Bullock v Kincare Health Services Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER 
CITATION: Bullock v Kincare Health Services Pty Ltd [2023] NSWPIC 688
APPLICANT: Patricia Dawn Bullock
RESPONDENT: Kincare Health Services Pty Ltd
MEMBER: Brett Batchelor
DATE OF DECISION: 21 December 2023
CATCHWORDS:

WORKERS COMPENSATION - Request for reconsideration by the respondent employer of Certificate of Determination containing an award of weekly benefits in favour of the applicant worker, on the ground that there was an error in the pre-injury average weekly earnings (PIAWE) used by the Member to calculate the award; the error arose as a result of an incorrect assurance given by the respondent at the arbitration hearing that the PIAWE pleaded in the Application to Resolve a Dispute was correct when, according to the respondent, it was subsequently ascertained not to be correct; this error was acknowledged by the respondent’s solicitor; consideration of section 57 of the Personal Injury Act 2020, the former section 350(3) of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 and the observations of Roche ADP in Samuel v Sebel Furniture Pty Ltd as to the power of reconsideration; consideration also of Ceccato v Australian Steel Mill Services Pty Ltd (No 2) and Fairfield City Council v McCall (No2); review of the Samuel observations as they applied to the facts of the case; consideration of Atomic Steel Constructions v Tedeschi, Sorcevski v Steggles Pty Ltd, and Steggles Pty Ltd v Sorcevski; Held – request for reconsideration refused.

DETERMINATIONS MADE:

The Commission determines:

1.     The respondent’s request to reconsider my decision in the Certificate of Determination dated 28 August 2023 is refused.

STATEMENT OF REASONS

BACKGROUND

  1. On 17 August 2015 Dawn Bullock (the applicant/Ms Bullock) sustained an injury arising out of or in the course of her employment as a home carer with Kincare Health Services Pty Ltd (the respondent), and a further injury in that employment on 28 August 2017.

  2. Following the injury of 28 August 2017 the applicant was in receipt of weekly payments of compensation from the respondent’s insurer, Employers Mutual Limited (EML). On
    14 January 2021 EML issued to the applicant a notice under s 78 of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 (the 1998 Act) bringing her weekly payments to an end (the work capacity decision). In that notice EML recorded a decision under s 43(1)(c) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (the 1987 Act) indicating that
    Ms Bullock could earn $237.69 per week in suitable employment, working nine hours per week.

  3. That decision of EML was confirmed on 8 April 2021 when it issued to the applicant a further notice under s 78 of the 1998 Act in the same terms as the work capacity decision.

  4. The applicant commenced the current proceedings in the Personal Injury Commission (Commission) with the lodgement of an Application to Resolve a Dispute (ARD) on
    16 May 2023, which proceeded to an arbitration hearing before me on 15 August 2023.

  5. On 28 August 2023 the Commission issued a Certificate of Determination…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bullock v Kincare Health Services Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWPIC 688
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Bullock v Kincare Health Services Pty Ltd, the applicant sought reconsideration by the respondent employer of a Certificate of Determination (COD) that contained an award of weekly benefits. The dispute centred on an alleged error in the pre-injury average weekly earnings (PIAWE) used by the Member to calculate the award. The error was said to have arisen from an incorrect assurance provided by the respondent at the arbitration hearing regarding the accuracy of the PIAWE. The applicant argued that the error did not constitute an "obvious error" as defined in section 57(6) of the Personal Injury Act 2020, and thus should not lead to reconsideration. The respondent, on the other hand, argued that the error should be rectified through reconsideration, irrespective of whether it met the criteria for an obvious error.

The legal issues before the court involved the interpretation of section 57 of the Personal Injury Act 2020, which governs the reconsideration of decisions by the Commission, and the relevance of prior statutory provisions such as section 350(3) of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998. The court also examined the observations made by Roche ADP in Samuel v Sebel Furniture Pty Ltd concerning the power of reconsideration, as well as other relevant cases like Ceccato v Australian Steel Mill Services Pty Ltd (No 2) and Fairfield City Council v McCall (No2). Additionally, the court reviewed decisions in Atomic Steel Constructions v Tedeschi, Sorcevski v Steggles Pty Ltd, and Steggles Pty Ltd v Sorcevski to understand the broader context of reconsideration and the factors that influence such decisions.

The court concluded that the error in the PIAWE did not constitute an "obvious error" as defined by the Personal Injury Act 2020. It found that the error did not fall within the examples given in section 57(6) of the Act, which include clerical or typographical errors, errors arising from accidental slips or omissions, defects of form, or inconsistencies between the stated decision and the stated reasons. The court also noted that while the respondent acknowledged the error, this alone did not warrant reconsideration. The court's decision was influenced by the interests of justice and the public interest in the finality of litigation, as outlined in Procedural Direction WC7. Therefore, the request for reconsideration was refused.

The final order of the court was that the application for reconsideration of the Certificate of Determination was dismissed. The court did not alter or amend the original decision, and the Certificate of Determination remained in effect as originally issued.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Section 57 of the PIC Act provides:“57 Reconsideration of decisions of Commission(1) The Commission may reconsider any matter that has been dealt with by the Commission in the Workers Compensation Division and rescind, alter or amend any decision previously made or given by the Commission in that Division.(2) If after the making of a decision by the Commission (and without limiting subsection (1)), the President is satisfied that the decision contains an obvious error, the President may—(a) alter the decision to correct the error, or(b) direct a registrar to alter the decision to correct the error.(3) Without limiting subsection (2), if the decision is contained in a certificate, the President may—(a) issue a replacement certificate with the error corrected, or(b) direct a registrar to issue a replacement certificate with the error corrected.(4) If a decision is altered, the altered decision is taken to be the decision and notice of the alteration is to be given to the parties in the proceedings in the manner directed by the President.(5) If a replacement certificate is issued, the certificate prevails over any previous certificate.(6) Examples of obvious errors in a decision are where—(a) there is an obvious clerical or typographical error in the text of the notice or statement, or(b) there is an error arising from an accidental slip or omission, or(c) there is a defect of form, or(d) there is an inconsistency between the stated decision and the stated reasons.” Practice Direction 4 referred to by the applicant at [40] above is dated 30 October 2018 and was issued pursuant to r 18 of the Workers Compensation Commission Rules 2011. These rules were repealed by s 67 of the PIC Act. Practice Direction 4 is now replaced by Procedural Direction WC7 – Reconsiderations of decisions of the Commission (PDWC7), which applies to the Workers Compensation Division of the Commission, and which commenced on 16 August 2022. Clause [15] of PDWC7 provides:“15. The following matters may be considered in deciding the reconsideration application:(a) the objects of the Commission under ss 3 and 42 of the PIC Act;(b) the reason for and extent of any delay in bringing the application;(c) any fresh evidence, additional evidence or substituted evidence, that could not have reasonably been obtained prior to the decision and which would have likely led to a different result if before the original decision maker;(d) the public interest in finality of litigation;(e) that mistake or oversight by a legal representative or agent may not, in itself, be determinative of whether relief should be granted, and(f) the interests of justice.” The applicant makes submissions in respect of the concept of “obvious error” in the COD, submitting that there is no such error in accordance with the examples given in s 57(6) of the PIC Act. The respondent does not specifically address this concept in its submissions, asserting simply that the error of Hall & Wilcox in respect of PIAWE should be remedied by reconsideration of [3] of the COD.