| CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER | |
Citation: | Cottom v Scone Race Club Limited [2022] NSWPIC 519 |
| APPLICANT: | Gregory James Cottom |
| RESPONDENT: | Scone Race Club Limited |
| Member: | John Wynyard |
| DATE OF DECISION: | 20 September 2022 |
| CATCHWORDS: | WORKERS COMPENSATION - |
| determinations made: | 1. The application is rejected. |
STATEMENT OF REASONS
BACKGROUND
Gregory James Cottom the applicant, brings an action against Scone Race Club Limited, the respondent, for lump sum compensation.
Dispute notices were duly lodged.
The Application to Resolve a Dispute (ARD) and Reply were issued.
ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION
The parties agree that the following issue remains in dispute:
(a) does the Personal Injury Commission (the Commission) have jurisdiction to order a reconsideration by the Medical Appeal Panel?
PROCEDURE BEFORE THE COMMISSION
At the video hearing on 28 April 2022, I issued directions for written submissions as set out below. The applicant was represented by Mr Christian Hart of counsel instructed by
Mr Raymond Blissett of Messrs Bale Boshev, solicitors. The respondent was represented by Ms Belinda Walsh from Messrs Hall and Wilcox, lawyers.I am satisfied that the parties to the dispute understand the nature of the application and the legal implications of any assertion made in the information supplied. I have used my best endeavours in attempting to bring the parties to the dispute to a settlement acceptable to all of them. I am satisfied that the parties have had sufficient opportunity to explore settlement and that they have been unable to reach an agreed resolution of the dispute.
EVIDENCE
Documentary evidence
The relevant documentary evidence will be referred to in the reasons below. It is impractical to list the evidence, most of which is of marginal relevance. There were over 50 files of evidence to download. I have accepted the factual background as it has been set out by both parties, as there is no dispute as to the chronology. I have also been assisted by the chronology filed by the applicant.
Oral evidence
No application was made with regard to oral evidence.
FINDINGS AND REASONS
This matter has a somewhat chequered history, as can be seen from the volume of documentation.
The matter number confirms that it started life as an ARD in 2020 for weekly payments arising from an injury on 23 May 2008. The matter was heard by Arbitrator (as he then was) Philip Young on 10 September 2020, by which time a claim for lump sum compensation had been added, as on 16 September 2020 Arbitrator Young remitted the matter for referral to an AMS (now Medical Assessor).
On 21 October 2020 a Medical Assessment Certificate was issued by Dr Mark Burns, assessing 20% whole person impairment (WPI).
On 17 November 2020 an Application for Reconsideration was lodged by the applicant’s solicitors pursuant to s 329(1)(b) of the Workplace Injury management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 (the 1998 Act), then in force. The application stated relevantly:
“We note that any application to appeal under section 327 (c) and (d) is required to be filed within 28…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Cottom v Scone Race Club Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] NSWPIC 519
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether the Medical Appeal Panel had committed a jurisdictional error by failing to properly consider and evaluate the evidence contained in the AALD. Specifically, the court had to determine if the Panel's decision to confirm the MAC was influenced by their alleged failure to adequately review the relevant documents, which included a letter from Mr. Cottom's solicitors, a statement from Mr. Cottom dated 25 February 2022, and two referrals to Dr. Sykes dated 17 November 2021 and 24 January 2022. The court also had to consider whether the Panel's failure to mention the AALD documents in their decision indicated an oversight or misinterpretation of the evidence.
The court examined the provisions of Section 378 of the 1998 Act, which allows the Registrar or an Appeal Panel to reconsider and amend decisions if an obvious error is identified. Despite the submissions by Mr. Cottom's counsel, the court found that the Panel had indeed considered the relevant evidence, albeit finding it unhelpful. The Panel concluded that the statement from Mr. Cottom dated 25 February 2022 did not provide new information relevant to the MAC date. The court upheld the Panel's decision, finding no jurisdictional error in their consideration of the evidence. The court's reasoning was based on the Panel's explicit consideration of the AALD documents and their subsequent determination that these documents did not alter the findings of the MAC.
The court confirmed the Panel's decision to uphold the MAC and dismissed the application for reconsideration. The court found no basis to interfere with the Panel's decision, affirming that the Panel had acted within their powers under the Act.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Section 378 of the 1998 Act as preserved states:“378 Reconsideration of decisions of Registrar or Appeal Panel(1) The Registrar or an Appeal Panel may reconsider any matter that has been dealt with by the Registrar or an Appeal Panel, respectively, and rescind, alter or amend any decision previously made or given.(2) Without limiting subsection (1), if the Registrar is satisfied that there is an obvious error in the text of a decision, the Registrar may alter the text of the decision to correct the error.(3) Without limiting subsection (1), if an Appeal Panel is satisfied that its decision or any medical assessment certificate it has issued contains an obvious error, the Appeal Panel concerned may correct that error and, if necessary, issue a replacement medical assessment certificate (which is to prevail over any previous certificate).(4) The reconsideration of a matter that is in response to an application for reconsideration must be completed within 2 months after the application is received.(5) This section does not affect any other power under this Act or the 1987 Act to review or amend a decision.” In considering this complex case the relevant documents were difficult to locate, and I am grateful to the parties for responding to my directions of 23 and 24 August 2022 and filing the nominated evidence. Mr Hart submitted that the Appeal Panel had fallen into jurisdictional error because it had either not received, or not read, or not read adequately the evidence relied on in the subject AALD. Mr Hart maintained that this evidence:(a) showed a deterioration in Mr Cottam’s condition since the MAC of 21 October 2020, and(b) showed there had been the onset of a consequential condition to the lumbar spine since the MAC of 21 October 2020. The evidence alleged not to have been available to the Panel was contained in the subject AALD[6]. [6] Insurance files vol 1 cc p 62. The documents concerned were:(a) a letter from the applicant’s solicitors addressed to the Commission;(b) a statement from the applicant dated 25 February 2022, and(c) two referrals to Dr Sykes dated 17 November 2021 and 24 January 2022 respectively. The Medical Appeal Panel gave its decision on 31 March 2022, and confirmed the MAC.[7] In doing so, the Panel considered the admissibility of documents contained within an AALD. One of the documents was an earlier statement from the applicant, dated 16 November 2020.[7] Insurance files vol 1 cc 3. In a considered decision, the Panel found the statement to be of no assistance. It did not mention the documents contained in the subject AALD. In his statement dated 25 February 2022, contained within the 9 March 2022 AALD, the applicant alleged that in February 2021, as a result of an event with a push mower, he further injured his right leg and sustained an additional injury/condition to his back.[8] He had consulted his general practitioner Dr Sykes, who had referred him Dr Kuru. The applicant said he was not good with paperwork and so he did not follow up on another referral to a Dr Salaria. He said at page 4:“18. I believe my lower back problems are related to my original knee injury and wish to claim same as part of my whole person impairment.”[8] Insurance files vol 1 cc p 72.