now appeals.

The case began when Emad Samuel filed an Application to Resolve a Dispute in December 2002, which was opposed by Sebel Furniture Limited. The dispute centred on whether Samuel had suffered a hernia or any other work-related injury on 7 January 2002. This issue was referred to an Approved Medical Specialist, Dr Endrey-Walder, who concluded that Samuel did not have a hernia or any work-related injury. A Certificate of Determination was issued on 24 November 2003, awarding the respondent based on the agreement to be bound by Dr Endrey-Walder's opinion. Despite this, Samuel continued to experience groin pain, leading to surgery in May 2004, which revealed bilateral direct inguinal hernias. A further Application to Resolve a Dispute was filed in February 2005. The Arbitrator's decision on 29 June 2005 was appealed by Samuel on 26 July 2005. The appeal was heard by Acting Deputy President Bill Roche on 7 July 2006.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Arbitrator erred in not giving sufficient weight to the findings at surgery made by Dr Sanki.
2. Whether the Arbitrator erred in not giving sufficient weight to the findings in the histopathology report prepared by Dr Bowen on 7 May 2004.
3. Whether the Arbitrator erred in not giving sufficient weight to findings of Dr Sanki and Dr Bowen considering Samuel's consistent complaints of groin pain from January 2002 and the medical evidence and investigations available in 2002 and 2003 which pointed to the presence of a hernia.
4. Whether the Arbitrator erred in preferring the opinion of the Approved Medical Specialist.
5. Whether the Arbitrator erred in preferring the opinion of Dr McKessar.
6. Whether the Arbitrator erred in rejecting the Second Application because it was filed nine months after the surgery performed by Dr Sanki.
7. Whether the Arbitrator erred in misdirecting himself that section 327(7) of the 1998 Act prohibited reconsideration under section 350 of the 1998 Act.
8. Whether the Arbitrator erred in finding that the grounds for reconsideration under section 350 of the 1998 Act had not been made out.

Held
1. The court held that the Arbitrator erred in not giving sufficient weight to the findings at surgery made by Dr Sanki.
2. The court held that the Arbitrator erred in not giving sufficient weight to the findings in the histopathology report prepared by Dr Bowen on 7 May 2004.
3. The court held that the Arbitrator erred in not giving sufficient weight to findings of Dr Sanki and Dr Bowen considering Samuel's consistent complaints of groin pain from January 2002 and the medical evidence and investigations available in 2002 and 2003 which pointed to the presence of a hernia.
4. The court held that the Arbitrator erred in preferring the opinion of the Approved Medical Specialist.
5. The court held that the Arbitrator erred in preferring the opinion of Dr McKessar.
6. The court held that the Arbitrator did not err in rejecting the Second Application because it was filed nine months after the surgery performed by Dr Sanki.
7. The court held that the Arbitrator erred in misdirecting himself that section 327(7) of the 1998 Act prohibited reconsideration under section 350 of the 1998 Act.
8. The court held that the Arbitrator erred in finding that the grounds for reconsideration under section 350 of the 1998 Act had not been made out.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court found that the Arbitrator made several errors in the assessment of the case, primarily in not giving sufficient weight to the findings of Dr Sanki and Dr Bowen, the medical evidence, and the Appellant's consistent complaints of groin pain. The court examined the legal principles applied by the Arbitrator and found that the discretion to reconsider under section 350(3) of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 was not exercised fairly. The court held that reconsideration was warranted due to the new evidence that could not have been obtained at the time of the first award and would have had a material effect on the outcome. The court also held that the Arbitrator erred in misdirecting himself regarding the applicability of section 327(7) of the 1998 Act and the doctrine of Anshun Estoppel. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that the reconsideration provision in section 350(3) of the 1998 Act allows the Commission to rectify errors by taking into account relevant new evidence and correcting previous decisions where necessary to ensure justice is served.