Nicolaides v Blacktown City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER 

Citation:

Nicolaides v Blacktown City Council [2023] NSWPIC 409

APPLICANT: George Nicolaides
RESPONDENT: Blacktown City Council
Member: Brett Batchelor
DATE OF DECISION: 15 August 2023
CATCHWORDS:

WORKERS COMPENSATION - Workers Compensation Act 1987; application for review of weekly payments following decision between the same parties which resulted in an award for weekly benefits and section 60 compensation as a result of psychological injury sustained by the applicant worker; submission that an acknowledgement by the applicant during the hearing of the matter that the respondent have credit for payments made to the applicant since he was suspended from work created an estoppel preventing the applicant seeking payment of weekly benefits ordered in the Certificate of Determination (COD) during the same period the applicant received ‘special leave’ from the respondent while it investigated allegations of misconduct by the applicant; Viney v Burwood Council and section 46 considered in respect of the alleged receipt of ‘dual benefits’ during the period that weekly benefits were ordered in favour of the applicant; the respondent submitted Viney could be distinguished and that the applicant suffered no loss during the period he was paid ‘special leave’, therefore he should not receive weekly payments during this period; submission by the respondent that the Commission lacked jurisdiction to hear the current application; the applicant also claimed section 60 expenses for car travel to and from his general practitioner, after having moved out of the area in which that practitioner practised; the respondent opposed this claim, relying inter alia, on section 60(2B); Held – the applicant was not estopped from seeking payment of weekly benefits ordered in the COD during the same period the applicant received ‘special leave’ from the respondent while it investigated allegations of misconduct by the applicant; that the Commission had jurisdiction to reconsider the COD in matter number W395/22; section 57 of the Personal Injury Commission Act 2020 considered; finding that the expenses claimed by the applicant for travel by car to and from his general practitioner’s surgery were not reasonable; the respondent was ordered to pay the weekly benefits awarded to the applicant during the period he was in receipt of ‘special leave’ from the respondent.

.

determinations made:

The Commission determines:

1.   The Commission has jurisdiction to reconsider the Certificate of Determination dated 15 August 2022.

2.   The acknowledgement by counsel for the respondent at the arbitration hearing on 10 August 2022 does not create an issue estoppel preventing the applicant from claiming the weekly benefits for the period from 20 January 2022 to 24 March 2022 awarded to him in the Certificate of Determination dated 15 August 2022.

3.   The payment of special leave to the applicant for the period 20 January 2022 to 24 March 2022 does not constitute dual benefits of the same kind being payable by the respondent during and in respect of the applicant’s incapacity for work for the period from 20 January 2022 to 24 March 2022.

4.   The respondent is to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nicolaides v Blacktown City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWPIC 409
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Nicolaides v Blacktown City Council involved a dispute between the applicant, Nicolaides, and the Blacktown City Council over workers' compensation payments. Nicolaides claimed that he was entitled to receive weekly benefits and section 60 compensation due to a psychological injury sustained during his employment. The Council argued that Nicolaides was estopped from claiming benefits for the period he was on 'special leave' while the Council investigated allegations of misconduct. The Council also claimed the Commission lacked jurisdiction to hear the application. Furthermore, the Council opposed Nicolaides' claim for section 60 expenses for travel to his general practitioner after he moved out of the area where the practitioner was located.

The court had to determine whether Nicolaides was estopped from claiming weekly benefits during the period he was on 'special leave' and whether the Commission had jurisdiction to reconsider the Certificate of Determination. Additionally, the court needed to decide if the travel expenses claimed by Nicolaides were reasonable under section 60. The court considered the principles of estoppel, the jurisdiction of the Commission, and the reasonableness of the claimed expenses in light of the relevant legislation.

The court found that Nicolaides was not estopped from seeking payment of weekly benefits during the period he was on 'special leave'. It held that the Commission had jurisdiction to reconsider the Certificate of Determination under section 57 of the Personal Injury Commission Act 2020. The court also found that the travel expenses claimed by Nicolaides were not reasonable as he had moved out of the area where his general practitioner was located. Therefore, the Council was ordered to pay the weekly benefits awarded to Nicolaides during the period he was on'special leave'.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Section 57 of the PIC Act is as follows:“57 Reconsideration of decisions of Commission(1) The Commission may reconsider any matter that has been dealt with by the Commission in the Workers Compensation Division and rescind, alter or amend any decision previously made or given by the Commission in that Division.(2) If after the making of a decision by the Commission (and without limiting subsection (1)), the President is satisfied that the decision contains an obvious error, the President may—(a) alter the decision to correct the error, or(b) direct a registrar to alter the decision to correct the error.(3) Without limiting subsection (2), if the decision is contained in a certificate, the President may—(a) issue a replacement certificate with the error corrected, or(b) direct a registrar to issue a replacement certificate with the error corrected.(4) If a decision is altered, the altered decision is taken to be the decision and notice of the alteration is to be given to the parties in the proceedings in the manner directed by the President.(5) If a replacement certificate is issued, the certificate prevails over any previous certificate.(6) Examples of obvious errors in a decision are where—(a) there is an obvious clerical or typographical error in the text of the notice or statement, or(b) there is an error arising from an accidental slip or omission, or(c) there is a defect of form, or(d) there is an inconsistency between the stated decision and the stated reasons.” Section 57(1) replaced the former s 350(3) of the 1998 Act which was considered by (then) Acting Deputy President Roche at [58] in Samuel v Sebel Furniture Ltd.[10] It is accepted by the Commission that the observations of Roche ADP are relevant to the consideration of s 57(1) of the PIC Act. They are as follows (omitting authorities with the exception of Anshun):[10] [2006] NSWWCCPD 141 (Sebel).“58. Having regard to the above authorities and the provisions and objectives of the 1998 Act I believe that the following principles are applicable to reconsideration applications under section 350(3) of the 1998 Act:1.the section gives the Commission a wide discretion to reconsider its previous decisions;2.whilst the word ‘decision’ is not defined in section 350, it is defined for the purposes of section 352 to include ‘an award, order, determination, ruling and direction’. In my view ‘decision’ in section 350(3) includes, but is not necessarily limited to, any award, order or determination of the Commission;3.whilst the discretion is a wide one it must be exercised fairly with due regard to relevant considerations including the reason for and extent of any delay in bringing the application for reconsideration;4.one of the factors to be weighed in deciding whether to exercise the discretion in favour of the moving party is the public interest that litigation should not proceed indefinitely;5.reconsideration may be allowed if new evidence that could not with reasonable diligence have been obtained at the first Arbitration is later obtained and that new evidence, if it had been put before an Arbitrator in the first hearing, would have been likely to lead to a different result;6.given the broad power of ‘review’ in section 352 (which was not universally available in the Compensation Court of NSW) the reconsideration provision in section 350(3) will not usually be the preferred provision to be used to correct errors of fact, law or discretion made by Arbitrators;7.depending on the facts of the particular case the principles enunciated by the High Court in Port of Melbourne Authority v Anshun Pty Ltd[1981] HCA 45; (1981) 147 CLR 589 (‘Anshun’) may prevent a party from pursuing a claim or defence in later reconsideration proceedings if it unreasonably refrained from pursuing that claim or defence in the original proceedings (‘Anshun’);8.a mistake or oversight by a legal adviser will not give rise to a ground for reconsideration, and9.the Commission has a duty to do justice between the parties according to the substantial merits of the case.”